This seems like the weirdest one to me. I mean if they don’t have a LinkedIn user account, why should they abide by the User Agreement?
Lawyer/legal time is costly, they probably didn't look into it too deep, they just saw the LinkedIn logo with "Scrape LinkedIn" written next to it on OP's main page.
The demands seem pretty reasonable in this case, I'd probably accede.
In any case, LinkedIn accounts are clickwrapped in the EULA, and you can't build a scraper for stuff behind their auth wall - which, I believe as a direct response to LinkedIn vs. HiQ, is more or less everything they serve - without being able to get past it yourself. So the question of whether or not OP has agreed to the EULA, which LinkedIn complains Browserflow is marketed in part to violate, isn't remotely germane to a meaningful discussion of the issue.
I mean if they have a contract with LinkedIn and they are violating it, they should stop lol. Since they make money from the tool apparently, and LinkedIn accounts are worthless, I’d probably stop violating the contract by terminating my LinkedIn account.
LinkedIn is being a lot more generous here than they really need to be. Getting an Ask HN to the front page about it wasn't terribly smart, but then this is why the only good advice for OP in this thread is "talk to a lawyer", which anyone who's already incorporated an LLC really should not need telling, but whatever.
> You agree that by clicking “Join Now”, “Join LinkedIn”, “Sign Up” or similar, registering, accessing or using our services (described below), you are agreeing to enter into a legally binding contract with LinkedIn
in other words, anyone that "access[es] or us[es]" their services are agreeing to the contract. This definitely includes what OP is doing.
[1]: https://www.linkedin.com/legal/user-agreement#introduction
Not a lawyer, but that is ridiculous. You'd have to accept the terms to even be permitted to read the terms, as they are hosted on linkedin.com.
I know law doesn’t work that way, but it doesn’t make it non-absurd either.
Edit: I remember from my childhood public transport “artists” who could enter a train, perform their “art” and then demand money “because I’ve seen that you watched it”. Not exactly the same, but strong vibes.
Bob would have to agree. And Bob would have to be getting _something_ out of it.
(I'm not a lawyer)
Not a lawyer, either.
“I’ll never do it again” may help decrease the punishment if this ends up in court, but why would you promise that now? IANAL, certainly not for every jurisdiction on earth, but I would think that’s risky from your side in that you’d have to agree to their user agreement, even if, in the future, they put things in it that aren’t legally enforceable.
IANAL, this is not legal advice, etc.
Remove all linked in examples, and indicate that you will not include them in your docs again
I wouldn't admit to writing or advertising this as a linkedin scraping tool regardless of if that was my original intention or not
people get the meaning without directly naming them.
> Cease and desist developing, offering, or using software or programs with features developed, marketed, or intended for automating activity on LinkedIn’s website or app, scraping LinkedIn member data, or otherwise violating the LinkedIn User Agreement;
> Cease and desist marketing or advertising Browserflow as a tool or service to be used in a manner that violates LinkedIn’s User Agreement, or promoting Browserflow in any way that represents or suggests functionality or features that can be used to violate LinkedIn’s User Agreement;
> Cease and desist violating LinkedIn’s intellectual property rights by removing from all Browserflow materials all unauthorized uses of logos likely to cause confusion with LinkedIn’s trademark; and
> Affirm in writing that you will not engage in any violations of the LinkedIn User Agreement in the future.
Just remove all LinkedIn examples and tell them you will stop marketing it as a LinkedIn scraping tool in the future. I don't know your extension if you make any "significant" money then get a real lawyer to look it over.