I am not saying that because it is in the constitution, it is valuable.
Instead, I am saying that the principle is valuable, and that this is why we put it in the constitution.
And that this idea of "don't put soldiers in my home without my permission", and "due process", and "free speech" are things that matter, regardless of the constitution.
And that therefore, people saying "well, its a private company doing it, therefore its OK" are wrong.
They are wrong, because these ideas "are things that matter, regardless of the constitution. "
The causation is reversed. We put them in the constitution, because they matter. Therefore, because these things matter, they matter outside of just the government.
> Due process is a valuable principle yes
Ok, you agree with me completely then, got it.
> what does the 3rd amendment have to do with anything
Because it is an example of something that matters, that thing being "don't put soldiers in my home, without my permission"
And this thing matters, both in the case of a private company, and the government doing it, even though the amendment only applies to the government.
It shows an example of this reverse causation. Where yes, the amendment only applies to the government. But the underlying principle also matters.
Therefore "Lol, its a private company" is a dumb argument.
I didn't say that it wasn't more important in some circumstances!
I am just saying that yes, the principle still matters, even if it is not the government doing it.
Therefore, "lol, its a private company" isn't a good enough argument, because even though, yes when the government sends you to jail, due process is very very important, due process can still be important in other circumstances, even if it is not the government sending you to jail, and is instead only a private company.
If you want a response, then rephrase my actual statement, in a way that I would agree with, in good faith, on what due process could mean in the concept of private companies, and as a general concept.
I can't argue against intentional misphrasings.
And if you're going to say "thats not what I mean," then, once again, do the work and argue what you mean instead of pointing at the constitution. Literally. It's not too much to ask, and it will help you get your point across less obtusely.
Yes, that’s why, e.g., the Constitution requires due process from government generally (see Amendments 5 and 14), not just in the criminal sphere.
But the 6th Amendment confrontation clause right is not the same thing as due process.