News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by fwlr on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:09AM (#35206581)
In times of crisis during war, countries may draft men into combat to fight against their will. If this fertility crisis keeps up, I wonder if we will see a similar kind of draft for women to breed. It seems unconscionable but literal existential risks can drive countries to do a lot of unconscionable things.

(Immigration isn’t the answer, their fertility rate also gets depressed just like the native population. All it achieves is to balance the birth/death rate on paper for the year.)

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by et-al on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:32AM (#35206702)
What's up with all these responses about turning women into breeding machines when the basic issue is that it's difficult to provide a decent life for a child on a single income?

How about we make it not a PITA to be a mother?

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by fwlr on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:29AM (#35206959)
We have been trying to do that for a good two decades or so. The article mentions several programs Japan has implemented to try and make not a PITA to be a mother. Doubtless we will also continue to implement more of these programs as the problem gets worse.

You are seeing these “breeding machine” type posts because people are extrapolating from the current poor success rate of these programs and thinking about what more drastic steps might be taken. (Do note that I don’t approve of forcibly turning women into breeding machines, just like I don’t approve of forcibly turning men into killing machines. I did call it unconscionable.)

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by Turskarama on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:28AM (#35206678)
>(Immigration isn’t the answer, their fertility rate also gets depressed just like the native population. All it achieves is to balance the birth/death rate on paper for the year.)

What? The reason low fertility is bad is that you end up with a proportionally small working age population, immigration doesn't "solve" low birth rates but it does solve the problem low birth rates cause. In fact it does it even better, because you have a proportionally lower number of children who are just as unproductive as retirees.

The reason Japan doesn't have much immigration is because they have, shall we say, a strong desire to remain purely Japanese and don't believe immigrants can become truly Japanese.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by Xcelerate on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:27AM (#35206675)
> but literal existential risks

Unpopular opinion (and playing devil’s advocate since I have two kids), but is it necessarily a bad thing if people stop wanting to have children and the human race just gradually disappears? There are a lot of other types of potential existential threats on the horizon that might be unsolvable and could entail a significant amount of suffering (e.g. global warming, super viruses, rogue AI)—perhaps it’s better to stop reproducing and just let things end peacefully? I can’t thing of a great argument for forcing societies to continue having children if they no longer wish to do so. Sure, you’ll have some “who will take care of all the elderly in 50 years?” but you could plan a bit for that and the problem would only last for one generation.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by whatshisface on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:40AM (#35206736)
The year is 2203. The Amish control the rich farmlands of the north; the Cult of Moroni controls the resources of the South. I am writing this as the last representative of the culture they once called western, and have no children of my own, since I am focusing on my career as a post-apocalyptic narrator right now and I'm just not as settled down as I would like to be, and besides, these are my prime earning years!
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by throwaway290 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:39AM (#35206731)
> better to stop reproducing and just let things end peacefully?

Prisoner's dilemma, I guess. If everyone stops reproducing, the people who keep at it secure more resources for their offspring.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by imtringued on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:19AM (#35207520)
They don't. Look at African countries with up to seven children per family.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by throwaway290 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:53AM (#35207958)
Reread the comment I was replying to. This is a hypothetical.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by fwlr on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:41AM (#35207011)
“Is it necessarily a bad thing if people stop wanting to have children and the human race just gradually disappears?”

People can make up their own minds on this, but I don’t think states and governments will want to stop existing.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by exolymph on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:57AM (#35207110)
It's a pure hypothetical because the people who do reproduce under conditions of modernity will become the future population.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by Ekaros on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:25AM (#35208940)
There is likely enough stable state populations that humanity doesn't go extinct. Now current global economy or culture might go, but if it doesn't support continued stable state existence, maybe it doesn't deserve to survive.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by imtringued on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:16AM (#35207508)
I don't know why people go from one extreme to the other. There is zero risk of humanity disappearing because of a lack of birth rates.

The shrinking growth rates are problematic for wealthy old people because they realise that their money represents economic power over other people, but if those other people don't exist, then their economic power will be worth much less than they deluded themselves it is. Indulging in the desires of these special interest groups makes no sense for the continued survival of humanity. If anything it makes it harder for humanity to survive as we run the risk of faster resource depletion. If you believe in mars colonies and so on, you would want our society to survive the next 1000 years and not prioritise the next quarter so an old person can retire from their stock returns.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by whatshisface on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:36AM (#35206720)
Based on the... distinct patina of some of the comments I am reading in this thread I think Hackernews is a few decades away from having a population crisis of its own.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by FpUser on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:31AM (#35206694)
For many having kids is unaffordable I guess you will have to create kids farms. So much to look forward to.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by mlhpdx on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:38AM (#35206728)
As the population drops resources become more accessible. The problem solves itself.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by imtringued on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:20AM (#35207524)
The problem is wealthy people want to be even wealthier. Telling them they will be less wealthy won't make them happy.
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by markdown on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:17AM (#35206620)
You only need to gain immigrants to do work that natives won't. You don't need those immigrants to breed, no more than you need the natives to keep breeding.

As more and more jobs become obsolete, a country will be able to run just fine on fewer people, so long as there are enough people to do the work that can't be automated.

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by IIAOPSW on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:26AM (#35206670)
>You don't need those immigrants to breed

Yeah, but maybe you want them ;)

Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by XorNot on Saturday March 18, 2023 @02:44AM (#35206759)
Christ it doesn't take much for people to go mask off on "start up the government rape squads".
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by fwlr on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:31AM (#35206971)
Buddy, don’t get it twisted, I’m just as worried as you are about this possibility. (“Unconscionable” means “not right or reasonable; unreasonably excessive”.)
Re:Community’s 25yrs without a newborn shows scale of Japan’... by hackerlight on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:42AM (#35207372)
> (Immigration isn’t the answer, their fertility rate also gets depressed just like the native population. All it achieves is to balance the birth/death rate on paper for the year.)

If fertility rate gets depressed then just keep letting in more people. I don't see how it isn't the answer if your objective is to keep the population at a stable level.