News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by fdgsdfogijq on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:46PM (#35235539)
What people arent saying:

VCs received cheap loans and financial services from SVB if they got their portfolio companies to bank with SVB. There were in some sense backdoor deals, which resulted in these odd loans and bad portfolios. It was all built on an assumption of cheap capital. People are not discussing how incestuous SVB was with VCs, and many will get off the hook for unethical financial behavior.

I dont think calling SVB poorly run is accurate, it was run for profits. The decision making is opaque at this point, and my guess is if the curtain is pulled back, it was run exactly as intended.

If you watch the most recent episode of the AllIn podcast, they hint at this being the case. Clearly they know there was bad behavior, but dont discuss it at length. This is just another case of wealthy people gambling, with the common man absorbing the losses.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by hbarka on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:00PM (#35235787)
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by fdgsdfogijq on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:19PM (#35236138)
This is a stunning clip, especially given how instrumental JCal and David Saks were on twitter calling for a bank run and subsequent bailout.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by unit_circle on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:28PM (#35237275)
I agree this is a stunning clip and a disgusting display of nepotism.

But I wouldn't say this clip is stunning (other than the temporal proximity). Sounds like this dude likes to run his mouth. He's bragging about his 3k sqft loft and these weird loan deals in front of strangers... I have no idea who he is, but if you showed me this clip and asked me to guess what he did when things went down, I'd tell you he said some (probably dumb) off-the-cuff stuff.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by permo-w on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#35236456)
if an organisation is giving out money that it doesn’t have, presumably from the deposits of other clients, is that not just a ponzi scheme?
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by thedangler on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:43PM (#35236534)
You do realize the US Banks run on 0 fractional reserve lending... They could do what ever they wanted with 0 cash to support the lending.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by admax88qqq on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:18PM (#35237126)
There are other rules on what they can do.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by permo-w on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:17PM (#35239589)
you say that as if it’s a contradiction
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by hbarka on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:47PM (#35236591)
It’s called Fractional Reserve Banking: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/fractionalreservebankin...

However, I’m not sure what percent SVB kept. Some are saying zero, is this true?

There is a requirement but not sure if easing of Dodd-Frank allowed SVB to bypass it. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/12/01/2022-26...

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by permo-w on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:18PM (#35239602)
calling it something different doesn’t change the fact that when people came for their money it wasn’t there

additionally it seems the US made their fractional reserve requirement 0% in 2020

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by carapace on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:22PM (#35236190)
Here's a loony thought: what if the VCs just exited the whole Valley 'cause they saw the handwriting on the wall in re: ChatGPT et. al. dropping the floor out of the startup industry?

It's not true, I think, but it makes for a neat movie plot idea?

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by frozenport on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:50PM (#35235620)
Sounds like legitimate business model, and not surprising for a place called "Silicon Valley" Bank?

If SVB can't offer better deals for VCs then nobody can?

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by luckylion on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:25PM (#35236245)
But it came with strings attached: you put all your companies' money here, far beyond FDIC insurance levels, and don't go anywhere else, and for that we'll get you a nice rate on this unrelated private deal.

Sounds pretty close to an investment where the investor shouldn't be made whole.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by enra on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:34PM (#35236400)
I never heard this to be the case. Yeah VC might recommend SVB but I’ve never seen or heard a term sheet that said you must put money in SVB. Once VC wires the money, it’s in the company’s control and they can put it or do whatever want with it (obviously within reasonable corporate governance). VCs don’t have much power, even if they do in some companies, you don’t want to spend it on something like where the company banks.

Companies put money in SVB because it was often the default option that everyone used that understood how startups operate.

Then in some cases, companies would raise additional venture debt from SVB and for that you had to park money there. I got invited to events too and rep pushed the debt as “dilution free money” (as opposed to normal money for equity vc deal).

I never took it as didn’t need it.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by luckylion on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:03PM (#35236858)
And apparently some (many?) got private back-room deals as well, a prominent example linked on a sibling tree: https://twitter.com/bradocapital/status/1635644287630159872 There was some discussion on HN about some VCs putting it in term sheets. I don't know if it's true, I guess we won't find out because law suits have been averted.

When you're mixing private deals (for investores and founders) with company deals, you're usually on the hook for something. Letting them off the hook is nice, but it sends a terrible message and will only lead to greater implosions later.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by x0x0 on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:33PM (#35237341)
You seem to be repeating nothing more than rumors you're unsure of.

If you claim VCs were demanding portfolio companies use svb, then let's hear names. I've raised money from multiple VCs and that's never been even hinted at.

We used svb because I've used Chase in the past. I know a bunch of stories that I'm not interesting in sharing publicly, but they're terrible. Here's one public story about what the "service" at Chase is like: the morons lost an updated phone number and almost shut down a small business with kyc inquiries dropped on them day of: https://twitter.com/joshtpm/status/1635083618380025858

The value of svb to us was they were a bank with a glowing rep, glowing ratings, good service when we called and asked for stuff, albeit with not particularly good software.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by enra on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:30PM (#35239057)
I don’t know if “backroom deals” means “relationship deals”. Basically every private bank operates with relationship deals, meaning they know who you are, what you do, and they know your assets, on which the relationship manager can make a call what kind of loans or other services to provide.

What SVB did was that they know your are vc/founder who raised from a16z and have this many assets or whatever. Because of that they were willing to give you a loan on favorable terms because see low risk defaulting on that.

How every other bank does it: they look at your credit score, ask 2 years salary, ask if you own 20% of any company and some other questions. The feed it to some algorithm running in cobalt which gives them answer if it’s good to go or no. They dont care about your profession, the fact that you run $100M business or your personal assets. You might have $10M equity portfolio but normal bank doesn’t care because it’s not part of their mortgage questionnaire. If you say yes to 20% company question, they have to look in the company revenue (again not assets but taxes and revenue) and the answer might be no because generally banks don’t like back entrepreneurs even if company has $100M in their bank account.

So imo SVB was going much more about the people they were making loans for than most common banks. Their main risk there was that they had huge tech industry concentration that could hurt them if tech completely melts down)

(Disclaimer: I don’t have loans or deposits in SVB. I did apply for the mortgage with but didn’t take it)

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by dragonwriter on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:26PM (#35236261)
Honestly, it sounds like an offer that banks should be prohibited from making by banking regulations, not something the counterparty should be punished for accepting.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by luckylion on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:35PM (#35236419)
Maybe, but that's probably not happening, and we already have a mechanism that heavily disincentivizes it: make risky deals that go bad and you only get the money that was insured, but not the risky deal-part.

It's just that we've decided that this time the risk mustn't be carried by those that profited from the deal.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by red-iron-pine on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:36PM (#35237394)
> you put all your companies' money here, far beyond FDIC insurance levels, and don't go anywhere else, and for that we'll get you a nice rate on this unrelated private deal.

that's called fleecing the rubes and scamming the noobs

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by jasmer on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:23PM (#35238096)
"far beyond FDIC insurance levels" ?

FDIC insurance is not there to insure most commerical banking.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with banks or any other business giving better deals to more valuable customers.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by SilasX on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:01PM (#35235805)
But the thing that did SVB in was, overwhelmingly, Treasury bonds, due to duration risk and interest rates going up, nothing to do with the bank's more exotic practices.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by cameldrv on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:17PM (#35236103)
The problem with the T-bonds and MBS losing value when rates went up may be the proximate cause, but there certainly is more to the story. They actually had a good portion of this exposure hedged in 2021 and didn't renew the hedge in 2022.

The people running SVB were not stupid and were very aware of this risk, yet they chose to take it. There is a reason for this which we will find out in the fullness of time.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by ummonk on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#35236062)
And mortgage backed securities. Both highly safe. It was in managing interest rate risk that they failed.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by fdgsdfogijq on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:04PM (#35235859)
This isnt the truth. 10% of their portfolio was worthless VC loans.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by raws on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:14PM (#35236046)
Another 10% was low % 5yrs bonds which they had to sell early with penalties to cover the run on the bank which incurred considerable losses. I would think a VC bank knows that some of its VC investments would not outperform. My understanding is that if the run does not happen, it's business as usual, nothing like '08 when borrowers started failing to pay en mass on internationally overrated loans in AAApackages.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by tomatocracy on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:19PM (#35236136)
Bank regulations are designed to ensure that this type of thing is a shareholder (and pref/AT1) risk - I haven't seen any claims that they were inappropriately or incorrectly rating those risks for capital purposes (but perhaps they were, who knows).
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by walrus01 on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:14PM (#35236042)
They also hold (held?) $80bn in mortgage backed securities, which I'm consistently suspicious of how much is really grade A investment material.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by cameldrv on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:38PM (#35237425)
MBS having too many defaults was the problem in 2008, which I think is making people turn their attention to this issue. However, we are in a different situation today. IMO the tradable securities that SVB held are probably the least of their problems. The MBS certainly has the problem of being worth less due to higher interest rates.

The MBS at least though is tradable and has a market price. Their own book of loans though is much larger and is subject to the same interest rate problems as their MBS and treasuries, and in addition to having lost value due to interest rate issues, it may now have default issues as well. Not a good combination.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by kurthr on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:07PM (#35236937)
Well, that's where the losses came in, but why were so many startups holding so much uninsured money at a medium sized (not systemically regulated) bank?

I really can't wrap my head around holding $500M earning almost no interest (>$10M annual) in an uninsured account. Why? It's not like they had that much in monthly expenses or income. Was it just more incompetence or as has been suggested in other posts were there "benefits" of doing this that may not have accrued to the corporation?

Of course it was the run of those giant uninsured depositors that caused the immediate cash. Of course it's not clear (had all depositors not been bailed out) that anyone withdrawing within the last 90 days would have not had their withdrawals clawed back... we'll never know. If that had happened, I think we would see a lot fewer flash runs.

edit: https://www.thestreet.com/banking/svb-collapse-roku-had-487-...

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by aeternum on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:27PM (#35237257)
Bank failures is just not something that most startups think about.

It's also weird that we expect large depositors to think about it. If we created the system today, we would never think it okay to just destroy people's money at scale. Large depositors get almost nothing (very low interest rate) in return for that immense risk.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by kurthr on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:29PM (#35237289)
Exactly, so why are they holding it there?

It could have provided 5-10% of (their negative) net income.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by aeternum on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:05PM (#35237803)
It takes time & effort to engage with one of the few fintech companies that ensures you store only 250k in each bank. That also opens you up to other types of risk as now you have some relatively new startup that has access to your company funds.

Companies and individuals are not trying to invest in their bank when they open a checking account. Does it really make sense that they need to dive into their bank's financials?

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by kurthr on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:25PM (#35238998)
Ummm, if it nets you $10-20M a year in risk free income on a highly liquid asset it does! Pay someone to do it. It's not a full time job.

We're not talking about a special fintech, we're talking about a MoneyMarket or Treasury account, which are higher interest and lower risk than a bank account, but you're limited to a withdrawal or two a week.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by walrus01 on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:05PM (#35235862)
> People are not discussing how incestuous

I think everyone would be served by a frank examination and critical review of buddy-buddy networks and "incestuous" relationships in the finance industry generally. Not just SVB and VCs.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by plussed_reader on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#35236074)
And now you're identifying the problem of analyzing the incumbent money and power structures; witness the corrupted speed at which an entity like UBS is absorbing DebitSuisse and the like within the banking industry consolidating at breakneck speed ahead of regulatory framework processes.

Smells of that too big to fail BS all over again.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by kneebonian on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#35237405)
The details may be different but the whole "bailing out people who had more than $250k in SVB", reeked to me of the big people with money and power getting bailed out, while the small people get screwed again.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by ProAm on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:50PM (#35235626)
This is why Im against the uninsured deposits being bailed out. There was a lot of under the table back office deals. Everyone with a million dollars knows what the word uninsured means.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by kqr on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:49PM (#35236639)
> I dont think calling SVB poorly run is accurate, it was run for profits.

Well, are they profitable? If they are currently failing to achieve what they supposedly aim for, surely the way they are run leaves something to be desired?

It may be tempting to argue that "they were well run until the bad thing happened" but that is a fairly low bar for running things well.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by chris_va on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:33PM (#35237339)
> with the common man absorbing the losses.

Most of your comment seemed reasonable, if a tad speculative given a lack of insider knowledge. But the last part feels like unnecessarily searching for a class warfare argument.

To date, said execs have lost their equity, and liabilities have been transferred. It remains to be seen if any more losses will be absorbed, and by whom and how much.

A counter argument is that a bunch of bank runs will destroy the "common man" and small businesses a lot more than folks parking money in hedge funds. The FDIC insurance pool works fine for a small number of regional banks, but it really is not that large.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by fdgsdfogijq on Monday March 20, 2023 @03:42PM (#35237474)
Gambles with customer funds -> looses -> passes losses to be bailed out through opaque means. This is really not that different than FTX, except it was legal. The current argument is they were incompetent and fell into some bad bets, this is the same argument Sam Bankman Fried tried to argue. Its all a facade
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by chris_va on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:10PM (#35237878)
"passes losses to be bailed out through opaque means" isn't at all correct. Comparing SBF to to buying treasury bonds is somewhat laughable... let's focus on what actually happened instead.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by fdgsdfogijq on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:13PM (#35237929)
Thats another misconception, there were mortgage backed securities and VC loans in their portfolio. The idea that this was purely about treasuries is another attempt at passing off the buck.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by jasmer on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:17PM (#35237984)
In what way is VC's getting deals for referring customers even remotely nefarious?

It's the way the entire world works and there's nothing wrong with it in general.

SVB did not collapse because of this, the collapsed because of bad risk management, a lot of money that they could not lend out in low yield bonds they were locked into. It wasn't even that bad.

The VCs decided to shoot themselves in the foot by creating a run on their own banks.

Their hypocrisy is stunning.

But Calacanis talking about getting sweetheart attention is a nothingburger.

Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by erredois on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:23PM (#35240841)
It was badly run, the main job a bank have is to manage it's risk. They did a bad job at managing risk.
Re:Fed Guy: SVB was particularly poorly run by Arnt on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:25AM (#35243713)
The bank died from a bank run. How much capital outflow per day, per week, per month should a bank's management plan to handle, do you think?