Coinbase tried repeatedly to register them with the SEC and was turned away, which seems to be lost on your point.
From the article:
> The SEC will not let crypto companies “come in and register” – we tried.
> The Wells notice comes out of the investigation that we disclosed last summer. Shortly after that investigation began, the SEC asked us if we would be interested in discussing a potential resolution that would include registering some portion of our business with the SEC. We said absolutely yes. Specifically, the SEC asked us to provide our views on what a registration path for Coinbase could look like – because there is no existing way for a crypto exchange to register. We developed and proposed two different registration models. We spent millions of dollars on legal support to build these proposals and repeatedly asked for the SEC’s feedback. We got none. We also reiterated that we stand by our listings process – we don’t list securities today – and repeatedly invited the SEC to raise any questions about any asset at all on our platform. They raised none.
My entire point is that the SEC doesn't like them, to them saying "please register" is the same as saying "get bent". I specifically mentioned that those registration papers are going straight into the trash.
Saying "please register" when you really mean "get bent" doesn't count as SEC clarity in my book.
The SEC stonewalled Coinbase at every attempt to submit a registration. It's not like Coinbase registered and was declined.
Some call it regulation by enforcement, but really I see all along the SEC has been clear in saying that it's all securities. Now, enforcement actions go in front of a court and the court may disagree with the SEC, which then clarifies regulation by setting a legal precedent for the SEC being wrong.
Edit: this is how I think about it: there is a gradient from "clearly under SEC jurisdiction" and "clearly not". The SEC says "most of this gradient is under my jurisdiction", crypto projects say "no it's not". Clarity in this situation means drawing lines in the gradient, and when enforcement actions get filed then a court gets to weigh and draw lines for them.
That's not the part of their stance that's unclear. The unclear part is the part where they say "please register" when they really mean "get bent".
> their calls for clarity are actually calls for "please change your mind"
Coinbase's calls for clarity are actually calls for "you asked us to register, so let us submit a registration application already".
> really I see all along the SEC has been clear in saying that it's all securities.
Again that's not the part of their stance that's unclear to me.
> Now, enforcement actions go in front of a court and the court may disagree with the SEC, which then clarifies regulation by setting a legal precedent for the SEC being wrong.
The SEC's job is to write clear regulations, not to invite corporations to pay $1000/hr lawyers to conduct mind-reading sessions in court.
The SEC is considered by many to be acting in bad faith by not clarifying regulation, which in effect is an abuse of a pocket veto of sorts over crypto.
Other jurisdictions do not have this issue. The SEC stands alone.
From what I gather the SEC just ignored Coinbase’s questions in this back-and-forth.
Seems strange kraken would stop supporting the ability to stake ETH if your claim was true. Thats a ton of money for them to throw away just for fun.
SEC rarely does it’s job until it’s too late and only after someone else has done all the work for them.
There are pretty decent arguments why the other prongs fail as well.
What can be a security, is if a provider offered a managed yield service promising a certian return and guaranteed instant liquidity and then used staking in the background to generate that yield. This is what got Kraken in trouble. And why they settled so easily. Where Coinbase falls is going to heavily depend on the specific facts of their service.
Validating by running your own node is a-ok. Sending your tokens to Coinbase, a registered public company, who is pinky-promising you they will give you 8% returns every year, without registering this product with SEC, is not a-ok. How is that hard to understand?
Basically
A) Kraken’s staking service was a little different, but
B) Kraken didn't fight it and the CEO resigned. Jesse was just over it and not willing to fight. Jesse grandstanded against New York’s bitlicense for nearly a decade, continued Monero support in Europe while dropping it in the UK, he’s had his fight and wants to do other things with his life.
On the UK Monero stance “Unfortunately, we have to pick our battles and look out for the broader business in the country.”
> "The U.S. Supreme Court's Howey case and subsequent case law have found that an "investment contract" exists when there is the investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits to be derived from the efforts of others.[5] The so-called "Howey test" applies to any contract, scheme, or transaction, regardless of whether it has any of the characteristics of typical securities."
So I guess they are arguing they are not securities since their is no "effort of others" even if there could be a reasonable expectation of profits? Similar to art I guess? This seems like a plausible case on a strictly by definition basis, regardless of the way people are actually acting.
If the case is that the SEC just doesn't want to let them register the any of it, is there really no way they could be more straightforward? It seems like post FTX they would have a lot of leeway for this kind of thing. Unless maybe they think enforcement is a better path to lead to eventual regulation?
Part of it is political capital imo: when crypto was going up, saying "none of this is legal" costs political capital and nobody wants to listen; when it's going down and FTX is collapsing, saying "none of this is legal" is free and suddenly Congress/courts are much more partial to the message.
It's the nature of such regulatory agencies. The path to career advancement is often shouting "this is bad, we should regulate" after a disaster occurs, not before. Before the disaster, <thing> made money, and putting a stop to it is hard; after the disaster, <thing> lost people money, people are angry, so putting a stop to it is much easier.
What's special about BTC and ETH that sets it apart from other cryptocurrencies?
A business registers with the SEC to gain a license to trade securities. Securities themselves don't register.
Happy to be educated if above is wrong.
And so, when I look at Bitcoin today, I do not see a central third party whose efforts are a key determining factor in the enterprise."
Almost every other cryptocurrency has one or a small group of person that can take control of the chain / app.
ETH is not leaderless to the same degree, and to my knowledge has not been declared "not a security" by the SEC in the same way BTC has.
and in 2018 an SEC commissioner gave a speech in which he said eth was not a security, but the SEC is doing all they can to muddy the waters on that https://cointelegraph.com/news/sec-seeks-to-keep-hinman-docu...
The crypto industry is not built around avoiding government rules, that's a myth propagated by its many detractors. It was born to address a failure of the banking system that hurt regular people the most.
Industry: Please give us more regulatory clarity
SEC: everything not BTC/ETH is a security, please register them (read: and we'll throw it into the trash because we don't like it)
Industry: but these are clearly not securities, please give us more clarity
SEC: everything not BTC/ETH is a security, please register them
Industry: that's not an answer, we would like to trade crypto
SEC: everything not BTC/ETH is a security, please register them
So the SEC is clear, it's just that the clear answer the SEC is giving is not up to the tastes of industry.
But the SEC is also constrained by politics in the sense of external pressure making them not want to crack down, and by internal politics of hard-to-win cases about proving Howey tests that take forever.
So we have the current situation where the SEC has been very clear that it doesn't like any of the crypto stuff, but the industry pushes the boundaries and sits in the legal grey area where the SEC says it's not kosher but courts may or may not agree. Hence sporadic enforcement actions where they think they have a good case, which then leads to complaining (please more clarity), with the same response (none of this is legal, just because we haven't filed enforcement actions doesn't mean it's kosher).
Edit: ETH is kinda borderline; there is semi-widespread consensus that BTC is not a security, and no such consensus for pretty much anything else.
Edit 2: I don't mean the conversation literally. As far as I know there is no official stance on BTC, but one gets the sense that trying to argue in court that BTC is a security is a losing proposition, whereas <insert governance token for newnotscamcoin> is much closer to a winning case.