News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by creddit on Friday March 10, 2023 @11:15PM (#35105252)
> due to good old regular banks doing what they do best: making customers deposits disappear.

What would you estimate is the total value of customer deposits that banks have loss in failure over the last say 30yrs?

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by TacticalCoder on Friday March 10, 2023 @11:45PM (#35105453)
> What would you estimate is the total value of customer deposits that banks have loss in failure over the last say 30yrs?

Well of course if we consider only those where loss actually happened and not those where the losses have been mutualized by bail-outs, it may not be gigantic. But, I don't know, in Cyprus hair cuts made $8 bn of customers deposits vanish.

That's just one I know from the top of my head without needing to google.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by brookst on Saturday March 11, 2023 @12:56AM (#35105864)
But you seriously believe that banks are generally better at completely losing deposits than keeping them? It’s just hard to see any evidence-based person believing that.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mirekrusin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:04AM (#35106174)
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by vkou on Saturday March 11, 2023 @03:10AM (#35106454)
And how much money was lost in those failures by depositors?

And don't fall back on 'they were bailed out'. They were bailed out by other banks buying their assets + liabilities, and by the insurance payments they were making. They weren't getting a blank check from the treasury. That's the system working.

Who bailed out the crypto losses? Some of the losers got made whole, but many, many, many are realized losses.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mirekrusin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:25AM (#35106815)
FDIC can insure up to $100k (before 2008) and up to $250k (post-2008), so that's at most one person can get back, the rest puffs and it's gone.

What crypto losses you're talking about? The ones from centralized custody operators that hold your money in arbitrary way rendering your balance on web page in crypto currency or something else?

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by rtpg on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:54AM (#35106940)
In practice since 2008 even if the theory is that it’s up to 250k in practice banks get acquired from the FDIC basically on the unspoken condition that all deposits are maintained at 100 cents on the dollar
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by dragonwriter on Saturday March 11, 2023 @05:18AM (#35107050)
Its not “unspoken”, its the overt goal to find a bank to take over that will provide that.

But SVB is a much bigger bank with a much larger share of uninsured deposits than a typical bank failure. If the problem extends beyond liquidity and really is an insufficiency of assets by any significant share, its going to be hard for a no-loss takeover to be facilitated.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by aroman on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:54AM (#35106942)
$250k is not the most an account holder can get back if a bank fails, it is literally the minimum.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mirekrusin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:22AM (#35108075)
It's the maximum bank can get insurance for.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by brookst on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:37AM (#35108583)
No, it is the minimum , maximum, and only insurance the FDIC provides. Banks can and do get private insurance beyond that.

And stop acting like any uninsured money evaporates in a bank failure.

Actually probably just stop talking about banks. This whole thread is an embarrassment of “smart people with strong opinions about things they have zero knowledge about”.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mirekrusin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @10:17AM (#35108912)
Well, thanks for clarifying, TIL that "(...) since 1933, no one has lost money due to a bank failure (...)" in US, according to FDIC.

I wonder how this situation looks outside of US in more distressed economies ie. Argentina.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by emondi on Saturday March 11, 2023 @12:26PM (#35110480)
We had foreign banks who advertised that as a strength and sent their profits to their countries. But when there was a crisis they said we are just a local bank with the same brand as a US bank and won't give the customers their savings back.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by dragonwriter on Saturday March 11, 2023 @05:06AM (#35106993)
> FDIC can insure up to $100k (before 2008) and up to $250k (post-2008), so that's at most one person can get back

This is wrong for two reasons:

(1) The insurance limit applies per owner per ownership class; its possible to have accounts in more than one ownership class, and thus more than $250k insured.

(2) Recovery of the insured amount is guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the US government. Recovery of additional amounts is possible, and FDIC will make an effort to make it happen, but that's no guarantee.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by bmitc on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:55AM (#35106949)
> And don't fall back on 'they were bailed out'. They were bailed out by other banks buying their assets + liabilities, and by the insurance payments they were making.

Is that true? I'm not sure it is. The U.S. government gave hundreds of billions of dollars direct to banks and other institutions. The total actual cost has been estimated to be around $500 billion, despite claims that the loaned money was all paid back.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Economic_Stabilizati...

https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/heres-how-much...

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by postexitus on Saturday March 11, 2023 @10:09AM (#35108827)
Let me correct that for you. "The total actual cost has been estimated to be around $500 billion, though to be frank the loaned money was all paid back."
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by bmitc on Saturday March 11, 2023 @12:29PM (#35110521)
That quote appears nowhere in the linked MIT Sloan article or the paper it summarizes, so please don't post such misleading quotes.

As I already mentioned and from the paper's abstract:

> Those conclusions stand in sharp contrast to popular accounts that claim there was no cost because the money was repaid, and with claims of costs in the multiple trillions of dollars.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by postexitus on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:20AM (#35168696)
I highly recommend you to check the original source referred in that article to understand the methodology used and what they were referring to.

https://gcfp.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/BailoutsARFE...

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by brookst on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:35AM (#35108568)
And that’s the majority of banks in the US, or the majority of bank customers that were affected?

Seriously, it was a childish and overly dramatic comment. Stop digging.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by beefield on Saturday March 11, 2023 @12:59AM (#35105883)
Would you be willing to make a honest try to compare quantitatively the percentage of deposits lost in regulated western banks vs money lost in failed crypto exchanges, stablecoins etc?

I think the difference must be many orders of magnitude to the benefit of regulated banks.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by chinchilla2020 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:34AM (#35106047)
Percentage wise I would bet crypto is way riskier.

In gross terms, crypto is tiny compared to the dollar/euro banking system, so it's likely to be a much smaller number.

Interestingly, for those who use crypto as-designed, the percentage lost to bank runs is almost nil since you 'hold your own coins'. It's people who leave their money on crypto exchanges that lose their coins.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by beefield on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:45AM (#35106096)
I think you are selective here. There are lots of coins that have lost value permanently (FTT, luna etc), I also remember reading that there are lots of coins whose network has simply shut down due to lack of interest (no source here, though)
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by areyousure on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:08PM (#35110904)
I don't think including "coins" that have lost value tilts the balance against crypto.

The vast majority of traditional currencies have lost nearly all of their value over time, including the US dollar.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by lottin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:52AM (#35106375)
> It's people who leave their money on crypto exchanges that lose their coins.

People who hold their own coins lose them as well. It was estimated that 3.7 million bitcoin have been already lost irreversibly [1]. That's a staggering number. It's roughly 20% of the entire supply.

[1] https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/bitcoin-market-data-exc...

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by zarzavat on Saturday March 11, 2023 @03:37AM (#35106587)
They equate “lost” with “not moved in 5 years”. That’s a strangely short cut off — I would use 10 years instead. It’s completely possible for coins to sit around for 5 years in cold storage addresses without being touched.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by redox99 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:52AM (#35106936)
It's funny because just this week I moved some BTC from a wallet I hadn't touched since 2013. And I used it to pay for something pretty mundane. In retrospective, the idea of someone whipping their "10 year old wallet" just to pay for something trivial is a bit amusing to me.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by random_kris on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:56AM (#35108309)
Be careful with statements like this to not dox yourself too much
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by redox99 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @10:22PM (#35116169)
Meh. I'm sure there's a lot of transactions like that.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by sebzim4500 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:06AM (#35107977)
Yeah but some of my own coins are considered to be 'irreversibly lost', simply because I haven't touched them in five years.

I don't see why I should take this seriously.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by lottin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:31AM (#35108528)
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by sebzim4500 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @11:51AM (#35110094)
There comes a point where an estimate turns into a guess though. I would argue they are way past that point.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by makingstuffs on Saturday March 11, 2023 @07:28AM (#35107751)
Tell that to Slope Wallet victims
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by smugma on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:16AM (#35105961)
Banks failing is pretty rare, not 30 times a year.

“Silicon Valley Bank is no more. It’s the first bank backed by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. to fail since 2020.”

https://www.marketplace.org/2023/03/10/how-silicon-valley-ba...

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by justahuman74 on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:41AM (#35106075)
I would argue that `since 2020` is still too frequent for most people
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by shuckles on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:30AM (#35106277)
There was a very uncommon event that began in 2020.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by pksebben on Saturday March 11, 2023 @03:21AM (#35106508)
there was also a very uncommon event in '01, '08, '22..

.. at some point, we're gonna have to step back and take a look at how we're doing business. Something about our whole way of organizing society is busted.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by shuckles on Saturday March 11, 2023 @04:36AM (#35106862)
Not sure how you come to that conclusion with the happenings discussed in this thread.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday March 11, 2023 @07:30AM (#35107762)
Aside from the crypto scandals, the insider dealing scandals, the money laundering scandals, the price and index fixing scandals, and the corruption scandals, there have been 562 bank failures since 2001.

https://www.fdic.gov/bank/historical/bank/

Finance is inherently an opportunist, if not outright criminal, industry which explodes regularly causing huge economic and political damage.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by shuckles on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:03AM (#35107959)
Appending scandal to an event isn’t having the persuasive effect you’re looking for. Finance is also the industry which helps us collectively coordinate our resources, grow our wealth for retirement, and facilitate risk taking. Every industry has issues.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by AnimalMuppet on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:21AM (#35108073)
562? Great. Now give me a context for that. How many banks are there?

And, of those 562, in how many of them did the depositors lose money?

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by Retric on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:06AM (#35108362)
Which is probably well under 0.1% of total companies that failed over the same period.

The thing is failed banks don’t mean depositors lose all their money. The point of banking regulation is fail fast so banks are taken out when they still have 98% of their depositors money not 8%. People with under 250k are made whole and people above that have already been compensated by higher interest rates.

It doesn’t always work perfectly, but in many cases a failed bank just means people come in on Monday and there is a new sign on the building with little else changed.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mirekrusin on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:03AM (#35106171)
Are you counting bailouts as failure or not?
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by mjlawson on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:34AM (#35106287)
It depends on the state of the market. During the banking crisis, 157 banks were closed in one year[1].

[1] https://www.fdic.gov/bank/historical/bank/

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by omgomgomgomg on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:08AM (#35105920)
Seems like its around 30 banks a year in the usa. Not sure about deposits, theyre relativelly covered. But shareholders get wiped out every time.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by kybernetikos on Saturday March 11, 2023 @07:12AM (#35107651)
I have personally been bailed out by a government when the bank I had a savings account in failed, and its countrys insurance scheme refused to pay. I have had fraudulent charges made to my bank accounts.

On the other hand, the keys to my ethereum remain safe on my hardware wallet, and none of my ethereum has ever moved without me telling it to. Perhaps my experience is atypical, but I am surely not alone.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by subroutine on Saturday March 11, 2023 @07:50AM (#35107892)
They said quantitatively not anecdotally.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by kybernetikos on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:30AM (#35108524)
Sure, and I didn't answer the question. I think it's hard to answer the question in a fair way. Banks and financial instututions fail in various ways from small to big more than most people think. On the other hand, they are 'too big to fail' so their mistakes get fixed by governments at the costs of the populace.

These options are not currently available to blockchain, but that's a social choice.

I tend to think that the scamming aspect of cryptocurrencies is massively overstated. There are lots of ways to be taken in and scammed, but that's true in the fiat world too. A small amount of care goes a long way in both worlds.

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by breck on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:40AM (#35108174)
US consumers lose about $30 billion a year to retail banks.

http://www.breckyunits.com/the-great-bank-robbery.html

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by alasarmas on Saturday March 11, 2023 @01:04AM (#35105910)
If I recall correctly, Cyprus “doesn’t count” because those depositors were making something like 9% interest, and therefore they were morally closer to investors. I don’t have a citation at hand...
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by shjake on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:33AM (#35106285)
Back then 9% was such a spectacular yield, “only” 2-3% above what many other more reliable Euro banks were offering
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by woobar on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:51PM (#35111960)
in 2012-2013 reliable European banks were offering 6-7% yield? With ECB rates <1%?
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by shjake on Sunday March 12, 2023 @04:18AM (#35117944)
Sorry, you’re right. For some reason I thought it happened at the same time as the Icelandic banking crisis back in 2008-2009.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by efaref on Saturday March 11, 2023 @02:49AM (#35106362)
There was also the Icelandic bank collapse, which was multiple banks totalling tens of billions of euros. I personally lost a large chunk of savings in that, and was eventually bailed out by my own government (i.e. my own tax money).
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by arcticbull on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:11AM (#35108007)
I would encourage you to learn about what actually happened in the Cypriot defaults.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by itsoktocry on Saturday March 11, 2023 @09:28AM (#35108503)
>But, I don't know, in Cyprus hair cuts made $8 bn of customers deposits vanish.

Ah, so less than 1 FTX?

Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by prewett on Saturday March 11, 2023 @10:58AM (#35109383)
It wasn't the banks doing the haircut in Cypress, it was the government. You can't blame that one on the banks.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by TomSwirly on Saturday March 11, 2023 @05:14AM (#35107039)
You are forgetting the many billions in taxpayer bailouts that have kept them alive, and the FDIC.
Re:Circle has $3.3B of USDC’s $40B reserves still at SVB by AnimalMuppet on Saturday March 11, 2023 @08:26AM (#35108097)
And who pays for the FDIC? Member banks. So the existence of the FDIC does not make the original claim any more true.