News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by seu on Friday February 03, 2023 @07:57AM (#34640456)
> Well, you can tie that into a lot of questions, like, ‘Is human population a good thing?’ ‘Is immigration a good thing, where we seem to have been able to take advantage of new sources of humanity that are willing to engage in economic activities and be directed by the markets?’

> The world is a hugely better place with our 8 billion people than it was when there were 50 million people kind of like living in caves and whatever. So, I am confident that the sum total of value and progress in humanity will accelerate extraordinarily with welcoming artificial beings into our community of working on things. I think there will be enormous value created from all that.

The problem with Carmack and many like him, is that they think of themselves as purely rational beings operating within scientific frameworks and based purely on scientific results, but whenever they step outside the technical fields in which they work, they are ignorant and dogmatic.

He seems to ignore a lot about what the living conditions for people were throughout history, and have a blind trust in the positive power of 'human progress'.

These people don't stop for a second to question the 'why', just the 'how'. They just assume 'because it will be better' and build their mountains of reasons on top of that, which just crumble and fall down as soon as that basic belief does not hold.

I have a LOT of respect for him, and I'm sure he's a very decent, honest human being. But he's unfortunately another believer of the techno-utopianist faith which only asks for more 'blind progress' without questioning whether that is a good thing or not.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by nobodyandproud on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:19AM (#34641296)
Creative destruction (see https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/creativedestruction.asp) is a core to the United States

The problems are the generational suffering that occurs with said creative destruction: There's no incentive to distribute or share out wealth and the results are brutal.

On your point: Note that in the US there's a separation of technical and engineering prowess (MIT, Caltech, ...) and power players (Yale, Harvard). It's almost like our system doesn't want our best engineers thinking about consequences or seeing what the political and wealthy are really like.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by throwaway4aday on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:14AM (#34642087)
Ok, let's see your foundation then.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by sershe on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:25AM (#34642259)
> He seems to ignore a lot about what the living conditions for people were throughout history, and have a blind trust in the positive power of 'human progress'.

Eh? A contender for the most self-contradictory sentence I've ever read ;) The best reason to believe in positive power of "human progress" is, specifically, not ignoring "what the living conditions for people were throughout history".

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by seu on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:11AM (#34643028)
Let me correct my sentence: there's a blind belief that _technological_ progress automatically equates to better life conditions.

And to clarify: I'm not saying "all technology is bad", but rather "not all technological progress is automatically good for humanity".

As an example, living conditions of hunter-gatherers were way, way better than living conditions of the first people in cities, and I'd argue, depending on which parameters you use, might still be better than our modern, big-city living conditions (except maybe for the richest 1% of the world)

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by sershe on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:22PM (#34644367)
On average technology has been overwhelmingly good. The GP is too vague, but what is the alternative to blind progress being proposed - some ethicist deciding what's good? When has that ever work out well? I'm pretty sure it has 100% track record of failure, I don't believe modern ethicists will do any better than luddites, inquisition, or Paul Elrich just because they have better manners. In fact I think less of a bioethicist than of an inquisitor, at least the latter had general ignorance as an excuse.

I, personally, think "techno-utopianists" don't go far enough. The contributions of some supposed non-technological progress - even to an extent of the institutional progress, but especially of some supposed cultural/ethical values improving, etc. - is overrated. Ultimately, it's all downstream of technology - only the technology enables the complex economy of abundance, and combined they allow good institutions to propagate. Even modern societies, as soon as they become poor, quickly start losing a veneer of "ethical progress". And we don't even usually see actual technological degradation.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by innagadadavida on Friday February 03, 2023 @05:17PM (#34648542)
> On average technology has been overwhelmingly good.

In order to achieve this, we are destroying the environment, other species and their habitats.

> but what is the alternative to blind progress being proposed

You don’t need and ethicist for this - but an accountant. We need to get stricter about negative externalities. For example, every inventor/manufacturer should be forced to take back their product after end of life. This will slow progress but if done right, it will avoid destruction brought by technology or at least not palm it off on to poorer society or environment.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by p1esk on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:46PM (#34644849)
living conditions of hunter-gatherers were way, way better than living conditions of the first people in cities

Why do you think so?

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by pegasus on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:50PM (#34646027)
Historians agree (based for example on studying human remains) that they were much healthier, amongst other things. Check out the book "Against the Grain" for example.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by p1esk on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:38PM (#34646702)
Harsh conditions might serve as a filter to produce healthier individuals (the rest died shortly after birth).
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by thfuran on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#34647238)
Urban areas also had roughly 50% infant and childhood mortality until recently.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by p1esk on Friday February 03, 2023 @04:08PM (#34647736)
This argument is silly: given a choice between living in a cave, or in a forest, completely outside of any civilization, and living in a primitive village, I'd choose the village any day. As would (and did) vast majority of people. To me, the social and physical construct of the first village looks like a huge advancement in terms of living conditions, and the quality of life has been improving steadily every since.

Occasional hiking into some wilderness and sleeping in a tent for a few nights is okay, but I am not a wild animal, and I don't want to live like a wild animal, surrounded by wild animals.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by LoveMortuus on Monday February 06, 2023 @03:54AM (#34674984)
Healthier compared to a person of equal age?

My assumption is that since we're living longer then ever we're probably living healthier then ever. (Or at least there's an option to do so).

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by serverholic on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:32AM (#34642361)
I’ve come to strongly resent the techno-utopian mindset that unfortunately plagues the tech world.

Tech for the sake of tech with zero thought about how it will affect humanity.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by ncr100 on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:19AM (#34643168)
Here, here.

I haven't studied it formally and I'm being asked to support techno utopia also. So it feels pretty shaky to me.

Certainly my livelihood is based on the premise of it and my dreams which fuel my workplace motivation serve as foundation to you know what I do with 50% of my life, work on technology. So I am biased.

Some utopian dystopia discussions here on hacker news sort of boil down to the chaos theory level of assumptions, where you can see people exercising their own defensiveness when they snipe on a naysayer, sniping on their grammatical concerns, but not actually engaging in value-based discussions into the hacker news thread. It's like they're not human, they're only practicing it being devil's advocate technicians.

Useful idiots is kind of what I think. We need to have more values discussions, ethics too.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by m3kw9 on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:32AM (#34642369)
If you got less people there is still no guarantee less percentage of people are gonna be suffering.

Feeling bad because more people are in your view is “suffering” is all in your head.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by _gabe_ on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:33AM (#34642378)
> The problem with Carmack and many like him, is that they think of themselves as purely rational beings operating within scientific frameworks and based purely on scientific results, but whenever they step outside the technical fields in which they work, they are ignorant and dogmatic.

I'm just curious, do you happen to work in a technical field and consider yourself rational and scientific? And if you do, why do you presuppose that your views are automatically correct? Couldn't it also hold that your views may be ignorant and dogmatic if you apply the same scrutiny to yourself that you do to Carmack?

And if you don't work in a technical field, then I guess this is all irrelevant anyways. I just don't like when I see people making these types of arguments where you can't speak on a subject that you're not actively pursuing a PhD in, and then they proceed to do exactly that.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by seu on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:20AM (#34643188)
I have a degree in computer science and worked in a technical field for over 20 years. I don't call myself "rational and scientific", though I do think that the Scientific Method is a great way of creating useful models of the world. But those models - like all models - are wrong. Maybe it's just semantics, but one of my points is exactly that some people believe that they are "rational and scientific" and ignore that we are not just computers; experience, emotions and unconscious bias plays an important role in our decisions. Thinking that the whole world (and themselves) can be perfectly rationalized, makes them miss the point that there are non-rational reasons for them to think the way they do. That's why I refer to when I talk about dogmatism.

I suggest everyone (who wants to hear me) to read Joseph Weizenbaum's "Computer Power and Human Reason"; he does a much better job than me at raising similar arguments to mine. Also, Daniel Kahneman's "Thinking, Fast and Slow", for the ways in which we _all_ are so _not_ 100% rational in our everyday decisions.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by JohnBooty on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:41AM (#34642522)

    The problem with Carmack and many like him, is that they 
    think of themselves as purely rational beings operating 
    within scientific frameworks and based purely on scientific 
    results, but whenever they step outside the technical fields 
    in which they work, they are ignorant and dogmatic.
I mean, what's the alternative? For a guy like Carmack to only comment on narrow areas in his field(s) of expertise? He's a human being; I think he's allowed to comment on other topics and I tend to find his comments interesting because I understand them in the correct context.

The problems arise when folks start to present themselves as experts and try to hold sway over others in areas in which they have no clue.

If Carmack took his musings on society, and presented himself as some sort of expert or tried to run for office or something, and push things on people that way, that'd be obnoxious. I'd have a problem. But that's not what I see.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by hipjiveguy on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:14PM (#34650224)
very nicely put. made me rethink somethings :D much appreciated.

ie - expand my domains

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by dadarepublic on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:53AM (#34642720)
Without value judgement on the above quotes, I think Carmack is very much aware of his own lane and would say to take any comments outside it with a grain of salt. For instance earlier in the article, he states:

>I’m trying not to use the kind of hyperbole of really grand pronouncements, because I am a nuts-and-bolts person. Even with the rocketry stuff, I wasn’t talking about colonizing Mars, I was talking about which bolts I’m using to hold things together. So, I don’t want to do a TED talk going on and on about all the things that might be possible with plausibly cost-effective artificial general intelligence.

He likes to figure out new puzzles and how things work. He's an engineer at heart and that's very much his comfort zone. AGI is an exciting new puzzle for him. I'm glad he's taken an interest.

(Edit capitalization & punctuation)

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by martin_drapeau on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:53AM (#34643782)
Can you tell us what is wrong with progress? Any examples?
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by mrguyorama on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:39PM (#34644726)
Define Progress
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by nickersonm on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:00PM (#34646944)
Greater control of our physical environment.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by flangola7 on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#34647052)
What if we had control to cause the sun to go supernova by doing something that everyone on earth has access to, like simply arranging a small pile of pebbles in a rough pattern?

That would not be good or progress.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by martin_drapeau on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#34647041)
Moving people up Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. Technology enables that.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by jareklupinski on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:11PM (#34647066)
my grandparents spent 8 hours sowing and reaped 100g of rice

yesterday I spent 8 hours sowing and reaped 200g of rice

today I spent 8 hours sowing and I will reap 300g of rice

progress

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by braindead_in on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:01PM (#34643940)
>> The world is a hugely better place with our 8 billion people than it was when there were 50 million people kind of like living in caves and whatever.

There is a theory that hunter-gatherers were much more happier compared to us because they were more in tune with the natural environment, had fewer sources of stress, and were more connected to their community than modern humans.

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/10/01/5510187...

From the article.

> Today people [in Western societies] go to mindfulness classes, yoga classes and clubs dancing, just so for a moment they can live in the present. The Bushmen live that way all the time!

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by solarmist on Friday February 03, 2023 @06:00PM (#34649037)
They also happily murdered unaffiliated tribes just because.

There are tons of trade offs.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by zquzra on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:17PM (#34650681)
> They also happily murdered unaffiliated tribes just because.

We still do it.

Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by solarmist on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:52PM (#34656422)
Many of us don't. In hunter gatherer tribes it was I, possible to not be personally affected though.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by elteto on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:37PM (#34650807)
Idk... I'm very grateful for modern dentistry...
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by thefaux on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:04AM (#34651711)
I have read that North American indigenous people were known for having great teeth. Here is one random citation I found searching for indigenous teeth: https://drscottgraves.com/the-secrets-to-healthy-teeth-from-...
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by Tycho on Saturday February 04, 2023 @09:22AM (#34654689)
I heard that animals usually have teeth in excellent condition, and the suggested explanation was that eating soft, processed, cooked foods is not what our teeth evolved to do, and so ours fall into disrepair.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by LoveMortuus on Monday February 06, 2023 @03:51AM (#34674977)
I'd say the big difference is the sugar. If I brush my teeth and then eat only meat for a whole week, my teeth are still incredibly smooth - giving the feeling of having clean teeth. On the other hand, if I eat a piece of chocolate or just one toffifee, in a couple of hours my teeth get very fuzzy - the tongue no longer glides across them smoothly.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by serverholic on Saturday February 04, 2023 @08:18AM (#34654222)
Why does it have to be a trade off?
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by elteto on Saturday February 04, 2023 @11:14AM (#34655500)
Because we have yet to discover the advanced dentist chairs used by indigenous people of the past.
Re:Exclusive Q&A John Carmack’s ‘Different Path’ to Artifici... by zquzra on Friday February 03, 2023 @09:08PM (#34650632)
>>The world is a hugely better place

I don't know. We live more, but a longer life can also be miserable.