The humans are just doing what is incentivized and what they see other humans doing.
Single family housing should not be seen as an investment vehicle apart from the equity one builds in their own home.
There are zoning laws in place for a reason and when you bypass those laws to turn residential areas into businesses, it does not end in a positive experience for either side.
People should do what they want in their own home
Equally there's some place for buy-to-rent investing to exist. There is, and will always be, a segment of the population who cannot, or doesn't want to, buy and this segment rely on rental for housing. If there was no invest-to-rent then that segment would be homeless.
The problem happens when there's an imbalance. When there's too much Airbnb (like Barcelona), locals get squeezed out of their own city. Some supply is good, too much is bad.
The solution to this is regulation. By regulating supply (prioritize in-home, limited permits for others etc) one can balance the three markets such that ultimately everyone wins.
I work remotely in tech, but I want to continue living here year-round, contributing to the community.
Short term rentals are simply too lucrative compared to owning and long term renting. Much of this is the government's fault -- the tax system has a lot of loopholes, like mortgage interest deductions, depreciation, business cost deductions, and untaxed fees that make short term renting even mire lucrative. I hope the government steps in soon to remedy this, but considering their response to the housing crises in the past I am not hopeful.
I also think you missed the part of owning property…because you don’t actually own it…just try not paying your taxes :)
How many people would you say be okay with having a homeowner run a meth lab next door? So back track from there and at some point there does need to be a line. I am not against building more housing, I think that would actually be fantastic, but if you think that people having total free reign over their properties ends up in a sunny picture, there are plenty of global examples of how it doesn’t.
If we extend your idea over total freedom in home ownership, why have building codes? Why have regulation on the mortgage/loan process? Why have anything that supports trust in the market?
Housing and rentals are different because unlike most goods, there really isn't a good alternative to not purchasing the good, and because the supply side of the market is necessarily slow, and constrained by geography.
In other words housing in your local area is an entirely different good than housing 100 miles away, and we should recognize that ensuring the opportunity for shelter to all people is a moral necessity higher than ensuring that pleasure travelers can stay in any given place.
We place a mountain of restrictions on real estate in most of the western world. Requiring that housing be used as housing is a pretty reasonable take.
If you think that people should be able to use their property for anything they want, fine, but don't get upset when someone wants to open a 24 hour go kart track nextdoor.
We see this all the time. People don't act like economic automatons; people do plenty of things for other people without any economic benefit to themselves.
I don't know why so many people hold this poisonous viewpoint.
The problem that people consistently seem to ignore is that 100% free-markets don't incorporate the costs of negative externalities. So frequently what arises out of the free-market is a situation of misallocated resources.
In this case, the cost to society of people not being able to live close to where they work, or having to pay more to live notably outweights the benefit of people getting to pay a bit less for a vacation. However, because that cost is paid by others and not the people putting the home up or staying there this misallocation still occurs.
Healthcare used to affordable for most. Now it’s insanely expensive per month for a family, and still costs a huge amount to actually use. That’s not free market, that’s government trying to help out.
Free market has raised hundreds of millions out of poverty. It’s far from perfect, but it’s better then everything else.
Markets free of regulation are not a silver bullet.
I figure you’re making reference to the US healthcare system, which is an anomaly in a world of public health systems that function cost effectively
I don't think the standard economics characterization of "externalities" includes the opportunity costs of people not being able to use a resource. Even then, I don't see how your argument that vacationers are creating an externality for long term renters is more convincing than the opposite (ie. long term renters are creating an externality for vactioners). Instead, what you seem to be doing is ignoring price signals (ie. the fact that vacationers are willing to pay more for the same unit than "actual" renters), substituting in your own value judgement, and then concluding that there's an externality because the market behavior isn't aligned with your value judgement.
True, but you can't build a functioning economy out of that. Many have tried - it just doesn't work.
Because it lets their own selfish behavior get a pass which they feel guilty for. I most commonly see this view point in bosses, go figure.
Do you buy things? Pay for services?
Maybe small nominal things, but I don't know many that spend considerable amount of money on anything other than themselves.
here's another scapegoat: companies like vacasa that buy up entire apartments and own 20000+ units in a city to put up on Airbnb. They're not beholden to the zoning laws or employment restrictions, compliance, etc that hotels are bound to. Yet operate basically the same way. not to mention cleaning fees scoot by, while resort fees are getting banned
For any human activity we can make an ethical judgment—life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness sort of thing.
This is the Wall Street Journal we're talking about, it's the paper for plutocrats and wannabe plutocrats.
These are folks who are wealthy enough to own excess housing stock, and they are using it not to house people but for vacationers.
Prices low for short term rentals? Good. Hopefully they'll enter the long term housing market (or be sold to home owners).