News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by nhchris on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:46AM (#34802176)
It's more than just fees and surveillance. It means you need permission for each transaction. Permission to buy a loaf of bread, a taxi ride, a train ticket. And even Canada does things such as freeze protester's bank accounts without trial. Let's not make it that easy for them, shall we?
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:38AM (#34802525)
And not just that...

I'd mention ukraine, but even in peace time, there can be huge power outages in relatively large areas (as in US, more than one in the recent years), where point of sale terminals stop working, there is no internet connection to process the transaction, but exchanging a few bills for whatever you need always works, even in the dark.

Also privacy... Want to buy a huge buttplug from a "Huge buttplug store ltd.", but your government could collapse in a few years and the new one might not like people (especially guys) using huge buttplugs? With cash, there's nothing to trace... with cards, the government can get a list of names in few seconds.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by throwaway4aday on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:58AM (#34803811)
Don't even need something as widespread as a power outage. Ransomeware or other security breaches can bring down payment systems for extended periods of time and can be far more difficult to fix.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by enigma20 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:32AM (#34806184)
Been in Norway recently. After long drive and reaching the airbnb, we went to the store to buy some food for dinner. Electricity went out. Payment by card not possible, payment by cash not possible. I even asked if I could take the food, leave my ID and come later to pay. They said no. What to do? Luckily after 20 minutes it was back, and after few more minutes all terminals were back online.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by makeitdouble on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:40AM (#34802533)
There are other options than the credit/debit card model.

NFC secure area base locally stored accounts are a pretty good compromise for instance. The account is locally encrypted, anonymous, with a ceiling on the max charge. You’ll pay for bread with no latency, and will only hit the network at charge time and/or if you need to for backup.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by traspler on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:03AM (#34802299)
Absolutely. Other comments here already discuss that. But I think there is discussion to be had about how cash enables certain crimes and what impact that has on us, how cashless can change this and on the other hand how handing full control over our ability to spend money is handed over to the government and what risks are associated with that and what mitigations are possible. Also the state already has many, many ways to make your life hell. How big the impact of this additional way is, also needs to be discussed. I'm pretty sure most people don't store their life savings in cash at home and freezing your bank account has a similar impact now even though cash is still available.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by esperent on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:32AM (#34802944)
* * *
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by irthomasthomas on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:47AM (#34803091)
People will just barter if they want the drugs bad enough. This only adds one step to the purchase.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by throwaway4aday on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:04AM (#34803866)
Black markets are notorious for dealing in foreign currencies or exchanging goods or other convertible assets. Removing cash from the equation has never stopped criminals from operating, see prisons, hyperinflation, wartime, etc. People just invent or adopt a new currency if you take away the current one.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by traspler on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:08AM (#34803928)
There should be data about that from Sweden, no? I don't know what the situation there is regarding that but would like to know.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by helloooooooo on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:23AM (#34802430)
It was under emergency legislation. Account freezing can’t just happen out of the blue.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by sethammons on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:34AM (#34802485)
It would never be used against political rivals or to prolong a corrupt government; nope, never.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by rightbyte on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:32AM (#34802476)
"Emergency legislations" can happen out of the blue. And flipping a bit to trash my card might take some hours after that.

Removing cash at least would have one or two elections between the ban and it taking effect.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by kragen on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:40AM (#34803612)
modi demonetized most bills overnight
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by rightbyte on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:05AM (#34805678)
Sure.

My point is also that "revoking all bills" is a bigger step than "disable a card", even though both or possible. Having cash is a bigger buffer against politicians up to no good.

Also you can't target an individual by revoking bills, so the threshold is way higher.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by kragen on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:05PM (#34812905)
fair point
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by tokinonagare on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:43AM (#34802550)
This doesn't change anything. It's actually even more scary that governments can pull up laws that quickly that are restraining liberties this much so quickly. I saw it in my country, which I hopefully didn't live in at the time: in less than half a year millions of citizens were stripped of basic liberties such as movement. And despite decades of anti-racism propaganda, it took less than a pair of months to create a state-enforced cast of paria with less rights than others (we're speaking of access to businesses, to healthcare, etc.) And they would have no legal way of exiting the country except by doing it illegally or by forging documentation.

Most Western states are a few bills away of turning full China. They now it, and will surf on any perceived or real crisis to get to that point somedays. In the meantime, they do it step by step.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by zirgs on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:45AM (#34803066)
So how does having physical cash in your mattress prevent your government from going full China?
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by fsflover on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:16AM (#34804045)
This is all-or-nothing security fallacy. Having physical cash makes such transition harder for the country, because the dissidents can stay anonymous easier.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by version_five on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @06:58AM (#34802655)
That's literally exactly what happened. People did something the government didn't like, and they made it an "emergency". It's a completely arbitrary power. If they can use it for a protest they can use it for anything.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by zirgs on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @07:35AM (#34802966)
If the state freezes your bank account then you're already fucked. And nothing stops them from raiding your home and confiscating your physical cash as well.

I'm from an ex-USSR country. You can't stop an authoritarian government with physical cash in your mattress.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by marssaxman on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:23AM (#34803447)
You can't stop them, but you can make it more expensive.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by nhchris on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:32AM (#34803534)
Yes, they can always stuff you into a cage when they catch you. That doesn't mean we should live in a cage full-time. As I and the sibling comment said, let's not make it easy for them. The USSR did break up, and tyrannical governments get overthrown - but that's going to be a lot harder to do if state repression becomes more efficient and easy.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by 0xblood on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:01AM (#34803844)
What a weird argument. I guess you also don't use encryption ever because authoritarian governments can just extort the keys from you. Somehow I doubt you grew up in an USSR country or ever cared about the life back then in more detail
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by zirgs on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:08AM (#34803934)
I use encryption to prevent criminals from stealing my data. Not because I'm afraid that my government might turn tyrannical.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by pbak on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:29PM (#34811710)
Give it a couple more years.
Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by retrac on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:27AM (#34804203)
> nothing stops them from raiding your home and confiscating your physical cash

Yes and no. I'm in Canada, so maybe the protests in Ottawa, which were mentioned above, are a good example to use.

It actually is much simpler for the Canadian federal government to just lock your bank account, than it is to raid a person's home and confiscate their cash. Entry to a person's home, or detaining them, invokes the entire set of constitutional protections against unlawful search and seizure and arrest. (And for complex, mostly stupid IMO reasons, your bank account does not.)

We do still have due process, judicial review, etc. If you were targeted during the protests without reason, and got a lawyer, you'd probably ultimately get the controls on your bank account lifted. But... you'd need to speak to a lawyer. And that requires some travel or an active phone plan. And that's where cash might actually help a lot.

There's also the question of scale. It costs a lot more, takes a lot more effort, to physically search for cash than to simply flip a bit in a database. Bank freezing can be done and applied at scale automatically, in a way that physical detention cannot. I do agree it is basically tending in an authoritarian direction. I'm worried about it and I'm not sure how we can and should fix it.

Re:Swiss to vote on preventing cashless society, pressure gr... by ashwagary on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:49AM (#34804522)
>And nothing stops them from raiding your home and confiscating your physical cash as well.

Nobody can confiscate what they dont know you have. You are making a case not to put all your eggs in your home.