News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:22AM (#35340624)
It is possible to have too much of a good thing. If you limit inflation too much, you grind the economy to a halt and people starve.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by dmpk2k on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:41AM (#35340901)
At this point you are probably correct.

That said, if the US were in a better financial situation, how would 1-2% inflation (as far as I can tell, this roughly the rate that gold is currently being extracted) lead to people starving in the US?

Obviously, reality is much more complicated, but I just want to understand the reasoning. Assume 0% inflation if you prefer.

Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @10:33AM (#35341771)
2% is a healthy level, which is why it's the Fed's target.

The problem is that pegging a currency to gold does not peg inflation. Inflation will still move around based on other economic factors. You will have just eliminated your best tool for influencing it.

If you needed to adjust a currency pegged to gold, you'd have to get more people working in the mines. Which is either not possible, or a human rights violation.

Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by carlosjobim on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @10:42AM (#35341917)
There's no reason for that. As production improves in efficiency it is natural for things and services to become cheaper. That also means you get more for your money, instead of getting more money. That concept is not too strange for the population to accept.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @10:59AM (#35342163)
For a few items in your CPI basket, that's fine. If you have significant deflation across your economy on average, people will start losing their jobs en masse, and zero dollars doesn't buy anything.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by carlosjobim on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:20PM (#35344578)
Why should that be the case? As I said, if you can buy more for less you won't need a raise.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:56PM (#35345157)
Likewise, business revenues will be going down but the investments in capital have already been allocated. Businesses start laying off employees to try to balance the books. Those newly unemployed workers, in turn, now have less money to spend. More businesses find themselves in the red, and it leads to more layoffs.

This is called a deflationary spiral. Basically every period of significant deflation in the past has led to dire economic consequences. You really do not want people to stop spending money.

Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by carlosjobim on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @03:17PM (#35346367)
This sounds like a myth. If the value of your currency is increasing, staying at 0 means you're actually turning a profit, just as making a 10% profit when the inflation is 50% means you're losing money. Inflation is a tax and redistribution of wealth, it's really not more complicated.
Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @03:59PM (#35346957)
Zero isn’t bad. I was explicitly talking about deflation above. The effects of deflation I explained above is not a myth, it is introductory macroeconomics.

https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/macroec...

Deflationary spirals have happened in the past, but they have stopped since we moved away from the gold standard and we can now intentionally inflate our currency to prevent deflation.

Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by carlosjobim on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @04:34PM (#35347422)
If you have a real business, you're still increasing value in the equation or breaking even. Deflation means you might have to lower wages, but your employees are still getting the same value paid. It means you might have to lower prices, but you're still getting the same value sold. It also means your costs are lowering, so as long as you have a value-adding business you will beat deflation. If not, then you shouldn't be in business.

In today's inflation economy, there are tons of tons of businesses that on paper make a profit, but in reality don't create value because that profit is worth less than the numbers tell. And what's worse: Individuals are becoming poorer and poorer without realizing it, because the nominal value of their pay check might be higher, though the value of the money is probably half of what it was 10 years ago.

And as individuals adapt their lifestyle and spending to circumstances we arrive at the ridiculous situation of today, where most young people after maybe a decade of working and advancing their careers still don't own a home, still don't have any children, and don't dream of splurging on luxurious hobbies.

Thank God there is a huge trend right now with workers of all "collars" saying "fuck it" and doing what they can to change companies, change careers, change cities and change countries to get as much as possible for themselves instead of continuing to be exploited.

Re:For the First Time, the Fed Is Losing Money by kube-system on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @05:33PM (#35348229)
This is not something economists disagree upon. All periods of any significant deflation anywhere and at any time were accompanied by economic recession or depression.

If it were just so simple that a “real business” could merely adjust everyone’s wage to balance the books when revenue drop, you would be the world’s most coveted CEO that could save any company.

It ain’t that simple. Businesses make capital expenditures. There’s also often a time gap between incurring costs and incurring revenue.