News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by garrettjoecox on Friday March 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#35010293)
Why would they expect anyone to build on top of their new social networking protocol?

It is owned and will be driven by a private company and it’s desire for profitability, ActivityPub is an open standard that has been around for ~5 years and battle tested and already in use across different platforms.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by linza on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#35011010)
> It is owned and will be driven by a private company and it’s desire for profitability [...]

I imagine that that's the exact reason why for example advertisers will opt for bluesky over mastodon immediately, under the assumption that the reach would be the same.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by ch71r22 on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:23AM (#35010780)
Maybe their efforts will be co-opted, but judging by the team's background -- André Staltz with Secure Scuttlebutt, Paul Frazee with dat/Beaker/Hypercore Protocol -- I think it's pretty clear the driving motivation for much of the team behind Bluesky is not profit.

As for why people might want to use it instead of ActivityPub, I think it's just... different from ActivityPub. Even though ActivityPub is an available option I don't see why it should be the last word.

Bluesky's answer is this

> Account portability is the major reason why we chose to build a separate protocol. We consider portability to be crucial because it protects users from sudden bans, server shutdowns, and policy disagreements. Our solution for portability requires both signed data repositories and DIDs, neither of which are easy to retrofit into ActivityPub. The migration tools for ActivityPub are comparatively limited; they require the original server to provide a redirect and cannot migrate the user's previous data.

> Other smaller differences include: a different viewpoint about how schemas should be handled, a preference for domain usernames over AP’s double-@ email usernames, and the goal of having large scale search and discovery (rather than the hashtag style of discovery that ActivityPub favors).

https://atproto.com/guides/faq#why-not-use-activitypub

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by smoldesu on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:33AM (#35010906)
> We consider portability to be crucial because it protects users from sudden bans, server shutdowns, and policy disagreements

I think this will have the opposite effect. Account portability means that being banned on one site can ban you on another if you try to use the same ID. Being persistently recognized across accounts seems like a net-negative for all of these things.

[dead]
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by dmix on Friday March 03, 2023 @01:22PM (#35013210)
Exactly, it's just removing the pointless (and terrible UX) step of having to sign up again.

I imagined trying to explain to my mom why she'd have to signup for Mastadon again because the server she signed up with is gone or she got on one of the massive blacklists for engaging with the 'wrong' accounts.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by hgsgm on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:34AM (#35011753)
Non-issue. You don't have to use account portability if it doesn't work. You can use it if it does work.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by wmeredith on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:50AM (#35011156)
>judging by the team's background -- André Staltz with Secure Scuttlebutt, Paul Frazee with dat/Beaker/Hypercore Protocol -- I think it's pretty clear the driving motivation for much of the team behind Bluesky is not profit.

Not to be overly cynical, but I just don't care. Things change. When mega-corps and investors come knocking with 10-figure checks... 99.9% of humans will cash out. It's human nature. I've invested my time and energy in many things that have been taken over and destroyed by bad/incompetent actors, virtually all of which had promising starts, or I wouldn't have gotten involved.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by rchaud on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:35PM (#35012699)
That's not a cynical take for anyone who's observed the past 20 years of the web.

Page and Brin explicitly spelled out how advertising could change the incentives of a search engine. That didn't stop them from selling out immediately and letting the VCs install a CEO to 'businessify' the company.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by scarface74 on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:49PM (#35012825)
Did you at any point think that Google was going to be a non profit?
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by blowski on Friday March 03, 2023 @02:16PM (#35013795)
I remember being a naive 20-something and believing they’d find a new way of doing business. Maybe a co-op.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by rchaud on Sunday March 05, 2023 @10:30AM (#35030432)
No I didnt. I did think they could make money outside of adtech as numerous software busineses before them had done.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by pfraze on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:43PM (#35012757)
The organization is a future adversary. You build the technology knowing you won’t be staying at the company forever, and you signpost the things that protect users / your-future-self. This includes open sourcing everything, moving specs to standards bodies when they stabilize, and building the network around low switching costs.

I can’t predict the future. We may screw it up. I’m trying to protect the community from us if we do.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by flowingfocus on Saturday March 04, 2023 @02:57AM (#35019110)
And besides the current people themselves changing, there are also many other ways in which incentives can change: new people get into the mix (investors, board members, c-level), people leave etc. I recently formulated it like this: As long as an experience of something that I want to have in my life can be influenced by a single entity I have to hope the incentives of that entity do not change drastically.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by bnewbold on Friday March 03, 2023 @05:28PM (#35015899)
As a small nit, André Staltz is not directly affiliated with Bluesky. Paul and a couple other folks on the team have a track record with similar open projects.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by hbn on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:13AM (#35010631)
And if they ever plan to monetize they're gonna be at the behest of payment processors and advertisers, and will censor just like everyone else.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by hgsgm on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:38AM (#35011828)
They can't censor other people's instances. Advertisers would advertise per-instance.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by wmf on Friday March 03, 2023 @04:00PM (#35014918)
I assume the iOS app would have to censor all instances.
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by JustSomeNobody on Friday March 03, 2023 @10:06AM (#35010528)
Maybe he expects Elmo to buy it and use it for Twitter 2.0?
Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by Kye on Friday March 03, 2023 @04:07PM (#35014997)
The OStatus crowd made similar arguments when Mastodon added ActivityPub support.

"We already have a protocol."

"I don't know about this new upstart's motives."

I think it's good to have competing protocols at first. Platforms will eventually consolidate on one for a while like they did AP until something new comes along. I know the BlueSky people considered building on AP, so I'm curious to hear what it lacked that they think they can improve on.

It could be that some new platform enabled by that new protocol drives a transition away from AP the way Mastodon did with OStatus.

Re:First Impressions of Bluesky's Brand New iOS App by warning26 on Friday March 03, 2023 @04:29PM (#35015284)
It's an open protocol, right? So theoretically, even if the company went evil, anyone could build their own client right?