Arguing about the ROI of a road, education, a new shiny F35 feature, foos stamps, etc. are of course completely valid.
Neither society nor the government is one big hivemind.
There are small government advocates (who usually turn out to be cruel totalitarian dickheads), there's a new wave of young people who parrot "eat the rich" and usually turn out to be clueless idiots cosplaying as leftists, who also say things like "just pay for everything out of thin air".
It's big, it's completex, it's hard, emotions run high, there's a chance of things turning for the worse, while a lot of things are inching toward the better.
I think in almost all cases except where private markets can’t deliver (for example police, army, possibly roads), private markets will almost always use money (or resources) much better.
If you look at the projects funded by the Roosevelt New Deal (where the stated purpose of the spending was to reboot the economy and create employment, rather than chasing a particular return), a lot of them returned many, many times the government's investment. For example, the Tri-Borough Bridge, the Hoover Dam, the paintings of Jackson Pollock.
Food stamps and pension funds are a bit harder, since they mostly boil down to three arguments: ethics, crime and stability. People tend to turn to crime when they have no viable other means, so feeding them is a way to reduce crime, and crime would cost more. Also people who are desperate are more likely to revolt, which is either very costly to the government or entirely prevents them from doing other activities with positive ROI in the future. So they are cost centers, but arguably necessary.
Postal service, telephone, internet and public transit would also fall in the infrastructure category. Societal benefit is often much larger than the willingness of the individual to pay for it, so it makes sense to have them either run or subsidized by the state.
Universal healthcare can deliver positive ROI by being more effective than the private alternative. As a society we want citizens to be healthy, because healthy people are happy and productive, and don't infect other healthy people.
I completely agree that governments should regularly run and publish ROI calculations, or maybe there should be an independent watchdog that does this. And a lot of money seems to be wasted because people on all levels of government have the wrong incentives. On the other hand, one of the major reasons why the idea of governments is so widespread is that they regularly do provide positive ROI overall.
To editorialise for a moment, as I read about various public healthcare systems around the world, the diversity of systems is large, including outcomes. Almost none of them in highly developed countries are good and cheap. In these countries, healthcare is damn expensive, no matter how you do it. It's very difficult to spend less than 10% of GDP (that is huge for these countries) and have "good" healthcare.
Another topic about which academics have debated for decades: Same question as above, except primary/secondary/tertiary education.
Issue: People lose healthcare when they switch their jobs.
Solution: Have people purchase their own healthcare rather than receive it through their employer.
Issue: People don’t like their healthcare plan.
Solution: Allow individuals to choose their own healthcare plans. They know what they need far better than their employer does.
Issue: People cannot afford the healthcare plan they want.
Solutions: Stop throttling the amount of doctors who can attend medical school so that there is a sufficient supply of doctors. Higher supply will lower prices and improve outcomes. Institute outcome-based pricing schemes, i.e. providers get paid when they fix your problem. This will fix insurance companies’ and providers’ misaligned incentives; right now, their goal is to charge you as much as they can for health care and provide you as little as they can. That maximizes their margins. If they were only paid when they solved issues, I’m sure they would prioritize that.
IMO, the debate over “public” vs. “private” healthcare is a false dichotomy. The US does not have a private, free market healthcare system today, but proponents of public healthcare use the current state of it to argue against private systems, since it isn’t public. Proponents of private healthcare ignore anything that could improve the state of healthcare because they do not want to see it socialized and assume all suggestions will come in this form. The people in need of healthcare are left with poor healthcare as politicians fight imaginary healthcare dragons.
There is also a secondary issue in the healthcare discussion: prevention. Why do we have to spend so much on healthcare? It’s not like the human body spontaneously breaks down at such a fast rate. The actions we take as individuals, and as a society, cause a lot of disease. If we are concerned about healthcare prices, it is ingenuous and negligent of us to not look at what is driving our healthcare costs.
A significant amount of healthcare spending in the US takes place in the last years of life which is, indeed, just the body breaking down at a fast rate.
11.4% of medical spending on ages 0-18 (23.11% of population)
21.0% of medical spending on ages 19-44 (36.23% of population)
33.2% of medical spending on ages 45-64 (26.17% of population)
34.4% of medical spending on ages 65+ (14.5% of population)
So there is definitely more spend in older age, which makes sense, but the majority of spend is in populations I wouldn't consider old (<65). Additionally, what we consider "old" is really a reflection of average lifespan, and if we had healthier habits as a whole, maybe "old" would be older than "old" is today. By definition, old is when the body does start to break down at a fast rate, like you say, so I suppose it is tautologically true. However, I don't think it means we have to accept high healthcare costs related to that.
[1]: https://www.cms.gov/research-statistics-data-and-systems/sta...
[2]: https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2...
In much the same way that environmental costs of business operations are subsidized across society instead of being born by the business itself.
It’s also the case in most of these countries that health insurance is delivered by (highly regulated) private entities.
NHS is an outlier in that the entire system is run by the government.
It's not so good at keeping regular people healthy so that they don't need expensive care to begin with; though I'm not sure if this can be blamed on the "healthcare system" per se, versus cultural or educational factors. The average American is quite unhealthy.
It's quite bad at delivering routine care at reasonable prices. Get in a car wreck and break your leg? Want to deliver a baby at a hospital? It will get done at high standards and short wait times, but the bill if you're uninsured or underinsured will be eye-watering. This is a result of broken incentive systems surrounding healthcare in America, and probably deserves a lot of policy attention.
This is sharply contrary to figures I've seen on the outcomes of government spending.
Got a citation?
Occasionally short term deficits and endless bottomless deficits are not the same beast. The latter is simply a lazy political tool used to buy votes and further enrich the bankers.
Another third is owned by state and local governments, mutual funds, pensions, private citizens etc. That is, other US tax payers that receive benefits from the interest.
Only the last third is held by banks and foreign debt holders.
Large deficit spending may or may not be a problem. Economists and politicians are divided on the issue, but the interest generated from the debt largely goes to US taxpayers and it’s pretty well mixed across the economic spectrum (at least compared to other government economic policies).
If these deficits creates positive externalities (eg. Jobs through expansion of business, new deal program, or even as we've seen in massive programs like NREGA - increasing purchasing power through direct cash deposits). If the deficit spending puts wealth in the pockets of financial speculators, this is often a problem.
Even for external debt denominated in local currency, devaluation is always an option (though may not be attractive). It's only foreign currency denominated debt which is a problem.
If. And if they did there would be endless piles of political fodder. Politicians patting themselves on the back praising their genius. Etc.
That's not happening. Conclusion? If is generally closer to highly unlikely.
As for left pocket / right pocket those shifts have overhead. A program(s) to manage the programs. Let's consider that interest. Let's consider that too little value added to the taxpayers. In other words, the deficit is being used to perpetuate the government and the status quo, and not much more.
In theory I agree with you. Unfortunately, the reality is much different. The fact it has been normalized doesn't mean we should accept it.
As for the rest. The taxpayer is paying the interest to borriw as well. So that's a wash. Then there's the bureaucratic overhead devoted to the deficit. That's a loss.
The reality is, it's a net loss to the taxpayer. That is money is magically moving around and too little value is being delivered. Ask any taxpayer if they're getting value.
Or are you claiming that the US has been in the situation of "risky economic situation (economic depression, loss of jobs etc)" for the past 15 years?
Really? I would bet that most people don't hold their views on government spending based on anything more than a gut feeling and what the political party they support and associated media tell them.
I believe this because time and time again we see surveys that show random groups of people have a very VERY poor idea of what the actual state the economy is in, what the history of the economy is, who increased the national debt, who decreased it and when, what inflation is actually at, how to plan for current and future interest rates and house prices, who can control energy prices, etc. And most importantly (to me anyway) how wealth and income is actually distributed. These are mostly indisputable facts that we can all look up but somehow don't.
So yeah I think we as a group are mostly misguided most of the time.
If the GP is misguided, points out how and why according to the content of his post, not some general platitude about potentially misguided people that aren't relevant here.
The second half certainly wasn't directed to you, just more of a follow up as to why I wrote my original comment.
Of that, ~52% is Social Security, unemployment, and labor programs (or ~40% of the total). ~28% Medicare and other health programs (or ~23% of the total).
Military is ~11% of the total.
Interest payments are a bit over 4% of the total.
International affairs is <1% of the total budget.
https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...
https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/what-every-american-shoul...
ACA is a great example. Most of the core tenets are widely supported across the population. But, ask conservatives about the ACA by name and they often claim it's an awful law.
Contrariwise on abortion it doesn’t matter whether you call it abortion, choice, life, murder, or whatever else, the divide in opinions remains.
Federally, some kind of "welfare" comprises 60% of the budget[0]. Sure, you could argue that Social Security and Medicare are benefits paid for by what you put in during your working years, but that's just a facade over the fact that it is a transfer of wealth from those who are working to those who have retired from work.
I'm not sure what your definition of "vastly" is, but certainly there is a substantial amount of transfers from those who earn more to those who earn less. All of this is separate from a discussion on whether that is good for society, but the facts should be laid out.
The common trope is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_queen
Shit, last I checked IIRC most people don't even understand how marginal tax rates work, which is something that directly affects most of them, is relevant every single year, and that is pretty easy to understand.
It's a miracle our democracy works even as well as it does. But, these results shouldn't be surprising, when you think about it—the average Christian, for example, hardly knows a thing about the belief system they claim holds the key to eternal life(!!!), which you'd think they might take super seriously and study with fervor, but most apparently do not. Why would we expect people to understand government any better than that?
Slow-moving train wrecks are still train wrecks.
If you're not worried about the long-term consequences of both the fiscal and monetary policy of the United States, I don't know what to say. M2 to the moon.
Shipping gold is expensive and risky, eventually they’ll start saying, “you own this amount of the gold we have stored safely”. The abstractions find a way…
Leaders have been debasing currencies since forever.
That said, if the US were in a better financial situation, how would 1-2% inflation (as far as I can tell, this roughly the rate that gold is currently being extracted) lead to people starving in the US?
Obviously, reality is much more complicated, but I just want to understand the reasoning. Assume 0% inflation if you prefer.
The problem is that pegging a currency to gold does not peg inflation. Inflation will still move around based on other economic factors. You will have just eliminated your best tool for influencing it.
If you needed to adjust a currency pegged to gold, you'd have to get more people working in the mines. Which is either not possible, or a human rights violation.
This is called a deflationary spiral. Basically every period of significant deflation in the past has led to dire economic consequences. You really do not want people to stop spending money.
https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/macroec...
Deflationary spirals have happened in the past, but they have stopped since we moved away from the gold standard and we can now intentionally inflate our currency to prevent deflation.
In today's inflation economy, there are tons of tons of businesses that on paper make a profit, but in reality don't create value because that profit is worth less than the numbers tell. And what's worse: Individuals are becoming poorer and poorer without realizing it, because the nominal value of their pay check might be higher, though the value of the money is probably half of what it was 10 years ago.
And as individuals adapt their lifestyle and spending to circumstances we arrive at the ridiculous situation of today, where most young people after maybe a decade of working and advancing their careers still don't own a home, still don't have any children, and don't dream of splurging on luxurious hobbies.
Thank God there is a huge trend right now with workers of all "collars" saying "fuck it" and doing what they can to change companies, change careers, change cities and change countries to get as much as possible for themselves instead of continuing to be exploited.
If it were just so simple that a “real business” could merely adjust everyone’s wage to balance the books when revenue drop, you would be the world’s most coveted CEO that could save any company.
It ain’t that simple. Businesses make capital expenditures. There’s also often a time gap between incurring costs and incurring revenue.
You need to understand economics as the metabolism of a larger organism.
This isn't just a hypothetical argument, it is reality. Let's take the digital device you're reading this with as an example. It's not created by any single craftsman. It is the result of millions of people's work. It is a "metabolite" of a larger organism.
You are a node or cell in a larger thing. Everything you know and can do is largely tailored to this system you're currently in.
Consider you are time-teleported back 10,000 years and come across a tribe of humans. Who would be more valuable to whom? Is your understanding of any of the technologies you presently enjoy sufficient enough to reproduce from scratch? Maybe a couple things, but they would most likely have a lot more to teach you than you'd be able to teach them.
I realize the above is very abstract from monetary policy, but the correct premise needs to be set before digging down.
Once you model economics as the metabolism of a larger entity, money reveals its true nature: to control what activities are performed by / within the organism.
There's no such thing as "intrinsic value" -- there is only a medium of exchange or signaling. This signal should not be tied to any physical thing, as that is inefficient to the state of an economy. There are better ways. Imaginary units are a more powerful tool, as they are not constrained by any physical limits.
You may be upset at how these IU's are currently handled, and rightfully so. The current methodology we have is very primitive. Our experts themselves (head of the Fed, treasury) readily admit this. When they take actions they "think" or "expect" it will have this or that effect. And the levers they pull are also very blunt.
When CBDCs come online, then we will start to realize a better economy. They will allow more granular control of things.
I won't argue that imaginary units of money are a powerful tool, they certainly are. So powerful in fact that there is no human on this earth who can be trusted to administer it without rampant abuse. The history of centralized planned economies speaks for itself, and I don't think further consolidation under CBDCs with more 'granular control' is going to improve its track record. The physical limits that constrain the use of commodities as money are what make it a viable as currency, it's a feature not a bug
I think that if people increasingly wanted to use cryptocurrency over dollars, the Fed would nevertheless be able to maintain the value of the dollar even as they got less common. Eventually the currency would disappear when the last dollar was traded to the Fed to pay off the last dollar-denominated bond, and I think dollars could maintain their value until that happened, even as the government started collecting taxes in other currencies.
> Is it legal for a business in the United States to refuse cash as a form of payment?
> There is no federal statute mandating that a private business, a person, or an organization must accept currency or coins as payment for goods or services. Private businesses are free to develop their own policies on whether to accept cash unless there is a state law that says otherwise.
In the future as the workforce shrinks and liabilities increase I imagine deficit spending will regularly exceed tax revenues.
Only because enough people believe that's true, and then only because there are aircraft carriers that convince people in other countries that it's in their best interest to use them.
Dollars are not worth anything.
Makes sense, but I do need to think about it.
That said, on the weekend I did listen to a podcast where at one point taxes were (indirectly) described as behaviour modification.
re: The right gov response...
In theory yes, but only if the system's purpose is to maximize the benefit to all. On the other hand, if the system's purpose is to tilt the game to favor the few then responses can take many forms, as long as they enforce the tilt. A simple graph of income inequality and wealth distribution tells us all we need to know.
I wouldn't say it's the purpose, since banks are better at extending loans than the government such that losses are minimized, but getting first dibs on newly created money, and taking a small cut of it, is an incredible privilege.
Just wait until you hear about this thing called the law and the police force...
For example, when the government introduces laws that prevent underage children from working, they do behaviour modification and they will even outright admit it and they won't even think they are wrong. Really insidious stuff, if you ask me.
The fact is, the act isn't that innocent.
Yes the govt has created a moral hazard where they can always just create more money to solve a problem, but inserting a ponzi scheme does not fix that
What do I get out of it?
If you want to live in a society were the banks and wealthy individuals can make significant income by doing literally nothing, that is fine, but the rest of us would like to live in a world where goods and services are produced at a rate similar to how they are produced today.
Young people who have worked hard their whole lives cannot afford a home to start a family. In what way does "the economy" function?
> If you want to live in a society were the banks and wealthy individuals can make significant income by doing literally nothing
You just described exactly how current society works.
Imagine if you went to a grocery store and it was completely empty. That is the situation in Haiti currently. That is a nonfunctional economy.
Functional does not mean that everyone has everything they want at the price they want.
It's like a sheep farmer thinking he is successful because he decided to kill all lambs every spring instead of letting them grow to adults. Sure, the meat tastes nice now, but he has destroyed his future for short term gains.
> Functional does not mean that everyone has everything they want at the price they want.
Nobody is demanding anything close to that, people want the basic necessities and have no way of getting them. Or should they just keep working hard and be grateful that they're not in Haiti.
The absolute best thing a young, enterprising person from a Western country can do today is to move out of that hemisphere and establish themselves in another country. That step gives a massive increase in quality of life, as well as a much better prospects for the future.
When there is deflation you do nothing. You don't even go to work. You don't even look at your bank account or the money. You don't think about it. You just wait and do nothing. It is the equivalent of taking a drug that makes you feel good. You won't find the need to actually accomplish anything.
If there is inflation, then banks actually have to do their bank related tasks to earn the money, people actually have to sit at their desks.
This is not a tiny 1% of the population. I would wager that most people reading this thread has at least one person among their friends or family who live a good life without having contributed much to the economy, or even having never contributed anything at all. Riding the wave of inflation in real estate.
Tell me again why I and others should contribute to the economy to support these people's lifestyle?
What you are talking about is something different, some sort of work police or something that forces everyone to work the same amount or something like that.
What's this statement based on?
As a thought experiment, say a load of survivors wash upon a deserted island, eventually settling into economic roles. I don't think their economy or productivity grinds to a halt because there isn't enough liquid currency. They are constrained by their access and production of real world resources.
But if the island became connected to a trading route he could trade excess fish for gold or another non perishable asset, he could store up those assets. But he would only do that if he believed that those assets had liquidity.
Sounds like his problem is lack of demand, not currency liquidity.
> But if the island became connected to a trading route he could trade excess fish for gold or another non perishable asset, he could store up those assets. But he would only do that if he believed that those assets had liquidity.
Ok, but that kind of breaks the island economy experiment, given that he was already trading fish in a closed system for some other good or currency.
When you have a large number of goods and services available you need a medium of exchange that has good liquidity.
The other piece that folks often conflate to extrapolate their intuition of how a household or a small business budget operates to how a country budget operates (the comment above on instant gratification). As a household, if you face a risky economic situation (economic depression, loss of jobs etc), the natural response is to reduce spending and increase savings. If you aggregate across households at a country level, this leads to lower demand, so reduction in jobs as less consumption which leads to further economic downturn, reduction in willingness of banks to lend, lower government income (as lower taxes) etc. The right government response is to spend more countercyclically and help create jobs to spur back demand through deficit spending. Then as economy improves, tax receipts go up and deficit goes down.