News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @06:57PM (#34918632)
You have no interest it seems in considering it, but your analogy is flawed. The only institution which _could_ conceivably quarter its soldiers in your house under the law is the US government, as it would be illegal for McDonalds to send its soldiers into your or my house even if there were no 3rd amendment. Hence, the 3rd amendment restricting the government's right to quarter soldiers and not mentioning any other institutions.

This applies to due process as well, as the only organization or institution capable of levying criminal punishment is the US government, and thus, the only relevant subject of the limitations outlined in those amendments is also the US government.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by prepend on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:20PM (#34918858)
It’s illegal for Stanford to slander you by saying you are a Nazi for reading Mein Kampf due to anonymous accusations. Yet they do that. And it’s bad that Stanford does that, regardless of whether they are tried for slander.

Similarly, it’s true that if McDonalds forced you to quarter their private security forces it would be tresspassing (at least). And it’s bad whether or not they are charged with trespassing.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by freejazz on Thursday February 23, 2023 @08:54PM (#34919691)
Yeah, we know those things are bad... that's why they are both illegal. Are you suggesting that before Stanford makes a statement, they have a trial? That seems a bit impractical, no? Like, you are just coming here assuming that slanderous situations are clear, but that's ex post facto logic.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by stale2002 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:03PM (#34918692)
> The only institution which _could_ conceivably quarter its soldiers

You have misunderstood my post.

I said this: "this is still bad even though it is not literally the government doing it"

This is not contradicted by you saying that it is illegal for corporations to do it.

Yes, it is illegal for a private company to do this. But my point is that "Its bad!". Which has nothing to do with if it is illegal or not.

> even if there were no 3rd amendment.

But my point, is that regardless if the 3rd amendment exists, it is bad for either the government, or a private company to do this.

> Hence, the 3rd amendment restricting the government's right to quarter soldiers and not mentioning any other institutions.

I didn't say that the 3rd amendment has to mention other organizations. Instead, I am saying that no matter what the 3rd amendment applies to, or does not apply to, it is still bad if a private company, which is not the government, to put soldiers in your home, without your permission.

Now, to get to the argument here, the reason why this is being pointed out, that it is bad if a private company does this, is that the same logic could be applied to other things in the constitution.

That it is still bad if a private company does it, and also people saying "Well its OK because a private company is doing it" are making a dumb argument.

> This applies to due process as well, as the only organization or institution capable of levying criminal punishment is the US government

Wrong. Due process is still important, even for private companies.

Because due process is a valuable principle that could apply to non criminal punishment.

Yes, people care about non-criminal punishment being fair as well.

Just like how private companies putting soldiers in your home, without your permission, would be bad, even if it were legal, and its not the government doing it.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:07PM (#34918738)
Due process is a valuable principle yes -- but it is a gap in your argument to say that since the constitution specifies citizens' rights to it under the most exigent circumstance, namely, when facing criminal penalty by the government, that it follows it needs to be applied and provided with the same universality and standards (beyond a reasonable doubt) in non-criminal contexts.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by stale2002 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:12PM (#34918788)
> to say that since the constitution

I am not saying that because it is in the constitution, it is valuable.

Instead, I am saying that the principle is valuable, and that this is why we put it in the constitution.

And that this idea of "don't put soldiers in my home without my permission", and "due process", and "free speech" are things that matter, regardless of the constitution.

And that therefore, people saying "well, its a private company doing it, therefore its OK" are wrong.

They are wrong, because these ideas "are things that matter, regardless of the constitution. "

The causation is reversed. We put them in the constitution, because they matter. Therefore, because these things matter, they matter outside of just the government.

> Due process is a valuable principle yes

Ok, you agree with me completely then, got it.

> what does the 3rd amendment have to do with anything

Because it is an example of something that matters, that thing being "don't put soldiers in my home, without my permission"

And this thing matters, both in the case of a private company, and the government doing it, even though the amendment only applies to the government.

It shows an example of this reverse causation. Where yes, the amendment only applies to the government. But the underlying principle also matters.

Therefore "Lol, its a private company" is a dumb argument.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:13PM (#34918798)
Your argument demonstrates absolutely no awareness of context and how a principle can be more important, or one might even say urgent to the point of needing to be spelled out in the constitution, in some contexts than others.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by stale2002 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:17PM (#34918828)
> how a principle can be more important

I didn't say that it wasn't more important in some circumstances!

I am just saying that yes, the principle still matters, even if it is not the government doing it.

Therefore, "lol, its a private company" isn't a good enough argument, because even though, yes when the government sends you to jail, due process is very very important, due process can still be important in other circumstances, even if it is not the government sending you to jail, and is instead only a private company.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:21PM (#34918863)
So it is a gap in your argument as stated then. Like, you need to do some work to explain why principles which are important in extreme circumstances, dealing with the use of force by and punishment power of the government, apply in less extreme ones like workplace disputes. You don't get to just point at the constitution and go "a ha!" and have everyone applaud your brilliant argumentation.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by stale2002 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:23PM (#34918889)
Edit: deleting comment due to the worthlessness of dealing with someone who is intentionally engaging in bad faith.

If you want a response, then rephrase my actual statement, in a way that I would agree with, in good faith, on what due process could mean in the concept of private companies, and as a general concept.

I can't argue against intentional misphrasings.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:34PM (#34918983)
You refuse to outline what you mean by due process, and only point to the constitution. Just name a standard, man. "Any concept of due process" is meaningless if the only reference you're able to produce is the constitution. Is that the problem? You can only reference the constitution because it's the only example you're familiar with?
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:25PM (#34918898)
Yeah, I don't think all allegations have to be proven to a legal standard beyond a reasonable doubt in a workplace environment. The US legal system and corporate employment in general agrees with me. Bullet bitten. Ya got me...

And if you're going to say "thats not what I mean," then, once again, do the work and argue what you mean instead of pointing at the constitution. Literally. It's not too much to ask, and it will help you get your point across less obtusely.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by dragonwriter on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:43PM (#34919066)
> But, I think it is self evidently clear, to most people, that the principle of due process is something that matters outside of just this singular extreme circumstance of the government sending people to jail.

Yes, that’s why, e.g., the Constitution requires due process from government generally (see Amendments 5 and 14), not just in the criminal sphere.

But the 6th Amendment confrontation clause right is not the same thing as due process.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @08:35PM (#34919530)
Alright bud. I see the self righteous ego defense. Good luck to ya.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by freejazz on Thursday February 23, 2023 @08:09PM (#34919289)
They aren't posting in bad faith, you are incredibly confused and refusing to engage with responses to you.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by chowchowchow on Thursday February 23, 2023 @07:04PM (#34918710)
what does the 3rd amendment have to do with anything if we're just agreeing it's bad for private companies to do it? Like, the 3rd amendment specifically exists to specify it's _also_ "bad" (and illegal) for the government to do something you wouldn't let anyone else do.