If it's done perfectly every single time - sure. But these are humans we're discussing...
It's silly to even have to think about if something can be recycled or not. Gotta look for that recycle number on the package first - ah, this seemingly regular plastic bottle cannot be recycled after all! Pizza box with a small amount of oil stain? Nope, can't recycle that either.
Sorting machines are clearly the only reliable way to manage waste. Everything else is a distraction meant to make you feel good about doing your part, even though the reality is you probably did some of it wrong and half of the stuff won't be recycled anyway.
Fine, throw anything remotely potentially recyclable together (and have it post-sorted), but not cooking fat, diapers, dog shit, and more.
Look at how every country's COVID strategy depended on cooperative, altruistic, collective action from ordinary people. This strategy failed everywhere it was tried.
Humans are fallible, and make mistakes. Humans also have more important things to worry about than what can or cannot be recycled (the reality shocks most people).
It must be automated if it is important enough to do at all. It has nothing to do with cooperation, altruism, collective action or whatever.
And also like you said, most things are not commercially viable to recycle, so a lot of things people put in blue bins ends up in landfills anyway.
Humans should only be used for a very rough split of garbage - e.g. separate yard waste from other trash, and that's it.
A system where humans split garbage from recycling, and then potential split recycling into e.g. corrugated cardboard, glass and everything else can work just fine.
How do I know this? It's the system we have where I live, and as far as I can tell, it works better than most others.
Contamination remains an issue, but that's likely to be even more true if humans do no separation at all.