That is not an engineering challenge but rather the natural state of nuclear warheads. If your device works perfectly, you get a nuclear explosion, if it does not, you don't, at best you get a fizzle that does a tiny fraction of the intended output. Of course, you do scatter some radioactive material around.
It would be a very interesting engineering challenge to design a nuclear warhead that can do a partial detonation even if damaged by some AA, but I don't think anyone has done that.
Apparently, the British managed, albeit inadvertently. In the 1950's they did not have access to American research on the behaviour of plutonium under extreme conditions any longer, so they to increase yield they built fission bombs with a larger amount of fissile material. There was the risk that during a crash landing and fire the conventional explosives cooking off would cause a fission reaction at a substantial fraction of design yield, consequently the cavity was filled with ball bearings to be removed only immediately before actual use.
They will most likely go off if the warhead gets exploded tho.
I doubt they test how the nuclear bombs react to getting shredded by AA
They don't need to bother testing against conventional AA because of how unlikely it is to ever happen.
Something like a Russian ZHU has an effective range of 1.4 km
A reentry vehicle travels around Mach 13 or 4km/s so it will only be in effective range for 350 milliseconds. Good luck shooting it down. You won't even be able to track the thing and it would just be the luckiest blind shot in the world.
That said, special extremely low sensitivity explosives are used in nukes now a days, so it’s not clear the explosives themselves would go off at all, correct.
Either way, it’s decently likely a cloud of plutonium or enriched weapons grade uranium will be released. Not ideal.
Not as big a deal as one would expect though.
Sure, I don't want to standing under a kilo of plutonium when it gets transformed into dust.
But the thing was supposed to detonate at (say) 8,000 ft; presumably it's intercepted well above that altitude. The dust is going to be spread over a wide area, and I suspect the excess deaths are likely to be about zero.
Compared to a 100 kiloton to 5 megaton explosion, it’s nothing.
Yes, because even without the nuke it's a respectable sized bomb and you don't want one "just going off" when someone crashes an aircraft or has a missile silo fire or whatever, even more so when it's likely to spray plutonium all over the place which is likely to be an expensive facility or vessel you care about not causing downtime for.
You no longer have a reentry vehicle, you now have a man-made meteorite burning up in the atmosphere.
I can sleep peacefully at night knowing that North Korea doesn't have a chance in hell of nuking Seattle because I have some understanding of how stupidly hard it is to keep a reentry vehicle from turning into a meteorite.
The flip side though is how stupidly hard it is to intercept something going that fast.
Why?
The primary in a thermonuclear bomb needs careful timing of the conventional charge. But don't they go to a lot of trouble to ensure that conventional charge dowsn't go off except under the correct control? The detonators are timed and triggered electronically. The charges are not like nitrogycerin, they won't go off on impact.
I don't see why damaging the delivery vehicle should affect the bomb, unless the vehicle explodes catastrophically, destroying the bomb. And unless, I suppose, there's a failsafe installed, so that a malfunctioning vehicle automatically disables the bomb. That would make sense to me; I don't want my ICBM exploding over some place that wasn't on the target-list.
Basically, I want a warhead that goes off correctly over the target, or not at all. That appears to be a fairly straightforward engineering challenge; as they say, it's not rocket science.