News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by isk517 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:55AM (#35169266)
Software no longer being updated and battery dying (and no longer worth the cost of replacement) seem to be the only reasons other than physical damage to replace a smartphone these days. Until I accidentally shattered the screen a month ago I was more than happy to stick with my Galaxy S9, my new phone is nice but other than the battery lasting the whole day and regular security updates I'm not seeing much difference from my nearly 5 year old previous phone.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by jeffwask on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:36AM (#35169924)
Imagine if your PC or Laptop just stopped working every 4 years and you had to buy a completely new one even if the current one meets all your needs.

How we allowed this to be the case for our pocket computers is beyond me.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by isk517 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:56PM (#35172176)
I'm in the process of replacing my 7 year old personal computer but it is completely my choice to do it. My old PC is perfectly functional and is going to reused for a different purpose. If it wasn't for the fact that I have something to do with the old machine I'd probably put off buying a new one for another year or two.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by ryandrake on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:17AM (#35169624)
It's really a shame. I have a bunch of fully-functional phones and tablets laying around that work fine, even with strong batteries, but became forcibly obsolete due to Apple (and others) 1. dropping software support and 2. deliberately sabotaging the devices against being repurposed with alternative software. This never happens with computers. I have a computer from the early 2000s still happily plugging away running useful things on Linux. It is a disgrace what consumers have allowed phone manufacturers to get away with support-wise.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by soylentcola on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:38AM (#35169960)
> 2. deliberately sabotaging the devices against being repurposed with alternative software.

This is why my old iPad 2 is sitting in a box somewhere. Old Android phones got wiped, bootloader unlocked, and the latest version of LineageOS, etc. they could handle. They mostly get used as readers, fancy remotes, or media players (older ones in airplane mode when not powered off fully for security reasons).

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by dorianG4 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:33AM (#35169887)
“This never happens with computers.”

Smartphones are computers.

Creating artificial product categories, taxonomy, is why we’re in this predicament.

Semantic woo is leveraged to decide a smartphone is not a general purpose computer such that corporate entity can label it new thing and set new expectations.

Intellectual property law and protections need to be thrown in the garbage, no device sold without being unlocked.

It’s thought policing when I’m convinced a general purpose computer (smartphone) is something else altogether. We live in a carceral society that’s extracting our agency to coddle a handful of replaceable figureheads.

War is peace. Apple is anti-1984.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#35170141)
Smartphones are computing appliances. You can sometimes put a new OS on them to make them into feasible GP computers, but that's not what they're designed to be.

That there's a GP computer inside isn't that meaningful. There's one inside "smart" TVs, too, but those TVs are still just appliances.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @07:25PM (#35176083)
Not only that, Windows 11 just did the same to a whole bunch of computers...
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JoelMcCracken on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:21AM (#35169693)
I use one of my old iPhones to run under my pillow every night with a sleeping app, wrapped in a faraday cage pouch to reduce emf concerns. Works well for me.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by nosecreek on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:39PM (#35171926)
Interesting, I've got a bunch of old iPhones in a drawer and would be interested in doing some sleep tracking. What app are you using/any idea how old of an iPhone would still work for this?
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JoelMcCracken on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:36PM (#35174369)
The app I use is called "sleep cycle"; it is old. I don't know if i'd be able to download it now from the app store, honestly probably not, I haven't tried, but I already had it downloaded onto the phone.

basically, the app judges your current phase of sleep by sensing your movements, and purports to wake you up at the optimal moment. It seems to work for me, which is good enough for me, after all. YMMV?

But if you're unable to download it now, I don't have a good solution for you, sorry. I hope you figure it out!

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by ianburrell on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:08PM (#35170479)
This does happen with computers. Windows 8.1 stopped getting support in January. There are lots of computers that don’t meet requirements for Windows 10. The timeframe is much longer than smartphones. Linux is special case that low requirements mean works on anything and is kept updated for everyone. But Linux distributions do stop supporting old releases, but the new release works for a long time.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by lukas099 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:41PM (#35170970)
It happens at the operating system level, but on a desktop computer the hardware is not inexorably tied to the OS. When Windows stops supporting 8.1, you can easily install Linux.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by saurik on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:40PM (#35170962)
The point was that those old computers aren't locked into running Windows and so you can install Linux on them and keep using them for something instead of chucking them in the garbage pile; the same is not true of many phones and is certainly not true of an iPhone.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by bradfa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:02AM (#35169375)
iPhone battery replacements, at an Apple store with 1st party parts and labor, now seem to be about $90 for many models. That's reasonable enough that I would definitely choose it over a slightly less expensive 3rd party repair or DIY and instead of buying a new phone if I was otherwise happy.

iPhone screen replacements at an Apple store seem to be in the $200-300 range, which is expensive enough that I'd consider other options, including just buying a refurb phone from a reputable reseller.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:49AM (#35170160)
> That's reasonable enough

$90 to replace a battery seems outrageously overpriced to me.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by bzzzt on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:01PM (#35170368)
It's not like they can just click a new one in place. $50 for a quality battery and $40 to pay someone a living wage to mount it in half an hour doesn't sound excessive to me. Oh, I almost forgot Apple replaced one of my earlier iPhones for free because the old one didn't boot with the new battery. No questions asked, even got a free loaner phone for the few hours until replacement was delivered. I wonder how many $25 battery replacement shops give that amount of service and warranty.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by mattl on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#35170307)
What's a reasonable price for a new battery + labor to fit the new battery?
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#35170837)
Well, I've never hired someone to replace a battery, so I clearly don't know the going rates. $100 was steep enough that it caught me by surprise, though.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by mattl on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:36PM (#35170883)
I think most batteries are $49 + labor + tax. I had mine fixed under AppleCare and it took about 90 minutes so I can see $90 being about right.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:20PM (#35171641)
Fair enough. It's a "what the market will bear" sort of thing in the end. I wouldn't be willing to buy a piece of equipment that required such an expense just to replace a battery, but I'm certainly not going to say anyone else is wrong for being willing to.

I just found it surprising that it was that steep.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by mattl on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:22PM (#35171684)
I'd certainly prefer it if I could change the battery myself. I can, I have the tools for it but doing it will also cost me $49 plus the time to do it... it seemed worth it for Apple to do it.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by Idiot_in_Vain on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:00AM (#35169351)
Newer phones have bigger screens with higher refresh rates, far better cameras and are faster. Many people change their phone every year.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by manv1 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:04AM (#35169405)
Most people at this level don't really care about specs like higher refresh rates. They care about cost and functionality.

Hundreds of millions change their phones every year, which is why there's supply for the used market.

Billions of people don't change their phones every year, because they can't afford to or don't care to.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by belthesar on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#35169444)
I think, to the GP's point though, that even though phones are having these significant tech refreshes, they're not significant enough to a growing number of end users to chase. I'm right there with him, tbh. I broke an iPhone 8's screen a couple years ago, and had to replace it. Had that phone not been damaged, I would have kept it for a couple more years.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by bradfa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:15AM (#35169596)
My iPhone 8 is still going strong! It has a bright spot in the middle of the screen, the battery isn't what it used to be, and the camera is clearly not as good as the newer iPhones that my extended family all have. But it's not bad enough to justify spending hundreds of dollars to replace it quite yet.

Knock on wood!

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by wil421 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:20AM (#35169677)
AT&T offered me $1000 for a 2 year old phone. It only cost me about $200-$300 for my new phone with a much better camera sensor. I could care less about other features including speed but now that I have young kids my camera is important.

The screen refresh and always on Lock Screen are added bonuses.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by teaearlgraycold on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:30AM (#35169846)
I think many people in this forum don’t change their phones as often because we view phones as limiting computing devices. I am using a 2nd Gen. iPhone SE. The newer iPhones don’t seem so appealing that I feel left out.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by NDizzle on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:30AM (#35169844)
Perfect username for the reference you made in your comment.

"Many people change their phone every year." I expect that to be one of the things that immediately changes with our current, fantastic economy in the US.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by joseph_grobbles on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:08AM (#35169477)
The refresh rate escalation is a complete jerkoff bit of tech spec nonsense. "Far better cameras" is an exaggeration, as most are marginally better. iPhones have been incredibly fast since the XR, almost five years ago.

There was a period of dramatic progress but now things have largely settled. I recently replaced a 12 Pro with a 14 Pro and it is likely nothing at all changed. There is zero impact in my life. Have the 12 Pro waiting in my drawer for my son with an XR to upgrade, but he doesn't even want the hassle of doing the transfer and then setting up the apps that don't properly migrate data.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:23AM (#35169734)
> The refresh rate escalation is a complete jerkoff bit of tech spec nonsense.

Exactly. "Oh look! It's so smooth when I scroll back and forth!"

I actually stop scrolling to read, but I guess I might be in the minority.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by rocket_surgeron on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:45AM (#35170101)
>Many people change their phone every year.

Very few people upgrade every year. The average lifespan of a mobile phone is 2.5 years.

In the late 2000s that length of time was lower because phones were improving by leaps and bounds every year but now phones are waterproof, have more resilient screens, cost more, and performance increases between models have slowed.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/17/smartphone-users-are-waiting...

The lifespan increase pattern is mirroring the personal computer upgrade cycle, but more rapidly.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:51AM (#35170171)
Many do. Most don't (at least from what I've observed around me).

I've never replaced a phone sooner than 5 years after I got it, but I know I'm a weirdo.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by isk517 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:42PM (#35171988)
My new phone has the same screen size as my old phone, and my old phone had a big enough screen that I'd need to sew custom pockets onto my pants if I went any bigger. New phone has a better refresh rate but all that does is kill the battery faster in exchange maybe things look slightly smoother when playing games, but the games I play on my phone don't really benefit from the increased refresh rate so I just keep it at the default 60Hz.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by vbezhenar on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:01AM (#35169373)
Flash storage degradation is an issue for old phones as well and it's not fixable. It could be worked around with buying a phone with huge flash, but people usually prefer cheaper ones (and manufacturers charging 1000% premium not helping of course).
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by bradfa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:04AM (#35169400)
I've never actually experienced this on a personal device (anecdata, I know). But my dayjob for many years has been in embedded systems and working with flash devices and even there, as long as you don't design the product to write to the flash in ways which will kill it (aka: Tesla logging and eMMC) then I honestly expect that modern flash devices have quite enough write endurance for >99% of customer uses.

Yes, those 1% who wear out their flash are going to be furious and complain online and even just 1% of phone buyers is still millions of people.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by vel0city on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:23AM (#35169731)
I used to always download lots of podcasts instead of streaming them and had a lot of Spotify auto-playlist saved locally. This used to cause a lot of write cycles on my devices. I would also usually end up with the smaller storage size version of the devices, so it would use a good percentage of the storage for this usage pattern.

Eventually the read speeds would get intolerably slow. Launching applications or rehydrating them would take forever as the storage would just be so slow compared to when the device was new. Rebooting would take 10 minutes or more. This failure mode pushed me to upgrade at least twice.

I now just stream the majority of my data, and on-board storage has ballooned so I don't end up rewriting that high of a percentage of the overall storage that often. It was easy to cycle through all the storage when the on-board was 16GB but at 128GB+ it takes a bit longer to burn through it all.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:54AM (#35170238)
> I've never actually experienced this on a personal device

I haven't, either. But then, I'm aware of the limited life of flash, so I only purchased phones I can put an SD card into, and then almost all of the data I store on the phone gets written to the card. I'd rather wear the card out than the embedded flash.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by bradfa on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:36PM (#35172738)
Have you ever worn out an SD card used in one of your phones?
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JohnFen on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:40PM (#35172796)
Not yet. I also build robots and various gadgets as a hobby, and most of those write more heavily to SD cards than my phone does. I've only worn out one card in those machines over the years. Flash memory can take a truly huge number of write cycles.

But I like replaceable cards anyway. It's a cheap way to minimize the use of on-board flash that is difficult or impossible to replace.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:24AM (#35169747)
The last time I experienced this was a Nexus 7. Nothing else since has really given me an issue.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by nine_k on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#35170144)
RAM size, too, sadly.

You want the two of your heaviest apps you want to use together to fit in RAM, to be able to switch between them.

Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by isk517 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:48PM (#35172063)
Honestly, the increased RAM is probably the nicest part of my new phone and not having to wait for large apps to reload has been the biggest quality of life improvement. That said, I don't feel like it justifies the price of a new phone by itself, mostly because large apps are usually games and if I have to switch back and forth between a game and some other app constantly then I probably should not be playing games.
Re:Why Apple and the Carriers Want Your Old iPhone by pongo1231 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:25PM (#35170719)
Yup, also still very happy with my Galaxy S9, now running an unofficial version of LineageOS 19 (though I am still rocking the original battery from 4 years ago and it shows, I need to look into replacing it soon). Really want to hold off replacing it for as long as possible as with phones nowadays there always seems to be a catch like either no headphone jack, no sd card slot, a notch, etc. while this one still does it all.