News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by MuffinFlavored on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:59PM (#35330824)
What would the online dating scene look like if apps let people filter by:

* race / ethnicity / religion

* weight / body type / body measurements

* height

* income / salary / net worth / debt

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:04PM (#35330897)
OKCupid back in the day gave you most of those knobs, but they got removed eventually.

The problem with spreadsheet-style filtering of humans is that in the real world that's not how you fall in love with someone. Someone can be too short, too chubby, of the "wrong" religion or political affiliation, but you still fall in love with them because of their energy, their warmth, their selflessness, their consistency, their presence and so on.

In theory more knobs = more better, but in practice I suspect it backfires by going against the grain of an authentic human mating experience. I can't imagine anything good coming out of the self-commodification and self-objectification that apps push us towards, even as someone who has more than extensive experience playing that game.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by Teever on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:24PM (#35331955)
I was under the impression that the reason that the UI of OKCupid has been radically dumbed down is because it was bought by the Match group who wanted the app to look and act more like the rest of their apps.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by erenyeager on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:26PM (#35331986)
This is backwards to human history. marriage within the tribe, caste, religion, etc. was preferred. The “knobs” were set by the families and matchmakers. The “love” marriage is more of an anomaly. Rather I’d say many people can make a relationship work and love is effort, not just “click”.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:32PM (#35332087)
I actually agree with you if we look at this throughout the entire human history. Mating and romance being a necessary pairing seems like a recent phenomenon, the last 200 years or so?
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by closeparen on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:02PM (#35332576)
It is possible for humans to survive and even overcome the hardship of effortfully maintaining loveless marriages, just as we can muddle through prison sentences or battles with cancer. People who needed partners in order to meet basic material needs just had to suck it up. In 2023, there is no reason to marry someone without profound and mutual love, and high confidence in the security and durability of that love. The horrifying, life-ruining, soul-eating catastrophe of loveless marriage is what makes it so beautiful and profound when people do chose to get married. That they feel confident enough to take that risk. It is a heartwarming display of optimism and faith.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:10PM (#35332681)
Yes, however, I suspect that (in the 21st century bourgeois West) we underestimate the ability for two people to learn to love each other profoundly in the context of an arranged marriage where choice is removed from them.

I'd love to see statistics showing how longitudinal life satisfaction compares between societies where marriages are arranged and where there is total freedom of marriage partner choice.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by fsckboy on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:58PM (#35432529)
every culture through history has told love stories, so it simply couldn't have been that unusual. in a tribe or small town, for example, you've been together since you were kids, so even if your marriage was arranged, the arrangers knew the landscape. It's a lot easier to make an arrangement with the arrangees are not pissing and moaning.
Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by midoridensha on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:49AM (#35336444)
>Someone can be too short, too chubby, of the "wrong" religion or political affiliation, but you still fall in love with them because of their energy, their warmth, their selflessness, their consistency, their presence and so on.

Right, and then you get married to them, and then after years of constant fighting, you get divorced because you just weren't compatible in the first place, and those fundamental problems never went away despite all the feel-good emotions you had.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by tric on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#35330960)
> height

I know that some of these apps allow for minimum height requirements. People don't like it went you suggest apps add width requirements in response.

Even if it's not explicitly a metric on the app, many people will say they have a min. height req. in their profile.

> income / salary / net worth / debt

I also seem to remember okcupid having some kind of education requirement, or heavily emphasized education.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:11PM (#35331770)
I find it sociologically fascinating that it’s perfectly acceptable for women to say “don’t you dare swipe right if you’re under 6’” on these sites, but you will get banned immediately if you ask for a minimum cup size or a maximum weight limit, because that’s body shaming.

I suppose it’s a reflection of which side of the marketplace is much harder to retain.

Re:Online daters are less open-minded than their filters sug... by CuriouslyC on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:06PM (#35330916)
They already let you do that, but via using different dating services. JDate, WooPlus, EliteSingles, etc.