News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:26AM (#34547044)
> Well, that's the fundamental problem.

A better problem, some may say, than having a thriving market for stolen laptops.

> Not a world I want to live in.

But a world many may prefer to the world with a thriving market for stolen laptops.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by m4rtink on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:38AM (#34547214)
While unfortunate for any affected individuals, still IMHO a much smaller problem than a few companies have basically full control over all computers people use.

That's much more dangerous for the society than a few thieves making a buck.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by smoldesu on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:54AM (#34547400)
Unfortunately, the insecurities of myopic rich people is easier to exploit than the desire for open and fair computing.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by widowlark on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:08PM (#34548523)
Too true, as evidenced by the comments in this thread. I fear for open computing and software based on what im seeing here.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by altairprime on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:34PM (#34549845)
* * *
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:50PM (#34550049)
> Open computing isn’t incompatible with secure computing — but secure computing is absolutely incompatible with reusable computing.

Is the first part even true? It does seem to me that there are a class of tasks, the most obvious being competitive video games, that do require that the user not have complete control over the hardware and software they're using.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by altairprime on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:04PM (#34551840)
It is absolutely possible to fully implement an open source hardware stack that builds up from an HSM secure store into a UEFI secure boot chained ti a signed, reproducible-buildable Linux kernel that can launch signed, reproducible-buildable applications and attest, with cryptographic signatures chaining from the hardware HSM clear to the kernel to the application. This is wildly unpalatable, but it’s already fully implemented and available on macOS and enterprise Windows 10+ today. (Seriously: Safari can, on stock macOS, attest to a website that you’re booted securely into an unmodified Apple kernel and OS, so long as your motherboard has the HSM boot chip.)

Whether this system is implemented as closed source or as open source is wholly irrelevant to secure attestation, which could be done exactly as it is today even if the complete source code were available. The difficulty is that, for anti-cheat, someone other than the user must have signed the key inside the HSM, or else it can’t be trusted to be unmodified.

This is why Secure Boot with Attestation, and the entire objection to Microsoft Proton, turns out to be about repurposeability — people want the right to repurpose hardware without a third-party services, such as anti-cheating checks, being able to exclude them based on their modifications. That’s not about open source at all. That debate is not about open source, and with the advent of widespread secure attestation computing, it’s overdue for serious conversations.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by smoldesu on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:48PM (#34552356)
> people want the right to repurpose hardware without a third-party services

Is that wrong?

Third-party services are temporary. Hardware lasts forever. If hardware attestation comes at the cost of ephemerally-usable hardware, it's not worth it. It's certainly not worth forcing it onto devices that would otherwise be usable, but instead become landfill because their previous IT team went insolvent.

People can (and should) get mad at this, and doing so with the Open Source community is not a mistake. Open Source represents leverage (AKA "Freedom") against corporations that would otherwise harm you for profit. You can excuse this behavior with all sorts of DRM and anticheat, but you'll never win until the kernel stops processing digital input and output. It's a snipe chase, and it's not worth pretending it's not a power grab.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by altairprime on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:27PM (#34552735)
Whether repurposeability should take precedence over secure attestation and antitheft is the correct question here. I’m glad to see you’re considering this in those terms now. I hope others do too.

Note, however, that as Apple takes back all products they’ve ever produced for electronics recycling, in each case where an Apple product does reach a landfill, that could have been avoided. If, as in your example, an IT department refuses to recycle Apple electronics responsibly, then that’s not sufficient to declare repurposeability a landfill-prevention measure. So I worry greatly when I see such arguments refer to Apple, because they’re easily undercut, and that’s then used as an excuse to ignore the repurposeability debate I that I consider most important here.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by smoldesu on Friday January 27, 2023 @06:05PM (#34553048)
Your repurposability debate is right to be ignored. Apple does not deserve the ultimate authority on device usability; case closed. If you want further deliberation, watch European regulators do battle with Apple's copywriters. Either way you cut it, this fantasy of Apple products being "built different" doesn't make sense on an international scale.

People want to hold Apple (the world's richest company) accountable. Why shouldn't they?

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by altairprime on Friday January 27, 2023 @06:22PM (#34553177)
I’d absolutely like this to be decided at a regulatory level one way or another, and I support Apple being compelled to adhere to whatever outcomes occur from that.

Using this “Apple products in landfill” sensational headline to make the regulatory case is easily defeated by Apple PR, however, so find an argument that holds more water. For example: what’s the recycling story for Microsoft, Samsung, Google, and Lenovo handheld and laptop products? Do they all take back any of their mobile computing products for recycling? If not, using whichever of them refuse to recycle as an example will go a lot further towards making a case for regulation than using the one of them that takes back absolutely everything.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#34553739)
Then isn’t the HSM just the part of your hardware that you don’t control? Isn’t that the complaint?
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by altairprime on Friday January 27, 2023 @09:24PM (#34554465)
You would still absolutely control the HSM, in this example, and whether you installed an HSM provided by a third-party or your own would be entirely your choice. It’s just another open source hardware component. Microsoft could release the source code to the Pluton HSM and it would still be just as effective at secure attestation.

If you want Microsoft’s online gaming services to trust your computing environment in ranked competitive play, then you may find that booting with a self-signed certificate in your HSM isn’t sufficient for them to allow you into ranked play; they might choose to require a Pluton HSM. That has nothing to do with “open source”, though; the signing keys stored in an HSM’s secure vault are not part of its schematic or software source code, any more than the SSL certificate for a Wordpress blog hosted on Linux is part of the Wordpress or Linux source code.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by aloer on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:39PM (#34549074)
Are you not free to simply not use find my/activation lock?

I haven’t used Asahi yet but the way I understand it you can install Asahi right away and the hardware is forever yours to control.

And if you are worried about Apple one day remotely adding a lock to your Asahi laptop you can probably block those requests proactively on a network level anyways

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:21PM (#34549673)
I tend to agree, but that's not really one of the options on the table for this particular discussion.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by 988747 on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:31AM (#34547100)
> A better problem, some may say, than having a thriving market for stolen laptops.

Some may say that, because having their laptop stolen is a problem they actually experienced. Having your device remain owned by a vendor, who only "licenses" it for you to use opens up a whole new world of problems, some of which average person can't even imagine.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by kaba0 on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:30AM (#34547889)
Isn’t that quite a slippery slope to call it licensing?
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by gretch on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:51PM (#34549267)
> Having your device remain owned by a vendor, who only "licenses" it for you to use opens up a whole new world of problems, some of which average person can't even imagine.

Actually, everyone experiences this right now. Macbooks are working like this. And 99% of people are fine with it. We don't have to imagine anything

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by jjav on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:45PM (#34561645)
> Actually, everyone experiences this right now.

That's not true. I think you're saying that Mac users are already today in an ecosystem where this could bite them hard, that much is true. But nobody gives it any thought until they personally find their multi-thousand dollar device useless and Apple refuses to help even though they totally could if they cared. Only then do they realize what a terrible situation it is.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by brookst on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:20PM (#34549662)
And yet “average” people buy and sell MacBooks every day without imagining, let alone experiencing those problems.

It is only thieves and ideologues who actually experience any difficulty. And while I’m all for righteous purity, I am also happy knowing that the thief who stole my MacBook from Spaces coworking in San Jose (do not ever use Spaces!) will get nothing for the risk they took, and/or that a buyer taking a too good to be true deal will get a brick.

Yes, I like this world better than the free-open-insecure alternative.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:33PM (#34549829)
> And while I’m all for righteous purity, I am also happy knowing that the thief who stole my MacBook from Spaces coworking in San Jose (do not ever use Spaces!) will get nothing for the risk they took, and/or that a buyer taking a too good to be true deal will get a brick.

That might be a minor consolation, but the bigger point is that this will (hopefully) significantly disrupt the market for shady used MacBook sales and thus the incentive to target MacBooks for theft.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by zakki on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:43PM (#34549956)
There is n=1 up there that someone is not stealing his laptop. He just forgot his firmware password. His Find My account still showing the device, but Apple doesn’t want to unlock it because he lost his receipt.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by brookst on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:24PM (#34550521)
Sure. And that sucks. But do is it worth incentivizing the theft of n = many laptops?

This is the government encryption backdoor all over again. There is no such thing as a security backdoor that can be used only by good guys. If Apple can’t determine someone is the legitimate owner of a locked device, they have two choices: allow thieves to unlock devices, resulting in more theft. Or decline to unlock for some legitimate owners who chose to lock their device and not take precautions.

It’s a tough choice, but I think Apple is making the right one here. You may disagree, and that’s fine.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by sbuk on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:52PM (#34550078)
It's unfortunate, for sure, but the warnings are abundant; in not so many words don't forget these passwords or the consequences will be dire. Losing receipts for big ticket items is, I'm afraid to say, irresponsible. File the hard copy, or scan and save in multiple secure locations. The burden of proof of ownership is on the owner, it cannot be any other way. Heck, I'm sure a credit card receipt would do. Find it on a bank statement and go to small claims in the worst case.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by olliej on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:29PM (#34552141)
Ok, so what is the metric Apple should use for deciding whether someone has lost their password or someone has stolen a laptop?

Or should Apple just remove the activation lock feature, that was added specifically in response to large amounts of theft because we don’t think those thefts are going to happen any more?

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by tshaddox on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:30PM (#34549787)
If you own a car and by some bizarre sequence of events all evidence that you own it has vanished, and then you lock yourself out, you might have a hard time getting a locksmith to unlock it for you. Police might even get upset if they see you trying to break into it! This doesn't seem very relevant to whether or not you "own" the car or "only license it." Granted, there is probably some "last resort" where you go to a judge or something, but I bet if you got an order from a judge for Apple to unlock your laptop they would do it!
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by quesera on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:37PM (#34552822)
In my experience, and FWIW, locksmiths do not bother asking for ID when unlocking your car or house.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by dijit on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:49AM (#34556440)
I had to present ID when a locksmith drilled my lock in Sweden.

He took down the details of it.