News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by bsder on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:11AM (#34882016)
Is beet juice magically safer in cured meat just because the nitrate comes from beets instead of from chemistry?

Without additives, your bread is hard and stale 24 hours from now. Are you willing and able to go buy bread every single day?

The base problem is, as with so many bad modern things, monopoly. There is no alternative I can choose. Without external forces, the system will converge to a single, optimized, industrial scale supplier who will converge to lots of additives.

If you don't want that, you have to break monopolies. And you probably have to be very aggressive doing so.

Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by not_kurt_godel on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:23AM (#34882134)
I don't see how a monopoly or not changes this much if the additive makes the product more profitable and people aren't generally aware of its existence or potential harm. Why is manipulating a rube goldberg machine of market economics - that will, by definition, still lead to a significant number of people consuming a harmful substance if it even 'works' at all - better than simply banning additives outright?
Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by bsder on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @07:55PM (#34890035)
> I don't see how a monopoly or not changes this much if the additive makes the product more profitable

If there is robust competition, I can vote with my wallet. At that point, compromising quality for a fraction of a penny isn't worthwhile to a smaller manufacturer.

I would very much like to buy France-level bread every day in the US. I, however, cannot because that tiny producer cannot compete with the monopolies--they can't get volume discounts; they can't automate with industrial processes to the same degree; they have to have retail space; they can't get into supermarkets (which are also monopolies), etc.

The US used to have very nice, local bakeries. They have been all wiped out by consolidation.

Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by not_kurt_godel on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @03:38PM (#34902310)
OK, but why should harmful additives be allowed whether the market is monopolized or has competition?
Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by justinclift on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:48AM (#34882434)
> Without additives, your bread is hard and stale 24 hours from now.

Doesn't that mostly happen when bread is exposed to air?

For example supermarkets here in Australia used to perforate the plastic bags they sold bread in, to make sure people kept buying more bread each day.

That seems to have stopped (a few years ago?), and now bread can last several days without becoming bad.

If you're in a warm + humid climate though, mould can make quick work of bread anyway so "several days" can be just 2-3 in that case.

Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by nottorp on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:17AM (#34882830)
> Without additives, your bread is hard and stale 24 hours from now. Are you willing and able to go buy bread every single day?

I have a bakery and 3 stores within 5 min walking distance. But I'm in Europe so I don't need to worry about those additives anyway.

Tbh the rule of thumb for bread is you should be suspicious if it doesn't go bad in a few days :)

Re:US food additives banned in EU. Expert says "almost certa... by jjgreen on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @06:20PM (#34889169)
Two day old (proper) break isn't bad, it's just become "toasting bread"