News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by zoltar on Friday March 24, 2023 @07:51PM (#35297251)
Is that the same Peter Schiff that said gold was going to $5,000/oz in 2012?
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by sph on Friday March 24, 2023 @08:24PM (#35297585)
Person that made a bad prediction in their life should never be listened to ever again, for everything they say is wrong.

Show me anyone that predicted two consecutive macroeconomic trends, ever.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by contravariant on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:02PM (#35297932)
If, as you your second sentence seems to suggest, nobody ever managed to get it right twice then we shouldn't listen to people how made a good prediction either.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by paulpauper on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:58PM (#35298358)
he made many bad predictions, and continued to double down on them:

dollar collapse, $5k+ gold, emerging markets boom, bitcoin crash, hyperinflation, bear market, recession, etc. every year

He never deviated from his predictions or view even when shown to be wrong. He never stopped to consider maybe he was wrong, not that the economy is wrong.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Operative0198 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:25AM (#35299737)
He isn't wrong on any of those predictions.

The dollar has never been at a more precarious position (on a hyper-inflation course and the BRICS are pondering about adopting the Yuan).

Bitcoin (who knows what's coming next, but for sure never seeing 70K again)

Hyperinflation (pretty obvious)

Bear market (most of 2022 was in one, and most probably this year will follow)

Recession (high certainty this will happen. Fed's soft landing is a mirage, history shows a rate cut after aggressive hiking usually leads into one)

Schiff is not outright wrong on his predictions. He just never gave time stipulations for his predictions.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by riffraff on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:36AM (#35299793)
Do you realize hyperinflation is generally defined to be 50% per month?

February US inflation is 6% year over year. This is orders of magnitude below "hyper".

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Operative0198 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:48AM (#35299851)
And the definition of a recession was rescinded last year by the White House.

Is inflation for you better now than it was in 2019?

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @04:07AM (#35300515)
> And the definition of a recession was rescinded last year by the White House.

It what? Also if you predict a recession every year you'll eventually get one right, but that doesn't make you right about recession predictions in general.

> Is inflation for you better now than it was in 2019?

Did he predict "higher than 2019"? If "higher than 2019" wasn't his prediction then I don't see why it matters that "higher than 2019" happened.

And that's not much of a prediction. 2019's inflation was below target.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Operative0198 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @07:18AM (#35301540)
> It what?

Muddied the definition of a recession when the question came up.

> Also if you predict a recession every year you'll eventually get one right, but that doesn't make you right about recession predictions in general.

Yep. That's pretty much the game of predictions.

> 2019's inflation was below target.

Which target? The one the Fed determines? Consumer inflation at the moment (~7%) is rivalling rates witnessed back in the 80s. Add the new money the Fed has printed over time (since 2008) and now expected to continue (covid stimulus, bailouts for banks etc.), anyone can see where the trend for inflation is going. No predictions are even needed for that.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @07:40AM (#35301666)
> Yep. That's pretty much the game of predictions.

So you agree the recession prediction is not evidence for Shiff's competence?

> Which target?

2%

> Consumer inflation at the moment (~7%) is rivalling rates witnessed back in the 80s. Add the new money the Fed has printed over time (since 2008) and now expected to continue (covid stimulus, bailouts for banks etc.), anyone can see where the trend for inflation is going. No predictions are even needed for that.

...have you looked at the trend, though? Inflation was climbing higher and higher until last June, and then it dropped by more than half. For the last 3-8 months the inflation rate has been about 4%.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Operative0198 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:35AM (#35302045)
> So you agree the recession prediction is not evidence for Shiff's competence?

Economists make wrong predictions all the time. Am saying Schiff is not exactly entirely wrong on some of the ones he's made in the past.

> ...have you looked at the trend, though? Inflation was climbing higher and higher until last June, and then it dropped by more than half. For the last 3-8 months the inflation rate has been about 4%.

Have you? The last time the inflation rate was even near 4% was in April 2021 [0].

[0] https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_inflation_rate

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:44AM (#35302107)
Wrong chart. That's a rolling average of 12 months.

The peak was in June, so it's still dragging the yearly number up. The last 8 months were much lower than the previous several.

https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/inflation-rate-mo...

https://i.imgur.com/MBwyLjJ.png

Though that chart also shows inflation dropping...

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Operative0198 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:32AM (#35302459)
I don't what you are on about. The chart figures I linked is sourced from the monthly CPI rate shared by BLS every month.

You are obviously trolling at this point.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by dalyons on Saturday March 25, 2023 @11:02AM (#35303311)
It’s not trolling just because you aren’t understanding what’s being said. Recent MoM figures show inflation is way down, the annualized will follow down shortly.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by Dylan16807 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @12:33PM (#35304276)
The main inflation number that everyone talks about compares each month to one year previous.

When inflation changes rapidly, it gives you outdated information.

When you look at the underlying data for each month compared to the previous month, you can see that the spike was higher than 9% and we are currently lower than 6%.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by fyzix on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:48PM (#35298294)
Schiff didn't account for the economic ignorance of the masses in his prediction. He understood that runaway inflation would cause the gold price to spike, he didn't foresee the confidence that traders have in the FED to fight off inflation.

The FED cannot win the inflation fight (confirmed by their recent soft pivot back to QE) and gold will not go up until the traders realize this fact.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by dragonwriter on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:00PM (#35298369)
> Schiff didn’t account for the economic ignorance of the masses in his prediction.

Literally every economic misprediction can be blamed on not accounting for the way people actually behave in real-world economies, but…that’s not something that adds credibility for the next prediction by the same predictor.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by fyzix on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:28PM (#35298591)
1.decade of 0% apr >>> 2.high inflation >>> 3.gold price surge

We have gotten 1 and 2 but we haven't gotten to 3 because traders believe that the FED can win the inflation fight. The FED abandoned the inflation fight with a soft pivot yet traders are still not buying gold. This is what Peter couldn't foresee...traders' unwillingness to go against the FED.

This is not a misprediction because in any sane world, the prospects of very high inflation would result in a spike of the gold price.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by bruce511 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:26AM (#35299744)
>> This is not a misprediction because in any sane world,

Describing any part of the financial system as sane (rational) is laughable. The system is built on the irrational nature of people.

In some absurd way, bank runs are an expression of actual rationality - give me my cold hard cash now, I don't trust you lot anymore.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by riffraff on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:31AM (#35299771)
> This is not a misprediction because in any sane world, the prospects of very high inflation would result in a spike of the gold price.

Keynes mentioned "animal spirits" and "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent" almost a hundred years ago. If your prediction doesn't account for reality and well know facts it's a bad prediction.

It would be like guessing that the next election will favor candidate X and when they don't win explaining it away with "well but people are dumb".

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by lottin on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:25AM (#35300325)
So he basically predicted "high inflation". He's been predicting that since at least 2010, probably earlier. Over a long enough period there is bound to be some episode of "high inflation", so sooner or later the prediction of "high inflation" will become true. This doesn't mean that the individual who made the prediction is some kind of visionary.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by dragonwriter on Saturday March 25, 2023 @03:26AM (#35300327)
> This is not a misprediction because in any sane world, the prospects of very high inflation would result in a spike of the gold price.

Since it was a prediction of the behavior in the real world, and it doesn’t reflect what actually occurred, it is a misprediction.

The fact that the predictor (or you) believes that a world in which the prediction was accurate would be more sane doesn’t make the wrong prediction better, since it wasn’t offered as a prediction of what would occur in some hypothetical sane world.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by fijiaarone on Saturday March 25, 2023 @07:16AM (#35301531)
The simple solution to this equation is that the assumption in number 3 isn’t correct.

Gold is not a store (or measure) of value. Nobody cares about gold. Sure, some people might like to have a gold ring or necklace, but that’s a tiny amount of material for a small number of people and it’s demand (like diamonds) is primarily marketing driven, and easily satisfied by a side effect of copper mining. Until the average Joe demands that his life savings be spent on a gold sarcophagus, it just won’t matter.

People tend to prefer fancy cars and houses and electronics and vacations and food and drink.

And you can see the cost of all those things has more than doubled in recent years, a clear indicator of inflation cause by (practically) zero percent interest rates.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by ZhadruOmjar on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:36PM (#35299047)
I don’t know if it’s the newspapers or economists I dislike more but I am pretty sick of watching these people incorrectly predict everything for the last 15 years and then turn around and say they are right when ONE thing sort of looks like the thing they kind of predicted.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by mo_42 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @02:48AM (#35300140)
It’s a convenient symbiosis: Doomsday economists get cited by newspapers, which serves him/her in publicly and the newspaper in clicks.

Simple heuristic: if it’s easily digestible, it probably doesn’t serve true understanding. I think that especially true for newspaper articles related to economics.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by sanp on Friday March 24, 2023 @09:57PM (#35298353)
Ah! Blame the economic ignorance of the masses and the traders. Peter was always right even if reality turned out to be different.
Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by paulpauper on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:02PM (#35298389)
Schiff didn't account for the economic ignorance of the masses in his prediction.

If he is as smart or knowledgeable as he claims or held up to be, then he should have factored that into his forecast and advice. IF the fed is going to do everything in its power to save the economy, why fight it?

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by fyzix on Friday March 24, 2023 @10:33PM (#35298621)
>IF the fed is going to do everything in its power to save the economy, why fight it?

This is a popular sentiment among traders...why fight the FED? Because there is nothing they can do to bring inflation back to 2%. They all but admitted this with their return to QE. When the masses realize this...gold will surge.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by bruce511 on Saturday March 25, 2023 @01:33AM (#35299779)
Certainly those who bought gold as a cash-hedge are hoping it surges...

Alas if, for some inexplicable reason, those unwashed masses don't realize that the gold I bought cheap, isn't the only thing worth buying (at my inflated price) then I will be most disappointed.

I guess it doesn't help that gold-hawking is looking more and more scammy everyday, like when c-level political celebrities with large followings seem happy to flog their "sponsors gold" during political messaging.

Re:Reasons the banking crisis isn’t a repeat of 2008 by kube-system on Friday March 24, 2023 @11:47PM (#35299122)
The actions of the masses is the economy.