News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by heavyset_go on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:44AM (#35311410)
I feel like this is a response to the exponential popularity of sites like r/exmormon among younger generations. For example, look at these exceptions. It seems like organic, unapproved discussion between users is what the bill is trying to stifle:

> (D) news, sports, entertainment, or other content that is preselected by the provider and not user generated, ... (Q) to permit comments on a digital news website, if the news content is posted only by the provider of the digital news website,

If this law was in place when I was growing up, my life would probably look very different, and not for the better. My interests, hobbies, profession, my sense of humor etc, all have deep roots in the online communities I participated as a kid. More importantly, those communities gave me a sense of hope when I didn't have much.

Parental approval does nothing to stop the real harm that social media can cause, nor does this bill provide incentives for platforms to improve past that potential for harm. It's about ensuring that kids aren't exposed to their peers, or ideas, that might disagree with what their parents believe.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by deepGem on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:35AM (#35311690)
+1. As an Indian kid growing up in a very conservative family/neighborhood I can attest that what I have learned and have helped me in becoming successful was all through my peers and books (mostly fiction). If I had no access to those and had purely followed what my parents prescribed, I would have been a very different individual and most likely, would not have pursued computer science. More than anything, succees or otherwise, peer learning and learning on my own was and still continues to be the emblem of freedom.

There surely is a downside to this, that this self learning can veer you off in a sub optimal direction of laziness, procrastination, lost concentration etc, as experienced in today's social media. However, it's better to bet the odds on freedom of individuals than on oversight.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by thrwwy27464 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:00AM (#35311838)
It always is about control.

Fox News ain't that popular anymore, so they need to ensure its popularity among the folks who believe in the right-wing media. Conspiracy theories don't sell that well anymore due to Russian propaganda, so the republicans must ensure their control again.

PS: A lot of democracies decided to have a two-vote system to try to prevent that from happening, so they have a direct candidate vote + an additional party vote.

The US lacks behind in its electoral system. The voting system is rigged from the start, because of how much of the population lives at the coast compared to the population of the mid/north-west (which coincidentally are more republican in nature of historical vote results).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electoral_system_of_Germany

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_France

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_party_strength_in_U....

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by transcoderx on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:11AM (#35313625)
Fox News makes the laws in Utah?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by morbia on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:57AM (#35312162)
Gay guy here.

I have always said that these sort of laws designed to protect children will do precisely the opposite. An LGBTQ child is effectively forcibly outed by this law, potentially before they've come to terms with their sexuality / gender themselves.

Whilst I don't doubt social media causes a lot of harm on children growing up, giving parents full access to your messages is not the solution. In my opinion, based off a scale of a child's age and maturity, children are entitled to some privacy. Clearly a 4 year old shouldn't be left alone with unfettered access to the Internet, but equally a 16 year old shouldn't have to feel like their parents are watching everything they do or say. Both can cause long term psychological harm to a child.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by watwut on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:51AM (#35312439)
They are not designed to protect kids. There is always campaign designed to elicit fear and contempt and then they take controlling laws.

Talking about it as if safety was a goal instead of control is just falling into their lie.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by xboxnolifes on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:16AM (#35312864)
It's never about the kids protection/rights. Kids don't vote, parents do. Nearly every proposed law marketed as protecting kids is actually about increasing parent or state control over kids.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by nine_k on Sunday March 26, 2023 @06:50AM (#35313062)
It's always important to remember that the tools that enable freedom, like voting, can be used against freedom, if enough of the population does not value it.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by pjc50 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:18AM (#35314116)
Yes. This should be seen in the context of the huge set of anti-trans laws and the Florida book banning. There is going to be another attempt at making it illegal for kids to hear about non-straight people at all. And outing kids to their parents, even at risk of violence, is a part of that.

The "land of free speech" always has a big "not you" exemption that can be wielded against people who aren't WASPy enough.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:08PM (#35317508)
> The "land of free speech" always has a big "not you" exemption that can be wielded against people who aren't WASPy enough

WASPs are the ones pushing pornographic books in schools. Florida is one of the most diverse states in the country.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by pjc50 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:17PM (#35317605)
Neither of those things are true? The books being banned are not pornographic?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:10PM (#35318292)
“WASP” has the specific connotation of northeastern white people of longstanding American lineage. (The term typically excludes southern and Appalachian whites that technically also are Anglo Saxon and Protestant.) Those people are the vanguard of social liberalism today, in states like Massachusetts and Connecticut.

In Florida, meanwhile, non-Hispanic whites are just 51% of the population (versus 65-70% in Massachusetts and Connecticut). And the white people who are there aren’t really “WASPs” in the typical sense of the word. DeSantis, of course, isn’t a WASP at all. He’s a Catholic. American social conservatism is primarily a coalition of southern whites, “ethnic whites” (German, Italian, and Irish), and Hispanics—none of whom were traditionally considered “WASPs.”

The books are absolutely pornographic: https://www.ibtimes.sg/texas-school-sparks-outrage-after-mom.... They contain graphic depictions of underage people engaged in sex acts.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by throwaway-blaze on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:46PM (#35318740)
The graphic depiction of underage people engaged in sex acts is against federal law and most likely Texas law as well. It is baffling to me how the media depicts this as "anti trans" or "anti lgbt" book banning while managing to never mention the specifics of the books.

I'm about as liberal as they come on social issues. But I don't think these books are appropriate in an elementary or middle school library.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:11PM (#35319687)
> It is baffling to me how the media depicts this as "anti trans" or "anti lgbt" book banning while managing to never mention the specifics of the books.

It’s because a lot of people are using marginalized people as a pretext for encouraging kids in general to explore their sexuality.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:28PM (#35329568)
Are all the books being banned pornographic? Is this a way for people to get some books that maybe should be banned but then go after books where gays and trans people are shown in a positive light?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Monday March 27, 2023 @06:11PM (#35333473)
It’s specifically a reaction to the American Library Association giving “Gender Queer” one of its top awards for the age 12-18 category. It revealed that the librarians teaching your kids are a lot more progressive about kids exploring their sexuality than even Obama-voting parents who support equal civil rights but still hold traditional beliefs about sex being shameful and something children should be protected from. That’s why republicans were able to leverage the issue in places like Florida and Virginia—places that often swing blue due to large Hispanic and Asian populations, who also happen to be pretty conservative on sexual issues.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:03PM (#35334423)
" It revealed that the librarians teaching your kids are a lot more progressive about kids exploring their sexuality than even Obama-voting parents w"

Source? I ask because I didn't know librarians teach kids

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:06PM (#35334923)
Do you have a kid (or remember being one)? We had scheduled trips to the library and librarians were actively involved in recommending books, both to individuals and in terms of reading lists.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:16AM (#35336221)
I don't but let me back up, I'm not doubting that happened. Can you provide a source for when a librarian taught sexed or something along those lines to kids?

How does banning books fix this? Was the person following the library's guidelines?

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:49AM (#35336447)
My third grader came home with a Pride sticker. To be clear, we have always told her that "sometimes kids have two mommies or two daddies and that's okay." But Pride also is wrapped up in a general positive and open attitude about sexuality that is inconsistent with my values. And frankly I don't trust my kids' liberal white teachers to talk about these subjects. There's clearly a huge disconnect between their values and my values.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @04:17AM (#35337387)
"It revealed that the librarians teaching your kids are a lot more progressive about kids exploring their sexuality "

And your proof is that your kid had a pride sticker which is about gay rights but you attribute to being open about sexuality

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:53AM (#35340156)
In a country where same sex marriage is already the law of the land, and has overwhelming public support, you think that there’s not a high degree of overlap between Pride and those who have liberal attitudes on sex for other reasons? As a racial minority I can tell you that the people organizing marches on that basis typically have views that are much more radical than protecting interracial marriage.

Half the country thinks it’s okay for teenagers to have sex and another half thinks it’s immoral: https://news.gallup.com/poll/393515/americans-say-birth-cont.... You think the teachers who send third graders home with a Pride sticker aren’t overwhelmingly in the pro-teenage sex camp? You think the folks at the American library association who gave a book with explicit depictions of underage kids having sex don’t support such conduct? How to socialize kids about sex and sexuality is a multi-faceted subject that involves sensitivities that have nothing to do with gay people. You can reduce it to that if you want but you’re left scratching your head why people who overwhelmingly support same sex marriage can also support laws to more carefully curate what books public libraries make available.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:11PM (#35364553)
"You think the teachers who send third graders home with a Pride sticker aren’t overwhelmingly in the pro-teenage sex camp"

No and prove it or shut the fuck up with bullshit "every liberal/democrat is a pedophile". Do you want to count the number of church official vs drag queens who have been arrested for child rape?

"Most child victims are abused by a parent. In 2020, a reported 483,285 perpetrators abused or neglected a child. In substantiated child abuse cases, 77% of children were victimized by a parent." Oh my god better make sure teachers don't send their kids home with pride pins, they might use it to defend against family rape.

https://www.nationalchildrensalliance.org/media-room/nationa...

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:08PM (#35334471)
Probably no one thinks it shouldn't but you are manipulating the debate by finding an example like that and ignoring books that are banned for other reasons.

Here's a list from one county https://pen.org/banned-books-florida/

I'm going to do one because I'm pretty sure I don't need to check anymore to determine that you are cherry picking.

Love to Mama: A Tribute To Mothers, by Pat Mora, Paula S. Barragán M.

"Pat Mora edited and contributed to this beautiful and celebratory collection, in which thirteen poets write with joy, humor, and love about the powerful bond between mothers, grandmothers, and children. These poets represent a wide spectrum of Latino voices, from award-winning authors to a 15-year-old new talent. They write passionately about their Puerto Rican, Cuban, Venezuelan, and Mexican American backgrounds and the undeniable influence of their mothers and grandmothers. Illustrated with exuberance by Ecuadorian artist Paula S. Barragán M.,"

They banned a valid book so you can hold it up and say what you said. In fact without these new laws I'm sure the book in question (which you didn't mention) probably wouldn't be in libraries

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:44PM (#35334762)
Nobody is "manipulating the debate." The book linked above is the most challenged book in these efforts: https://www.npr.org/2022/04/04/1090067026/efforts-to-ban-boo.... The American Library Association gave that book its Alex Award in 2020, for books for children 12-18. It's not some random book cherry-picked out of nowhere.

None of the books are "being banned." States are deciding what taxpayer-funded school libraries are making available to children. No decision has been made regarding the specific book you linked. An entire set of books approved in 2021 are being reviewed for appropriateness.

Of course valid books are going to be pulled in the meantime while the government does its review. It's like a product recall--you pull the batch while you figure out how bad stuff made it through the filter.

I can’t help but notice your attempt to imply that Florida educators were somehow trying to suppress “Venezuelan, Cuban, and Puerto Rican” authors given that Cubans and Venezuelans in Florida are major DeSantis supporters, and that he won 56% even among Puerto Ricans. These left wing librarians do not share the values of most immigrants in this country. Pornographic material caused a similar kerfuffle in Loudoun County VA, which is full of Asians and Hispanics which had flipped the state blue, but who split about evenly to Youngkin after Terry McAuliffe said that parents shouldn’t decide what kids learn in schools.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @12:13AM (#35335834)
"I can’t help but notice your attempt to imply that Florida educators were somehow trying to suppress “Venezuelan, Cuban, and Puerto Rican” authors with your example"

I don't know how you are noticing anything when I seriously just picked a random book and said nothing about their ethnicity. No where in my argument did I use that as an argument.

"None of the books are "being banned." States are deciding what taxpayer-funded school libraries are making available to children."

That's still a form of a ban. You highlighted that it's taxpayer funded, which to me means it's a violation of the first amendment. If it was a private library then that would be fine.

"Of course valid books are going to be pulled in the meantime while the government does its review. It's like a product recall--you pull the batch while you figure out how bad stuff made it through the filter."

Was there some imminent danger that they need to be pulled before reviewed? How long is a review going to take and who gets to make the decision about what is appropriate? However you're right that my example was under review. I didn't notice that the list was of books was of those both under review or banned. So let's check out another book that was banned.

"And Tango Makes Three"[1] is banned in the Lake Country School District for K-3 [2]

The stated reason is: "Administrative removal as per HB 1557 due to sexual orientation/gender identification". The book is a children's book about gay penguins. There's no sex in it and therefore it's not pornographic. Why is this justified?

The parent comment also stated "it is baffling to me how the media depicts this as "anti trans" or "anti lgbt" book banning while managing to never mention the specifics of the books."

Well there's a specific book and it's Anti-LGBT. How does this protect kids.

-----------------------------------------

Finally what about the bible? It contains descriptions of sex acts, incest, prostitution. It also is a religious book that pushes its own moral values and agenda. Why is that allowed but not books about gays?

I believe the true purpose of this law is to enforce moral values on the community and attack gays/etc by hiding their existence. The goal being to appease conservative Republicans and/or evangelicals who consistently vote Republican.

Why doesn't the 1st amendment apply here? The safety of children? How is hearing that gay people exist unsafe for kids? If you are willing to make exceptions to the 1st amendment for the safety of children that is questionable then are willing to make exceptions for one amendment why not the 2nd amendment? Guns are the leading cause of death for children between 1 and 19 in the US [3]?

[2] https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2023/02/07/heres-a-l... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_Tango_Makes_Three

[3]https://www.kff.org/global-health-policy/issue-brief/child-a...

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:14AM (#35336209)
> That's still a form of a ban. You highlighted that it's taxpayer funded, which to me means it's a violation of the first amendment. If it was a private library then that would be fine.

It doesn't violate the first amendment for the same reason it would violate the first amendment for the government to tell Barnes and Noble that it can't stock those books. When the government buys books with taxpayer money and makes them available in a taxpayer-financed public library, the government is the speaker. The first amendment permits the government to have a particular viewpoint when it acts as a speaker and provider of services.

> "And Tango Makes Three"[1] is banned in the Lake Country School District for K-3 [2] The stated reason is: "Administrative removal as per HB 1557 due to sexual orientation/gender identification". The book is a children's book about gay penguins. There's no sex in it and therefore it's not pornographic. Why is this justified?

As you admit, that is a book directed at children. Children don't think about penguins as having any sexual orientation. Sexual attraction is not a concept that's appropriate to introduce to young children.

> I believe the true purpose of this law is to enforce moral values on the community and attack gays/etc by hiding their existence. The goal being to appease conservative Republicans and/or evangelicals who consistently vote Republican.

Yes, but the moral value that's being enforced is sheltering children from being exposed to concepts of sex, sexuality, and sexual attraction. Conservative Republicans and evangelicals support that goal, but so do most people. I have literally never heard my Biden-voting Muslim-immigrant parents say the word "sex" or the Bangladeshi equivalent. And I'm married with three kids! The subject is nonetheless completely taboo. That's even though all of us support same-sex marriage in the abstract.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:59PM (#35350557)
"Sexual attraction is not a concept that's appropriate to introduce to young children"

Valentine's day is celebrated in schools, countless movies and books talk about marriage, love, and attraction between a man and a woman. You're trying to make same sex attraction a "sex act" instead emotional.

Yes, but the moral value that's being enforced is sheltering children from being exposed to concepts of sex, sexuality, and sexual attraction. Conservative Republicans and evangelicals support that goal, but so do most people

I don't care how many people support it. The majority does not mean you can ignore the constitution.

I have literally never heard my Biden-voting Muslim-immigrant parents say the word "sex" or the Bangladeshi equivalent. And I'm married with three kids!

1.Your personal experience has no value in this conversation.

2. You having a repressed upbringng doesn't prove the opposite. I've never worn a seatbelt and have never been in a crash isn't proof that seat belts don't work.

Finally you come from a country with less rights, especially for woman and you come here and have no issue with taking the rights of another smaller group of people shows your ignorance. Not to mention the people you support along with this would remove muslims from this country if they could. You should be ashamed of yourself

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by selimthegrim on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @07:16AM (#35355505)
You realize Bangladesh and West Bengal have extremely open prostitution and that BD is the only country in the region with legalized prostitution? Ever heard of Sonagachi in Calcutta or Kandapara near Dhaka?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by random314 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @03:29AM (#35500691)
It's cool as long as they also ban the Bible - incest, rape and what not.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by nonethewiser on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:34AM (#35314277)
> An LGBTQ child is effectively forcibly outed by this law, potentially before they've come to terms with their sexuality / gender themselves.

How?

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by woodruffw on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:40AM (#35314342)
Presumably the "giving parents full access to online accounts" part. It isn't difficult to imagine scenarios in which a minor is "outed" because a parent exercises their power under the law.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by Eumenes on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:41AM (#35314349)
This has me scratching my head too
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by GrabbinD33ze69 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:21PM (#35316216)
How is it that difficult to imagine how someone could be outed as gay etc if another party has the right to read through all of their messages etc lol.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by insane_dreamer on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:50AM (#35315039)
In theory I agree with you and the other posters on this. But as someone with preteen kids there’s the other side of me that wants to a) protect them from all the actual shit out there, and b) perhaps more importantly encourage them to do something more constructive than mindlessly scrolling through TikTok clips that have no value whatsoever. In fact I’m far more worried about b) than a) because I know they can learn to discern a) but b) can become a true addiction. I want them to explore whatever their interests are - which may be very different than mine were at their age - what I don’t want is for them to become the equivalent of “zombie couch potatoes”. I’m also concerned about all the negative comparisons that come with “oh look how those peoples lives are so much better than mine” ; I suffered from that myself as an adult (even though I knew that what I saw on social media was not a true representation of peoples lives) and was happier after I deleted my FB account (not to mention wasting less time). Anyway I wonder how many people responding here have teenagers, because when you do, you think of this issue from a different perspective. (I’m not religious nor in Utah)
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by insane_dreamer on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:56AM (#35315110)
PS. Having said the above, I do not agree with a law parental consent being required until 18. I would want my kids to have acquired good habits and be able to make reasonable decisions in their own without our involvement by 14 or so.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by fatnoah on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:53AM (#35326696)
As someone with a teen, it's tremendously difficult to navigate, and like all things related to child-rearing, it probably depends on the actual kids in question.

For our teen, the rule is that mom and dad have full access to all devices at any time. Technological limits and locks don't seem to be good options, since there are so many ways around them that I think they provide a false sense of security. Also, as teens, they're always around others that may not have locked-down access, so we simply operate under the assumption that they're seeing anything and everything. Instead, we apply some time-limiting to certain things, and make sure the phone is in it's charger in a public place at night, and generally try to make sure there are breaks from the media throughout the day.

Instead, we really try to engage with the content that they are interested in, and actually try to discuss it in a constructive manner, such as how most of what you see is stage-managed to present the best side of things, or to simply get eyeballs to build a brand and/or get advertising dollars. We never apply judgement or talk down to them in these conversations. With our child (and for many, I suspect) that's just a great way to get them to tune you out.

There's also an upside. We moved to a different town before middle school, and it was via social media that our child was able to stay in touch with old friends and to stay in touch with new friends during Covid. They're also inspired to do creative things that they've seen on TikTok. They has zero interest in cooking or baking but, for whatever reason, seeing people make stuff on TikTok sparked their interest in a way mom and dad never could.

This isn't to say that we're not worried, but at some point we have to do what we can to try to prepare them as much as possible. We were also worried the first time they walked to school alone, walked with a friend to the theater in the city for a 9:30pm movie showing, and will absolutely worry when they first get into a car at 16 and drive away. We also understand that social media is a totally different animal. It's full time, all the time, and designed to suck you in. Anything you post, even in private, will be public at some point. (This was one of our earliest topics of conversation! Unfortunately, there is a not of actual evidence to support this)

All that said, it really depends on the child, their own self-image, friends, environment, etc. If we took TikTok away, our child would be upset but would be over it quickly. Getting rid of Discord, however, would be devastating as that's how they chat with their friends. Parents should 100% be knowledgable and involved, but I think legal efforts like Utah's are doomed to fail because they'll only be successful at making adults feel like they're doing something, and there are too many ways around it. I also worry that parents will have a false confidence that restricting access will somehow solve the problem and reduce parent-child dialogue about these topics, or that kids will suffer for being digital have-nots.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by insane_dreamer on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:09PM (#35329286)
Good point about separating use of social media to stay in touch with and have fun with friends vs doom scrolling
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by datavirtue on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:05AM (#35315195)
The goal was to make kids unwilling to use social media.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by stuckinhell on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:26AM (#35315465)
Social media is not the same as it was 10 years ago.

The level of which kids compare themselves to other kids took an exponential leap to a near hive mind level. Constantly comparing themselves to the instagram people with fake lives, rich kids, or extremely beautiful people is mentally damaging them.

My daughter asked me for plastic surgery, and I was dumbfounded. So I went check her internet logs, and she's been watching rich kids of instagram/tiktok/etc. So now I'm trying to figure out how to talk with her about this.

There is balance, but as her mother I don't think I'll be letting her have internet privacy until she's grown up and moved out.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by Version467 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:42PM (#35316479)
May I ask how old your daughter is? It's concerning regardless of age, but if she's ~17 than I can see how this came to be, vs. if she's ~12 then I need to update my mental model of the world.

Also, did she ask about plastic surgery, or did she express interest in getting plastic surgery?

I don't mean to pry, I'm just more surprised than I (apparently) should be and would like to fix my gap in understanding.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by bcrosby95 on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:50PM (#35316561)
I'm not sure why it would be too surprising.

The problem with the internet is simple: it's easy to be constantly exposed to the top 0.001% of any aspect of life.

Consider this website. How many people feel diminished in the face of the achievements of others? How many seek out their advice on how to up their game? If you could get surgery to make you better at software development, how many would do so? If grown-ass adults are subject to this sort of stuff, how do we expect children to be able to cope?

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by whats_a_quasar on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:57PM (#35316650)
The mental health of teens and pre-teens has gotten really bad. This isn't just another "think of the children scare." Since the early 2010s the rate of self harm among girls 10-14 has ~tripled, and the rate of suicide among 10-14 year olds has doubled [1].

And there is now lots of evidence that this is because of social media and smartphones. The social lives of kids have changed drastically, in a way that does not meet their basic psychological needs [2].

I think that people's perceptions of social media are lagging behind the reality on the ground. There have always been moral panics and silly scares about whether the kids are alright, most of which were unfounded. So I think we are now reacting too slowly to the genuine health crisis caused by technology.

[1] https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/the-teen-mental-illness...

[2] https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/social-media-mental-ill...

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by api on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:57PM (#35318109)
I really think it’s important to stress that it’s not all technology generally. It’s a specific thing: addictive content on mobile phones, especially when it also delivers toxic messaging (whether intentionally or not).

The really toxic thing here is the portable omnipresent virtual Skinner box.

Highlighting that specific thing will help make sure any regulation we do enact will be properly targeted. Kids learning to code or doing homework on a computer or even playing a few games is not the problem. “Social” media and hyper-addictive content is the problem. Tech that is designed to be addictive is the problem.

Addictive trash on PCs can be harmful too, but the form factor limits just how extreme and pervasive it can be.

I also think the mobile ecosystem is just culturally more oriented toward making things addictive. Mobile games, media, everything on the platform seems designed to suck people in and keep them staring. The PC ecosystem still seems to have some sense that computers should exist to help people or make them smarter, not addict them. It’s like mobile is run by the people who design slot machines.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by heavyset_go on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:58PM (#35319536)
> https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/the-teen-mental-illness...

I don't necessarily buy the premise that the economy isn't having poor effects on teenagers' mental health just because the GFC is "over". Maybe to financial markets it is, but for people who need to work for a living, things changed since 2008 for the worse.

Teens are more likely to see their parents struggle to pay bills despite working full-time and with two incomes, they're more likely to see their parents face real threats like being unable to afford housing and the consequences that brings, they're going to see how the march of increasing costs of living affects their family in the face of stagnant wages. They also see countless examples of older people who do "everything right", yet are still laid off and can't re-enter the workforce in the same capacity as they had in the past, and are pushed out of their careers entirely.

On top of that, they're being told that they'll be relegated to a life of even worse poverty if they don't get into a good college, but even then, they aren't guaranteed a sustainable job and will have to take out a mortgage-sized loan just to attend. That loan will hang around their necks until they die even if they're only able to find a job that pays $30k a year. And if they want a job that even pays that much, they'll need a degree anyway, because those jobs have degree requirements, too.

I can understand why that would be overwhelming and depressing to teenagers.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Sunday March 26, 2023 @07:58PM (#35321093)
Is that the economy, or is it the way people are socialized to think about the economy, and life in general? The suicide rate in America is four times higher than in the poor developing country I’m from.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by bioemerl on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:27AM (#35325789)
And the economy isn't even that bad in general. I don't understand this tendency on the internet just so overly exaggerate how bad the economy is. Unemployment is near record lows right now. We have a bit of wage growth lag in the last few years thanks to everything going on, but up until then we had pretty strong wage growth.

I don't know if I'm just in a bubble because I don't live in one of the big cities with crazy housing prices? Right now it seems to be better time to be out and getting a job than any.

.... Unless you're a programmer.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by autoexec on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:41PM (#35334737)
> And the economy isn't even that bad in general. I don't understand this tendency on the internet just so overly exaggerate how bad the economy is. Unemployment is near record lows right now.

Unemployment doesn't tell us a whole lot. There's more people out of work today than before. Unemployment numbers don't tell you about the people whose only employment is part time or pays a fraction of what it used to pay either.

In the US evictions are on the rise, homelessness is on the rise, child poverty is on the rise, household debt is on the rise, utility service disconnections are rising, 80% of people in the US think their children will grow to be worse off than they are. None of this signals a healthy economy. The economy is making many already rich people even more money than ever before while the middle class increasingly struggles and the poor face ever rising expenses.

Outside of the tech world, this is a great time to find a job, but that doesn't mean you'll make enough money to support yourself. Programmers have it a bit rough right now, and it always hurts like hell to see your standard of living decline, but it's not that bad really. For so much of the country their standard of living starts a lot lower and it's still getting worse.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mrguyorama on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:11PM (#35330136)
In what way is "Mom and dad can't afford rent" Not actually the economy? What is this absurd statement you are making?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by autoexec on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:06PM (#35334451)
Being poor is depressing, but I suspect watching your standard of living decline, your hopes and dreams destroyed, and your children forced to struggle in ways you or your parents never had to before hits harder.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by antifa on Monday March 27, 2023 @11:33PM (#35335551)
All while being looked down on by your politicians who also shout at you about how it's the greatest thing ever and you should be thankful for it.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @08:59AM (#35340252)
If you have socialized people into a culture where higher housing and educational costs more than offsetting the fact you make more money than your parents did at the same age causes four times as many people to kill the selves than folks in a Bangladeshi village, then I’m sorry the problem is your culture. You have created a culture where people have no resilience to a bump in the road.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by acuozzo on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:01AM (#35342179)
The poor in your country know how to be poor.

After decades of prosperity, the USA has lost the majority of the generational knowledge and skills that poor people pass on to their children. I've spoken with people who spend almost an entire day's wage on a visit to the local laundromat.

Moreover, the poor here have very little access to mutual aid networks due to the loss of "third places" like churches. It's not uncommon to hear of poor people here having their children taken away by the state because they were just making ends meet and can't afford to pay for child care and have nobody to rely on to watch their kids after school; not even a neighbor.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mordae on Monday March 27, 2023 @07:58AM (#35325516)
I don't think this is about smartphones. This is about the online systems they interact with. We really should ban systematic user manipulation, advertising as a business and all unmoderated online spaces.

Most on-topic and/or small communities are fine. It's OK to create forum, but you need someone to step up and step in when necessary. Unmoderated FB-style exchanges and viral content with attached comment section need to go.

Well, that won't happen. Capitalists wouldn't allow it and regular people have this toxic environment internalized and normalized.

So I guess people will kill themselves. And a lot more will be permanently damaged.

It doesn't matter anyway. Soon there won't be any meaningful employment for kinds of people who fall prey to this due to ML replacing them, so this is just a drop in the ocean.

Root cause is the profit motive. Get rid of that and we can start having real discussions about what do we want.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by dTal on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:10PM (#35332691)
>ban systematic user manipulation, advertising as a business and all unmoderated online spaces

One of these is not like the others.

Ban private communication because think of the children? Heard that one before. And "moderation" is "systematic user manipulation", so I guess just ban everything? "Moderation" is not some panacea, it just means some unspecified third party interfering. Moderated by whom, and by what critera? And those "FB-style exchanges" you hate are "moderated" by the FB algorithm.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by altair222 on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @11:41PM (#35352116)
This has to be one of the most boomer, gaslighting take i've ever seen. Yes, not the constant attack on LGBTQ rights, not the domestic abuses, not the shit education and academic culture, not blatant racism and neo-nazism but smartphones are what caused the mental health issues.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by thomastjeffery on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:10PM (#35321191)
What has changed is the level of engagement.

The only adequate solution is to respond in kind.

That can only be done from a place of empathy, which is particularly difficult to have if you are starting now.

I think the best approach is to be clear about your intentions and motivations, and make it explicit that you are not looking for opportunity to pass judgement. Be clear about what you want to change, and ask for input.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by morbia on Monday March 27, 2023 @05:24AM (#35324585)
Just to be clear, I am not a parent and I would not be so presumptuous to criticise someone's parenting skills when I have not gone through it. I wholeheartedly agree with you that the internet of 2023 is nothing like 2013 (or 2003 when I was growing up), and I don't think your reaction to the situation you described is wrong. Needless to say, parenting in this era is really, really hard and I don't envy you.

However, I want to exercise a hypothetical with you: what if you had discovered through access to her internet logs that she was a lesbian, or a trans man? How would you deal with that situation? Would you confront them, or would you pretend you didn't see it? Even if you have liberal views and are supportive*, that is a very deep and intimate piece of knowledge on your child that you hold now. Instead of them dictating the terms of their coming out, you effectively control that. That is quite a violation of trust.

Presumably your daughter knows you can see their internet logs, what if she does not feel like she isn't being her authentic self online because she knows you will find out? Even if you are supportive, discovering your sexual and/or gender identity takes time and takes having a safe space to feel comfortable to confide in someone.

This is all working under the assumption that you are comfortable with this, what about the many parents out there who are not? This becomes a weapon they can use to inflict psychological trauma on their child. Growing up as a LGBT kids is really hard for many of us, even today. Giving any more control or power to conservative parents is extremely dangerous.

You might think I'm exaggerating, or perhaps this is a niche point (it is far more likely your daughter is straight and cis-gendered) but the stakes are really high here. I came out to my parents when I was an adult, on my own terms when I moved out. I still got the 'it's just a phase' speech and all that sort of rubbish, but it was very clear to my parents that they had zero control over my life at that point. If they wanted to maintain a relationship with their son they had to change their viewpoints pretty quickly (and they did). Without hyperbole, if they had outed me when I was a child at best I would have been traumatised, at worst I would have killed myself.

I hope parents reading this really think about what I am saying here and take it seriously, because for some of you this will be something you'll have to deal with. How you do that will define everything about your relationship with your child.

* There is a whole separate discussion on what medical intervention for gender dysphoria is appropriate for children, but for the sake of this discussion I mean are you comfortable with the concept having a trans child more than specifics on medication.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by codeguro on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:31AM (#35326473)
Parents, for their children’s best interests, have a prerogative to control what their children are exposed to. Social media is absolutely within that domain. I’m inclined to believe anyone who disagrees with that principle is a potential predator who seeks to undermine that authority. Sexual preferences are fundamentally sexual in nature, and parents absolutely have the prerogative to gatekeep the kinds of content their children are exposed to, especially sexual content. Children cannot (and should not be) expect(ed) to have any real form of privacy while under the care and supervision and oversight of their own parents. If parents see their children on internet chats they have a right to be involved and snoop on the logs and intervene to nip bad ideas in the bud. They have a prerogative in influencing the upbringing of their children in every aspect of their lives. Children simply cannot consent to life-changing decisions such as having sex, or sexual reassignment surgeries, or taking puberty-blocking hormones (aka sterilization drugs also given to convicted pedophiles). This includes intervening when strangers on the internet are grooming their sons / daughters to convince them they are gay or trans orcc by whatever.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by fknorangesite on Monday March 27, 2023 @11:44AM (#35328157)
> strangers on the internet are grooming their sons / daughters to convince them they are gay or trans

This is just the latest bullshit moral panic du jour.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by norwalkbear on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:06PM (#35329239)
Except libs of tiktok shows everyday, we do have people trying to push personal agendas onto kids.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:27PM (#35329549)
One example?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by officeplant on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:05PM (#35330911)
All libs of tiktok shows everyday is their hate mongering.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:45PM (#35334771)
Note that libsoftiktok produces fake content alarmingly often. You ought to read the impact section of their wiki page where it describes how they like to accuse teachers who resign of being fired for grooming children without evidence, or how they manipulate footage from serious discussions between prison psychologists to produce such fantastic rage bait that even Russian propaganda networks use it.

If you follow accounts like these and take any of their content at face value you are choosing wilful ignorance via propaganda. There's nothing else to it, they show you nothing but a cruel facsimile of reality in an effort to make you into a bigot.

Here's a snippet from the end of the article, note that some of these targets did literally nothing other than criticize libsoftiktok

> After analyzing Libs of TikTok's online activity in April 2022 through November 2022, a counter-extremism research group called Task Force Butler Institute estimated Raichik singled out a specific event, location or person over 280 times, resulting in 66 incidents of harassment or threats against her targets.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by peyton on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:54PM (#35334837)
I checked out that account. It looks like it just reposts content from elsewhere. I’ll trust my eyes over what’s written in Wikipedia.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:14PM (#35334970)
If by "that account" (???) you mean the charity investigating right wing extremism in the USA then sure but I think that's a pretty sad response all in all.

> I’ll trust my eyes over what’s written in Wikipedia.

Wikipedia editors generally exhibit honest behaviour that your preferred propaganda outlet handler Chaya Raichik conspicuously lacks. The authors of the wiki page haven't sicced an online mob on anyone, I'd count them fairly trustworthy by comparison.

If you'd truly like to use your eyes I suggest the gigantic multi-paragraph list of abusive behaviour on behalf of Libsoftiktok, all replete with citations for proof so you can be certain it's the truth.

Righteous anger is a very dangerous human emotion, these accounts exist to exploit that part of you. I think anyone who makes it their business model to tell you who you should feel angry about should be treated with utmost suspicion.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by peyton on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:18PM (#35335011)
I have no idea what this is but it doesn’t seem like that big a deal.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @04:21AM (#35337411)
If you're not here to engage in good faith just say that rather than openly wasting my time.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by norwalkbear on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:23PM (#35381667)
You aren't in good faith here. Pot calling the kettle black
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:14PM (#35429685)
If you'd like to substantiate that feel free. I've provided plenty of evidence, GP has dismissed both replies without supplying any refutation.

Further, if you're unhappy about the points I'm making then explain why you think I'm wrong. Sniping at me from two different comment threads with out of hand accusations isn't doing you any favours.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by codeguro on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @06:29PM (#35364764)
> Wikipedia editors generally exhibit honest behaviour

Oh, shut up. Even the co-founder of wikipedia Larry Sanger no longer trusts wikipedia because its staff and biases are so far skewed to the left that he can no longer trust it. You are in a cult if you honestly think this kind of disingenuous editing is trustworthy.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=R_ygjNVFDMM

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:24AM (#35371539)
It isn't totally shocking that someone who's made it their life's work to repeatedly try (and then fail) to replace Wikipedia would be sour about Wikipedia. I also don't as a matter of course trust the opinions of people who appear on Fox News, a network specifically for propaganda dissemination who admitted in court they do not aim to tell the truth.

That he's appearing on Timcast, hosted by yet another right wing propagandist agitator, does not shock me. It does mean I won't believe a word he says.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by norwalkbear on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:22PM (#35381661)
No it doesn't, fake content doesn't mean content you dislike
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by chownie on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:13AM (#35422177)
In this case it's fake AND I dislike it :) Thankfully, both can be true.

Feel free to peruse the long cited list of occasions in which Chaya Raichik outright lied on libsoftiktok, it's in their wikipedia article which reads as one long controversy section.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by buffington on Monday March 27, 2023 @02:11PM (#35330141)
I'd rather not share specific details due to privacy concerns, but I've personally needed to rescue a loved one who was groomed by a stranger on the internet, convinced their loved ones were manipulating them and oppressing them, then kidnapped (across state lines), then encouraged to start hormone replacement therapy.

To be clear: I support trans kids and I find opportunities to support them however I can. The loved one in the case I describe is not trans. They were a minor at the time, and according to them, didn't really have a sense for how they might identify. A stranger took advantage of that, inflicted severe emotional trauma and irreversible changes, and, thankfully, will remain in prison for at least another 3 years (for this one case).

Whether it's "the latest bullshit moral panic du jour" I can't speak to. According to the FBI and state police involved in my particular experience, they've seen a sharp uptick in cases like the one my loved one experienced. I've seen my young teen age nieces nearly fall into similar traps. I only know about those close calls because my nieces have the experiences of their older family member to lean on, and know to share sketchy communications with their parents and me.

I suspect the "gay or trans" angle is indeed "bullshit moral panic" motivated by politics/fear more than anything, but the idea that young people are being manipulated and sucked into dark places is very much real.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by stuckinhell on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:17AM (#35326953)
Instead of hypothetical, let me be very very clear. It's my child not yours, not the schools, not the governments.

It's my child, that I carried for 9 months. I'll do what I think is best. I don't care about your opinion here in the slightest because at the end of the day you have no connection to my family and aren't responsible for their well being.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by fknorangesite on Monday March 27, 2023 @11:32AM (#35328015)
> you have no connection to my family and aren't responsible for their well being.

Sure, but you are, and morbia's comment here was a thoughtful call for introspection on your part when considering what that well being entails, exactly. It was not out of place.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by stuckinhell on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:03PM (#35329203)
My point was that I am and he isn't. His comment was only thoughtful on his own terms.

His terms aren't universal or acceptable because it's my family not his. He's projecting his personal experience onto my kids, which I've clearly discussed prior is not the same generationally or ever personally.

I'm not alone in this. Parent's are tired of people who have no business in our families trying to push their own visions of family, culture, politics, etc.

That's why home schooling is on the rise in both liberal and conservative circles (https://www.pbs.org/newshour/education/as-u-s-schools-reopen...).

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by morbia on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:57PM (#35329981)
> His terms aren't universal or acceptable because it's my family not his. He's projecting his personal experience onto my kids, which I've clearly discussed prior is not the same generationally or ever personally.

I am doing nothing of the sort. In fact, I haven't made any comment towards which I disagree with your actions with regards to your example. I haven't really formulated any opinions on this, and certainly not towards your family. I was wanting an open discourse using a hypothetical scenario and received a rather personal defensive retort in return.

All I believe is LGBT children have a right to be protected, sometimes that is from their own parents. Yes, that is formulated through the lens of my experiences in the same way yours are through being a mother of a child in 2023. I am not trying to push a vision of family, culture or politics, I'm trying to make parents think about this that is all. My hypothetical scenario is not so hypothetical for many families.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @08:54PM (#35334354)
What you think as "pushing" is simply making people aware of the existence of another culture, idea, or political view and that's why I don't agree with you. It's similar to how people misuse "indoctrination". This whole "I'm a parent" mantra to shut down opposing views is pathetic. Being a parent doesn't make you special, doesn't mean you get more power than others, and it certainly doesn't make you right.

I also consider people like to be a danger because you think your view is 100% correct, that exposure to different opinions is wrong, and finally is that you'll use the government to push YOUR agenda, and yes that is the correct usage this time. It's already happening in Florida.[1]

You don't like what it's in public schools feel free to home school your children. You don't like what it's in the library, don't go. Unless you lock your kids away they are going to see and hear about things you disagree with and maybe you pushing so hard is going to backfire.

ON THE OTHER HAND

Keep banning books, keep calling your enemies pedophiles, and keep pushing just because you've had local success when no one was watching (i.e. Mom's for Liberty). You'll turn the right of center and moderate voters towards the Democrats and, hopefully, just like Arizona, enough states will fall and this nonsense will stop.

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65071989

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:26PM (#35329535)
What if you think is best harms the child? Obviously there's limits you can think it's best to lock your kid in a basement 24/7 right?

I'm not against parental rights but also hate absolute statements like your first sentence

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Monday March 27, 2023 @12:21PM (#35328619)
You may be too deep in the community to appreciate, but younger teens have had family supervision for millennia and for good reason. Their brains are not fully formed yet.

That you can think up a problematic case doesn’t mean we throw out the concept for the other 95% of kids that benefit from involved parents.

I personally grew up in a “lord of the flies” environment and wouldn’t recommend it. Would have been nice to have some guidance, even if not perfect.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:05PM (#35334437)
That's great, feel free to supervise your kids. You don't get to use the government to do it. Are you saying that the 1st amendment can have exceptions if a child's safety is at stake?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:32PM (#35335107)
Oh but we do. Kids have been prohibited from entering bars and buying tobacco, by law for a long time. We generally think that's a good thing, and why it continues to be law.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @01:14AM (#35336202)
Ok that's fair. It turns out that guns are the leading cause of death for kids in the US. Can we make exceptions to the 2nd admendment?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @04:41AM (#35337552)
* * *
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Tuesday March 28, 2023 @09:13PM (#35350694)
Can states arrest people for what they say?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @07:43PM (#35365578)
I'm going to let NY know they can ban all guns since the bill of rights doesn't apply to them
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Friday March 31, 2023 @06:29PM (#35394605)
Yes, the Constitution limits state govts as well, a slight misstatement written in a hurry.

Your obtuse pedantry is not useful. Particularly when it appears you still have missed the main point of the previous statement—that the Constitution limits government, not citizens.

Also, these laws restrict children, not adults as you're suggesting. Basically this whole subthread is irrelevant. Good day.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by morbia on Wednesday March 29, 2023 @02:15PM (#35361078)
> You may be too deep in the community to appreciate, but younger teens have had family supervision for millennia and for good reason. Their brains are not fully formed yet.

Of course, I'm not claiming otherwise. Hell, I'm not even saying that legally children should be entitled to privacy from their parents, clearly that isn't feasible or desireable in any way.

However, morally and ethically it is not black or white. It is not a case of "lord of the flies" or parental prison as a binary choice.

Honestly, I'm not even disagreeing with the original poster I replied to. I don't think they were wrong for snooping on their child's internet history. I just wanted to start an open discussion on a legitmate concern caused by snooping which many families go through. It is something that heterosexual parents often do not consider or appreciate because it was not part of their experiences when they grew up. To use your terms, they are "too deep in their community" to appreciate it.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Friday March 31, 2023 @09:19PM (#35396002)
Sure. The internet has become even more dangerous as time goes by however, so I don't feel like it should be the first or only solution to the real problem cases you mention.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by rayiner on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:50PM (#35316568)
The science is that people’s brains aren’t fully developed until age 25. What they have access to before that time should be carefully curated by adults.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by random314 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @03:32AM (#35500702)
But peoples brains also deteriorate with time.

I believe only men(women have a smaller brain size and never achieve maturity) between the ages 25 and 40 should pick books for everyone else.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by brvsft on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:06PM (#35316765)
Think of the gay children.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by WeylandYutani on Sunday March 26, 2023 @02:29PM (#35317746)
It is well known that more teens commit suicide in insular religious communities.

It's not social media it is people driving other people to despair. Ofcourse you can't really fix that.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by throwaway-blaze on Sunday March 26, 2023 @03:47PM (#35318757)
Source? That isn't true.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by camhart on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:29AM (#35324266)
I disagree. I don't think full access to messages is always necessary, but it can be in some circumstances and it should be up to the parent to decide how responsible their child is online and grant privacy accordingly.

A 16 year old is still going through tons of life changing events. Everyone needs help charting a course through life, especially at that age. Who better than a loving parent to guide them?

Parents should be aware of what their kids are doing online. More and more of "life" is online. More and more harm is impacting kids online. A parent whos entirely unaware of what their child is doing online is simply failing to be a parent.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by PretzelPirate on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:12AM (#35326261)
> Who better than a loving parent to guide them?

Many of us didn't have loving parents. We had parents who would weaponize any detail they learned about us in order to hurt us.

I used the internet to get away from my parents when I physically couldn't.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Monday March 27, 2023 @12:34PM (#35328805)
A constructive solution to that is to call CPS or even run away. Getting hooked on tiktok as you would a drug is not.

I don’t believe this bill blocks iMessage for example.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by themitigating on Monday March 27, 2023 @09:12PM (#35334508)
So a child getting addicted to Tiktok is worse than them running away or calling CPS, which could lead to their removal?
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by mixmastamyk on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:34PM (#35335128)
Hard to judge "what is worse" without more information. What I do know is that tiktok is not a solution to anything.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by johnchristopher on Sunday March 26, 2023 @04:18AM (#35312286)
> If this law was in place when I was growing up, my life would probably look very different, and not for the better. My interests, hobbies, profession, my sense of humor etc, all have deep roots in the online communities I participated as a kid. More importantly, those communities gave me a sense of hope when I didn't have much.

There's not enough details but I take it online communities were social networks of that time ?

I understand self-hosted boards would still be available to teens under this law.

Otherwise, I don't see how algorithmic generated content benefits teens if the goal is to participate in a community.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by data_maan on Sunday March 26, 2023 @05:01AM (#35312496)
This is yet another instance of "Think of the children":

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by Mezzie on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:15AM (#35314084)
I'd like to add that this may have outsized unintended effects like COPPA did - COPPA being the law that established that accounts online required you to be 13. I was 12 when COPPA went into effect. What a lot of people don't know about COPPA is that there is a provision to allow for children under 13 to have accounts with proven parental permission. My parents would have allowed me - I'd been online for 8 years at that point and they were both techy types who could supervise me. However, it wasn't worth the extra logistics for companies, so they just outright banned anyone under 13.

Likewise, if this is enacted in enough states or the logistics of figuring out which people to track becomes too burdensome, I'd expect to see sites not letting anyone under 18 use them and to start collecting everyone's information.

Which would have some really bad second-order impacts. In addition to the impacts others have mentioned on minority populations, I have two main concerns:

- Cutting off the parental rights of those who want to be permissive with their kids. My parents didn't believe in content restrictions; the one ideological idea they agree on is free access to knowledge. I was given an adult library card at 5-6 and full Internet access at around the same age and discussions on how to interpret what we saw in the news/in media/etc. was a common discussion point. My mother is from a media studies family and my father's family are tech tinkerers. Families like mine will be functionally unable to raise their children as they would prefer.

- More relevant to society as a whole, sure, let's ban their access until they're 18. Then when kids move out/leave at 18, not only do they have to navigate the world, they have to be introduced to social media with absolutely no oversight. And 18 year olds are legally "adults", so companies will have a group of completely defenseless people to take advantage of who can be held to their bad decisions. (Think like credit card companies who hang out at freshmen college/uni events). It's similar to raising the driving age: While raising the driving age does prevent accidents, the highest rate of bad driving comes from new drivers. If the driving age is lower, those new drivers are more likely to have people to call if they do get into trouble and make their mistakes when they're less likely to ruin their lives. Likewise, the worst effects of social media will be felt by those who are new users.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by BeFlatXIII on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:24AM (#35314746)
How likely is it that today's teens simply check the "I am over 18" box and set themselves a fake birthday that is Jan 1 from 20 years ago? I've been 25 for the past 25 years, after all.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by Mezzie on Sunday March 26, 2023 @11:05AM (#35315193)
The problem is that you can't easily verify whether someone is 12 or 14 with documentation so the checkbox is all they had. You can easily verify if someone is over 18 and there are systems in place to do so, which means it's highly likely if this takes place that ID is going to be required. (I mean I also just lied after COPPA, but I was pissed to lose so many accounts that I'd signed up for honestly in 95-99.)

Are the kids going to get around it? Yes. (And good, that's one way to develop a healthy skepticism as well as some systems thinking.) But it's going to be way harder and likely involve forging documents or impersonating particular adults. (I can see a reverse of a situation I had growing up where my parents used us as shields against piracy accusations: "Ooops, sorry, I'll talk to my kid. They're totally the one who downloaded this game." nudge nudge wink wink where children act through their parents - it's not like it's hard for a 15 year old to take their mom/dad's driver's license and use it). Those actions are more likely to be punished, whereas a simple lie is 'kids will be kids'.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by BeFlatXIII on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:16PM (#35329391)
Perhaps the kids will start forging ID cards as foreign nationals with completely fictitious ID templates (or just say "not from Utah").
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by noirscape on Monday March 27, 2023 @10:08AM (#35326858)
The main thing COPPA failed at was that iirc the parent who wanted to allow their child on the platform would have to physically email their approval to the operator of the site in question.

Nobody wanted to make their address accessible/wanted to pass the hordes of physical mail that would end up at that address (see the inherent issues with any public email address and spam), so this quickly fell to the wayside in favor of the pinky promise you're above 13 checkbox.

For what it counts, outside the US, minimum age for this sorta thing (although there it's more about general data processing, not some weird "think of the children" nonsense) is often higher.

Here for example you're not allowed to have a Google account if you're >=16 years old, end of story. Still skippable with a checkbox (and from what I know any teenager just does that), but the age being at 13 is not at all a standard.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by sprite on Monday March 27, 2023 @01:04PM (#35329211)
I don’t understand how social media companies will enforce this without requiring an ID for any signup. Even then users could just select another country. Without enforcement this is just as useless as click link to verify you are 18 or enter birthdate.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by nonethewiser on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:33AM (#35314266)
> (D) news, sports, entertainment, or other content that is preselected by the provider and not user generated, ... (Q) to permit comments on a digital news website, if the news content is posted only by the provider of the digital news website

Sounds more like they are protecting against children consuming toxic or mind numbing content.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by tzs on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:18AM (#35314703)
> Sounds more like they are protecting against children consuming toxic or mind numbing content.

If that was the case it would not exclude comments on digital news websites. Those are usually a cesspool.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by jjeaff on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:08PM (#35316802)
I doubt anyone thinks reading those comments are good. They just made the carve out to avoid including news sites in the ban.
Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by akersten on Sunday March 26, 2023 @12:28PM (#35316290)
And, if I may be so bold, the positives of exchanging ideas between peers to chance some of them escape a cycle of sheltered brainwashing far, far outweigh any imagined harm these sites exhibit.

For once I'd like to see any tech company take a stand and just direct Utah visitors to a page that says "we don't operate here anymore, because of this law, call your representative at this number if you don't like it, here's some ex-mormon reading material we selected in the meantime, hail satan."

But they won't, they'll just task two interns to hook the site up to Id.me and we'll fall further into the privacy dystopia of requiring a driver's license to surf the web, waiting on our 6th settlement check of $0.89 after the database somehow leaked again despite promises that the 5th time was the last time.

These sort of bills are always about power, control, and chilling online expression. Any claims of "safety for the kids" is window dressing.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by taxyz on Sunday March 26, 2023 @01:11PM (#35316840)
I think this is a little less sinister than you are making it out to be. To me, it reads as the intent of those exemptions is because those sites (CNN, Fox, ESPN, etc) exercise editorial discretion around what content is posted and, presumably, should be more active in moderating/enabling/disabling discussion comments. Sites like reddit (since you mention r/exmormon) while are user moderated ultimately escape liability behind section 230.

It's a separate debate for us to argue what is more harmful to children/minors/teens - news/sports/entertainment media vs social media but with our current legal framework these exemptions kinda make sense. If what you are worried about is brainwashing, being solicited, general harm from both users and algorithms, its probably true that that is less likely to happen to a kid in the comments section of an ESPN article than it is on reddit/4chan/tiktok/instagram - and when it does happen at least there is someone to hold somewhat responsible.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by thomastjeffery on Sunday March 26, 2023 @08:05PM (#35321151)
I think you have recognized a significant part of the motivations behind this, but you're missing a key detail: pornography.

The Corporation for the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints - which is currently embarrassed to be known colloquially as the Mormon church - has declared "pornography" to be one of the most menacing and dangerous things in our society.

Most of the people in Utah's government, including the governor and both senators, are active members in the Mormon church. "Active" is a key word here: it is not by any means a casual relationship, especially if you want political support from other Mormons.

The narratives surrounding porn as "a threat to children" tend to conclude that all content a child interacts with must be curated to protect them from that danger.

It's trivial to just blacklist pornhub et al with DNS filtering. You can't go blocking Reddit or Facebook, though: that would be an overreach, placing you clearly in the realm of "helicopter parenting".

This law has two effects:

1. It gives parents the social excuse to invade their children's privacy: It's the law's fault now.

2. It gives parents the social responsibility to invade their children's privacy: it must be irresponsible not to.

To invade a child's privacy is to do harm. This law, and all of the intent it came from, demands that harm be done in the name of safety.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by jstarfish on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:54PM (#35321976)
"Children's privacy" isn't a thing. They are wards of their parents, whose basic fucking job requires they have some clue where the kid is and what they're getting up to.

Then you bring up porn, something illegal for children to be accessing anyway. You are aware of this, yes?

Shame on parents for daring to uphold the law in their own homes.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by thomastjeffery on Sunday March 26, 2023 @10:57PM (#35322374)
Legality is not morality.

It is a parent's responsibility to ensure their child is safe, and that does involve some level of intrusion. It doesn't mean reading their diary or listening in on every conversation they have with their friends. How else can a child learn healthy boundaries?

Is it really a surprise to you that many humans under the age of 18 are watching porn? A vague legal threat never stopped me, and it's not going to stop most teenagers. No matter what the law says, that is the reality we live in.

As I see it, changing the legal age for porn consumption would be a political nightmare, not because it's hard to argue that teenagers should be allowed, but because it is hard to argue that teenagers should be marketed to as direct consumers. Personally, I find this entire situation counterproductive, but the tacit allowal of teenagers to watch porn (and not necessarily pay for it) without prosecution has been a workable compromise.

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by camhart on Monday March 27, 2023 @04:19AM (#35324196)
I think it's far more likely this bill is due to the high teen suicide rate in Utah.

[1] https://utah-health.shorthandstories.com/state-of-suffering/...

Re:Utah is first US state to limit teen social media access by xnx on Monday March 27, 2023 @03:10PM (#35330971)
Good point. I hadn't even considered the Mormon angle. I've learned so much about Mormon culture on Tiktok that blew my mind.