Re:Ask HN: What happens if a nuclear missile is air-destroye...
by JoeAltmaier on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:12AM
(#34568783)
Not bloody likely. Its a very delicate balance of geometry and timing. Hit it with a hammer (blow it up) and that's all destroyed. You'd get the same effect as blowing up a pile of parts not yet formed into the missile. That is, some radioactive material vaporized and spread around.
Re:Ask HN: What happens if a nuclear missile is air-destroye...
by ilyt on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:18AM
(#34568834)
I meant that the charges will blow off from explosion, not that they will blow off in exact way needed for nuclear bomb to happen
Re:Ask HN: What happens if a nuclear missile is air-destroye...
by JoeAltmaier on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:29AM
(#34568942)
Ah. More likely.
Re:Ask HN: What happens if a nuclear missile is air-destroye...
by lamontcg on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:10PM
(#34575394)
> I doubt they test how the nuclear bombs react to getting shredded by AA
They don't need to bother testing against conventional AA because of how unlikely it is to ever happen.
Something like a Russian ZHU has an effective range of 1.4 km
A reentry vehicle travels around Mach 13 or 4km/s so it will only be in effective range for 350 milliseconds. Good luck shooting it down. You won't even be able to track the thing and it would just be the luckiest blind shot in the world.
They will most likely go off if the warhead gets exploded tho.
I doubt they test how the nuclear bombs react to getting shredded by AA