IMO, PopOS is the ideal Ubuntu alternative right now. They're mostly doing things right. For Desktop, anyway.
It does have some nice UI improvements.
It is also terrible:
- Suspend did not work
- My GPU would always be activated, which would make my fan run at maximum speed.
- Steam didn't work out of the box, so I never actually played any games, which was the whole point. Steam did work with some effort on regular Ubuntu.
- Eventually, the system became glitchy in record time, i.e. random crashes.
Going back to Ubuntu server edition, I felt like I had been given a new computer again.
Snap has some downsides for server/infrastructure packages. Automatic updating being the most visible, but they are generally all about lack of control. This is what Snap does, it moves the power from users to developers.
[1] https://wiki.debian.org/LXD
Do debian ships with a microsoft signed bootloader ? Is that easy to install on Debian ?
All of this is installed by default with a normal Debian install.
Yes.
I'm unhappy with them but it will be a tragedy when they are finally acquired.
26 years of Linux, been running Ubuntu for at least a decade.
Ubuntu server on laptops, because it gives me nice things.
Debian on servers, because it's minimal and conservative.
- Debian still has the unattended-upgrades thing. I don't like this.
- Debian's package manager doesn't support zstd compression so you can't use modern Ubuntu packages on it (I _think_ they're fixing this)
- Debian's packages can be quite far behind, for example the current version of Boost is 1.74 where the offical release 1.81
- I couldn't see any obvious performance improvements (Apache stack)
+ No snap shit.
If anyone can provide me with more ammo to move to Debian I'd welcome it.
The don’t install it? I don’t get the problem.
> - Debian's package manager doesn't support zstd compression so you can't use modern Ubuntu packages on it (I _think_ they're fixing this)
Fixed and released a week ago: https://bugs.debian.org/892664
> - Debian's packages can be quite far behind, for example the current version of Boost is 1.74 where the offical release 1.81
Boost 1.81 is in experimental; download the package if you want it.
> - I couldn't see any obvious performance improvements (Apache stack)
“No obvious performace improvements” is a negative? What you can reasonably expect is the same as Ubuntu, minus the bloatware.
> Boost 1.81 is in experimental; download the package if you want it.
1.74 was a year old when bullseye was released, and there had been at least three boost releases in that time. PHP is another example. From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28180482 :
> PHP 8.0 is 10 months old, and debian’s upcoming release will be upgrading from 7.3 to 7.4, which will make 7.4 the standard for the next ~3 years (even though it only gets upstream support for 1 more year)…
There is plenty of software this happens to in Debian, and Debian isn't the only distro this happens with. We need distros maintaining stability as must as we need distros moving fast and breaking things, and everywhere in between. It just means that some distros might not be an exact fit for all use cases. And that's fine.
Packaging PHP 8 would have required to drop, e.g., the mediawiki package, which only become compatible with PHP 8 in 1.39, released November 2022.
Debian is released every two years. Debian gets security updates through LTS for five years.
If the packages in Debian are "old" it's because of the biennial release cycle. As a sysadmin I'm fine with that, and Debian is no worse than Ubuntu which has its LTS every two years as well.
If you're on the desktop then there could be an advantage to running the more frequent non-LTS releases. But I'm fine with the biennial LTS, which makes Debian and Ubuntu roughly equivalent.
Ubuntu runs boost 1.74 just like Debian. Upgrading to a new version is likely to break stuff and neither Ubuntu not Debian are rolling release distros, so it wouldn't make sense for them to update already. The upcoming 23.04 not containing the newer Boost version makes less sense, unless there are compatibility problems that can't be fixed before release.
Either way, Debian is Ubuntu without all the Ubuntu. If Ubuntu works for you now, Debian will probably work for you with minimal changes to your workflow. In many cases it packages more recent versions of software because it's "LTS" cycles are faster than Ubuntu's.
If you want rolling release updates completely under your control, consider Arch or one of its derivatives (Endeavour/Manjaro/etc.) instead. All three of them come with the warning that a standard system update can make your OS unbootable if you don't read the change logs, but that's just a consequence of always using the latest and greatest.
>>Canonical has been taking steps to advertise their paid offerings in increasing velocity lately. Is there something that's been triggering this?
>https://techcrunch.com/2022/04/21/canonical-now-hopes-to-ipo... "Canonical now hopes to IPO in 2023" (April 2022 story).
So it sounds like it is the start of an active commercialisation of the users. Since Snap started getting pushed more heavily I've been looking to change. I've tried Pop_OS but it doesn't fit well for me. I want to stay on a relatively vanilla KDE ... probably try Debian next (been on Ubuntu for something like 15 years, was Slackware before that).
You can always run Debian testing or sid if you don't need rock solid stability.
If you don't want to do that, you can stay on Debian stable and use the backports repo: https://backports.debian.org/
Well... okay? You can't install Fedora RPMs on it either. Installing packages from another distro might sometimes work, but only more or less by coincidence; you really shouldn't be doing that.
Debian is a community project, therefore everything is best-effort rather than guaranterd like Ubuntu or RHEL/-clones.
Although for all the hate it gets, Ubuntu Pro is genuinely a good offering when comparing it to something like RHEL.
Also fuck snaps, no body wants to use that crap, neither on the desktop(flatpak is just better) or the server(use containers already).
If you want to study the data, I guess you could compare <https://ubuntu.com/security/notices/rss.xml> with <https://www.debian.org/security/dsa-long>.
I guess anybody interested in a minimal Ubuntu install would be better off installing Debian instead. The value Ubuntu added "back in the day" was end-user friendliness, where end-user is somebody not necessarily technical. But that's kinda pointless anyway for a minimal install. Ubuntu was also useful vs Debian for its regular release schedule and long term support but you basically have this with Debian too nowadays and it's been like this for years now.
Can't wait to have the linux kernel installed as a Snap package.