Like you, I personally nuke Windows immediately and run fwupd from Linux... but then... I'm lucky I get to choose my own laptops. And I only buy those whose manufacturers support fwupd. It's a growing number, but I don't think it's a majority...? I'm not sure, I would be happy if anyone had hard data here.
>those updates might not be available under Linux
Just because FWUPD exists, doesn't mean that FWUPD has updates for all laptops or HW devices in your laptop. All HW manufacturers ship Windows drivers and FW updates for Windows, but not all push their FW to fwupd as well. That's why you should use Windows to update everything first.
Maybe you're buying used and you can get a great deal that just has that one drawback.
Too bad many that can don't. There's no way for the little players to achieve economies of scale of the big players if folks keep buying Windows hardware from the big players.
Also, with that mentality, we would never extend Linux support to new hardware.
It doesn't sound as good as a fully supported option. It sounds a lot like commodity Windows hardware.
> Also, with that mentality, we would never extend Linux support to new hardware.
No, hobbyists will still do it (see e.g. Asahi)
If folks keep giving their money to Windows hardware companies instead of Linux ones, they should not be surprised if the range if Linux-supporting hardware remains smaller. Like if you could just slap OSX on some random Windows PC M1 and such would never have come about.
We actually have options as Linux users these days. It's a shame folks insist on wasting the opportunity.
And unless you're a GNU/Nerd, most people have better uses for their time than scouring through the web to find out if fwupd works for the HW when they go shopping for a new laptop. Most normal people just buy a laptop that fits them best and that's it.
After all, why would they need to do any extra research for this? Isn't the whole internet and HN preaching that the year of the Linux is here and that it "just works(TM)"? Maybe not without caveats.
If you keep buying Windows hardware and slapping Linux on it, you'll have to be the systems integration team all by yourself. Without documentation of the hardware, or support.
It's a mug's game. Don't play it. Buy Linux hardware, with support.
Or you buy Linux hardware with support.
Perhaps you're thinking of responses to the perennial genre of, "I slapped Linux on my Windows box, and it was terrible, so Linux sucks!" posts?
I did in fact say that in the article. (I wrote the story at the top of this post.)
[0] https://fwupd.org/ [1] http://rufus.ie/
If you did your research and made sure to buy linux supported hardware, then good for you mate, youa re free do whatever you want, but for us with less linux friendly hardware or unknown to the user, my point still stands, you should first update everything under windows (including usb-c/thunderbolt docking station FW) to ensure a good linux experience later.
System76 supports LVFS and Framework has started using it for its latest beta firmware updates. (for a full list of vendors: https://fwupd.org/lvfs/vendors/ )
I actually plan on buying a X1 Carbon Gen10 in the following weeks, and use Arch as my daily driver, and yet I didn't think of checking the (honestly amazing) ArchWiki.
Also I think you'll love the machine - it's certainly my favorite Linux laptop.
It will reflect the reality of the situation for that specific set of hardware. The vendor is going to give you a sales pitch.
And I say this as someone who has gone out of my way to buy hardware from vendors that officially support linux (Dell & Lenovo).
In many cases - the most official support you'll get is "This is a known issue, we are working on it."
Ex: https://www.dell.com/en-us/lp/linux-systems
I used an XPS 13 developer edition for quite a while. Great little machine, but a couple of known issues around wifi/bluetooth and the fingerprint reader. Fixable, and Dell actually did provide drivers in a deb for Ubuntu, but it took them a little while.
But generally speaking, yes you can call - they will provide resources and point you at fixes they've implemented, but it's still a bit of a grab bag. I would definitely not buy a linux machine from them without checking the Arch wiki first.
Ex: The current developer machine shipping from Dells link is here: https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Dell_XPS_13_Plus_(9320)
Mostly fine across the board - some known issues with very recent kernel versions, and some problems with the webcam. Dell fixed the webcam issues in their default Ubuntu release, but it requires manual fixing on other distros.
My general rules of thumb for selecting laptops for linux:
- Avoid Realtek wherever possible, usually in favor of Intel. Even though Realtek hardware usually technically works on Linux, it's often in a reduced or buggy capacity.
- Avoid Nvidia. This might change soon now that Nvidia is finally being a bit more open with driver development, but for now Nvidia cards are still likely cause of unnecessary pain.
- If possible, avoid discrete GPUs. AMD cards are more likely to be well-behaved than Nvidia cards but often the most trouble-free experience is with nothing but an iGPU. This is really only practical for users who use laptops for their portability and have a desktop for where raw power is necessary.
I disagree on this and the supposed Clevo point. Got a source for "just a Clevo" rebadge?
Also, support and firmware.
But yes, if you want a non-Clevo ODM there aren't as many options.
Note, though, that buying from Windows vendors will make the situation worse, not better.
It's the best way to describe it: they change maybe the wifi card, certainly the logo, tweak a few bios defaults, and for sure you a premium for that, but that's all they can do, and nothing you couldn't do yourself (except the logo, unless you like stickers lol)
> Note, though, that buying from Windows vendors will make the situation worse, not better.
In term of having more rebadging? Yes, there will be more parasites taking advantage of people who want to buy the right to have someone to blame for their laptop not working correctly on Linux.
But it terms on Linux support, it will not change anything: Lenovo still offers the best support, with other companies except Framework limited by their dependance on Clevo
It might even make things worse, by leading those who've been taken advantage of by unscrupulous companies that Linux just doesn't work well on laptops.
More important, for those wanting the best results, it will be counter productive: they will certainly have someone to blame (they paid for that "right" after all) but they could have instead taken the problem in their own hands and made their hardware work, with the help of resources like archwiki.
It's not the ideal solution, but I think Framework will need another 5 to 10 years to be really competitive to Lenovo. In the meantime, I would be happy to support them or help them, but now that I've decided 2023 is my year of Linux on the desktop, it'll have to be on a Lenovo.
Nope. That's 100% false.
https://twitter.com/jeremy_soller/status/1322954630448427011
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17039414
I don't get why Lenovos are supposedly so great. The one I had at work was _terrible_, hands down the worst Linux experience I've ever had. And I put Linux on a bunch of Windows boxen back when we had no choices in the matter.
You only had one? How can you pretend to know a brand with 1 model?
FYI, of the modern thinkpads, only those from the X1 series are good.
On the others series, too many corners have been cut. At work, you're unlikely to have gotten a X1, so I'm not surprised about your experience.
If you are curious and want to try, get a X1, even an old one from ebay. It can be great after some minor configuration, and I'd be happy to help: my 2 lenovos (a hold on windows and linux, a nano just on linux) are both perfectly stable, consume less than 5% of battery per 10h of sleep, and resumes perfectly. I don't know any better computer to run Linux, or I would have gotten it already.
TBH the nano is so great that I've moved from Windows to Linux on the desk(lap)top in 2023 :)
> That's 100% false.
Look at the comments from your own link, from actual users of Clevos who are trying to politely say it's not as good as claimed. There's a lot of astroturfing from linux related brands on sites like HN.
And FYI a tweaked fan curve is nothing to brag about, when they have components not even working like the fingerprint reader.
Now if you are curious, invest a few hunders in a used thinkpad and see for yourself.
Because it is also a common sentiment I've heard from others, on X1s. But also because it was my experience
> FYI, of the modern thinkpads, only those from the X1 series are good.
I'm sure if you research thoroughly and are lucky it xan work. I'd rather pay fir a company that fully backs Linux on the hardware.
> TBH the nano is so great that I've moved from Windows to Linux on the desk(lap)top in 2023 :)
I'm glad you did, welcome! (I've been running Linux since the 90s. :) I'm glad it's working for you, but I'd suggest it's a poor strategy even if it's perhaps an acceptable tactic.
> Look at the comments from your own link, from actual users of Clevos who are trying to politely say it's not as good as claimed.
Yes, because Clevos are not System76? That's rather my point. They're the people who bought Clevos and discovered the hard way that they're different in very salient ways.
> There's a lot of astroturfing from linux related brands on sites like HN.
Astroturfing? I've talked woth these folks and have used their hardware since the late to mid-aughts. Saying they're contradicting their claims, and they're saying up front they work for System76.
It's like claiming a RedHat dev is astroturfing when they say how the internals of the distro work. (And I'm highly sceptical of them having the disposable cash to splash out to hire astroturfers!)
> tweaked fan curve is nothing to brag about, when they have components not even working like the fingerprint reader.
It's not just a tweaked fan curve. The firmwares are entirely different.
The reply about the fingerprint reader sounds reasonable. They don't have nearly the leverage of Dell, Lenovo, or Apple to get the ODM to do what they want. This sounds reasonable (and not my own experience.) They're a small shop, in no small part because people keep showing Linux on Windows computers.
> Now if you are curious, invest a few hunders in a used thinkpad and see for yourself.
I could, or I could keep buying hardware that is for Linux, with support. I think my time is worth it.
Unless they are featuring coreboot, they just tweaked options in say the Insyde bios, so no, not entirely different.
> I could, or I could keep buying hardware that is for Linux, with support. I think my time is worth it.
Personally, I prefer quality.
Should you ever change your mind, get in touch, I'm preparing a sick arch image with absolutely perfect hardware support on wayland!
What about a fully Free CoreBoot firmware and EC?
https://github.com/system76/firmware-open https://github.com/system76/ec
> Personally, I prefer quality.
Me too! It's why I don't waste time with hostile hardware.
I'm also glad I can rely on the original, preinstalled Pop! or Ubuntu distro instead of having to trust some stranger's spin of Arch to get full hardware support, or do it all myself.
You had me curious, now you have me interested.
I will investigate the system76. I need something with ECC, ideally with a AMD Zen3 too.
The Gentoo wiki illustrates to me that Linux is about constructive solutions, not crowd sourced testing. If I have a Windows problem, I Google for the magic incantation that was inferred by a thousand desperate disparate voices. If I have a Linux problem, I learn about the components I am using, and how they are intended to behave and fit together.
* https://linux-hardware.org/ - this is where uploaded `hw-probe` results are collected and shared. It's easy to search for your exact model #/SKU and get a very detailed compatibility list, eg: https://linux-hardware.org/?probe=6677ca6be8
* Reddit is actually one of the best general sources for people talking about Linux compatibility issues, especially as most laptop OEMs don't have dedicated Linux support forums (only Framework and Lenovo do, AFAIK), so searching for "[model] linux report/review/compatibility/issues reddit" is usually a good sanity check as well.
* Oftentimes doing a search for the exact model and adding "linux bug" is the best way to get any bug reports that are in kernel, distro, or package trackers.
* IMO Notebookcheck is the best general/objective review site for laptops. While there are usually some more in-depth reviews that might give additional color on a laptop, the Notebookcheck reviews cover most of the important points with some very objective, and more importantly, standardized tests, whose results can be compared against their gigantic database of other reviews. Important things like screen quality (brightness, color gamut, PWM flicker), speaker quality (I find the percentile vs other laptops most useful there), and power usage (most importantly IMO, their WiFi v1.3 rundown test). While it's not the easiest to link to, they allow you to add comparisons to arbitrary laptop models for any of their numerical results. It's fantastic.
* Lastly, for Linux laptop compatibility in particular, I've found there a lot of documents in single developer/user's wikis, or as Github repos/gists writing up their experiences. I've done two of them myself since I found the other ones I've found to be so useful: https://github.com/lhl/linuxlaptops
This is a problem with reddit in general. For example, some variation of "how do I reduce System Data in iOS" has been asked 37,000 times. All one has to do is search. But redditors don't search.
I don't even run Arch, but in my experience, the Arch wikis for hardware support are amazing: complete, accurate, and to the point. For laptops, they start with a small table indicating what works and what does not. Then concise but precise explanations of the pain points. And whenever a fix exists, it is explained in a way that will make it work not only on Arch, but often also on other distros.
Take this very laptop for example, the X1 Carbon Gen10. The Arch wiki entry [1] has all the information found in the OP, but it cuts right to the point without any fluff. And then it adds technical explanations and workarounds.
[1] https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Lenovo_ThinkPad_X1_Carbon_(...