News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by throwaway742 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @06:59PM (#35190125)
Why exactly did we overthrow their government again?
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by dilap on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:20PM (#35190347)
To serve as an example to North Korea to show what happens if you agree to give up your nuclear weapons program.

Oh, wait...

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by m463 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:56PM (#35191273)
no wasn't that what happens when the ukraine gives up their nuclear weapons?
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by bilbo0s on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:58PM (#35191290)
So it sounds like giving up nuclear weapons doesn't really work out for most people in the long run. I'm just saying, no one would be F'ing with Ukraine if they had a few hundred warheads.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by Fatnino on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:05AM (#35192964)
They would be soviet era warheads. Most probably don't work.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by jacooper on Friday March 17, 2023 @10:28AM (#35197567)
Doesn't matter really
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by justsomehnguy on Friday March 17, 2023 @01:13AM (#35193409)
> a few hundred warheads.

Maintaining 'a few hundred warheads' costs a lot more than $225000/month: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_cruiser_Ukraina

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by einpoklum on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:26PM (#35190403)
Some ha-ha-only-semi-kidding answers:

* Qaddafi thought he could trust NATO to play nice after he shut down Libya's nuclear program: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disarmament_of_Libya . Gives those North Koreans a chance to say "We told you so."

* Needed to free up some Mujaheedeen to go fight in Syria and Iraq.

* It's been a while since the US government had done anything for the African slave industry.

* Had to kill the African Union idea before it got off the ground: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_Union

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by rafram on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:42PM (#35190567)
Qaddafi was not a serious pan-Africanist, and the rest of Africa knew that. He was sometimes an Arab nationalist, sometimes an Islamic nationalist, sometimes an African nationalist, sometimes a socialist, and his only consistent ideological position was military dictatorship. He provided a venue for the founding of the AU, but both it and its predecessor organization are/were based in Ethiopia. The US intervention in Libya didn’t go very well, but it’s silly to pretend that Qaddafi was a hero by any measure.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by simple-thoughts on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:06PM (#35190778)
Which policy killed more Libyans - Obama’s or Qaddafi’s? Considering many people consider Obama a hero, the bar is quite low to jump.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mjfl on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:10PM (#35190812)
at least there weren't slave markets in Libya while he was a dictator....
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:46PM (#35191172)
No he just had his own harem of literal sex slaves. Who were abducted as children and tortured into sexual servitude.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by throwntoday on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:25PM (#35191560)
Is there any evidence for this or are you parroting western talking points meant to vilify/justify deposing him? I'm more inclined to disbelieve the statement given the west's track record for fabricating reasons to invade foreign nations.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:41PM (#35191736)
Based on testimony from his all-female "amazonian guard" and an in-depth book by a french investigative journalist including one detailed testimony of one of the victims.

There is far too much smoke from independent sources for there not to have been any fire.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mjfl on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:07AM (#35270731)
it's still a fundamentally non-utilitarian argument because you're talking about the sins of one man vs an entire country full of chaos and disorder.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by orangepurple on Thursday March 16, 2023 @10:29PM (#35192153)
He was killed because of his speech on 23 Sep 2009 at the United Nations General Assembly
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by einpoklum on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:07AM (#35195124)
That's why I said "semi-kidding". Of course he was no here. TBH I have very little grasp of how Libya was managed with him as the ruler, they appear to have had a rather strange system there which on the one hand had this strong-man leader and harsh prisons, but on the other hand had distribution-of-power mechanisms.

Anyway, certainly no hero, and had Libya been serious about pan-Africanism we would have seen a lot more serious work and investment of resources to that end. But - Libya was not willing to play along well enough with the interests of NATO members (US? France? Some combination of those?) so they offed him.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by landemva on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:05PM (#35190200)
Hillary was Secretary of State at the time. Neocons control Democrats and Republicans. We left Afghanistan after two decades and are now surging our treasure into Europe's backyard.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by badrabbit on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:43PM (#35190579)
Because they were hostile.

You know it really amuses me both with saddam and gaddafi how people wonder why they were invaded. Excuse the language but they fucked around and found out.

If someone threatens to kill you, do you say to yourself "nah, he won't actually do it?" Or remove them from a position of threar against you like having them jailed?

Well between nations, it isn't exactly unprecedented to invade a country and remove from power leaders that publicly and vocally threaten to cause you harm. Bush lied about wmds because of oil but the reality is, if saddam was friendly to the US or even indifferent he would have been left alone.

Now vietnam and korea, I can see how you can argue the US had no business being involved but the moment saddam, thr taliban and gaddafi threatened the US, the US was involved. Pre-emptivr strike is term they used to justify these invasions. You don't have to agree with the concept to appreciate the fact that the US is one of many countries in a long line of countries that invade in response to a threat made by other countries.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by pessimizer on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:55PM (#35190682)
Any specific reference to Libya, or just a general grievance against any country that refuses to obey the US? We killed Gaddafi after he gave up the weapons and started working with us.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by Maursault on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:40PM (#35191113)
> We killed Gaddafi

NATO failed to kill Gaddafi. The Misrata militia killed him.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muammar_Gaddafi#Capture_and_as...

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by actionfromafar on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:08PM (#35191376)
Your honour, my bullet and gun didn't kill the victim, the bloodloss did.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by badrabbit on Thursday March 16, 2023 @07:57PM (#35190707)
It isn't disobedience but making threats that is the problem. You can give the US the middle finger without threatening anyone's lives.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by simple-thoughts on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:03PM (#35190750)
This is a transparent might makes right argument. USG employees frequently threaten countries that merely possess resources USG wishes to add to its base. These countries are unable to take action against USG due to a massive power differential.

While you’re sadly correct, that doesn’t mean a rules based international order can survive when the most powerful actors think this way, greatly increasing global instability.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by badrabbit on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:12PM (#35190841)
I was not justifying the US, in international relations all you have is reality. There is no law nations have to follow, only treaties. Both the US and Russia ignore "rules of war" and get away with it. The reality is might is all a country has, either directly or via alliances to determine its fate and guarantee the security if its people. And it is incredibly reckless to act mighty without having actual might.

And tbh, I was ranting there a bit, gadaffi was very terroristy until he saw what happened to saddam the he started to act in accordance to his strength. His downfall was how he treated his own people, the US would have at least avoided taking part in his invasion had he not been so hostile in the past.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by simple-thoughts on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:46PM (#35191174)
>in international relations all you have is reality.

This is transparently false. International relations are deeply driven by both popular and elite opinion, which is why national agents constantly work closely with media to justify their narratives. If the narratives fail to sway the opinion of key actors (whether individuals or populations) there can be severe consequences if the policies are followed anyway. That’s why we have lots of small states around the globe - even though it would be a profitable action to colonize those states in theory, in practice limitations on both elite and popular opinion prevent these activities.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by badrabbit on Friday March 17, 2023 @01:25AM (#35193481)
You're talking about diplomacy there, those opinions matter so long as the mighty cares about them, everyone is at the mercy of the whims of the strongest
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mjfl on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:12PM (#35190836)
What an incredibly irresponsible opinion that completely disregards the civilian lives lost or destabilized due to these interventions.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by badrabbit on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:26PM (#35190974)
No, my point was actually to regard those lives. Gadaffi was ovethrown by his people, it was a conflict of their choosing and there is no known civilian casualty in that invasion by the way. But wars can be avoided and civilian lives saved if dictators big and small knew their invasion was a guarantee if they threatened a mighty country they can't resist.

If you are going to have a war anyways, use that horror as a signpost that tells others "this is what will happen to you" to avoid more wars. If you say "we're sorry, won't happen again" guess what? It will happen again because they will use direct or indirect means to threaten other nations and the by the actions of one dictator millions die. This isn't about justifying war but about preventing it.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by 2xpress on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:44PM (#35191768)
More civilian lives would be lost or destabilized if there were no interventions.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by arcanemachiner on Thursday March 16, 2023 @10:28PM (#35192146)
I would love to borrow your crystal ball if you can spare it.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by mjfl on Thursday March 16, 2023 @11:08PM (#35192481)
I have a really hard time believing that. Syria for example.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by DoItToMe81 on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:54AM (#35195049)
I could see an argument being made with Saddam, considering the treatment of the Kurds. But Libya post Gaddafi has had more extrajudicial killings than even under the bloodiest parts of his reign. In part by collapse of the new government allowing terrorists to run rampant, but also in part because the new government before the collapse was partially staffed by the bloodthirsty lunatics he was repressing.

One of the first actions of the new Libyan government was to instate the death penalty for blasphemy. Which was then used on anyone from political opposition to women daring to seek education. The government collapsed before any sentences could be carried out, but that's intent to apply repression on a vastly broader scale than Gaddafi cared to.

Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by elashri on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:19PM (#35190904)
Because he was literally killing his people in wide spread massacre.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by FpUser on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:22PM (#35190940)
So did Pol Pot and many others.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by elashri on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:26PM (#35190989)
Not in one of the oil rich exporting countries. Also if you don't do the right thing everytime this doesn't mean you can't do a good thing from time to time.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by FpUser on Thursday March 16, 2023 @08:29PM (#35191009)
The end result does not look like a "good thing" at all.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by arcanemachiner on Thursday March 16, 2023 @10:26PM (#35192131)
I'm glad things are better there now.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by rdevsrex on Thursday March 16, 2023 @09:54PM (#35191862)
Because of Hillary Clinton. Kidding. Kind of.
Re:Tons of uranium missing from Libyan site, IAEA tells memb... by wahern on Thursday March 16, 2023 @10:39PM (#35192227)
Libya was a French initiated and led operation. Full stop. If any one person bares the most responsibility, it would have been Nicolas Sarkozy. But France's interest in Libya, specifically, and Africa generally were and have been extensive.

A properly educated, cynical perspective proceeds from the above factual context and proceeds thusly: The biggest opponent to the Libyan invasion was Italy, because France and Italy have vied for influence in North Africa for over a century, and Italy's initial instincts were to take the other side of France's gamble and protect Gaddafi. But even Italy came aboard. Why? Until Ukraine, France's commitment to NATO has always been tenuous. In fact, it was only in 2009 that France rejoined NATO's Military Committee, and to this day France still has a special arrangement. Libya was NATO's reward to France for both previous and future concessions. France's entire foreign policy has historically revolved around maintaining its influence in Africa, including in particular its oil interests in Libya. And because of France's size (population, GDP, military budget, nuclear capability, etc), and Libya's pariah status, France's participation in NATO meant far more to NATO member states than Libya, albeit with Italy being a close call--but not because it cared about Libya, per se. Therefore, placating France was an easy call. Almost everybody fell into line in short order, which is so completely rare, even when it comes to U.S. demands. It was quite fascinating, really.