Note, however, that as Apple takes back all products they’ve ever produced for electronics recycling, in each case where an Apple product does reach a landfill, that could have been avoided. If, as in your example, an IT department refuses to recycle Apple electronics responsibly, then that’s not sufficient to declare repurposeability a landfill-prevention measure. So I worry greatly when I see such arguments refer to Apple, because they’re easily undercut, and that’s then used as an excuse to ignore the repurposeability debate I that I consider most important here.
People want to hold Apple (the world's richest company) accountable. Why shouldn't they?
Using this “Apple products in landfill” sensational headline to make the regulatory case is easily defeated by Apple PR, however, so find an argument that holds more water. For example: what’s the recycling story for Microsoft, Samsung, Google, and Lenovo handheld and laptop products? Do they all take back any of their mobile computing products for recycling? If not, using whichever of them refuse to recycle as an example will go a lot further towards making a case for regulation than using the one of them that takes back absolutely everything.
Is that wrong?
Third-party services are temporary. Hardware lasts forever. If hardware attestation comes at the cost of ephemerally-usable hardware, it's not worth it. It's certainly not worth forcing it onto devices that would otherwise be usable, but instead become landfill because their previous IT team went insolvent.
People can (and should) get mad at this, and doing so with the Open Source community is not a mistake. Open Source represents leverage (AKA "Freedom") against corporations that would otherwise harm you for profit. You can excuse this behavior with all sorts of DRM and anticheat, but you'll never win until the kernel stops processing digital input and output. It's a snipe chase, and it's not worth pretending it's not a power grab.