News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by radu_floricica on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:30PM (#35330408)
That's our excuse, but in practice when you find yourself swiping left simply because they're not the right age only 5 minutes after you set the age filter, you start wondering if maybe there's a difference between your stated and revealed preferences. I know I do.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:43PM (#35330591)
> but in practice when you find yourself swiping left simply because they're not the right age only 5 minutes after you set the age filter, you start wondering if maybe there's a difference between your stated and revealed preferences.

Meh…

I almost always set a really wide band on age on dating apps. The catch is that the folks at the extremes have to be exceptional in one or more ways in order to get a positive reaction from me.

Typically it’s:

- Really young people (I’m in the middle aged dating pool) have to show some maturity — I don’t want to date a kid, and I don’t want to date someone with a daddy complex.

- Older ladies need to show some youthfulness. Some people have clearly given up in middle age in terms of taking care of themselves and doing interesting things. I’m not interested in these folks — they seem like they have one foot in the grave to me.

For reference, my dating range has been -15 to +7, so I don’t think I’m being overly narrow in my band. That said, most of my dates are in the -5 to -10 range.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by Nifty3929 on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:42PM (#35331350)
>> The catch is that the folks at the extremes have to be exceptional in one or more ways in order to get a positive reaction from me.

I think this is the crux of the issue - we don't have absolute, binary requirements, we have weighted preferences. "He's a bit older, but then again he looks youthful. OTOH he doesn't have any hobbies. But then again we're aligned politically. Okay, I'll chance it."

A better way would be to allow you to set these weights and have a scoring system, and then you can set a numerical threshold.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:57AM (#35336104)
>A better way would be to allow you to set these weights and have a scoring system, and then you can set a numerical threshold.

That would be great, but it won't work. Too many people will answer questions incorrectly or not at all, and almost no one will be able to even use the app effectively even if the app designers implemented it. And I have no confidence the app developers would even be able to implement it properly.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by mock-possum on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:47PM (#35331421)
Yep that’s where I’m at too, more or less - I’ve given up on imposing strict boundaries on potential matches, I just meet people and see if I like them. One of my buddies is real outraged about it, she thinks I’m wasting people’s time, but I don’t see it that way - I’m consistently surprised at who I end up vibing with, and i don’t know how to set rules for myself that would still allow me to meet those people, while excluding everyone else with no potential. I’d rather just try stuff on and see what fits.

At this point the best I can do for ‘my type’ is weirdos who like me.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:16PM (#35331834)
> I’m consistently surprised at who I end up vibing with, and i don’t know how to set rules for myself that would still allow me to meet those people, while excluding everyone else with no potential. I’d rather just try stuff on and see what fits.

Great observation.

I’m basically a “look at profile, send a dm of interesting, schedule a meeting if they reply” type of guy.

The first few minutes of a “coffee date” tells me more about the person than any amount of detailed profile or DMing can.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:58AM (#35336118)
I mostly like this approach too, but the main problem I've found is that I've frequently found that I wished I could end the date within 5 minutes, and feel like I've wasted my time. But I couldn't tell this before actually meeting them in person, and I haven't found a way of gracefully aborting the date early.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @06:48PM (#35349162)
Schedule something immediately after.

It’s easy to leave if you want, and it’s also easy to make it clear that you’re interested in spending more time together.

“Hey, I’m meeting some friends at 6. I really enjoyed talking with you today. Would you like to go to $ACTIVITY on $DATE?”

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:50PM (#35350481)
Huh? No, I'm asking how to end a date very quickly because it's immediately obvious that it won't work out. I don't want to make up an excuse and then schedule something later, and then contact them afterwards and say I can't make it: that's lying.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:18PM (#35350733)
That’s not what I was suggesting.

Plan of action:

1. Schedule date #1 (e.g., at 5pm at a coffeehouse).

2. Schedule anything else at 5:30pm or 6pm. This can be date #2, something with friends, or even just a phone call to someone (like a friend from high school or a dear relative). No need to lie.

3. If date doesn’t work out, just announce your scheduled plan and dip. You might not get out at 5 minutes, but you can get out at 15-30 minutes easily.

4. If date does work out, you can reschedule your plan from point 2 (at 5:30 or 6) and extend date #1. Or you can end date #1 as scheduled and just give positive vibes about round two with that person.

Dating, especially online dating, is a numbers game. You have to figure out how to meet (potentially) a lot of people, ideally in a short period of time.

When I was doing online dating, I typically scheduled 3-4 first dates a day on weekends, or 2-3 first dates on weekdays (again, these were just “get to know you” dates). Most second dates were the only date that day, and third dates were almost always designed for intimate outcomes (in my dating area, you run a serious risk of getting ghosted if the romance isn’t happening by then).

I do have to ask, are you male or female? I’m a male, and I’m not sure how this might be different for females — possibly a very different dynamic.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:09AM (#35354522)
I see now, thanks!

I'm male BTW. However, in my locale and age range, it seems like women are not so keen to get to the intimate outcome stage by the 3rd date.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @12:48PM (#35359844)
May I ask where you are?

Your name is made of Japanese words. Is it Japan?

If you are in Japan, then I think romance should be a goal on the second date if the women are over college age (22).

There are very few inhibitions about sex in Japan (in my experience), and most Japanese women I have dated seem to think it’s difficult to find partners who are keenly interested in romance.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Thursday March 30, 2023 @12:11AM (#35367854)
I'm in Japan. But I'm not dating women in their 20s. It seems like older women are only interested in long-term relationships, which is understandable of course, but it's quite different from women in their late 20s being happy to go to a love hotel on the 2nd or 3rd date. Maybe I'm missing something.

I'm not complaining really, but every time I read stuff about women here not having many inhibitions about sex and sex being really commonplace, I feel like I'm in an alternate universe because that just isn't my experience, but again, I'm not dating women in their 20s any more so I think there's probably a big generational difference.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by csa on Thursday March 30, 2023 @03:23AM (#35369260)
I think that there may be some specifics that matter (that I may have glossed over).

Note that this is talking mostly about women in their 30s, but also women in their late 20s and early 40s:

- If you’re doing omiai or some proxy thereof, then the push to committing to long term relationships is real. Sex is not really a goal with that process.

- It’s important to know if the date event is known by her family and friends or not. If so, that’s almost like omiai (esp. for women in their 30s), and it puts a lot of pressure on the two of you. They will be questioned non-stop about the date. It’s really unhealthy, imho.

- It’s important to be able to hang out in a place where their friends and family are not likely to find out about the date. This takes a lot of pressure off the woman. This is easy to do in places like Tokyo, but maybe not as easy in towns and smaller cities.

- It’s important to have your own place, imho. It can be awkward and less easy if the guy lives with his parents. Love hotels are nice sometimes, but they are not good for a regular thing, imho.

- Many/most of the Japanese women I dated definitely looked for early commitment, but you have to take that with a grain of salt. Most of them just don’t want to be used for sex only (although some do seek that out), and that’s understandable. That said, you can set reasonable expectations (e.g., “i’m really enjoying getting to know you, and I look forward to more”), and break it off if and when it doesn’t seem right for you.

- I’m not sure if you are Japanese or gaijin, and if gaijin, where you are from. Some nationalities are less popular and/or have very narrow groups who are interested in them. Just find someone like you who has game, and try to do what they do. If you are gaijin, make sure you Japanese is on point. Japan is a very different place (mostly better, imho) when you can speak Japanese.

- Related, go with your friends to places where people go with their friends to unwind and have fun. I have found it very easy to meet people like that — inhibitions are down.

Anyway, best of luck!

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by FalconSensei on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @05:14PM (#35363764)
> it seems like women are not so keen to get to the intimate outcome stage by the 3rd date

At the same time, they might be thinking that you are not getting romantically involved enough, sharing details about yourself, or moving on a direction of an exclusive relationship.

Maybe they are not yet comfortable/intimate enough with you for sex. Maybe you are setting unrealistic expectations based on people you are meeting, and how you are acting during the dates.

Also, don't want to offend you but... WTF? There's no obligation in someone having sex with you just because they've seen you 3 times.

Maybe try to be more forthcoming about your true intentions (sexual relationship instead or romantic), or go to places where people go for hookups (pubs/bars/clubs).

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by daniel_reetz on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:53PM (#35330736)
Profound statement. Online dating reveals a whole lot to a careful self-observer- most of it quite uncomfortable or counter to self-image. I'd bet there are many analogs in advertising and other surveillance/tracking heavy industries. "They say they want this, but they consistently click on that"...
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by MuffinFlavored on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:59PM (#35330824)
What would the online dating scene look like if apps let people filter by:

* race / ethnicity / religion

* weight / body type / body measurements

* height

* income / salary / net worth / debt

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#35330897)
OKCupid back in the day gave you most of those knobs, but they got removed eventually.

The problem with spreadsheet-style filtering of humans is that in the real world that's not how you fall in love with someone. Someone can be too short, too chubby, of the "wrong" religion or political affiliation, but you still fall in love with them because of their energy, their warmth, their selflessness, their consistency, their presence and so on.

In theory more knobs = more better, but in practice I suspect it backfires by going against the grain of an authentic human mating experience. I can't imagine anything good coming out of the self-commodification and self-objectification that apps push us towards, even as someone who has more than extensive experience playing that game.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by Teever on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:24PM (#35331955)
I was under the impression that the reason that the UI of OKCupid has been radically dumbed down is because it was bought by the Match group who wanted the app to look and act more like the rest of their apps.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by erenyeager on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:26PM (#35331986)
This is backwards to human history. marriage within the tribe, caste, religion, etc. was preferred. The “knobs” were set by the families and matchmakers. The “love” marriage is more of an anomaly. Rather I’d say many people can make a relationship work and love is effort, not just “click”.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:32PM (#35332087)
I actually agree with you if we look at this throughout the entire human history. Mating and romance being a necessary pairing seems like a recent phenomenon, the last 200 years or so?
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by closeparen on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:02PM (#35332576)
It is possible for humans to survive and even overcome the hardship of effortfully maintaining loveless marriages, just as we can muddle through prison sentences or battles with cancer. People who needed partners in order to meet basic material needs just had to suck it up. In 2023, there is no reason to marry someone without profound and mutual love, and high confidence in the security and durability of that love. The horrifying, life-ruining, soul-eating catastrophe of loveless marriage is what makes it so beautiful and profound when people do chose to get married. That they feel confident enough to take that risk. It is a heartwarming display of optimism and faith.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:10PM (#35332681)
Yes, however, I suspect that (in the 21st century bourgeois West) we underestimate the ability for two people to learn to love each other profoundly in the context of an arranged marriage where choice is removed from them.

I'd love to see statistics showing how longitudinal life satisfaction compares between societies where marriages are arranged and where there is total freedom of marriage partner choice.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by fsckboy on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:58PM (#35432529)
every culture through history has told love stories, so it simply couldn't have been that unusual. in a tribe or small town, for example, you've been together since you were kids, so even if your marriage was arranged, the arrangers knew the landscape. It's a lot easier to make an arrangement with the arrangees are not pissing and moaning.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:49AM (#35336444)
>Someone can be too short, too chubby, of the "wrong" religion or political affiliation, but you still fall in love with them because of their energy, their warmth, their selflessness, their consistency, their presence and so on.

Right, and then you get married to them, and then after years of constant fighting, you get divorced because you just weren't compatible in the first place, and those fundamental problems never went away despite all the feel-good emotions you had.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by tric on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#35330960)
> height

I know that some of these apps allow for minimum height requirements. People don't like it went you suggest apps add width requirements in response.

Even if it's not explicitly a metric on the app, many people will say they have a min. height req. in their profile.

> income / salary / net worth / debt

I also seem to remember okcupid having some kind of education requirement, or heavily emphasized education.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:11PM (#35331770)
I find it sociologically fascinating that it’s perfectly acceptable for women to say “don’t you dare swipe right if you’re under 6’” on these sites, but you will get banned immediately if you ask for a minimum cup size or a maximum weight limit, because that’s body shaming.

I suppose it’s a reflection of which side of the marketplace is much harder to retain.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by CuriouslyC on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:06PM (#35330916)
They already let you do that, but via using different dating services. JDate, WooPlus, EliteSingles, etc.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by wodenokoto on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:42PM (#35331347)
I wish I could hide their age. Instead I can pay to hide my own. Sigh.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by opportune on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:13PM (#35331790)
Dating apps have minimum allowed age ranges. So a lot of people probably do this but only because they can’t set a smaller range.

You may think 4 years is plenty wide for most people, but as a 26 year old male I really only am interested in eg 24-26 or even 25-26. There is also an “Elo”/mmr aspect where even if you are ok with dating someone 27-28, the reality of dating is that those women users will reject you at much higher rates than in 25-26, so including them in your range will lower the frequency with which you’re presented even to women that you do want to date due to lowering your “MMR”.

Agreed with other commenters that there are weighted preferences. While I may be ok seeing 22 or 23 year olds and in principle open to dating people in that range, in practice the rate of people I want to date in that range is much lower (but not 0). Same with people older than me.

I’d say including people beyond your actually revealed preferences actually indicates that you are open minded, assuming there are at least some people in that cohort that you are actually interested in, because it shows that you are willing to go through a much higher reject rate to find people who you are interested in.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by JohnFen on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:07PM (#35332645)
> Dating apps have minimum allowed age ranges.

It's been a long time since I've used dating apps, but when I used them, you could set any arbitrary upper and lower age boundaries. Has this changed?