Putting the table of contents shortcuts on the left instead of the top, on the other hand, seems pointless to me, since if I wanted to jump to a particular section, I would already know that at the top of the page, and I wouldn't need to do it after I was already halfway down. Putting languages halfway down makes more sense to me, since it's exactly halfway down where if I find some controversial text or a disappointingly slim section, that's exactly when I want to see which other languages are available and if those versions contained more details or a different point of view.
I read a lot of Wikipedia, so literally every day since the redesign I've found myself annoyed at all the extra scrolling and clicking I have been required to do while this new floating sidebar sits there providing negative value. Negative because it's both wider than the old one, and because it constantly distracts my reading as I scroll by changing the color. I do like the idea of providing a floating sidebar, and I am not opposed to putting the table of contents in there for people who want it, but removing the language navigation functionality was really a big miss for me.
No, this feature had always been one click in the toolbar. Now it needs at least two clicks, and usually also a bunch of scrolling. Definitely a regression in my eyes.
That's because it was a different page about the same thing.
Pages in other languages aren't and shouldn't be translations.
Now the Spanish page for Cheems is probably at risk of being merged into the Doge page because that's what happened on the English Wikipedia because Cheems isn't as popular with English speakers.
I don't see how being "different page about the same thing" justifies lack of the language switch.
> Pages in other languages aren't and shouldn't be translations.
That's a straw man. I didn't say they are or they should be.
> That's a straw man. I didn't say they are or they should be.
I didn't say or imply you said that, just that it could be a result of the new policy.
> This has always been the case, and the rollout of a new skin certainly hasn't changed that.
Often concerns are about things that haven't happened before, and yet they still come true. For instance the pandemic was full of firsts.
Why would you think that?
Each language's Wikipedia is a separate project with its own administration and its own criteria for notability. This has always been the case, and the rollout of a new skin certainly hasn't changed that.
I think a search engine is appropriate.
Literally the only thing which has changed about them with this skin rollout is that they are now shown in a dropdown at the top of the page, rather than on the sidebar or at the bottom of the page.
First of all, English is not my native language. Common pattern when reading Wikipedia for me is to check native version, then switch to English if there was not enough info. In the previous design I had to re-Google English version of the page. Now it's one click in the toolbar.
Then, the content narrowing. It wasn't until I got some pages in the old design that I felt reading full-width text (on a 16:9 display) uncomfortable.
Table of contents on the left also helps and makes experience more uniform across different sites and software (Google Docs, PDF viewers, and so on).
Overall, the changes just "clicked" right. Don't even have anything to rant about, the design gets out of the way after the first five minutes of reading.
Thanks to Alex and team!