News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:11PM (#35225317)
The western world needs to switch to plant-based diets.

We stuff our bellies with 100+kg of meat per capita per year (not counting fish, iirc), we produce a lot of dairy (we started in WW2 and stayed with it), fishing and fish farming is not sustainable at all as well, and the developing world is copying our ways - those people of course want to live like we do, they want to have the same stuff and same quality of life.

There are not enough Earths to sustain all people living this life, no planet B, C, D and E.

There is enough evidence that we drive wild animals to extinction, and animal agriculture / fishing is the culprit, ergo our eating habits are to blame.

No politicians will ever do anything meaningful, when everybody just wants to eat fish several times a week and meat everyday and will stone anybody suggesting otherwise.

No wild mammals? No fish in the sea? Maybe do something ... personally ... while there's time.

West has to make veganism cool and show the world how to save the little that still remains.

Without public support, nothing will ever happen.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by matheusmoreira on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:42PM (#35225614)
> the developing world is copying our ways

Eating meat has been part of our culture for a very long time.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:46PM (#35225656)
We eat way more meat/dairy than our ancestors did (after we switched to farming, because we killed off most of the megafauna).
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by matheusmoreira on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:47PM (#35225672)
It's got nothing to do with "copying" developed nations, though. We're simply becoming rich enough to afford it. Eating meat every day used to be prohibitively expensive. That's changed.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:50PM (#35225696)
It's cheap because we destroy nature in the process, and those externalities are not priced in ... in fact, most of the meat/dairy production is heavily subsidized.

It's affordable, yes. But it's not sustainable.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by ahzhou on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:49PM (#35225687)
While true, I think the quantity is abnormal in terms of human history, since meat used to be considered a luxury item.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by krmboya on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:00AM (#35227478)
And there are some cultures that lived exclusively on meat based diets
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by grozzle on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:39PM (#35234288)
Like who? Inuit, who live where plants don't grow? Historical Mongolians, until cereal crops were introduced to their lands? Nomadic Masai who don't stay around for crops?

Can't think of anyone else, without a similar exceptional reason.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:37PM (#35225562)
I agree. A good first step would be to figure out how to align the markets with the needs of the ecosystems that support those markets.

It's hard to get excited about going vegan when that can of lentil soup costs the same as a can of beef stew despite one being 10x more energy intensive to create. Are you really reducing demand for meat or are you just making making meat cheaper for everyone else?

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:56PM (#35225765)
You're right that many foods, processed ones, are much more expensive than animal based ones despite them being more energy and land resource intensive.

But most vegan foods are the cheapest ones in the supermaket ... I mean raw rice, beans, lentils, vegetables. If you cook that soup yourself, it won't cost more than a bag of lentils, 1-2 onions, veggie stock, few potatoes, salt, pepper, and 20 minutes in pressure cooker (I've done it today :) Delicious too, and you've got 5l of soup for ... 3 USD?

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by no_butterscotch on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:35PM (#35225534)
We could use less meat but I don't think you should take a "moral" argument to this.

There are plenty of cultures around the world for which cuisine plays a big role including being carnivore-based. There are festivals, arts, traditions, culinary heritage, etc.

I believe as said we could eat less meat, but I think taking an argument from a "moral supremacist" sort of stand-point isn't the right solution to get people over to that side.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by barbazoo on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:41PM (#35225609)
> here are plenty of cultures around the world for which cuisine plays a big role including being carnivore-based.

You're totally right obviously that there are but also I think we're at a point in the history of humanity where we're informed enough to take the impact of our actions into consideration regardless of how long we've performed those actions.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:17PM (#35225982)
> I don't think you should take a "moral" argument to this

And I've done that ... where exactly?

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by tossaway0 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:35PM (#35225539)
I’m a bit ignorant on this, but what are the projections for consequences to ecosystems if we just keep eating to extinction?

I ask because your solution seems to just get us to the same place diet wise: having to eat plants now instead of later. You could see why that alone wouldn’t be a motivation.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:20PM (#35226022)
> I ask because your solution seems to just get us to the same place diet wise: having to eat plants now instead of later

We will have to eat plants sooner or later.

But if we'll start sooner, we'll also may have the functioning land and sea ecosystems and a lot of biodiversity.

I know you wouldn't notice it on your plate, and maybe you don't see any value in that, but I'm hoping that many (or at least some) do.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by NoZebra120vClip on Sunday March 19, 2023 @10:24PM (#35226511)
Why not chown down on some bugs, on the way down? Plentiful protein. Less moral ick than eating milky mammals, flappy floofs, and scale wiggles.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:01AM (#35229821)
We already get 63% of protein from plant sources. There is nothing magical in animal protein ... all animal protein comes in fact from plant sources.

https://ourworldindata.org/land-use

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by adam_arthur on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:34PM (#35225522)
If the plant based meat alternatives ever got around to actually being substantially cheaper than meat, this would likely be mitigated to a large extent.

Beyond Meat's revenue has actually been declining YoY, which was surprising. It turns out people aren't very excited about paying more for an imitation version.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by barbazoo on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:38PM (#35225572)
"Plant-based diet" != "Plant based meat". I wish people learned at school how to cook a vegetarian meal. You don't need meat to make something delicious, you don't need meat to get the required amount of protein, it's all bullshit. You get everything you need from non-animal sources.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by adam_arthur on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:40PM (#35225597)
Sure, but that's not reality.

The average person isn't going to give up the taste of meat. If you want to solve problems, work within the realms of the actual constraints. It's far easier to make plant based meat cheaper than to change the taste preferences of billions of people.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by O__________O on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:50PM (#35225694)
No, the obsession over “meat like” is counterproductive. No “meat” anything. As soon as you make something comparable, no one is going to switch unless it tastes a multi-times better than it’s comparable.

Just make nutritious non-meat food that’s delicious and doesn’t impact global ecosystem.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by AuryGlenz on Monday March 20, 2023 @01:01AM (#35227486)
Nutritious non-meat already exists.

As a non-meat eater where the idea of eating meat literally makes you sick, you're not really qualified to talk about what the rest of us meat-eaters would need to switch to more plants. People would absolutely eat more of it if it tasted just like meat and was the same cost or cheaper.

They won't if it doesn't hit the same craving or is more expensive, as we've seen.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:21AM (#35229983)
> you're not really qualified to talk about what the rest of us meat-eaters would need to switch to more plants

Don't forget that most of those non-meat eaters were in fact meat eaters before.

> They won't if it doesn't hit the same craving

Stop drinking sugary drinks, and cravings for them will, in time, stop. Stop eating meat and dairy, and those cravings will stop too. It takes maybe few weeks, but after that ... you may even find it repulsive, however alien that thought might seem to you now.

> or is more expensive, as we've seen

It may be, it depends on you and on what you choose to eat. You'd find most vegans in the poorest countries.

There's no reason why vegan diet should be more expensive than animal based one. The variety of available processed foods goes up, and prices are being driven down by increased production and demand.

If you're used to cooking your own meals, you can expect to lower your grocery bill. Beans, lentils, peas, tofu, all that is cheaper than meat. Cheeses and yoghuts are more expensive in my area, but you can make it easily from plant based milks youself (it's not so hard or time expensive).

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by O__________O on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:54AM (#35230244)
Thanks, agree with all your points, though at some point unless others are agreeing with me, 100% sure it would feel like I am dead set on my position, which I am not, and happy to reasonably assess any points made by others.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by dinvlad on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:50PM (#35225702)
I remember reading that growing meat is one of the most inefficient methods to produce food, in terms of time, energy and money required. I guess making it even less economical is what could drive a natural transition towards more sustainable/efficient sources.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by ChatGTP on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:21PM (#35225410)
Personally I tried to be vegan I was tired, hungry and depressed.

I love the idea of it though.

I do think we could reduce the amount of meat we eat though.

We try do like 3-4 days / nights of week vegetarian, probably mostly vegan really.

If everyone started something like this and tried to do more of it it might help.

Realistically we just have to many people on Earth, we've also polluted a ruined a lot natural environments.

I believe the most healthy/ethical way to consume meat and fish would be if most people do their own hunting, fishing and farming, smaller scale. The problem is the river near my house is full of toxic pollution so I can't fish there, what do you do?

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by colordrops on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:37PM (#35225558)
There's no scientific reason for you to have been tired, hungry, and depressed unless you introduced foods you were allergic/sensitive to, or you did not eat a balanced complete diet. All essential nutrients can be found in vegan diets, other than B12, if you are not eating fortified foods. You may have had a B12 deficiency, which is extremely cheap and easy to supplement.

It might be worth trying again and seeing a doctor and getting blood work if you feel off.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by seb1204 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:17PM (#35226845)
I simply are not up to speed with what to replace the meat with. I know there are alternatives out there but knowing them, knowing where to buy them, prep and cook them is the main hurdle.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:03AM (#35229838)
Sorry, I'll recycle my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35229804
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:44PM (#35225643)
> tried to be vegan I was tired, hungry and depressed

First I've ate what my vegetarian girlfriend was eating. I too was always hungry, and soon gave up.

Later when I've decided to switch to veganism I've read a lot about it first (as always with anything new). I've started replacing my favourite recipes with their vegan variants. For few weeks I've counted calories and nutrients (there're apps for that) to make sure I'm eating healthy. I've learned to cook and replace meat products with their plant-based versions.

There are many ways how to eat vegan, not all of them are healthy (junk) or wise (raw / fruit only).

> healthy/ethical way to consume meat and fish would be if most people do their own hunting

10000 years ago there were only 5 mil. people on Earth, and they've managed to reduce wild mammals population from 20 mil. tonnes of C to 15 mil. tonnes. Can you imagine doing something similar today, with 8 billion of us?

> the river near my house is full of toxic pollution so I can't fish there, what do you do

Don't eat fish at all, and maybe take up on activism ... complacency won't save us.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by dinvlad on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:47PM (#35225668)
Here's hoping that new tech like lab-grown meat will also be there in time to achieve this..
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:51PM (#35225709)
It may not come for decades ... at scale. Then it may be already late.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by javman on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:51PM (#35225712)
Have you seen what modern plant farms look like?

Massive water usage, lowering river levels drastically. Some don't even reach the ocean anymore (see the Colorado River, from Wikipedia: "Since 1960, the Colorado has typically dried up before reaching the sea, with the exception of a few wet years."). Aquifers are running low (here's some info on that from 20 years ago: https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/fs-103-03/).

Pesticides, herbicides and fertilizers.

Massive land use for mono-culture farms, displacing whatever wildlife and native plants were present before the farm. Add more farms and you'll have less wildlife.

Everyone switching to plant-based diet sounds nice, but is really not going to fix much. Unless you can change farming to not be so resource intensive? There are just too many people.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:14PM (#35225955)
Animal agriculture uses 3x more land than plants.

Do you really think that those things you've listed (water, pesticides, herbicides, fertilizers, displacing wildlife...) are solely a problem for plant farms? I must have misunderstand you.

> Everyone switching to plant-based diet sounds nice, but is really not going to fix much

We could save 75% of those lands. https://ourworldindata.org/land-use

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by ajmurmann on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:01AM (#35227125)
And a lot of the plants we grow are to feed livestock.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by andbberger on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:51PM (#35227055)
irrelevant given efficiency losses when raising livestock. where do you think the food your chickens eat comes from
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by stainablesteel on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:53PM (#35225726)
> The western world needs to switch to plant-based diets.

i've never seen any data to back up this viewpoint, and its always coupled with other alarmist messages. i'm skeptical of comments written this way.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:15PM (#35225970)
That's my viewpoint. The data is there, but most choose to ignore it, together with all those reports of environmental destruction.
Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by DiscourseFan on Sunday March 19, 2023 @08:55PM (#35225757)
I was vegetarian for a while and then vegan for a whole year. I understand where you're coming from but it's simply not healthy for most people to go without any animal products in their diets, especially for growing children and those who cannot consume hight amounts of fiber (crohns disease). Perhaps the tax breaks enjoyed by the beef and dairy industries should be removed, but most sources of animal protein are remarkable environmentally friendly--farmed fishing is far less carbon intensive than almost all plant-based sources of protein[1]. Once you look at the facts of the matter, veganism has more to do with how someone feels about harming animals than actually helping the environment: most vegans still eat a lot of heavily processed foods, drive cars, fly on planes, have most of their food and consumer goods delivered to them via trucking. These are not issues that can be solved on an individual level but systemic and society wide problems that need to be addressed with public policy. No individual(s) are to be blamed. It is a collective, social responsibility.

[1]https://news.asu.edu/20190621-solutions-environmental-impact...

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:08PM (#35225901)
> it's simply not healthy for most people to go without any animal products in their diets

That's not true, sorry. https://talkveganto.me/en/facts/suitable-for-all/

> Salmon and tuna also ranked high for efficiency, but only when they were wild-caught.

Do they also account for by-catch? Do they account for the fact that 40+% of marine plastics is fishing nets & equipment? https://www.seaspiracy.org/facts

> most vegans still eat a lot of heavily processed foods, drive cars, fly on planes, have most of their food and consumer goods delivered to them via trucking

There are many things wrong with our society. But I don't agree with you here. Plant-based is one of the best things an individual can do the lower his carbon footprint (together with reduction of driving & air travel).

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by DiscourseFan on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:34PM (#35226154)
>> it's simply not healthy for most people to go without any animal products in their diets

>That's not true, sorry. https://talkveganto.me/en/facts/suitable-for-all/

Please cite a neutral source on the matter.

In the end, the food you buy, clothes you wear, even the computer you're using right now, no matter animal based or not, is, as I said, almost certainly shipped to you by some sort of carbon-emitting vehicle, usually one, like a truck, that emits far more carbon than any car you might drive. The industrial processes involved to create these, everything in your life, emit carbon--certainly worse than that, your computer was built with rare earth minerals that were probably extracted with near or actual slave labor. Your existence, on this planet, as a human being, is harmful in some sense to the environment, there is no getting around the fact that you, as an embodied ego, has to cause some level of destruction to the life around you in order to continue living. And there is no getting around the fact that the industrial revolution has radically improved the quality of life around the world for the better, and that nobody, I assume yourself included, as you responded to me on an online forum, would ever abandon all the luxuries it brings. That doesn't mean that we can't improve things as they are. On the contrary, for instance, when you said:

>Plant-based is one of the best things an individual can do the lower his carbon footprint

That only applies to a developed economy. India has some of the worst pollution in the world on account of their backwards agricultural practices, and their population is something like 50% vegetarian, it is only on account of technology that we have been able to feed the large populations of the US and Europe without destroying local environments. When that technology is employed for the benefit of people who work together to improve their conditions, then society flourishes. But technology, scientific and social development are all developed collectively, and they are the only way to improve our environmental conditions--nobody alone, no individual responsibility, as I said, will change what the mass of society will do. If you let individuals alone to do what they like, on the sole condition they eat plant-based diets, I'm sure you will get something a lot closer to what they have in India than anything else.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Sunday March 19, 2023 @09:45PM (#35226227)
>> it's simply not healthy for most people to go without any animal products in their diets

> Please cite a neutral source on the matter.

I did.

American Dietetic Association

It is the position of the American Dietetic Association that appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases. Well-planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for individuals during all stages of the life cycle, including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood, and adolescence, and for athletes.

NHS UK

A vegetarian or vegan diet can be suitable for everyone, regardless of their age.

British Dietetic Association.

It is possible to follow a well-planned, plant-based, vegan friendly diet that supports healthy living in people of all ages ...

World Health Organisation

For adults, protein from two or more plant groups daily is like to be adequate. For children, however, and especially those aged 6-24 months, each meal should contain wherever possible two complementary sources of plant protein

> In the end, the food you buy, clothes you wear, even the computer

We have to choose our battles.

> That only applies to a developed economy

Yes, I'm talking about western economies. No point talking about Ethiopia, for example. [1]

> we have been able to feed the large populations of the US and Europe without destroying local environments

Have you read about soil degradation [0] or that animal agriculture is leading driver behind tropical deforestation ? What's the point in celebrating of "saving" of local environments, when we're destroying rainforests in the process?

> no individual responsibility, as I said, will change what the mass of society will do

Yesterday I was clever, and wanted to change the world. Today I'm wise, so I'm changing myself. Or something along the lines ... No, one individual can't. But many together can. And that was my point.

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/daphneewingchow/2020/06/24/eart...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_meat_cons...

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by AuryGlenz on Monday March 20, 2023 @12:56AM (#35227457)
Most people with omnivorous diets are pretty far from eating healthy, balanced diets. You expect them to be able to follow "appropriately planned" vegan and vegetarian diets?

In no world would I risk my daughter growing up nutritionally deficient because I didn't get the right supplements or yeast paste or whatever. It's far easier to give her a balanced diet and not worry.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:58AM (#35229804)
> In no world would I risk my daughter growing up nutritionally deficient

Start yourself, learn and experiment. It's not so hard. But I warn you, it's addictive ;)

> because I didn't get the right supplements or yeast paste or whatever

Just B12 is necessary, either as supplements (vegan are also available) or in fortified foods. Also don't do junk food/raw version of veganism.

Other than that ... variety is the answer.

What to replace meat with? Try a search engine:

https://html.duckduckgo.com/html?q=how%20to%20replace%20meat...

https://html.duckduckgo.com/html?q=how%20to%20veganize%20rec...

https://html.duckduckgo.com/html?q=%3Cmy%20favourite%20recip...

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by freilanzer on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:00PM (#35235789)
> Start yourself, learn and experiment. It's not so hard. But I warn you, it's addictive ;)

It's a complex and a time-consuming activity. My ex was vegan and buying groceries was not easy.

Re:Nations reach accord to protect marine life on high seas by myshpa on Monday March 20, 2023 @02:53PM (#35236696)
It gets better every year.