News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by hourago on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:41AM (#34643549)
> the alternative is violence or unionization, neither of which are optimal in resolving disputes like these in a civilized and efficient manner.

Unionization is a great way of solving disputes. Many big corporations need to be counter-weight with some other big organization.

To put violence and unions at the same level seems uncalled for.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by Idk__Throwaway on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:55AM (#34643816)
> Many big corporations need to be counter-weight with some other big organization.

Such as labor boards, or rather the government that gives them power.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bmitc on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:00PM (#34643934)
A lot of unions directly block solving disputes, choosing instead to deny all disputes. I know one union that was perfectly happy letting government workers make sox figures while "working" from home, while they produced objectively zero work over a period of months. These were the type of workers that would keep government equipment after retiring, quitting, or rarely being fired, requiring the government to send officers to collect. Any movement towards trying to get the workers to do literally anything or simply rating them low was met with vehement pushback. Like a union representative storming into you're office and yelling.

In this case, the union was a giant ball of mud whose only existence was to hold the government hostage.

As much as I dislike Thune power corporations can hold, unions are not a fix all and can become the same overlords.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by hourago on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:12PM (#34644181)
> I know one union that was perfectly happy letting government workers make sox figures while "working" from home, while they produced objectively zero work over a period of months.

"Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fake “manager” titles" is fraud. If you do not like unions because ONE did something that you do not like , how much do you hate companies were you have thousands of examples of bad behavior?

> As much as I dislike Thune power corporations can hold, unions are not a fix all and can become the same overlords.

I do not know what concept do you have about unions, but it seems come from anti-union propaganda and not from any reasonable definition of what a union is. Unions gave us the eight hour work week, vacations and many more rights. That is not "overlord" behavior but being able to negotiate with powerful corporations.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by wobbly_bush on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:16PM (#34646434)
>If you do not like unions because ONE did something that you do not like

Not the person you are replying to, but I think discounting the behavior of unions as one-off is not helping. The examples I have are from outside US though - there are entire states where union presence is strong. Those states had a good industrial sector but over several decades the unions made it so problematic for the industries there that majority of businesses moved to states where there were no unions. Public calls for "strikes" and other work-stopping behavior and violence is common occurence in those states. So the risk of a union becoming mafia-like is more than just propaganda - it has plenty of examples worldwide in several countries.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by JamesBarney on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:36PM (#34647382)
On hackernews most of the complaints I see about unions are people who've had direct experience with unions.

My experience with unions was they were shady, jobs were given out based on nepotism, work was given out solely based on seniority and most work you did for them involved kickbacks.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by drewcoo on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:03PM (#34650133)
We must read different HNs. Most of the what I see is anti-union FUD from people raised on horror stories about unions but without any actual contact with them except for possibly being inconvenienced by someone else's strike.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by quantified on Saturday February 04, 2023 @03:47PM (#34658087)
I have direct experience with both types of unions and it's super frustrating. SF labor unions whose members threaten you with violence over who can move your own property to your car: screw them. Harvard University union trying to get basic benefits for staff of which my wife was one: love them.

Every system is only as good as the people in them.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bmitc on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:41PM (#34647458)
I described something that literally took place, and the behavior was performed by a union, not me. This isn't propaganda. It is a description of something that happened involving a union. If I am anti anything, it is anti-"institutions that have mismatched incentives and conflicts of interest", and so that involves both corporations and unions, but not all of them. Note that my original comment said very clearly that "unions are not a fix all and can become the same overlords". Your comment that I replied to seemed to imply that unions are a silver bullet that fixes anything wrong with corporation and worker relations, and that is what I was replying to that that is not always the case. There are plenty examples of this.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by Georgelemental on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:59PM (#34645139)
Generally I am more suspicious of public sector unions than private. The power of private sector unions is counterbalanced by the profit motive of the company; meanwhile governments are often perfectly happy wasting a fortune in taxpayer dollars.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by acdha on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:01PM (#34646220)
To the extent that the government wastes money, why should we believe that's due to a union and not unrelated issues such as outside politics?
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by kennend3 on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:24PM (#34646528)
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/federal-union-wants-4...

You tell us, is a 47% increase in pay "normal"?

why did the body intended to help with the negotiations write this:

The union’s proposals “do not appear realistic for what should be a fairly advanced stage of negotiations. The numerous proposals are not focused and they would result in an increase to compensation far beyond what is reasonable,” reads the unanimous report signed by three commissioners.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by mistrial9 on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:49PM (#34646827)
Conrad Black built the National Post around the Financial Post, a financial newspaper in Toronto which Hollinger Inc. purchased from Sun Media in 1997. Financial Post was retained as the name of the new newspaper's business section.

Beyond his political vision, Black attempted to compete directly with Kenneth Thomson's media empire led in Canada by The Globe and Mail, which Black and many others perceived as the platform of the Liberal establishment.

--wikipedia

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by kennend3 on Saturday February 04, 2023 @07:41AM (#34654022)
The point you are attempting to make is unclear??

Is your point that you can copy/paste from wikipedia and provide no actual commentary??

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bawolff on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:39PM (#34647418)
> You tell us, is a 47% increase in pay "normal"?

Maybe. Depends on what the value they provide is.

In the tech industry, getting a 47% raise by job hopping to a new job that does the exact same thing, isn't unheard of, so it seems entirely plausible it could be justified. If it actually is in this case, i don't know, but its not crazy on its face.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by acdha on Friday February 03, 2023 @07:18PM (#34649772)
You can’t say whether that’s unfair or not without looking at where they’re starting from. Did they have long pay freezes under past austerity programs? Has the cost of living increased significantly in the primary areas they work? (e.g. how much would a Vancouver school teacher’s pay needed to have gone up over the last 20 years just to live in comparable housing?)

Given that PSAC are asking for 4.5% raises during a period of high inflation I’m skeptical that this is that unreasonable rather than that there’s political hay to be made claiming it is. If they haven’t had cost of living increases for a while, they’ve already effectively had a pay cut.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by kennend3 on Saturday February 04, 2023 @07:37AM (#34653998)
> you can’t say whether that’s unfair or not without looking at where they’re starting from.

Assuming that you did not read the article, I am not stating it is unfair, the independent board they engaged to help with the negotiations stated this.

Many people lost their jobs and had to take pay cuts during COVID, why are federal employees exempt from market forces?

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by kennend3 on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:19PM (#34646472)
You can simply step back and watch what is taking place in Canada right now.

https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/federal-union-wants-4...

Because it is not going anywhere, they had an independent body get involved, their commentary says it all:

"The union’s proposals “do not appear realistic for what should be a fairly advanced stage of negotiations. The numerous proposals are not focused and they would result in an increase to compensation far beyond what is reasonable,” reads the unanimous report signed by three commissioners."

These same union employees are also fighting "unilateral contract changes" that mandates they return to the office, but did not fight the unilateral contract changes that allowed them to WFH in the first place?

The contract they signed was for "IN_PERSON" work, so they are simply being asked to do what they signed up for prior to COVID.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bawolff on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:36PM (#34647380)
> would result in an increase to compensation far beyond what is reasonable

Its a negotiation. The union asking for the highest number it can get is what its supposed to do.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bmitc on Friday February 03, 2023 @05:07PM (#34648422)
> Its a negotiation.

Only relevant in a spirit-like sense, but reading this line immediately reminded me of this scene in Intolerable Cruelty: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PpQk63iIWw

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by cool_dude85 on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:40PM (#34647432)
>These same union employees are also fighting "unilateral contract changes" that mandates they return to the office, but did not fight the unilateral contract changes that allowed them to WFH in the first place?

Huh? They fight against contract changes they don't like, and don't fight against contract changes they do like? Sounds pretty crazy to me.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by bmitc on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:43PM (#34647474)
Apologies for the phone-based typos. Corrections: sox -> six, you're -> your, and Thune -> the.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by HEmanZ on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:14PM (#34646402)
Unionization can have serious problems/risks. I this case, where the business is literally breaking the law, there is no need to get a union involved.

Wage theft is illegal. It should be treated as a legal issue where the state gets involved and uses its monopoly on force to enforce the law. That's what the state is there for.

[Aside, putting violence at the same level as unions: I've been around a union, while working in a factory in the midwest US, that had "kneebreakers" that "encouraged" members to vote a certain way by threat-of-force, support certain candidates for union leadership, and used the Union to blatantly extort local businesses and politicians. Not every union is like this, but blue-collar unions in the US have a history of going this way. Which, even tho I like unionization in theory and cheer a bit inside when I see union action at e.g Starbucks or Amazon, I have seen a very terrible union and so they scare me.]

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by drewcoo on Friday February 03, 2023 @07:58PM (#34650109)
Labor laws didn't happen because of noble-minded politicians or kind-hearted captains of industry.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by 93po on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:50PM (#34650503)
Wage theft is overwhelmingly not enforced, and it's the largest form of theft in the country. Until this is not the case, unions are the best option.
Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by sophacles on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:58PM (#34646925)
> To put violence and unions at the same level seems uncalled for.

You'd think so, but there's a long history of shooting, beating, etc striking workers in the US.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by WesternWind on Friday February 03, 2023 @04:23PM (#34647889)
Folks with union jobs tend do better then their same industry non union counterparts, in terms of wages, health care, access to sick days, etc.

There is however a third choice, which is government regulation. Unfortunately government regulations can't adapt as quickly as a union can to changes.

Maybe the relatively inflexibility of regulation is what is needed to maintain a minimum necessary commitment to living wages and reasonable benefits though.

Re:Companies save billions of dollars by giving employees fa... by fooker on Friday February 03, 2023 @04:37PM (#34648054)
> Folks with union jobs tend do better

Just like planes which survived battles only had bullet marks on their wings.