News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by AlecSchueler on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:10PM (#35442812)
This sort of ignores the global nature of our supply chains though. Someone can be very green in life here in the EU because all the products they buy are manufactured in China and their environmental impact is externalised and put onto the stats of another country that's trying to meet our demands.

By regulating what's available on markets here we can pressure maufacturers elsewhere.

What is the alternative you would suggest? We have no direct regulatory power over anyone but ourselves.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:16PM (#35442904)
I understand that pointing out problems in complex systems without proposing a solution is ultimately indifferent from eloquent bitching, which I can certainly be fairly accused of.

That said, what the west is currently doing to address climate change - analogous to cheering for the people trying to push a derailed 130-ton freight car back onto the rail tracks with unassisted manpower alone - is not a solution either.

The first step towards a real solution is recognizing that what we are currently doing is a categorically pointless waste of time, so we can stop wasting energy and thought on that and start diverting it to actual solutions.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by bluGill on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:32PM (#35443155)
The west is moving to renewable energy quickly. It will take time, but we have made a lot of progress and are making more.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by ireflect on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:25PM (#35443017)
You are a very good writer and I’m intrigued by this thread. Can you elaborate on what you see as actual solutions and how they would look (no matter how far fetched)?
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:50PM (#35443444)
Thank you for the complement. I'm under no delusion that I have the solutions to the whole world's problems figured out. These ideas are like unrefined chunks of coal, rife with imperfections and riddled with flaws and only under the great pressure and heat of vigorous, critical debate may they ever hope to become diamonds.

I think R&D on the scale of what the US spent relative to GDP during WW2 might be a place to start. That's economically likely to require severe and heavy cuts across the board and may require a transformation of what are seen as the traditional roles of government. Half of all spending in the US goes to social security, medicare, and medicaid. These three programs combined take up almost triple US military spending. What's worse, they're mathematically unsustainable. Social security and medicare are effectively pyramid schemes that are running out of new people to recruit (result of low birthrates, dramatic improvements in life expectancy, and the lowest rates of net immigration into the country, as a % of existing population, in this country's history). These programs are going to die sooner or later anyway, why not rip off the band-aid now and start putting that enormous spending towards solutions for problems that can save billions rather than millions?

At the same time, there probably needs to be major overhauls to the US tax system. Even when top marginal rates were close to 90% last century, large corporations effectively bought politicians to create enormous tax write offs for them. As a result, total federal government receipts as a percent of GDP have never left the range of 16%-26%. Let's consider a flat federal tax rate of 27% across the board, with only one category of write-offs: R&D for carbon-negative / climate-healing solutions (as opposed to carbon neutral / climate-unaffecting solutions). We're going to need to be capable of removing other countries' carbon emissions if we fail to get them on the same page diplomatically or militarily, and I will never support military intervention (read: mass murder of innocent civilians) as a solution.

Imagine the sheer power of the US government being deployed full-force, with such overwhelming financial backing that we strive to go so deeply carbon negative that it doesn't even matter whether India and China are on board or not.

Yes we would be giving up the fights on a lot of problems, but IMO, no problems other than climate change and nuclear conflict between superpowers threatens the whole of humanity. While not perfect, the nuclear superpower problem is not getting worse as quickly as climate change, so on some level it makes sense to go full-steam-ahead on resource allocation to the largest issue first, and then work our way down the chain to smaller ones, rather than overextending ourselves and failing to solve problem #1, like we're doing now.

These are obviously some pretty radical proposals and I don't think there is political will to even have anything remotely like this seriously considered, so our corrupt, money-influenced political system probably needs to be changed first.

Just like how FTP separates the data plane (political outcomes) from the control plane (political process), we too need to protect the control plane from adversarial influence (big corporation lobbyists, citizens united, etc) before we can ever hope to achieve meaningful political outcomes.

Accordingly, whatever solves the political corruption ("lobbying") problem first should probably be our first step.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by quesera on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:15PM (#35447549)
The usual response is that this would be economically suicidal for the US, and that other ambitious competitors would attempt to create a new world order more suited to their preferences. This would probably anoint China as the next century's global hegemon, although it's at least equally likely that the world would devolve into warring fiefdoms as the world economy imploded.

Tens or hundreds of millions of people would die as a direct consequence of this economic malpractice, including a decent portion of the US citizens who voted for the persons responsible. Reelection would be tricky, although it would not be difficult to imagine the US democratic process being suspended as a reaction to the catastrophe (legal precedent is not relevant, see history).

Don't get me wrong: climate change is a problem! But this would create a much bigger and more acute problem.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by smoldesu on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:35PM (#35443204)
> so we can stop wasting energy and thought on that and start diverting it to actual solutions.

If there were better "actual solutions", stupid moonshots wouldn't get funded in the first place. I don't think your framing of this situation is very accurate.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by jjoonathan on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:46PM (#35443371)
If you think that nothing we are doing could possibly help, you are ignoring the power of exponentials and economies of scale. Besides, a planet with colossal amounts of solar/wind/battery/nuclear production capacity left over from a developed world ramp is in a much better place to help the developing world than one without.

> stop wasting energy and thought on that and start diverting it to actual solutions

I thought you didn't have any actual solutions and admitted as much?

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:09PM (#35443720)
To be clear, it's not that I think nothing we're currently doing helps, it's that I think everything we're currently doing is grossly insufficient.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by beepbooptheory on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:48PM (#35443399)
I think its right to point out the particular futility here, but I also think that it is a mistake to attribute it all to a "mistake" or particular irrationality of the West as a whole.

These things appear to us a "pointless" and a waste of time because there are overriding economic principles we just don't want to touch, it is a willful pointlessness that is quite apparent in the big picture. It's not China, it's capitalism, (of which, granted, China is a huge agent within).

If we lived in a world where the problems were simply about the distribution itself of food and shelter and power, we could point to the complexity of the systems, and understand the risks of wrongheadedness in the face of them, but we live in a world plagued by bad faith and non-human incentives that certainly muddy these waters, but it doesn't mean there aren't some simple solutions to a few things people haven't thought of...

To create this dichotomy between the West and China is to deny the Anthropocene we are all in! One that is defined necessarily by the literally geological forces of a world-dominating economic order.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by 8note on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:04PM (#35443650)
I don't think you're giving the west a fair shake here.

The work the west(and China) is doing to develop non-fossil fuel based tech cheap is directly applicable to those growing economies, and not a pointless waste of time.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:48PM (#35447812)
What would really help is across the board carbon taxes. Tax imports by carbon equivalents. But that seems politically impossible.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by slowmovintarget on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:19PM (#35442942)
Do the difficult thing. Stop buying from China. As consumers, buy things with a transparent supply chain. Look for ESG reports on the companies you buy from.

The hard part of this is it requires consumers to be educated and act. This almost never happens unless the costs for not acting are built into the prices of goods. Doing that requires political will. It's going to make a lot of people very angry; and we're not talking indulgences in the form of cap & trade, either.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:29PM (#35443086)
>The hard part of this is it requires consumers to be educated and act.

Agreed 100%.

>Doing that requires political will. It's going to make a lot of people very angry; and we're not talking indulgences in the form of cap & trade, either.

Also an astute observation. It may be the case that this is ultimately a problem with our political system first and foremost.

But economic sanctions alone will not halt the manufacturing base of an economy the size of China's.

China and India need to get on board for real. Asking politely is not working. I'll never advocate for the initiation of force, but something is going to need to change in a big way to convince these countries to join us in a fight that will strip all of us of a little short-term prosperity, if we want to leave a planet that our great grandchildren can safely habitate.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by 39 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:03AM (#35449150)
Really enjoyed reading your writing. Do you have any other outlets?
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:45AM (#35454061)
I do not, sorry if this comes as a disappointment.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by munk-a on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:32PM (#35443150)
I might suggest the slightly less difficult thing that I think could be reasonably politically accomplished. Introduce carbon tariffs on goods imported from dirty countries to make their products less competitive and provide an incentive to clean up manufacturing.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:56PM (#35443537)
Great baby step. I'm all for it. Let's just make sure nobody is under the impression that this is anything more than a baby step - far more will be needed, ultimately.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by evandale on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:29PM (#35446085)
I want to go one step further than this idea and introduce carbon tariffs on imported goods coupled with price ceilings so corporations can't pass off the tariffs to wealthy people and still profit. The corporations should be paying these taxes and their bottom line should suffer if they're selling dirty goods. They should not be able to make the profit margins they're making today by manufacturing cheap trash in China and selling it for insane markups in first-world countries.

The price ceilings should be set based on some amount of maximum profit margin companies should be allowed to make. If they want to make bigger margins they're going to have to move manufacturing to cleaner countries and then they can apply their insane markups.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by munk-a on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:50PM (#35446313)
I'm actually quite in favor of, essentially, a minimum VAT tax. The US demands that good manufacturing pays some reasonable level of VAT taxes (let's say 10% as an example). If Apple builds a laptop in China they value at 300$ (paying 45$ in VAT to China) and then ship it over to Bermuda to "endow it with their brand" adding 1700$ to the value and paying a VAT tax of .5% then, once it arrives at US shores, we simply bar the good entry until 9.5% of 1700$ is surrendered to the US government to account for VAT dodging.

It's an incredibly easy way to close a whole bunch of tax loopholes at once.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @06:03PM (#35446434)
So, an import tariff that is waived against imports from countries with sufficiently high taxes on production, provided those taxes are characterized the right way?

Seems like a monumentally bad idea

> It’s an incredibly easy way to close a whole bunch of tax loopholes at once.

I don’t think it closes any tax loopholes.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by munk-a on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @06:51PM (#35446922)
Tax compatibility is a pretty solved problem - countries frequently coordinate to make sure income and other taxes don't end up being double counted so it's not like this would happen accidentally[1]. And the point isn't so much that the US should collect all this revenue - it's just to make tax havens moot and unnecessary.

Why spend money shipping laptops to Bermuda so you can put a sticker on them there if you aren't saving any money?

1. There's a positive incentive here, if you work and live in country A and are considering working in country B either country B can craft their tax system so that you won't end up paying the same taxes to both country A or country B... or they can not do that. If they fail to make their tax law compatible they lose out on your tax income (it instead all goes to country A) since nobody wants to be double taxed - if they make their tax laws compatible then they essentially get some free income and another earner. Digital nomads pulling down six digit salaries in low cost of living countries also injects a whole lot of money into the local economy and generally just makes things better - and the country retains the right to limit visas if they ever have any issues with it.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:08PM (#35447505)
> Tax compatibility is a pretty solved problem

Tax compatibility with VAT only is a sensible concept where the destination country has a VAT itself, which the US does not. Otherwise, a minimum VAT on imports is just a global punitive import tariff, and has nothing to do with compatibility.

Even where its sensible, it still has potential problems that can be introduced through other parts of the tax system, but…we don’t really need to consider that in this case.

Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by TylerE on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:55PM (#35443513)
So, don't buy anything containing electronics?
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by anonym29 on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @02:10PM (#35443741)
Produce political solutions that steer the market towards developing electronics domestically again, or reducing the need for such electronics in the first place.
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by ikiris on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:08PM (#35445879)
what political solutions do you envision that would reduce demand for electronics in a meaningful way?
Re:‘This shouldn’t be happening’: levels of banned CFCs rising by timmg on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @01:50PM (#35443435)
> This sort of ignores the global nature of our supply chains though.

To me the answer is a pretty easy one:

Take the CO2 emissions of a country and divide by its GDP. That gives you a CO2 per dollar. Then decide on a CO2 cost per unit for your country. Now apply that as a tariff per dollar of imports from said country.

It's imperfect, of course. But I think it is close enough to estimate what we want it to do.