> it is ok for McDonalds, the RIAA, Microsoft, or Elsevier to quarter their soldiers in your house even without asking for permission.
really? trespass and private property are not a thing, or just not in your hypothetical because it would obviously be stupid then? like, are you seriously argue that because the constitution doesn't prohibit people from coming into your homes, people can come into your homes? did you think that through?
> The “that amendment only restricts what the government can do” excuse comes up a lot when companies censor speech that they don’t like, and it is pretty funny to see it applied to some of the lesser–known amendments.
It's not funny at all, it's shockingly ignorant, actually, if anyone thinks what you posted.
So do you admit that if a private company forces you to have troops in your house, without your permission, this is still bad even though it is not literally the government doing it?
If you answer "yes, this is still bad, even though it's not the government" then congratulations you now understand the argument!
The argument is that people saying "well, it's OK because it's not the government doing it, it's a private corporation" are stupid.
Now, question for you. Did you read the original comment and really not come to this obvious conclusion/explanation of the argument?
It's seems like super obvious that the person was making fun of people who claim that something is OK because a private corporation is doing it.
And they are using a funny example of "well what if a corporation forced you to have soldiers in your house".
That funny example, makes the point pretty easy to understand.
This applies to due process as well, as the only organization or institution capable of levying criminal punishment is the US government, and thus, the only relevant subject of the limitations outlined in those amendments is also the US government.
Similarly, it’s true that if McDonalds forced you to quarter their private security forces it would be tresspassing (at least). And it’s bad whether or not they are charged with trespassing.
You have misunderstood my post.
I said this: "this is still bad even though it is not literally the government doing it"
This is not contradicted by you saying that it is illegal for corporations to do it.
Yes, it is illegal for a private company to do this. But my point is that "Its bad!". Which has nothing to do with if it is illegal or not.
> even if there were no 3rd amendment.
But my point, is that regardless if the 3rd amendment exists, it is bad for either the government, or a private company to do this.
> Hence, the 3rd amendment restricting the government's right to quarter soldiers and not mentioning any other institutions.
I didn't say that the 3rd amendment has to mention other organizations. Instead, I am saying that no matter what the 3rd amendment applies to, or does not apply to, it is still bad if a private company, which is not the government, to put soldiers in your home, without your permission.
Now, to get to the argument here, the reason why this is being pointed out, that it is bad if a private company does this, is that the same logic could be applied to other things in the constitution.
That it is still bad if a private company does it, and also people saying "Well its OK because a private company is doing it" are making a dumb argument.
> This applies to due process as well, as the only organization or institution capable of levying criminal punishment is the US government
Wrong. Due process is still important, even for private companies.
Because due process is a valuable principle that could apply to non criminal punishment.
Yes, people care about non-criminal punishment being fair as well.
Just like how private companies putting soldiers in your home, without your permission, would be bad, even if it were legal, and its not the government doing it.
I am not saying that because it is in the constitution, it is valuable.
Instead, I am saying that the principle is valuable, and that this is why we put it in the constitution.
And that this idea of "don't put soldiers in my home without my permission", and "due process", and "free speech" are things that matter, regardless of the constitution.
And that therefore, people saying "well, its a private company doing it, therefore its OK" are wrong.
They are wrong, because these ideas "are things that matter, regardless of the constitution. "
The causation is reversed. We put them in the constitution, because they matter. Therefore, because these things matter, they matter outside of just the government.
> Due process is a valuable principle yes
Ok, you agree with me completely then, got it.
> what does the 3rd amendment have to do with anything
Because it is an example of something that matters, that thing being "don't put soldiers in my home, without my permission"
And this thing matters, both in the case of a private company, and the government doing it, even though the amendment only applies to the government.
It shows an example of this reverse causation. Where yes, the amendment only applies to the government. But the underlying principle also matters.
Therefore "Lol, its a private company" is a dumb argument.
I didn't say that it wasn't more important in some circumstances!
I am just saying that yes, the principle still matters, even if it is not the government doing it.
Therefore, "lol, its a private company" isn't a good enough argument, because even though, yes when the government sends you to jail, due process is very very important, due process can still be important in other circumstances, even if it is not the government sending you to jail, and is instead only a private company.
If you want a response, then rephrase my actual statement, in a way that I would agree with, in good faith, on what due process could mean in the concept of private companies, and as a general concept.
I can't argue against intentional misphrasings.
And if you're going to say "thats not what I mean," then, once again, do the work and argue what you mean instead of pointing at the constitution. Literally. It's not too much to ask, and it will help you get your point across less obtusely.
Yes, that’s why, e.g., the Constitution requires due process from government generally (see Amendments 5 and 14), not just in the criminal sphere.
But the 6th Amendment confrontation clause right is not the same thing as due process.
It's literally trespassing - there is a law against, it need not be a constitutional amendment. Your point actually runs completely against your argument.
>Now, question for you. Did you read the original comment and really not come to this obvious conclusion/explanation of the argument?
I'm going to be perfectly honest with you and tell you that you think you are discussing something that is interesting, but you aren't. You don't realize this because you are really confused.
>It's seems like super obvious that the person was making fun of people who claim that something is OK because a private corporation is doing it.
Yeah but they misunderstand what the constitution is and does. We have laws against all sorts of conduct and do not require constitutional amendments as exemplars of the laws- so what's the point? That private individuals should have trials over everything that can be in dispute? have you even thought that through at all?
>That funny example, makes the point pretty easy to understand.
No it doesn't, it only reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of how US law works and what the constitution is and does.
The constitution isn't a list of bad things, its a document that describes the gov't's powers and the limitations thereof. I think you are really confused. Trespass law has LONG preceded the constitution, so to whatever point you are making that "trespass is bad", that's like a pretty big NO DUH. The constitution doesn't take us any further in that understanding, I guess unless you are really and needed the third amendment as an example of a trespass? still really struggling to understand the fundamental brilliance of this argument...
So then yes it is bad! Even though a private company is doing it, and it is not the government, it is bad! You agree with me!
And therefore someone saying "well a private company is trespassing, and a private company is not the government" would be making a stupid argument.
> so what's the point?
The point is that the commonly brought up argument of "well it's a private company!" is dumb.
> Trespass law has LONG preceded the constitution
Indeed they have! And the reason is because there is an underlying principle of something that is bad, even if it isn't literally the government doing it. You agree with me.
Therefore someone saying "it's a private company" is making a bad argument.
> that's like a pretty big NO DUH
Oh it is extremely obvious that just because a private company is doing something, that something can still be bad, due to an underlying principle. You agree with me here as well.
And yet despite how extremely obvious this is, people still make this "well it's a private company!" Argument over and over again.
I am glad you agree completely with me, and not only that you think my point is obviously true.
> still really struggling to understand the fundamental brilliance of this argument...
The reason why it is funny is because people legitimately make this "it's a private company!" argument over and over again, which is a really dumb argument.
Have you truly never in your life heard someone making this "it's a private company!" argument?
That could be the confusion here.
>The point is that the commonly brought up argument of "well it's a private company!" is dumb.
It's not. You misunderstand the argument. That argument applies to the constitution. Not to things that are also paralleled in statute or the common law. That's the difference between the two. You don't call the police and say "someone is violating the third amendment" you call the police and say "someone is trespassing on my property!" they are similar in a vague principal, but not identical at all. The difference, I thought, was pretty obvious, but if you have questions, I'm happy to get into it.
>Therefore someone saying "it's a private company" is making a bad argument.
It's not, because there are differences between private actors and the gov't. The gov't, for example, is incredibly limited with regards to speech. Private actors aren't. You can't make me say anything. That's a good thing - do you understand that? The difference is, that the gov't is empowered to threaten you with your life and liberty in order to compel speech- except for the constitution. This has nothing to do with private actors. There is no principal that private actors can compel or restrict speech, because we are all free individuals that can choose to partake or not - that isn't the case when the gov't is involved. I'm surprised you don't seem to grasp this basic concept of civics.
>And yet despite how extremely obvious this is, people still make this "well it's a private company!" Argument over and over again.
Because they are referring to a limit placed upon the federal gov't by the constitution.
>I am glad you agree completely with me, and not only that you think my point is obviously true.
I don't agree with you completely. This is a bizarre way to conduct yourself.
>The reason why it is funny is because people legitimately make this "it's a private company!" argument over and over again, which is a really dumb argument.
Because those are contexts where the constitution doesn't apply. For example, there is an amendment that gives women the right to vote... what does that have to do with private actors? Nothing. Your argument that the constitution <-therefore-> anything else... is confused at best.
I am going to keep my response short to ensure that you cannot possibly misunderstand it.
Point 1.
There are principles that matter, even if it a private company doing the bad thing.
Agree or disagree with this directly.
Point 2.
Yes, if the government does bad thing X, it could be worse than if a private company does it, but it is still bad if a private company does it.
Agree or disagree with this 2nd point, directly.
Edit:
And point 3.
Some of those principles that are mentioned in the previous 2 points are in the constitution.
As in people care about things and principles and motivations, of the things in the constitution, even if it isnt literally the government doing the bad thing.
(Such as, for example, a private company putting soldiers in your house, without your permission)
2. too vague, for me to agree, again. there things the gov't can do that private companies can't. the gov't can, within the confines of the law, put you in jail, private companies cannot, so I don't think your point here makes any sense. sure, there are obviously some circumstances where that is true, just like in example 1, but you aren't offering it in that fashion.
3. you didn't mention any particular principals in the previous 2 points. The constitution isn't a list of principals. It's a list of restrictions on gov't conduct. Full stop. Like anything else in the world made by people, it reflects their principals to one extent or another (like this post, or website, or desk I'm typing on).
>As in people care about things and principles and motivations, of the things in the constitution, even if it isnt literally the government doing the bad thing.
Okay? That has nothing to do with what people are telling you when they say "it's a private company". They are saying, you can't rely upon the principle of the constitution alone, because the constitution isn't a list of principles (it's not the bible) its literally just a document that describes how the gov't works.
>(Such as, for example, a private company putting soldiers in your house, without your permission)
But this isn't a principle of society. Society has the principle that people are entitled to control the space they have the rights to, and that's reflected in numerous laws. What you cite isn't a principle, it's just a limitation of what the gov't can do.
You are backwards rationalizing the constitution into whatever principal you want to argue for. That's just not a good argument because the constitution doesn't list or even describe principles. The writers of the constitution wrote a lot about principles, and that's reflected in the specific limitations they placed on the gov't. But those authors would never say that the constitution is the basis of those principles, because it isn't. They would point to other writers, or documents, such as the bible, or the declaration of independence (which unlike the constitution, did declare a number of principles to be self evident, you might recall).
For example, if you wanted to say that private actors (companies) should not be able to restrict what their customers say because of the principle in the constitution, it's not a good argument. That is because a) the principle reflected in the is specific to gov't, b) because the constitution only addresses what the gov't should do, not what people should do. The constitution doesn't tell us how to behave, it tells the gov't how it cannot behave. So if you want to make an argument about what people should do or not do, there are probably some overlapping inspirational sources that underly the constitution, but the constitution ain't it.
So, once again, you are getting it quite backwards! I appreciate you pushing me to really make this clear on your terms, and not just be rude. But it'd be nice if you actually bothered to engage with what I'm saying in my response, which I see you haven't done with the others posters in this thread.
Great!
You agree with me, that there are "obviously some circumstances where that is true", which is exactly my point.
The 3rd amendment is about quartering soldiers without your allowance. It's become a kind of joke because it's basically never been relevant since it was written.
This was a pretty common tactic of oppression back before the war; it’s harder to plot a rebellion if a squad of Redcoats is camped out in your living room. I understand that China is fond of it as well.