News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by somenameforme on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:40AM (#35455996)
First off, no it doesn't. Their profit for 2022 is $18 billion. This is less than half of one year of profit even, again spread out over 25 years. During which inflation + revenue growth will further dilute it. They even have $23 billion cash on hand. [1] I'd also add income is a regularly gamed metric for tax avoidance purposes.

But really the whole point here is that without painful penalties, there is no deterrence whatsoever. Seeing 'megacorp knowingly sold asbestos tainted product for decades' is not even going to elicit a 'omg I can't believe it' from anybody not born yesterday. Nor will the fact that they faced a civil penalty that was but the mildest of prods on the wrist, and 0 criminal penalties. We seemingly have a government completely incapable of holding large corporations accountable for their actions. And that is seriously not normal, nor acceptable.

[1] - https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/JNJ/johnson-johnso...

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:45AM (#35456077)
You realize J&J is a massive company with a huge range of products?

Imagine if Google was fined 50% of a year’s revenue because of Google Voice.

That’s a massive penalty by any measure.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by 93po on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:00PM (#35456317)
If I gave 40,000 people cancer as an individual and killed several thousands of people as a result, I wouldn't lose 3 years of disposal income. I would lose all of it, forever, as I sit and rot in prison for the rest of my life.

This is the sort of punishment we need for corporations.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:11PM (#35456482)
40,000 people got cancer from talc? Please link the research paper that shows that.

Everybody thinks personal injury lawyers are slimy but then quotes their “data” like it was proven fact.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by bastawhiz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:43PM (#35456939)
Let's consider, for a moment, that they paid nine billion (with a B) as a settlement because they thought that it would be cheaper than the outcome of fully litigating it. Which is to say, $9B was the cheaper option.

Regardless of the numbers, for that to be true, you've got to be pretty convinced you've fucked up really hard.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by thfuran on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:34PM (#35459995)
No, you just have to be convinced that there's a pretty good chance that a jury can be convinced that you need to pay for what you did.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by bastawhiz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:17PM (#35461163)
Clearly J&J was convinced
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by 93po on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:53PM (#35457074)
40,000 people claimed it did and followed through with legal action. Sure, maybe only a percentage of them actually got it from talc. But globally, what percent of people who did get cancer from talc actually sue? Also likely a low percentage.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:22PM (#35462438)
Maybe none?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by westpfelia on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:39PM (#35456877)
What do you think the lawsuit was about? You think J&J is being forced to pay the measly 8.9 billion just because they want this to go away? 40,000 people got cancer that we know of. People should be in jail.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by _a_a_a_ on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:11PM (#35457330)
Where is this figure given? I can't see it (may have skipped over it accidentally)
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by freeone3000 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:06PM (#35459713)
It is the number of members in the class.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by AuryGlenz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:46PM (#35463054)
Which would just be people that got a relevant cancer that also used the product - that signed up to be part of the class.

People get cancer all the time. It’s very, very hard to prove a causal relationship.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by freeone3000 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:54PM (#35471118)
Assumably this is why there’s a trial. J&J is willing to pay $9B to avoid one; this leads me to believe that they think they have a significant risk of having cancer be linked to their product.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by smabie on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:17PM (#35459085)
Which people?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:01PM (#35460987)
Lawyers don't create the data.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:23PM (#35462445)
No, but they certainly take weak data and argue why it's strong.

And they make a ton of money doing it.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:38AM (#35464196)
And? That has nothing to do with what I'm replying to. Your just making another complaint.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by za3faran on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:20PM (#35458396)
They should pierce the corporate veil and go after any individuals who had personal involvement in the matter while being fully aware of what the consequences of their actions were. That way, the livelihood of other employees who have no say in the matter is not affected, and only those who directly participated are held accountable.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:00PM (#35460978)
I agree with this and that included people who have retired. Find the people that knew and make them pay with jail time and a financial punishment
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:22PM (#35461218)
Which specific criminal law do you think they have violated? Please provide a citation to applicable state or federal criminal code. What they did was shitty, but I'm skeptical whether it would be possible for prosecutors to win a criminal conviction.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by ryandrake on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:33PM (#35462963)
If you can give 40,000 people cancer and not break a law, maybe it's the law that needs to change.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:58PM (#35463163)
Sounds good. Have you contacted your elected officials with a proposal for such a law?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:39AM (#35464199)
Negligent homicide,?

Maybe make a new law

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:44AM (#35464220)
The way that negligent homicide is defined it would be impossible to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a particular person's fatal cancer was directly caused by talc. A strong probability isn't sufficient for a criminal conviction.

Some new law would likely be needed. How could such a law be written in a manner that satisfies the vagueness doctrine?

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:31AM (#35469750)
Laws don't need to be perfect and many are vague for whatever reason but that's why there's trials.

This is a serious problem if you want to wait until a perfect law is written it won't be solved.

Also, can you provide a some other solution?

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:19PM (#35470588)
You're really missing the point. Criminal laws must satisfy the vagueness doctrine or else all convictions will be thrown out on appeal. There are literally centuries of case law in this. So your comment makes no sense and displays a lack of understanding about the basics of the criminal justice system.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by themitigating on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:46PM (#35472631)
I did miss the point. I thought "vagueness doctrine" was just a term invented here because it kinda sounds like it. You know, a catch all to deter people who want to make rules or regulations.

Considering laws exist for many types of actions it should be possible to make one in which knowingly producing and distributing any product for any price that you know to cause harm, and that harm is not made of aware of to the public in an obvious way, should be held liable for any damages that occur from the use of that product as indicated by the instructions

This includes people that approve of the actions and/or responsible for the subordinates involved in the production/approval of said products, in the company/subsidiary/any related entity, as long as that person was provided with the information or access to information that would allow them to ascertain the risk with a reasonable amount of accuracy. However, it shan't be required to show that person actually consumed or understood that information if it was expected that they do so.

The punishment must be but can not be limited to monetary fines which can not be purged through bankruptcy. <something about jail here>

etc etc.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:28PM (#35459924)
That's not how the system works. It would be very difficult to convict you as an individual of a felony that would send you to prison. The burden of proof in criminal cases is much higher.

Even if you were found liable in civil court you wouldn't lose all of your income forever. You would be able to declare personal bankruptcy and clear the debt.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by felipemnoa on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:45PM (#35460815)
>>Even if you were found liable in civil court you wouldn't lose all of your income forever. You would be able to declare personal bankruptcy and clear the debt.

I guess it depends.

From the net:

"Instances in which a court ordered judgment won’t be overridden by bankruptcy include debts related to:

Student loans

Any debt owed to the government, including taxes and fines

Court ordered awards related to criminal proceedings"

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by nradov on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:18PM (#35461181)
None of that is relevant. This case is not a criminal proceeding. Civil court judgments can generally be cleared in bankruptcy.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by arrosenberg on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:56AM (#35456254)
I would imagine Google as a corporation would be more careful about giving people cancer. “We are too big for accountability” has been a bad idea every time it has been used in America.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by evilduck on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:41PM (#35456916)
More importantly, Google's competitors would also be more careful about it too.

Kill a giant after it steps on people and other giants will learn to tiptoe.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by chii on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:44PM (#35463043)
The only way to kill a giant is to have an even bigger giant. What then, if the biggest giant is now the one killing people?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by arrosenberg on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:58PM (#35463164)
Ideally a combination of intracompetitive federal agencies that form a legal Voltron when required.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by evilduck on Thursday April 06, 2023 @09:30AM (#35468074)
Gulliver's Travels says otherwise.

It's an analogy, trying to take it too far will get silly.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by triyambakam on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:03PM (#35456368)
If Google Voice killed people then yeah, that'd be fair.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by webdood90 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:03PM (#35456352)
again I ask, why do people shill for corporations?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:14PM (#35456511)
Who is shilling? The data suggesting asbestos in talc is a real health hazard is tenuous at best.

A bunch of class action lawyers just made $30B dollars. So we know they’re happy either way.

I thought HN followed tge sxience?

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by arrosenberg on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:40PM (#35456910)
J&J should be punitively punished for knowing about asbestos in their product and hiding it from the public. Whether or not anyone died as a result, corporations should not be allowed to be malfeasant and get away with it because only a small number of people were provably harmed. Corporations should have to behave like the cops are watching them.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by refurb on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:21AM (#35464084)
They never hid it?
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by arrosenberg on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:19AM (#35464839)
k.

> Johnson & Johnson executives knew for decades about the risk of asbestos exposure linked to its talc products, including the famous baby powder it began selling 129 years ago. After years of pushing back on researchers and scientists, the company began facing a flood of lawsuits in recent years, along with government investigations and lawmaker inquiries.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by lakecresva on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:37PM (#35456858)
Who are you even responding to? No one's arguing the science, they're talking about the size of the settlement relative to the corporation's financials.
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by gnicholas on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:26PM (#35459201)
> A bunch of class action lawyers just made $30B dollars.

Where is this number coming from? The listed settlement amount is an order of magnitude less than this, and lawyers typically get some percentage (15-30?), which has to be approved by the court. I'm not saying they didn't make a lot of money here (and for full disclosure, I used to be a lawyer), but I'm not seeing how they raked in tens of billions.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:38PM (#35460727)
> Who is shilling? The data suggesting asbestos in talc is a real health hazard is tenuous at best.

If you really believe that preposterous claim, put "asbestos" on the package and see how many people buy it. You sails will fall off a cliff. All your other products will be treated like they are radioactive too.

You want free market? That's free market for you. If you lie about the product, you are defrauding the customer.

But somehow fraud only ever sends the little people to jail.

Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by dzader on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:54AM (#35456226)
Imagine if google was knowingly killing people with google voice for decades
Re:Johnson and Johnson Reaches Deal for $8.9B Talc Settlement by chii on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:38PM (#35462999)
But j&j is a conglomerate business, so using their entire business profit is not right to check what percentage loss the fine is.

If you only consider the profit from the talc business, how much is the fine compared to profit?