News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by tensor on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:28AM (#34897074)
I won't play any iOS game with either ads or with a "free but micro-transaction model." If you look in the pay up front category on the app store, there are very very few games. It's too bad.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by tombert on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:36AM (#34897223)
I'm right up there with you.

I will admit that paying like $15 four years ago for Stardew Valley on iOS felt a bit weird, but $15 is pretty cheap considering that it's the full game. It doesn't make you buy gems every twenty minutes, or watch an ad every time you plant six crops, or spam your friend to share your status for some extra gold.

It's a full game, and you pay a nominally-high-but-ultimately-reasonable price for it.

Similarly, The Binding of Isaac is also a pretty good iOS game. I don't remember how much I paid, but it was slightly higher than average, but it doesn't spam me with any microtransaction crap.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:05AM (#34897708)
$15 is a screaming deal for a game like Stardew Valley.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by tombert on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:09AM (#34897764)
Yeah, honestly, for the amount of content you get in that game, it's insane. That's not even taking into account the fact that it still gets free updates.

It's definitely my go-to recommendation when people ask about good iOS games.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by gen220 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:42PM (#34901505)
I imagine that a lot of people would retroactively pay $100 (i.e. future-you would be able to easily convince past-you that paying $100 is worth it).

I wonder what mechanisms exist for capitalizing on that retroactive price. You can obviously make the up-front price higher, but this obviously erects a barrier to people experiencing the retroactive value.

Some other ones that come to mind: paid DLC, "remastered" versions released N years later (Skyrim has famously done this. I think I've paid for 3 or 4 $60 versions of Skyrim at this point), and open "tip" jars / patreon style support. Any other ideas?

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by tombert on Thursday February 23, 2023 @08:31AM (#34910309)
In regards to Stardew Valley specifically, I ended up purchasing it on multiple other platforms after I bought it on iPhone.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by Jasper_ on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:35AM (#34897205)
Google and Apple aggressively push developers to use IAPs rather than up-front paid games, and often won't feature games & apps costing more than 99c. They incentivized the current market.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by qwytw on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:40AM (#34897274)
I think the demo/trial model is still very reasonable. You get to download the game for free and play a level or two and then you need to purchase the full game to continue.

Of course the problem is that it's sometimes a bit hard to tell apart games like this from the P2W micro-transaction shovelware junk

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by jaywalk on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:06AM (#34897730)
On the app store page for the game, you can see all of the in-app purchases available. If there's only one for the full game, you're safe. If there's a bunch of different coin/whatever purchases available, stay away.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by wlesieutre on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#34897157)
The "Top Paid" category isn't really the whole story, since there's no official "free demo" system in the app store. Instead, games are set up as a "free + microtransactions" and then the only in app purchase is "buy the whole game." But unless you look closely down at the bottom of the store page, you can't distinguish games like this from the microtransaction trash.

PinOut comes to mind as an example, I'm sure there are many others: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pinout/id1108417718

  In-App Purchases
  PinOut Premium $2.99
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JadoJodo on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:54AM (#34897517)
I'm sure there are app devs that use this to offer a "free demo", but I suspect the bulk of them use it because IAPs aren't subject to Family Sharing the way that paid apps are.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:30AM (#34897114)
I think we should really call out Apple and Google for mismanagement here. Imagine if there was the option to play a game for an hour as a free trial, and then buy the game instead of having to plunk down $4.99 sight-unseen - or having your game in the Free category with the microtransaction shovelware around it.

If I'm the developer who wants users to have any semblance of try-before-you-buy, the free category (with an IAP for "Premium") is the only option. Which is a real shame.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by yamtaddle on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:42AM (#34897304)
They don't even need to do much, just add a category for developers who want to have a free + single-IAP-to-unlock-the-whole-thing version, and let people search that category specifically. No need for Apple to enforce time limits or anything. The trouble now isn't that demos can't exist, but that it's hard to tell which IAP-bearing apps are just full version unlocks and which are whale-chasing bullshit.

For that matter, just segregating games with any "consumable" IAP from those without would probably help a lot.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by falcolas on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:34AM (#34897196)
Games could still do this (via a single one-time "microtransaction"), and some do this. But standard microtransactions are stupidly profitable, enough to tempt most devs.

And, frankly, the gaming industry at large has proven that paying up front does not prevent microtransactions. Even in mobile games.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:09AM (#34897766)
But the pool has been poisoned already. If I see that an app uses microtransactions, I won't install that app -- so I'd never even know that the microtransaction was to purchase the game outright.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by falcolas on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:02PM (#34898644)
I get that. But you can preview what micro transactions are offered prior to purchasing, which is progress.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:09PM (#34898793)
Is that an Apple thing? I don't remember seeing anything like that in the android Play Store. That would be useful.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by falcolas on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:18PM (#34898974)
I thought it was both stores, but yes, I'm referring to the Apple app store.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:09PM (#34902790)
I just checked. I don't see anything like this in the Play Store, sadly.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by scarface74 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:00AM (#34897617)
It still wouldn’t help. There is nothing stopping a developer from releasing a free game with a single in app purchase that unlocks everything.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by branko_d on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:02AM (#34897646)
I always wondered why Apple can't implement something similar to Steam refunds.

Quote from https://store.steampowered.com/steam_refunds:

You can request a refund for nearly any purchase on Steam—for any reason. Maybe your PC doesn't meet the hardware requirements; maybe you bought a game by mistake; maybe you played the title for an hour and just didn't like it.

It doesn't matter. Valve will, upon request via help.steampowered.com, issue a refund for any reason, if the request is made within the required return period, and, in the case of games, if the title has been played for less than two hours.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by cld8483 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:14AM (#34897852)
For all their faults (Steam is glorified DRM), the people at Valve seem to actually understand gamers and have gaming in their own blood. Apple has never understood gaming and I doubt they ever will.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:17AM (#34897909)
I mean, even Google has a policy like this (with a tighter time limit).
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by Marsymars on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:04AM (#34897704)
It's not a well-supported/advertised path, but you can always download a pay-for game for an hour and then get a refund if you don't like it.

Google at least used to do automatic refunds if you uninstalled a pay-for app very quickly - I once had that happen with a utility app that I used to convert some stuff - since it worked exactly like I wanted, I re-purchased and left it installed for a few days.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by tdeck on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:31PM (#34900366)
Mismanagement? Do you realize some people spend tens of thousands of dollars a month on in-game micro transactions? Yes I do mean individual people. These people are basically the entire revenue stream for the Play Store. Of course they're not going to discourage that business model.

On a less discouraging note, there is a "try now" button in the Play store that games can implement. You can upload a lightweight version of the game for people to play without installing / paying for the game.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by speeder on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:45AM (#34897371)
I had a startup that made games in the pay up front model (with variants, like having a free episode and then selling more episodes, or demo + paid version, etc...)

It just doesn't work, people don't want to buy stuff when on mobile, they just don't. The price made no difference in sales either, could be high, low, 99c, whatever, people just ignore your game and get only the free versions.

On Android this is even worse than iOS, my startup could had SOME sales on iOS, on Android we had millions of downloads and literally zero sales.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by JohnFen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:04AM (#34897692)
The fact that most apps are ad-based is what drove me away from the app store entirely on Android. It's impossible to tell what's actually free, and it's hard to find honest apps that you can just pay for instead of dealing with ads or microtransactions.

So I would never have seen your app. I was already driven out of the "ecosystem". I wonder how many others are like me -- fully willing to pay, but so disgusted by the app scene that we aren't even there anymore.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by hesdeadjim on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:49AM (#34897438)
Apple Arcade provides a ton of value in this regard. No ads, no micro transactions, games like they used to be.

Funny enough given this article, they have Angry Birds 1 remastered.

It’s the only games I’ll let my six year old play on her iPad. It’s disgusting to me that her first experiences playing games would be one’s trying to get her to buy stuff or watch ads.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by germinalphrase on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:30AM (#34898121)
I have no affiliation, but Zoombinis is a nice kids logic game throwback. They have released an IOS port for a few bucks.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by joenot443 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:56AM (#34897569)
Tell me about it. I'm an iOS engineer at FAANG, but I've been shipping my own apps since 2011. It's depressing that there's no longer a market for paid, high quality, ad-free, fully packaged apps and games. I actually interned at a mobile games studio for a summer and it was made clear to me what the profit model was: pander solely to the whales, ignore the free users.

Something like 70% of our revenue came from 2% of our users. Super bleak and helped contribute to my realization that there's just not reliable money to be made as a solo iOS dev anymore. Better to collect a paycheck building someone else's app.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by stoicjumbotron on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:27AM (#34898082)
Can't believe this is the story with iOS as well. I thought Apple fared better as compared to Android when it came to paid apps.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by smugma on Thursday February 23, 2023 @09:13AM (#34910811)
Very similar story with iOS as well. Adware and InApp is the standard.

One way around it is Arcade, which has lots of quality games with no ads nor in apps.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by dgb23 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:14AM (#34897868)
Is that the only conclusion? There's a subset of users who are hungry for high quality applications and games. They will happily pay for substantial extensions and content upgrades. They will remember your name and see anything you release as worth considering. It's a smaller market of course but a sustainable one.

In terms of video games. I'm personally not a mobile gamer though. Maybe it's quite a bit different from desktop and console.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by itsoktocry on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:24AM (#34898019)
>There's a subset of users who are hungry for high quality applications and games. They will happily pay for substantial extensions and content upgrades.

Can you point to someone having this sort of success based on this model in the mobile space?

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by nucleogenesis on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:59AM (#34898578)
I have no idea how financially successful they are but the game Dawncaster is great and seems to be faring well.

$5 up front, $5 for each expansion (currently 2) which add a substantial amount of content each.

The devs are active, patching regularly, and planning another content update this year. They just released a free new mode to the game as well.

No ads, no microtransactions just a fun and complete game with lots of replay value - I hope they can sustain it over time

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by phillryu on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:43AM (#34898307)
For mobile gaming there might be some creators here or there scratching out a living like that but probably about 0.1% as many as you imagine, or as there seemingly should be considering how much money is in the ecosystem. The vast majority of that money is sucked up by big IP and older established apps and pseudo publishers/install networks that rip off the latest trends and blast them to their audience full of ads etc. Apple Arcade was trying to create a healthier walled garden within App Store but years later feels kind of like a big brand bargain bin the way it's been run. It's just very extreme winner takes all dynamics.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by qikInNdOutReply on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:54AM (#34898499)
I actually think there is a function of whales, not yet explored. Dont try to milk them with items. Make them gatekeepers. They get to decide who plays the game, who gets to enter, and who gets to stay. Sounds strange, but if they keep the thing afloat, they might aswell have a total say on that.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by fho on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:04PM (#34898683)
Wow ... That sounds like a massive power trip.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by sitzkrieg on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:14PM (#34898880)
obnoxious pay to win items in garbage pvp games definitely cater to this
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by circuit10 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:02PM (#34899866)
What advantage would that have to anyone? That sounds bad for both the developers and the players
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by mdip on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:22PM (#34899064)

   > There's a subset of users who are hungry for high quality applications and games.
You're right on, here, and it points to a few problems and opportunities. I'm that subset of users yet I have an incredibly hard time finding apps meeting my criteria in the app stores. They are there. I often find them right after purchasing something that isn't as good or using one of a hundred free-but-varying-degrees-of-awful apps because I don't trust that spending even $3.00 isn't going to get me a paid-but-varying-degrees-of-awful app[0].

The amount of awful going on in the space of "mobile development" long passed unacceptable to me. The idea that McDonald's is $10.00 or $4.50 if I use their app that crashes, needs my location, sends me random empty notifications and every other minor and major brand's app that wants to slurp up any little bit of data they can and make my notification tray useless. I'm not happy with the "check this box and we'll track everything you do but 'trust us'" cloud-enabling Windows and every app being non-functional without an internet connection and the "functionality provided" often being "license validation" and/or "share this! social network features and data mining"... takes a breath yeah, that got away from me ... but it's just nuts.

[0] The reviews which mix in the mess of one-stars from "a bad release" among the five-star "some of which were clearly paid for" just leave one wanting to take up drinking.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by milsorgen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:13AM (#34897847)
>It's depressing that there's no longer a market for paid, high quality, ad-free, fully packaged apps and games.

I can't tell you how crazy it is on Android, to find a killer app that does something that's exactly what I'm looking for and to see perhaps it has or is a paid version, usually for just a few bucks, and I to go-to the store page and see some ridiculously small number under downloads. People will put up with a lot of cruft for free. Even worse in terms of apps and games is that younger people I know don't bat an eye at most it whether it be ads or IAPs. A younger guy I talk tech with will happily pay to win in games he plays, or expensive cosmetics, and he doesn't consider it at all. It's just how things are and he enjoys it. Sometimes I tactfully ask, where is the game if you just buy X or Y? And I don't think he quite gets what I'm hinting at and he's one of the most tech savvy zoomers I know.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by cptcobalt on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:01PM (#34898639)
you're not an engineer at one of the A's (Apple) if you're shipping your own apps — the employment agreement restricts it.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by flangola7 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:20PM (#34902024)
Those agreements aren't permitted in many countries, where OP might be at.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by angelbar on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:24AM (#34912542)
He can have a Spouse or son that can manage/have the finance side of things -edit: Or husband, whatever be
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by mdip on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:02PM (#34898641)
That's so sad.

I had this pain with my kids a few months ago while "looking to kill some time" in the Android world. I don't play a lot of phone games and was dismayed at the crap that was out there.

I like to introduce the kids to more low-fidelity games -- I started with 2048 -- I want to say probably 5-10 different choices; all I was looking for was "lets me buy away the ads", works offline (one choice was a webview to a URL which was not cached, several were very low quality) and has a small number of features that I like (and mostly sacrificed).

I ended up buying mobile version of The Kittens Game[0]. $2.99, minimally updated[1], and worth every penny. The pollution in the market as it were, I would have spent $9.99 for it.

Your comment kind of got me thinking, though. While searching, I used a "mental sorting method" (after I found a game matching my requirements) best summarized as "price, descending" because -- in a hurry -- I equated price with quality and assumed "a more expensive game in this category is not going to have ads/be a scam." In some spaces (slot machine/casino games), I wouldn't touch an app that wasn't "upfront payment only/no ads/no tokens" or "free without ads"[2], yet would happily pay for any that worked anything like the old Xbox Texas Hold'em (without voice/any casino-style game).

[0] https://kittensgame.com/web/ (I'm sorry for those who have yet to be exposed).

[1] So my kids got hooked which meant I went down that rabbit hole, again. I'm not sure when the last update was, but many bugs mentioned in the Wiki aren't present in the mobile game.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by cld8483 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:33PM (#34899303)
Try FDroid instead of Play Store. FDroid has a clean version of 2048. And Shattered Pixel is pretty good too; a well polished touch-based graphical roguelike, free on FDroid without any ads or IAPs.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by testTED on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:35PM (#34901381)
Kids love Super Tux Kart!
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by jareklupinski on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:07PM (#34903633)
strangely happy that I grew up with Solitaire

every platform has a free version (hidden beneath the ad-ware ones)

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by axus on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:32PM (#34899274)
The Netflix Games you can get for being a subscriber are decent quality with no ads. I imagine that will get cut at some point unless they've got a way to measure how much this benefits their subscription numbers.

The Amazon Underground thing they used to incentivize their app store was pretty great also, the "Actually Free" games let you unlock everything in the App. That was discontinued in 2019.

It's interesting how much more effective advertising is than word-of-mouth. Maybe its because I'm not an "active gamer", but it's been hard to find honest recommendations for good paid games by small developers. Trying to research through the Play Store is very difficult though not completely impossible. The store credits from "Google Rewards" certainly lubricate the process of trying things out.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by throwaway743 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:42PM (#34899481)
My assumption at first was that netflix would be crappy. Haven't looked at wm since they started appearing, but just the other day saw that Devolver is making games for netflix now. Pair that with seeing recent positive feedback, it made me second guess my wrongly held assumption

I'm guessing it's not a bad platform?

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by WastingMyTime89 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:24PM (#34903011)
Netflix has been licensing some top indie games for their offering. Some of them are a cut above decent. Just Kentucky Route Zero, Immortality, Spiritfarer and Into the Breach would be worth the subscription by themselves.

The App Store and Play Store are full of ad free and micro transactions free good ports of popular PC games if you are ready to pay the price. Some are strictly targeting the iPad but others can be played on a phone. I have spent an insane amount of time playing Slay The Spire on mine. They are not really put forward by Apple and Google however.

Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by dbspin on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:01AM (#34897635)
Lots of great games on Apple arcade. All add free and microtransaction free. Pay to rent but pretty low cost, and lots of them are not available on any other platform.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by cptskippy on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:04AM (#34897702)
Android is in the same situation.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by mysterydip on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:09AM (#34897779)
That's because games where you pay once get dropped so far down in downloads compared to "free" ones. I've had people tell me to my face "your ($1) game costs too much" while sipping their daily $5 latte.
Re:Rovio delists original Angry Birds from PlayStore because... by wellthisisgreat on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:55AM (#34898517)
luckily there are still good quality games that can fill in some downtime / waiting.

Highly recommend "Slay the Spire", "Dead Cells" and any of Trese Brothers games. Of the free games "Vampire Survivors" is really good and not intrusive with ads (I think it's some kind of altruistic business model).