News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by wollyhood on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:13AM (#34895795)
I sincerely believe that I am a respectful, reasonably attractive, healthy, financially successful and emotionally mature person.

I found dating so hopelessly difficult in America, that I decided to literally learn another language and relocate to another country. I felt like I had no future in America because of that. The difference where I am now is night and day. I have had to decline more dates and advances, which never happened before. Which I feel confirms my belief in the toxicity of dating in America.

In America, I had many women who were my close friends. They would regularly initiate conversations, share personal details of their life, and even stay at my home some days. In fact most of my friends were women. Although I have introspected on this greatly, and certainly have grown, I believe this is additional evidence that, perhaps, the problem is not me but the environment.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by bluetomcat on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:30AM (#34896083)
> They would regularly initiate conversations, share personal details of their life

As a non-American, what strikes me about young American females in particular is how talkative and expressive they are. I've never talked with them in person, but I've observed young tourist groups in Europe. They can be talking trivialities about their experiences in a self-assertive way non-stop, constantly littered with "I was like", "it was like", "he was like".

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by penguin_booze on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:48PM (#34902476)
Ah, the Great American "like" metronome; the universal connective; the default prefix to all sentences.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by goethes_kind on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:27AM (#34896034)
If you have many women as friends you are doing something good and bad at the same time. The good is that you can meet women and can interact with them and can get them to trust you. The bad is that you somehow give off all the wrong signals.

Then you go abroad and you think the women are different, but they aren't. I have lived in three countries. You just have a higher value as an American man abroad. Ironically, this might result in you partnering up with a more superficial woman.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:33AM (#34896134)
You should always strive to maximize your value in the dating market - any other strategy is self-defeating (note that you can settle after maximizing - that is totally allowed). That means you should try to meet women doing activities you excel at (relative to other people), demonstrating leadership qualities (giving talks at conferences, for ex.) or in GP's case, moving abroad. I'm not sure how the people you attract by doing these things are any more superficial than the rest; attraction to status-displaying qualities like this is built into the human genetics and goes way beyond intellectualization.

Basically we think that we are advanced apes, but in practice we're really very fancy peacocks with brains :) Note that social status/leadership quality is actually more important than income (there's lots of anecdotal data that women would prefer a doctor over an engineer making the same income, because of social connotations).

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by tester756 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:28AM (#34897064)
If you're using "strategies" then you're already not genuine, thus not trustworthy, imo.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:09AM (#34897770)
Have you seen how women approach dating? Double standard much?
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by tester756 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:35AM (#34898190)
I didn't say anything about sex.

Point stands regardless of sex.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by antisthenes on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:29AM (#34898110)
Everyone is using strategies, whether they are aware of it or not.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by tester756 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:36AM (#34898195)
One of those is genuine, the other is not.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by nradov on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:05PM (#34900931)
Why would that matter?
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by Fatnino on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:19AM (#34907782)
ChatGPT has entered the chat.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:44PM (#34900567)
Women have plenty of ways of determining whether someone is genuine or not.

Some of the things have nothing to do with you whatsoever; this advice is merely about increasing the probabilities (i.e. card-counting in blackjack, if you prefer). A man living in NYC will have a better chance of finding love than a man in San Francisco purely based on the city that they live in - both could be very genuine people. The only thing different between the two is the ratio of men to women in the city.

We must remember not to attach emotional judgements to statistics.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by red-iron-pine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:16PM (#34901080)
> A man living in NYC will have a better chance of finding love than a man in San Francisco purely based on the city that they live in

[citation needed]

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:32PM (#34901328)
I should have also added this is more true than average for Software Engineers.

Specifically, as a partner, you have to ask yourself what you are bringing to the table in a given relationship; if the answer to that is income/stability, it would make sense that a struggling artist will appreciate that more than a solid well to do professional with their own income. If the answer is crazy parties (or whatever other flavor of fun), you might have an easier time trying to find a partner who has stability and wants excitement in their life.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:20PM (#34901140)
Looks like I should have used Seattle instead of SF :)

https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-male-female-ratio-in-San-F...

Ratio of men to women (age 25-45) to save you a click:

Seattle: 1.5

San Francisco: 1.2

New York: 1.0

Chicago: 1.0

--------

How those statistics correspond to anecdotal stories:

"First off, to say that this is not an apple to big apple comparison is an understatement - it's comparing an apple to a bushel of apples. Add in the east bay, and NYC is only about 8 times larger then SF.

So, even without the gender skew, there are just a lot more women in NYC, and a lot more types of women. NYC is far far far more diverse on every axis / scale. There are also a lot more men, but since the population is way less self selected and homogeneous then SF, being a tech guy who makes good money is a big plus, not just average."

https://www.quora.com/Do-straight-men-find-dating-easier-in-...

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by red-iron-pine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @10:55PM (#34906565)
Fair enough, I stand corrected.

Thank you for bringing something, even if quora.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by nradov on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:54PM (#34901669)
Here's a citation.

https://www.kqed.org/news/11231284/does-san-jose-deserve-the...

In "Man Jose" there are 134 men for every 100 women.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by GaryNumanVevo on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:31PM (#34900362)
Counterpoint: Ignore any advice that uses the phrase "maximize your value in the dating market"
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:39PM (#34900478)
And reap frustration in your romantic endeavors.

Look, anyone can close their eyes and believe in fairytales. The advice I gave doesn't guarantee anything - it merely increases your chances of a favorable outcome.

If you have issues with the phrasing, read it as "make yourself into a more attractive partner" or however it is politically-correct to phrase the above statement.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by GaryNumanVevo on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:38PM (#34902312)
Framing, it's the framing that's the issue here. Women can smell desperation from a mile away and this "Pick up artist" mindset will set off red flags for most.

Framing the dating world as "increas[ing] your chances of a favorable outcome" (i.e. sex) is only going to lead to disappointment.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by hnfong on Thursday February 23, 2023 @10:49AM (#34912062)
Your advice might be statistically correct and I don't doubt it works for many, but for the individual deciding whether to heed your advice, N=1 and the probabilities are subjective when N=1.

Also your first sentence and your third sentence are pretty much contradictory.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:37AM (#34912761)
It's true that probabilities are subjective. It's also true that dating market behavior is very sensitive to small changes in the gender balance since behavior is set at the margins (i.e. when people pair off, any dis-balance gets amplified)[1]

That's true at the scale of a city, and it's also true in small cliques. Just like in poker (the analogy I keep coming back to), the table and position you sit at (and who you're playing against) matters much more than your absolute skill at the game. And you might still lose - chance is still a part of it, no matter how hard you try.

"A ratio of three college-educated men to every four college-educated women may not seem dramatically skewed, but Jon Birger insists that, in reality, it is. He uses a musical chairs analogy to explain how a 4:3 ratio can create such a large imbalance. Birger explains that after people start to marry off, that ratio quickly drops to 2:1, then 3:1."

"For his first book, “Date-onomics,” Birger studied this phenomenon in the perfect control setting: college campuses. He found that when there are more women than men on campus, students’ dating behavior is oriented more towards hookup culture and less towards monogamous relationships. (When men are in oversupply, the culture is more monogamous.)"

"Pop culture programs, such as “Sex and the City,” tend to paint New York City as a haven for singles — a place where single women can surely find a match. But if you look at the numbers, this is far from reality, Birger points out. In fact, if you live in the 10001 zip code in Chelsea, Manhattan, 78% percent of 20 year olds are females (according to the 2010 census). Birger advises that college educated women may have better luck in areas where the ratio is reversed, such as Silicon Valley or Denver— dubbed “Menver.”"

https://www.wgbh.org/news/lifestyle/2021/09/24/when-romance-...

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by francisofascii on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:32AM (#34896121)
* * *
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by GalenErso on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:25AM (#34895995)
There are so many people looking for respectful, reasonably attractive, healthy, financially successful and emotionally mature men. My guess is that your approach is the problem. Perhaps you don't go to the right places, or strike conversations with the right people (e.g. women too young or immature to recognize emotionally mature men). Maybe you should work on improving your social skills. Or maybe your self-perception doesn't match reality or other people's perceptions.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by b800h on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:29AM (#34896068)
Both the article and the comment you're replying to suggest that isn't the case.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by jimbokun on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:04AM (#34943488)
Do you have any data to back up your claims?
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by ShredKazoo on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @12:40AM (#34966058)
>There are so many people looking for respectful, reasonably attractive, healthy, financially successful and emotionally mature men.

In what region?

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by hgsgm on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:19AM (#34895889)
A war helps thin out competition from other local men.
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by red-iron-pine on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:15PM (#34901066)
Are you a man or woman? Are you trying to date women? The implication is that you're a guy after girls, but that's not clear and I'm not sure what to take from that.

And did you explain anything about why it is toxic, just a reflexive "it's bad mmmmmkay" and that you left -- but you didn't say what you went looking for, or what you found, and why it's better.

Furthermore there is the "[probably rich] guy in a foreign country" thing, which may skew things further.

Nor did you explain why, despite having a ton of female friends who stayed at your house, you weren't able to turn those into romantic options.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by midoridensha on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:23PM (#34952933)
>Nor did you explain why, despite having a ton of female friends who stayed at your house, you weren't able to turn those into romantic options.

How is he supposed to answer that? The only way to get a definitive answer for your question is to find all the female friends, then arrest them and interrogate them for a week or so (to ensure they give honest answers). Assuming OP was actually interested in some of these women, it's very likely he doesn't know why they weren't interested, and normally people don't give honest answers about why they're not interested in being more than friends with someone, to avoid hurt feelings.

What really galls me about these comments is that many people here, including you, seem to completely not understand that different countries have different cultures, and what things are considered attractive traits in romantic partners differ greatly from place to place. People are NOT the same in different parts of the world.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by medvezhenok on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:16PM (#34901088)
I originally wrote this comment to someone else, but that parent comment was deleted, so I'll copy it here.

I think you've done many of the right things - perhaps it was just bad luck. Depending on where you live - that could be another factor. Who is your competition? Who are women comparing you against? The other thing to note is - did the things you do for self-improvement actually improve your status, as the women would see it. Status is frequently linked to power (and not necessarily income), but not always.

The other counterintuitive thing is that you want to be capable of evil, but choose to do good. I think a lot of people who are good people miss this point. It is crucial. If you have no capacity to commit evil, then by doing good you are showing no virtue - you are just acting by default. Develop your own dark side, learn to be selfish and then choose not to be (but don't go overboard).

(lots of parallels here in popular stories - Harry Potter / Voldemort, Vampires, Werewolves, etc etc)

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by dennis_jeeves1 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @02:37PM (#34901417)
>I sincerely believe that I am a respectful,

Therein lies your 'problem'.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by ASalazarMX on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:53PM (#34917892)
Whoa, what's wrong with respecting other people?

I assume your parent comment meant he doesn't respect them exclusively for being women and having fleshiness, but as a recognition of their qualities as human beings, if they're worth respecting.

At least, that's what any sensible adult should do. You can admire someone for being a good leader, honest, brave, smart, etc., regardless of their sex.

Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by cleribus on Thursday February 23, 2023 @09:56AM (#34911360)
Just out of curiosity, which is the country you have relocated to that seems to be much better than the US for dating?
Re:Most young men are single. Most young women are not by philangist on Sunday February 26, 2023 @04:42PM (#34949815)
Not the OP but I relocated to Barcelona from New York City a year ago and my dating life has never been healthier or funner. Women here are the most open of anywhere I've been in the world. Now dating a young Russian artist who's very sweet and easygoing and I wish I'd moved here 4 years earlier.