News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules. We got lega... by medellin on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @11:23PM (#35270177)
Do you have anything pointing to the SEC giving actual guidance around BTC and ETH because i have never seen it.

Seems strange kraken would stop supporting the ability to stake ETH if your claim was true. Thats a ton of money for them to throw away just for fun.

SEC rarely does it’s job until it’s too late and only after someone else has done all the work for them.

Re:We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules. We got lega... by wmf on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @11:37PM (#35270250)
Spot ETH trading is not a security, but staking ETH may be.
Re:We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules. We got lega... by yokem55 on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @11:56PM (#35270362)
The only way validators who have staked eth make any earnings is if they perform their validator duties. If they don't do the work, they get penalized. If they abuse or attack the network, they get slashed. Since a validator's earnings come from their own work, the whole 'To be derived from the efforts of others' prong completely fails.

There are pretty decent arguments why the other prongs fail as well.

What can be a security, is if a provider offered a managed yield service promising a certian return and guaranteed instant liquidity and then used staking in the background to generate that yield. This is what got Kraken in trouble. And why they settled so easily. Where Coinbase falls is going to heavily depend on the specific facts of their service.

Re:We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules. We got lega... by polygamous_bat on Thursday March 23, 2023 @12:17AM (#35270482)
> The only way validators who have staked eth make any earnings is if they perform their validator duties. If they don't do the work, they get penalized. If they abuse or attack the network, they get slashed. Since a validator's earnings come from their own work, the whole 'To be derived from the efforts of others' prong completely fails.

Validating by running your own node is a-ok. Sending your tokens to Coinbase, a registered public company, who is pinky-promising you they will give you 8% returns every year, without registering this product with SEC, is not a-ok. How is that hard to understand?

Re:We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules. We got lega... by yieldcrv on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @11:39PM (#35270263)
The SEC is kind of relying on these appeals to authority to pile up so nobody really questions anything

Basically

A) Kraken’s staking service was a little different, but

B) Kraken didn't fight it and the CEO resigned. Jesse was just over it and not willing to fight. Jesse grandstanded against New York’s bitlicense for nearly a decade, continued Monero support in Europe while dropping it in the UK, he’s had his fight and wants to do other things with his life.

On the UK Monero stance “Unfortunately, we have to pick our battles and look out for the broader business in the country.”