News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alwillis on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:45PM (#35461496)
We’ve seen many instances of documents that weren’t highly thought of at the time of their publication, with that changing radically later.

Vannevar Bush‘s essay “As We May Think” in 1945 is a visionary document that describes technologies we take for granted today more than 70 years ago.

It’s possible the Bitcoin white paper will be looked at in similar ways, especially if Bitcoin ends up being one mankind’s most important inventions in addition to being a critically important financial asset.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:19PM (#35461846)
Yeah, but, it's really not going to be. Like, there is absolutely no chance of that, ever.

Even in the very-unlikely world where some sort of decentralized cryptocurrency is used for anything other than scams and drugs, it's not going to be bitcoin, and blockchains existed for decades before bitcoin did.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by doodlesdev on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:37PM (#35462033)

   > blockchains existed for decades before bitcoin did
That's absolutely not true. Bitcoin was the first blockchain like the ones we know today, the idea existed before but no one had implemented it in a decentralized way [0][1]. Bitcoin was also the first to solve the double spending problem. [2]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockchain

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-spending

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:53PM (#35462165)
We had DHTs, we had blockchains, and double spending was solved at least 2 years before the bitcoin white paper.

Satoshi combined them together in a novel form, for sure, but it’s still largely useless.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by pcthrowaway on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:50PM (#35463095)
We had linked lists of hashes which themselves referenced hash-tables, and we had a solution to the Byzantine Generals problem, but the bitcoin whitepaper combined them, and the combination of those two properties (not even tied to the consensus mechanism) is the thing people are talking about when they use the word "blockchain" now
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:49AM (#35464247)
> Satoshi combined them together in a novel form, for sure, but it’s still largely useless.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alchemist1e9 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @10:16AM (#35468579)
You seem to have a odd definition of “useless”.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:05AM (#35469309)
It's only useful for speculation, scams, and drugs. What other utility does it have?
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by tempera on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:09AM (#35478981)
Sending money on the internet without a trusted third-party.

I think that's revolutionary.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:38AM (#35479152)
There is a ton of trusted third parties involved. You're trusting:

- The KYC of your exchange, and any exchange in the coins path

- The wallet you're using

- The recipient to provide the correct address

- The exchange rate

And you're trusting all of that hasn't been tampered with, which involves even more trusted parties.

It requires an order of magnitude less trust to send cash in the mail. It's cheaper, too.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alchemist1e9 on Friday April 07, 2023 @09:02AM (#35481143)
Maybe take others advice and stop commenting on this topic because everything you said is wrong. I’ll contradict all your points using specific personal examples of my usage.

I’ve bought Bitcoin many times without any KYC. In old days localbitcoins and these days ATMs in many countries.

There aren’t any “exchange in the coins path”. I’ve exchanged paper fiat currency at Starbucks, in a hotel lobby.

The wallets I use are open source 100%. In fact I’ve personally written a python script to manually generate a transaction to broadcast. There is no third party. only your operating system, the internet connection and the source code. In that particular case I was using NixOS linux and so my operating system was also open source. I also broadcast my transaction over the ToR network so my internet provider and the Bitcoin network has no visibility.

Now onto usefulness. By holding Bitcoin I’ve preserved and grown my wealth. But how has it been used practically. Lets see.

- yesterday I bought my lunch for my wife and I, $21 using by Bitpay debit card. I loaded the card 2 mins before with those dollars by sending Litecoin which was auto exchanged by Bitpay at exactly the current exchange rate and with no fee. I exchange Bitcoin for small amounts Litecoin periodically as Litecoin is fast and cheap to send for small payments. Savings vs Checking.

- Years ago I met an artist from Argentina on an internet forum. She was painting what I thought were nice paintings. She was selling professional prints of those. I sent her Bitcoin and she sent me the prints. I’ve framed them and they hang in my home. I get many compliments on them.

- I’ve hired a developer in Crimea to work on a security software and he was paid for his work in Bitcoin

- When my sister in law had a baby shower I bought all the gifts at Buy Buy Baby using a digital gift card purchased 30 mins earlier using Bitcoin.

I could actually go on and on and on. But clearly you don’t have experience or understanding of what you are discussing as you proposed sending cash in the mail, which I don’t know anyone who would do that.

Bitcoin is revolutionary and has a decent shot at bringing fiat government currencies to their knees so they are forced to act responsibly and not brr brr money print.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:27PM (#35497280)
> Maybe take others advice and stop commenting on this topic because everything you said is wrong.

Oh lord.

> I’ve bought Bitcoin many times without any KYC. In old days localbitcoins and these days ATMs in many countries ... There aren’t any “exchange in the coins path”. I’ve exchanged paper fiat currency at Starbucks, in a hotel lobby.

Sure, ok. Now take just one tiny step forward. Think about what happens next. Those coins have extremely high odds of passing through a KYC system in the near future. That can, will, and frequently has been used to trace users who are dumb enough to think "I paid for bitcoin for cash, I'm now anonymous".

> The wallets I use are open source 100%.

And nothing nefarious has ever slipped into open source software, right? Do you have no idea what a supply chain attack is?

You use NPM, you really ought to.

> There is no third party. only your operating system, the internet connection and the source code.

And, of course, your OS and the internet can be trusted. This is a great example of the level of critical thinking cryptobros achieve.

> I also broadcast my transaction over the ToR network so my internet provider and the Bitcoin network has no visibility.

Ok, so you mitigate the announce IP, which is one of the least useful ways to do analysis. Cool.

> yesterday I bought my lunch for my wife and I, $21 using by Bitpay debit card. I loaded the card 2 mins before with those dollars by sending Litecoin ...

So it has objectively worse utility, UX, and more dependencies than fiat?

This is not a good example.

> Years ago I met an artist from Argentina on an internet forum. She was painting what I thought were nice paintings. She was selling professional prints of those. I sent her Bitcoin and she sent me the prints.

Ok. This is still not useful. Western Union, Paypal, SWIFT, all cheaper and in some cases faster.

> I’ve hired a developer in Crimea to work on a security software and he was paid for his work in Bitcoin

Protip: if someone is willing to be paid in bitcoin, they are not worth the bitcoin you're sending.

> When my sister in law had a baby shower I bought all the gifts at Buy Buy Baby using a digital gift card purchased 30 mins earlier using Bitcoin.

As above: "So it has objectively worse utility, UX, and more dependencies than fiat?"

> Bitcoin is revolutionary and has a decent shot at bringing fiat government currencies to their knees so they are forced to act responsibly and not brr brr money print.

You have absolutely no idea what a central bank does, do you? Well, I mean, you obviously think you do. But you really don't. A basic class on economics would do you a world of good.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alchemist1e9 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @07:28PM (#35507480)
I keep thinking I should respond as you are so unbelievably wrong it really needs refuting these categorically false claims of yours.

However it’s seems doubtful you will even be willing to acknowledge your flawed understanding and perhaps even unlikely you will see my response give how HN works.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by viridian on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:34AM (#35513558)
Despite being nominally on your side in this discussion, the way you reply makes me actively wish I agreed with you less, because you are so hostile and abrasive.

This is no way to talk to other human beings.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alchemist1e9 on Monday April 10, 2023 @12:38PM (#35514229)
A civilized discussion would certainly be much more productive. I can easy address the claims made and they are false.

If this poster actually knew how much experience I have with all the topics they profess such knowledge about I’d hope in that case they could be more mature.

Probably one of the must outrageous statements was to try and lecture me on the function of central banks. I’m intimately familiar with the US financial system and the function of central banks. I’ve extensively discussed Bitcoin with a very senior researcher of the Fed and was also directly involved in preparing private presentation to the ECB in Frankfurt. The central banks themselves are very concerned about how competitive Bitcoin is with fiat currency.

Bitcoin has more utility nowadays than dollar funds. It can be converted to almost any currency anywhere almost instantly and can be used by consumers with no friction via instant funded prepaid debit cards worldwide.

This poster brings up legacy payment systems that can’t even remotely compete with Bitcoin on the technical merits.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by eru on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:21PM (#35463329)
Any more background on how double spending was solved 2 years before bitcoin?
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:49AM (#35464244)
Sure. Whitepaper was released in 2008. Genesis block was in 2009.

In 2007 we had Combating Double-Spending Using Cooperative P2P Systems[0]. Prior to both the whitepaper and the genesis block, we had Distributed Double Spending Prevention[1].

These are all particular subsets of distributed consensus problems, which have been studied in the context of CS for at least 30+ years (Consensus in the Presence of Partial Synchrony[2]).

[0] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4268195

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/0802.0832

[2] http://groups.csail.mit.edu/tds/papers/Lynch/jacm88.pdf

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by eru on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:52AM (#35465058)
Thanks!

Do you have a pet theory on why bitcoin was the first such system to take off? Why not earlier?

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:37AM (#35465430)
I think it depends on what you consider to be the first such system.

The earliest ones I personally recall using were Liberty Reserve and E-Gold, which were basically fine, I guess. It was a good way to send money around with less eyes on it. Before that there were things like DigiCash, but I don't know much about that one. There was a whole bunch of random ones during the 90s, but most of them were ponzis and rugpulls (some things never change).

In my opinion, BTC took off in a way that others didn't for a bunch of reasons:

1) It was the first usable system that was decentralized, AFAIK. This is a pretty desirable characteristic, of course.

2) It had (and has) flaws, but there was no obvious means of it being a rug-pull or complete scam. E.g., it wasn't supposedly backed by gold/silver/whatever that didn't really exist.

3) You were able to get some bitcoin to use for 'free' by mining. Prior systems you had to buy into. The threshold to participate and profit was much lower.

4) The protocol is simple enough for those first few points to be trivial to verify.

5) It entered a sort of 'spiral' relationship with darknet markets and more general cybercrime. As those surged in popularity, the demand for bitcoin surged, which fueled interest in bitcoin, which fueled interested in markets, which.. etc.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by ngcazz on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:27AM (#35465355)
the great recession of 2008
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by olalonde on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:18AM (#35464069)
No.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:49AM (#35464250)
Wow, that's a great point. I hadn't even thought to approach it like that.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by olalonde on Thursday April 06, 2023 @07:26AM (#35466905)
I mean the whole comment is wrong and I mean not just a little, like straight misinformation.

> We had DHTs, we had blockchains, and double spending was solved at least 2 years before the bitcoin white paper.

- Bitcoin doesn't use DHTs.

- The term blockchain was invented after the Bitcoin white paper was published, to describe the mechanism used in Bitcoin.

- Bitcoin was the first system to solve the double spending problem in a decentralized way.

> Satoshi combined them together in a novel form, for sure, but it’s still largely useless.

The network is actively used. Just yesterday, there were 345K on chain Bitcoin transactions yesterday totaling a value of around 4 billion USD.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alchemist1e9 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @07:58AM (#35467171)
No-coiners are exhausting. Bitcoin triggers a deep psychological anxiety in some people and their reaction is to construct these defensive arguments in their heads about why Bitcoin is stupid, a scam, useless, etc.

If in another 10 years it continues it’s success and we have widespread point of sale usage and micropayments etc, and value is, maybe $200K/coin. Then these people might require some type of specialized psychological therapy to handle their disbelief.

On the other hand, Bitcoiners even if it crashes to zero somehow, will be saying at least we tried, oh well.

Bitcoin opinions are some type of strange personality litmus test. I find it very curious as the test result feels very unpredictable for me when applied to people I know well.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:16AM (#35469483)
> No-coiners are exhausting.

More than naive cryptobros?

> Bitcoin triggers a deep psychological anxiety in some people and their reaction is to construct these defensive arguments in their heads about why Bitcoin is stupid, a scam, useless, etc.

It is obviously stupid, slow, and wasteful. Ignoring all the other problems with cryptocurrencies, just on those three axes ETH is superior.

> If in another 10 years it continues it’s success and we have widespread point of sale usage and micropayments etc, and value is, maybe $200K/coin. Then these people might require some type of specialized psychological therapy to handle their disbelief.

You love to monologue, huh?

> On the other hand, Bitcoiners even if it crashes to zero somehow, will be saying at least we tried, oh well.

A great sign of a moron is that they attach themselves to non-falsifiable ideas so they can't be wrong.

> Bitcoin opinions are some type of strange personality litmus test. I find it very curious as the test result feels very unpredictable for me when applied to people I know well.

It's very predictable. Is someone naive to the point of being borderline childlike? Wants to get-rich-quick? Hates the government? Bitcoin fan.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by olalonde on Friday April 07, 2023 @12:49AM (#35478143)
To be blunt, you have no idea of what you're talking about and should refrain from commenting on a topic you clearly don't understand. You're all over the place and clearly letting your emotions take over reason.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:41AM (#35479173)
Another great point. Truly insightful.

This is the level of discourse adults experience from cryptobros, and it's why no-one except other cryptobros actually take you seriously.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by olalonde on Friday April 07, 2023 @06:58AM (#35480306)
You are the one making sexist comments, spreading misinformation and using insults... If you have concerns about Bitcoin or wish to express your personal dislike for it, there are certainly valid points to be made without resorting to fabrications or personal attacks.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:11AM (#35469397)
> - Bitcoin doesn't use DHTs.

I didn't say it did. But the idea of distributing data in a P2P fashion is not novel.

> - The term blockchain was coined after the Bitcoin white paper was published, to describe the mechanism used in Bitcoin.

I'm not very interested in the particular etymology. The fundamental ideas of a blockchain, regardless of what you call it, had been laid out by multiple people years before the bitcoin whitepaper[0].

> - Bitcoin was the first system to solve the double spending problem in a decentralized way.

No, it wasn't[1][2].

> The network is actively used. Just yesterday, there were 345K on chain Bitcoin transactions totaling a value of around 4 billion USD.

..Ok? That's about the level of activity I would expect between speculation, scams, and drugs, sure.

[0]https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.06130.pdf

[1]https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4268195

[2]https://arxiv.org/abs/0802.0832

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by throwaway2190 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:15PM (#35461806)
Well, you could make the same argument for any document, including the RFCs.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by bigbillheck on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:31PM (#35462513)
I'm gonna need a cite on "As We May Think" not being highly thought of at the time.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by EamonnMR on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:16PM (#35462828)
> if Bitcoin ends up being one mankind’s most important inventions

That seems unlikely.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by s1gnp0st on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:04PM (#35463199)
It's really disheartening how much unjustified disdain is heaped upon Bitcoin the technology by commenters here.

You're going to claim you're certain that a solution to the Byzantine generals problem will have no useful consequences?

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:23PM (#35463340)
> You're going to claim you're certain that a solution to the Byzantine generals problem will have no useful consequences?

Yes.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by s1gnp0st on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:59PM (#35463955)
Your cranky hatefulness has no power here. Be gone.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:36AM (#35464180)
I thought cryptobros had moved on to AI?
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by culi on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:30AM (#35464514)
Solutions to the problem have been proposed since at least 1982. if you wanna get theoretical Bitcoin isn't even a game-theoretically unique

In fact that's probably the biggest criticism in general of the technology. What does it solve? I can't really think of a single use-case that couldn't have been solved using other, existing technologies. It seems like it's just adding extra constraints with no actual benefits. And it never lives up to the supposed benefits. In terms of centralization that's turned out to pretty consistently be a false promise. One Bitcoin transaction uses about as much electricity as a US household uses in a month so it's not scalable or sustainable. The cryptography techniques aren't particularly novel except maybe the way they were put together. But you can usually get a lot more use out of just using those cryptography techniques without all the added baggage. The idea that it provides anonymity is also very false. If anything, quite the opposite.

The one thing it does somewhat well is introduce scarcity where there previously was none. Which is often a major cost rather than a benefit but even when it's the main benefit it's not really an effective tool (see all the examples of non-tech-literate people buying "NFTs" as art and then finding that that encrypted URL they just bought got taken down)

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by EamonnMR on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:09AM (#35464019)
Now we're moving the goalposts from:

> one mankind’s most important inventions

to merely

> useful consequences

Sure, maybe there are useful consequences, especially if you need to defy governments or whatever. But surely not something in the same league of importance as, say, fire, the wheel, writing, powered flight, the hammer, steel, math, or even Quicksort.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by s1gnp0st on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:03PM (#35476279)
"The grain mill was merely an application of the wheel and uninteresting by itself".

Absolute embittered curmudgeons.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by EamonnMR on Sunday April 09, 2023 @01:34AM (#35500286)
Are you responding to the right comment?
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by alex_sf on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:04AM (#35464349)
I like bitcoin. I use it. It's cryptobro nonsense to claim anything to do with it is in the 'top 100 non-literary' documents ever produced by humanity.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by palata on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:38AM (#35465440)
The one thing that blockchain is good at is cryptocurrencies. Whether we want cryptocurrencies or not is a separate question (I don't).

For absolutely everything else, blockchain is a worse solution than technology that already existed before.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by littlestymaar on Thursday April 06, 2023 @05:26AM (#35466140)
Solutions to the Byzantine generals problem have been long known before that (PBFT was in 1999 for instance).

The interesting part of bitcoin was the “permission-less BFT algorithm” (because other algorithm at the time required to know the list of nodes up-front) through proof of work and game theory”.

The game theory part is only applicable to Austrian-style (scarce money) crypto-“currencies”, not to other cases of byzantine generals problem (it only works because everybody has financial incentives in the robustness of the system), and even in that specific niche, the proof of work scheme has been abandoned by pretty much everybody else in favor of proof of stakes (which isn't really a permission-less system anymore).

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by pyrale on Thursday April 06, 2023 @06:18AM (#35466444)
It seems that some people really build their world around one element, and become obsessed about it that they make outlandish claims about its utility.

Based on the simple reality that bitcoin wouldn't exist without them, we can find a couple seminal papers of cryptography that had way more impact than this white paper. To name a few :

Claude Shannon's A Mathematical Theory of Communication: https://people.math.harvard.edu/~ctm/home/text/others/shanno...

Rivest, Shamir and Adelman's Method for Obtaining Digital Signatures and Public-Key Cryptosystems: https://people.csail.mit.edu/rivest/Rsapaper.pdf

Diffie and Hellman's New Direction in Cryptography: https://ee.stanford.edu/~hellman/publications/24.pdf

And that's the first three that come to my mind.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by mrguyorama on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:05PM (#35472045)
Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies only solve the byzantine generals problem inside of the blockchain itself. The second anything has to touch the real world you are right back to needing trust. It's robust against a pointless thing.

It's like building a bridge that can withstand the earth being swallowed by the sun. Sure the bridge will survive but that's pointless, and the energy and material being spent on that bridge has a billion better uses.

Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by gnu8 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @10:20AM (#35468640)
Perhaps not the most beautiful or noble thing, but it certainly has been impactful, like the invention of nerve gas.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by imtringued on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:52AM (#35464654)
At its best Bitcoin is just a slightly more convenient digital gold. That isn't exactly innovative. Even modern fiat is more innovative than that.
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by WinstonSmith84 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:07AM (#35465177)
Maybe you don't know, for sure governments of Europe and North America don't advertise this, but it's used more and more in various countries. For example here in Costa Rica, the most popular country after Mexico for North Americans. People using a smartphone app leveraging the lightning network, check that video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrEDaFEW6yI
Re:The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS by hnbad on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:53AM (#35467698)
Yes, she certainly seems a reliable and unbiased source: https://www.youtube.com/@julietlima6339/videos (this is not financial advice).