News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by DeRock on Friday March 31, 2023 @01:52PM (#35390617)
It's not just Gen Z, 79% of all US car buyers would only buy a car with CarPlay: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/22/apple-carplay-could-be-a-tro...

GM will absolutely lose this battle. Idiotic move.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by mikestew on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:31PM (#35391283)
GM will absolutely lose this battle.

They will, but not by standing firm. No, first will come the backlash, then GM will "listen to its customers" and backtrack on this.

The problem is, I've already as of this morning stopped listening to GM. I sent the link to my wife, and now we're planning which Hyundai/Kia dealer to go to first to look at Ioniq 5s and $(whatever the equivalent Kia is called). Doug in Edmonds says he has 65 of the l'il buggers. We might just drive one home this weekend, at which point GM has not only lost a sale but further convinced me to stay away from GM.

Did I mention that my father worked for GM all his career, and already pre-ordered an EV Blazer, which we said we'd take if he didn't want it at delivery? Yeah, I need to send Dad quick email about that...

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by hexane360 on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:51PM (#35391570)
Make sure you get a Hyundai/Kia with an immobilizer...
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by vel0city on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:21PM (#35392069)
All Hyundai/Kia EVs are push to start.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Baeocystin on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:15PM (#35391987)
As someone who is quite concerned that I'm going to have to sell my Kia because insurance companies are refusing to cover them because they're so easy to steal, just... be careful which model you pick.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by vel0city on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:20PM (#35392061)
Its only really the models and years where they didn't have immobilizers. He's looking at an EV, it doesn't even have a cut key for starting the car.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Baeocystin on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:46PM (#35392460)
A good point. Also worth mentioned that Kias are (apparently) easy to break in to. Twice over the past year my neighborhood has had a group come around and jimmy just the Kias in the neighborhood to steal stuff from inside. I don't live in a high-crime area, either. It's real problem.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by CameronNemo on Friday March 31, 2023 @09:27PM (#35396069)
This is already what is being discussed.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:47PM (#35392474)
One of the reasons I've taken Hyundai/Kia off my list is because I don't trust thieves to be aware of which models are easy to steal and which aren't. Even if they can't steal it, they can still fuck it up by trying.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by p1mrx on Friday March 31, 2023 @06:36PM (#35394698)
Product idea for Hyundai/Kia: always-glowing high visibility start button
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by mikestew on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:21PM (#35393058)
I think I'll pick a 2023 that doesn't have that problem, starting with the fact that it doesn't have an ignition key. :-) But thanks for the heads-up.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by kulahan on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:07PM (#35390864)
I'm glad to see that I'm not alone in that being an absolute requirement for a car purchase. I guess it's not surprising that GM is making another stupid move though.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Moto7451 on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:12PM (#35390974)
Definitely not alone. Some VP doesn’t get it and is going to find themselves in a new job elsewhere after they figure out what they just committed themself to.

I love GM cars once you remove their terrible UI and escape to CarPlay/Android Auto. The biggest issue with cars is that they rely on a touch screen for controls and the UX is awful. I now have an Audi and a Porsche and the MMI suite is Android based. This isn’t too bad but the services and mapping are far behind Apple and Google.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Robotbeat on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:37PM (#35391369)
If it’s that dominant I wonder if there needs to be some anti-trust action done with Apple?
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by MBCook on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:40PM (#35391412)
On what grounds? Because people like it too much?

Apple isn’t forcing anything. They don’t have exclusive contacts. Almost every car with CarPlay supports Android Auto.

Customers are just demanding it.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by calciphus on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:26PM (#35392154)
Apple does restrict access to much of their platform for only Apple-based access. There's exactly one company stopping Google or anyone else from building a compatible car system that runs for both Android and ios, and that's Apple. The use of private APIs and preventing competitors from using them, to secure another market (car infotainment systems) certainly should run afoul of anticompetitive laws in spirit, even if it doesn't to the army of lobbyists and lawyers the most valuable company in the world can muster.

By comparison, nothing (not even Google) is stopping Apple from producing CarPlay for Android. All the APIs are there. They could even distribute it in the Play store.

Compare the PhoneLink capabilities between iPhone and Android, vs the macOS integration Apple offers iOS.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by alistairSH on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:43PM (#35392407)
Uh, my Honda's factory radio is literally an Android device.

It happily allows CarPlay from my iPhone.

CarPlay is (very roughly) the phone pushing video to the car's head unit like it's an external monitor (with a UI tailored for the size/location/usage of a typical car display).

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by MBCook on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:33PM (#35392267)
Are you comparing the car infotainment OS with the CarPlay feature running on the phone?

I was not talking about the infotainment OS. No one has an Apple OS running on a car so I don’t know how they could dominate the market.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by sokoloff on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:54PM (#35393513)
I have a ~$175 Android head unit that offers CarPlay functionality in one of our daily drivers. There's nothing stopping car makers or head unit/car infotainment systems makers from creating CarPlay compatibility in their devices.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Marsymars on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:51PM (#35393473)
> I'm glad to see that I'm not alone in that being an absolute requirement for a car purchase.

My issue is that my #1 requirement (no functionality that requires a touchscreen to use) basically pre-empts me from having any other requirements.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by unethical_ban on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:08PM (#35393680)
Mazda may come close. They have the control knob in the center.

I agree no touchscreen for AC/volume knob and some other things, but zero touchscreen at all (even for radio and menu) seems out there. Time to get a 2001 Cherokee.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Marsymars on Saturday April 01, 2023 @02:34PM (#35402774)
Note that I’m not requiring zero touchscreen to be present, just that I don’t have to use the touchscreen for any functionality in the vehicle.

My 2011 car can accomplish everything perfectly well without a touchscreen while I’m wearing giant ski mitts in -30 weather; I’m not interested in a downgrade.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by skunkworker on Friday March 31, 2023 @02:18PM (#35391070)
I will only rent a car if it has CarPlay. If it doesn't then I will rent another vehicle. It's not worth trying to get maps/phone setup in a car that I haven't driven and in a location that I am unfamiliar with. Where CarPlay allows me to use the same UI, apps settings et al that make it significantly easier.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Reason077 on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:06PM (#35391833)
> ”GM will absolutely lose this battle. Idiotic move.”

I dunno. Lack of CarPlay support has not exactly stopped people buying Teslas.

On the other hand, Polestar uses Google’s Automotive OS for it’s infotainment system and yet also supports CarPlay. So the two aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by theshrike79 on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:43PM (#35392403)
Tesla's infotainment systems are in a whole another category from whatever the other manufacturers are attempting.

That being said, not supporting CarPlay (and Apple Maps) is a big factor of me not buying a Tesla.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by KerrAvon on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:37PM (#35392331)
But it actually has. Lack of CarPlay support was a major reason I didn't seriously consider a Tesla for my last purchase (long before they became electric MAGA hats), and I know other people who have the same issue. Are we statistically significant? Not enough data. Maybe not. But there's definitely some money that Tesla's leaving on the table.

Volvo/Polestar has a rather nice, well-integrated implementation of CarPlay, in fact. It definitely can be done. GM is insane.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by kitsunesoba on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:17PM (#35392007)
GM is very much not Tesla, though. They don't have Tesla's reputation of being tech-forward and somewhat competent in software UI/UX, plus I'd argue that the kind of buyers who'd consider e.g. a Bolt are those who are looking for normal cars that happen to be EVs — they're the type who'd normally be buying something like a Toyota Camry or Honda Accord. They want something that's a reliable commuter, not a touchscreen gadget on wheels.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by MBCook on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:35PM (#35393259)
Tesla had a very strong alternate benefit to offset the CarPlay loss.

They were basically the only non-low end electric car. Also their infotainment is reportedly pretty good, not the quality of most car makers.

GM doesn’t have a Tesla quality infotainment system, and doesn’t have a “we’re the only choice” level hook.

It won’t work for them. And it may be starting to hurt Tesla as they lose their uniqueness selling point.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by Reason077 on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:15AM (#35398993)
> “GM doesn’t have a Tesla quality infotainment system”

Yet.

Having poked around with a Polestar, Google’s infotainment software is actually very good.

It’s certainly in the same ballpark as Tesla’s. Clean elegant design, tight integration to the car’s systems, fast smooth performance. And has clear advantages over Tesla in some aspects (ie: ability to install 3rd-party apps).

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by mikestew on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:36PM (#35393271)
Lack of CarPlay support has not exactly stopped people buying Teslas.

Oh, it absolutely does. I bought TSLA when it was in the double digits, and I bought lots of it (and long since sold it all). Despite scooping up capital gains with a backhoe, my wife and I never considered a Tesla simply because it didn't have CarPlay. As it applies to any car maker, CarPlay/Android Auto seems like an easy win, and if the company can't be bothered, then we'll look elsewhere.

Lack of CarPlay just doesn't stop everyone from buying one.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by diebeforei485 on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:04PM (#35393633)
Tesla is probably an edge-case. Tesla's navigation has excellent support for Superchargers and even pre-conditions your battery a few minutes before you arrive at the charger for more efficient charging.

There are ways to run CarPlay in the browser, and it works fine (plenty of videos about it), but it isn't enough of a value-add for people to want it.

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by pedalpete on Friday March 31, 2023 @06:57PM (#35394900)
Not having Android Auto or CarPlay is the thing I dislike most about Tesla. I doubt they would be more popular if they had these features, but I also doubt GM will suddenly find they have the software capabilities of Tesla.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by taylodl on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:39PM (#35392358)
I'm honestly surprised anybody is still buying GM cars/trucks.

If you want a truck, get a Ford. They're hands-down the best in class. Or get a Toyota or Honda if you roll that way.

If you want an SUV, well, everybody is making those and GM doesn't have any standout offerings.

If you want a luxury car then there are much better options that are not only more luxurious, but more reliable, and oftentimes cheaper.

If you want reliable, cheap transportation then you're getting a KIA or Hyundai.

No matter how you slice it and dice it, the answer is never GM. (I'll concede the Corvette, they're great sports cars, but c'mon! Not many people are buying those!)

And now they're nixing CarPlay?

Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by rdl on Friday March 31, 2023 @03:49PM (#35392523)
They are still pretty solid for vehicles like the Suburban/Tahoe/Yukon for specific uses (fleets, large family, tow vehicles) and the Sierra isn’t quite as nice as the F-150 but isn’t bad.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by ambrice on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:28PM (#35393141)
The Bolt is the best EV in its price range (<30K)
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by taylodl on Friday March 31, 2023 @04:39PM (#35393318)
Completely anecdotal, but I know far more people owning the Nissan Leaf, and they're about as obsessive about their Leafs (Leaves?) as Tesla owners.
Re:GM is ditching CarPlay in all future EVs and teaming up w... by sokoloff on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:00PM (#35393584)
I have a LEAF and generally very much like it. The massive Achilles heel of my car is the 24kWh battery, which is slightly annoying about once a month and seriously annoying about 4x per year.

Any Bolt is a better car hands-down on battery capacity alone.

On the infotainment topic: I have the top-spec LEAF for my year and the (upgraded) infotainment unit is hot garbage, easily bested by the $175 Android touchscreen I put in my wife's car.