News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by PradeetPatel on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:09AM (#35147659)
Is there anything we can do as consumers to promote ethical fishing practices?

For example, there are certifications and accreditations fisheries can obtain to prove that eco-friendly methods are used.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by adrianN on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:32AM (#35147766)
The best thing we can do is to eat less fish. There is no ethical way to fish from an overfished ocean. A distant second is to eat fish like sardines which are further down the food chain than, say, tuna.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by kortilla on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:43AM (#35147836)
Abstinence doesn’t work. The best thing we can do is heavily promote farmed fish. Heavy heavy taxation on anything wild.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by adrianN on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:37AM (#35148089)
Abstinence is not a good policy, but it's pretty much the best thing you can do personally unless you're somehow in charge of your countries fishing policy. By the way, as far as I know, fish farming is not much better.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by namaria on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @03:22AM (#35148321)
Most protein fed to farmed fish is caught in the ocean fisheries.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by Seabiscuit on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @03:51AM (#35148489)
This actually isn't true for some types of farmed fish, like Norwegian salmon, but it varies by area and by company.

The industry is looking into alternatives like insects, and typically 30-40% of the feed now comes from vegetable proteins and oils.

On the other hand, farmed Faroese salmon (just next door) has a much higher % of wild-caught fish in its feed, which contributes to the high omega 3 content of Faroese salmon.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by barbazoo on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:07AM (#35147945)
> Abstinence doesn’t work

Why do you think that?

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by RGamma on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:47AM (#35148808)
The planet may be limited but consumer entitlement is not.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by drewm1980 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:10AM (#35148936)
It was news to me until recently, but the shifting of blame for destructive business practices onto the consumer is extremely well documented to be greenwashing. i.e.:

https://www.vox.com/22429551/climate-change-crisis-exxonmobi...

It's not inconsistent to boycott destructive products as an individual, but political pressure should focus on flat out banning destructive business practices. The electoral system failed to prevent another oil-drilling president from entering office, but it's still possible his administration will be successfully sued in court under USA's (admittedly weak looking) version of Duty of Care laws. The TLDR is that ~some democracies have it baked into the constitution that the government must act in the interests of the citizens, and are getting successfully sued in court to do so, despite regulatory capture and corrupt politicians.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by evandijk70 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @06:51AM (#35149574)
I have read this argument many times and I still don't understand it.

You can attack emissions by limiting supply (stopping new oil drilling projects) or by limiting demand (flying less / driving less etc.). Both should work, since supply and demand are generally balanced. Reducing supply without reducing demand (what you seem to be proposing) will lead to massive price increases and energy poverty. This is confirmed by the energy crisis in Europe this winter, which was the result of a sudden decrease in supply. Reducing demand without reducing supply will lead to massive price decreases, which should increase demand from those that are less worried about climate change.

The transition to renewables can only be done by reducing both supply (less oil drilling) and demand (consumers and industry). I don't see how advocating for flying less, eating less meat, buying heat pumps etc. constitutes greenwashing, even if it oil companies co-opt it to deflect attention from themselves.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by junon on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:10AM (#35149709)
The problem is with the limiting demand part. Most people don't have a choice.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by zizee on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:02AM (#35150140)
They don't have a choice to eat more plant based protein? They don't have a choice to drive smaller cars?

I get that change needs to happen at government/ industry levels to see the level of change required, but individuals can (and should) be the change they want to see.

To not make changes to your own life whilst wanting government to force the same changes on all of society seems pretty hypocritical.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by junon on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:34AM (#35150453)
> They don't have a choice to eat more plant based protein?

This isn't going to do much at all in the grand scheme of things

> They don't have a choice to drive smaller cars?

Most people aren't driving dualies. Usually they're driving sedans. I'd wager, anecdotally, most people cannot afford new, more efficient cars. If they need to get to work to feed their families, and they're strapped for cash, they'll buy an emissions ridden piece of crap just to get there.

People can't hardly live for themselves and you expect them to shoulder all of the burden that the manufacturing and oil industries are causing.

> To not make changes to your own life whilst wanting government to force the same changes on all of society seems pretty hypocritical.

I'd much rather governments ban net-positive carbon emissions by the major offenders entirely and force all further major offenders to shut down, but that doesn't make our government officials rich does it?

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by zizee on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:54PM (#35162132)
> I'd much rather governments ban net-positive carbon emissions by the major offenders entirely and force all further major offenders to shut down, but that doesn't make our government officials rich does it?

What do you think happens if governments do this? On one hand you are saying most people don't have the option to change, but then quickly followup with saying governments should force massive change.

> you expect them to shoulder all of the burden that the manufacturing and oil industries are causing

Ultimately, the issue is that industry is not bearing costs of their activity. We want them to pay for the externalities, so that someone can be paid to cleanup after them, or more likely that they change behaviour to some alternative that has become cost effective.

But these costs will be passed onto the general population. Now instead of having the unrecognised costs loaded onto people through climate change, we will do it explicity. This will be the oil companies, or via whatever replaces that industry. I think that is a good thing, because it will make people vote with their wallets, to change their consumption patterns.

But they'll still have to pay, or change their behaviour. They'll end up eating less meat, more plants. They'll drive smaller cars, buy electric, take public transport, live in smaller houses, fly less.

I agree with needing to do this for us. Externalities should never be unaccounted for, it distorts everything. What I am saying is that it is hypocritical for an individual to campaign for governments to step in and force everyone to adapt enmasse, if they're not prepared to proactively change their behaviour to match the world that they are wanting everyone else to live in.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by NoZebra120vClip on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:50AM (#35148164)
> Abstinence doesn’t work.

It works for me! I haven't gotten anyone pregnant in 30 years!

Also, I tested negative for everything! I don't even have crabs!

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by Charlie_26 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:17AM (#35148626)
I don’t eat fish. It does work.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by kortilla on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:23AM (#35151997)
The crisis begs to differ.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by drewm1980 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:53AM (#35148845)
They are scooping up entire ecosystems from the sea floor and grinding them up to feed farmed fish. With rare exception, fish farming should be viewed as a way to allow humans to (inefficiently) eat the entire marine ecosystem.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by junon on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:09AM (#35149699)
Sorry but I'm jaded on the whole "we can do" part. I think it's a joke to think any amount of laypeople involvement will solve the problem in any measurable amount.

These are corporations and factories and rich folks fucking it up for the rest of us.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by adrianN on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:54AM (#35152451)
Rich folk alone can't eat enough fish to deplete the stock. Unless of course you count everybody in a developed nation as "rich". In any case, I agree that policy change is required, but I have less influence on policy than on my personal actions.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by junon on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:56AM (#35152473)
I wasn't implying rich people eat more than others...
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by adrianN on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:49AM (#35164022)
Rich folk also don't trawl the ocean floor for fun, but to sell the fish to somebody.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by jnmandal on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:18AM (#35147702)
To be honest, this has very little to do with fishing practices. It's more about the temperature of the ocean.

There are some folks who think by catch (a very destructive externality from ocean floor trawling) has an impact on this fishery but unfortunately that's more of a guess. The science certainly shows that the temperature anomaly literally preempts reproduction. So heat waves eviscerated an entire generation, perhaps multiple generations.

So can you affect the temperature of the ocean? Not anymore than you can stop global warming. Even if you did everything to become carbon negative, it's gonna be getting warmer before it gets back to normal temperatures.

But stopping eating seafood would be a good start. Lowering demand for them means that they have a chance of surviving through to a time when climate change could be reigned in, maybe in several decades.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by standardUser on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:21AM (#35147719)
Or eat more farmed seafood, or seafood that we have high confidence can be safely harvested, per the link I posted above.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by dathos on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:38AM (#35148094)
Or just dont eat seafood, even farmed Salmon is having a massive impact on nature around it
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by saiya-jin on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:46AM (#35149999)
Not only that, its meat is much lower quality / health benefits compared to wild salmon, much closer to pork. Eating BIO variant won't help that much with that
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by standardUser on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @12:09PM (#35153785)
What an oddly narrow comment. Many types of seafood are farmed and very few have the environmental concerns that Salmon has when it is farmed adjacent to natural waters. It's almost like you lead with cynicism and then leave no room for facts.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by liotier on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:36AM (#35148748)
Farmed seafood requires protein input, which currently is mostly wild fish.

Expanding insect production for animal feed would be significant progress.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by codeisawesome on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:03AM (#35148906)
That's interesting; when searched there seems to be very little mainstream media coverage of the concept. What are some of the disadvantages of the insect feed approach for aquaculture?
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by liotier on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @05:40AM (#35149146)
Large scale insect production for animal feed has only been going for about a decade, so not much hindsight - but so far it is looking great: https://www.science.org/content/article/feature-why-insects-...
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by standardUser on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:19AM (#35147711)
The Monterey Bay Aquarium has a program called Seafood Watch that publishes consumer guides. I used to carry around a business-card sized version. Now they have versions for different US regions and one for sushi...

https://www.seafoodwatch.org/recommendations/download-consum...

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by defrost on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @01:40AM (#35147819)
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by drewm1980 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:50AM (#35148821)
The way certifications and accreditations work in the fishing industry is covered in the documentary Seaspiracy.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by batmaniam on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:35AM (#35153224)
And to sum it up: basically the entire sustainability accreditations have been taken over by corporate interests. So the label itself on every seafood item is super inaccurate and doesn't actually save the planet or the fish population at all. Not even a dent.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by lm28469 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @07:56AM (#35150083)
Eat less of it and buy the expensive stuff. Expensive = better margin = less fish needed to pay the wages, and 99% of the time expensive = high end sustainable

It's not bulletproof but it's a good rule of thumb, I eat fish once in a blue moon, last time it was a can of "traditionally hand fished" tuna, 40 euros a kilo

If it's cheap as fuck there is no way it's sustainable, you're either abusing nature or fellow humans, or both

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by peanuty1 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:15AM (#35150244)
I'm less bothered with "abusing" fellow humans than destroying nature.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by lm28469 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @08:31AM (#35150415)
We're part of nature. If the "us vs them" is at that level now we're fucked
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @09:19AM (#35150971)
Can we not admit we’re fucked and any effort at this point is to take the edge off the pain we’re going to experience globally over the next century or two?
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by modo_mario on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @10:17AM (#35151900)
A quick google top result check shows: "all natural phenomena and plant and animal life, as distinct from man and his creations" I dare say that's the way it was used and intended so semantics doesn't really bring anyone forward here. I'm also not really sure what you're alluding to with the "us vs then" bit.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by red-iron-pine on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:13AM (#35152791)
There is no shortage of humans. Arguably too many.

There is a shortage of nature. On top of that, the ecosystems are changing, and once they're gone they're probably not coming back.

We could lose half of the population tomorrow and still, eventually, hit that predicted 10 billion souls -- it would just take a lil longer. If WA and BC turn into chaparral things like Salmon and Snow Crab ain't gonna live there any more, and never live there again.

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by lm28469 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:43AM (#35153351)
You make it sound like it's a maths problem, and that we have to abuse humans or nature but must chose at least one

All I'm saying is if you stop eating cheap sea food we won't have to send underpaid humans to risk their lives to catch them. Put you money where your mouth is

Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by jurimasa on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:43PM (#35156495)
That's a nice Malthusian fragment of excrement.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by giraffe_lady on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @11:11AM (#35152764)
Slave labor is used to harvest seafood cheap seafood to a very significant extent.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by mech765 on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @04:41PM (#35158175)
My intuition is that small fish are more sustainable than large fish. It's harder to overfish sardines than tuna because their lifecycle is short and there are a whole bunch of them. Not sure if my intuition holds up really.
Re:Crab crisis in Bering Sea a sign of ‘borealization’ by FuriouslyAdrift on Tuesday March 14, 2023 @02:57PM (#35156702)
https://www.msc.org/what-you-can-do/eat-sustainable-seafood/...

Herring is a good bet long term. China will fish the Pacific to death.