News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by smoldesu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:12PM (#34537092)
Clarke's third law: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

Most people don't understand that ChatGPT has no idea what they're talking about. It lacks it's own thought and heuristic patterns, and only gives you the most-likely response to your prompt. People don't know that though, so they think the Mechanical Turk is actually playing chess.

I mostly agree with the headline here. ChatGPT is hardly any more innovative than a Markov chain.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hbrn on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:30PM (#34537441)
> ChatGPT has no idea what they're talking about. It lacks it's own thought and heuristic patterns, and only gives you the most-likely response to your prompt

Funny thing is, same could be said about lots of people. Try listening to any political debate.

Which leads me to believe that the thing that's missing from AI is the same thing that we miss in those political debates: ability to explain and justify your own thought process.

As long as AI is a blackbox, we won't consider it to be a real intelligence.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by Lambdanaut on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:38PM (#34537564)
There's the argument that any AI built on silicon is doomed to be analogous to the Chinese Room* because it is reducible to its parts.

It's interesting that I am also reducible to my atomic parts.

I may be a Chinese Room that has not yet experienced fully looking down at my self. I don't have enough self-recursive input yet to see through the illusion.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room#Chinese_room_thou...

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hbrn on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:47PM (#34537695)
An interesting way to escape being reducible to your atomic parts is quantum consciousness. Not that I believe in it, I just find the theory too beautiful to ignore.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:55PM (#34537807)
A beauty that means to blind the mind and stop you looking further. Penrose is a dead end.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hbrn on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:04PM (#34538811)
You can definitely choose to interpret it that way, but you don't have to.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hgsgm on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:49PM (#34540014)
Searle didn't understand his own model. The Chinese Room is intelligent, even if the librarian isn't.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by kgarten on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:00PM (#34540637)
in my opinion, the person/entity who wrote the books with the lookup tables is intelligent, the room is not …
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fnordpiglet on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:40PM (#34537590)
If it weren’t that remarkable, how come Siri, alexa, and whatever google calls it’s unused voice assistant are so useless? If it were not a substantial advance, why are chatbots so useless? The reality is, if Alexa had half the ability to “understand” as chatgpt it wouldn’t be nearly as frustrating. It’s not like Amazon, apple, and google haven’t dumped metric tons of investment into these things.

Y’all simply have lost the ability to be amazed.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:59PM (#34537863)
It's more pragmatic than that. Google can afford to run a 300M weights model on every search or click, but can't afford a 175B generative model for the same thing. Generative models require a forward pass per token, all done serially, while embedding or classification models only need one pass no matter the length of the input.

It's too expensive for Google.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by lagrange77 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:48PM (#34539349)
Do you think this is also the reason, why Translate is still not as good as e.g. DeepL?
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hgsgm on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:51PM (#34540032)
How could it be too expensive? OpenAI charges a penny per response. That's cheap enough to wrap in a premium subscription or product price.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by Jcowell on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:55PM (#34541528)
One of the best thing about google is that outta free. Charging a premium subscription for Google is no longer google but a different product all together
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fnordpiglet on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:06PM (#34541981)
In my example of a voice assistant the lifetime fees are present valued into the upfront costs. These cloud enabled devices incorporate a portfolio effect pricing model for service usage.

Google can charge advertisers more if they can somehow figure out how to extract more personal information from you and shove ads in your face posing as information.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by rafaelero on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:29PM (#34537410)
> Most people don't understand that ChatGPT has no idea what they're talking about.

I wonder why people keep saying this. Is it some type of psychological defense to future AI displacement?

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by DrSiemer on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:40PM (#34537601)
No, it is an accurate evaluation of what ChatGPT does. The model is not trying to explain something to you, it is trying to convince itself that what it is writing looks like it could have been written by a human.

There is no logical thinking involved. Output can appear to be real communication, but it's basically just a very advanced trick, that has some serious drawbacks.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:40PM (#34537595)
It's because ChatGPT's knowledge doesn't come through interaction with the world. Words mean things to us because they point to world interactions. I saw a demo where ChatGPT could create a VM. It could be trained to interact directly with a VM, send commands to an interpreter. In this case, it would understand the response of the VM, although it wouldn't understand the design behind the VM, because humans did that based on interaction with the physical world.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by rafaelero on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:49PM (#34537726)
Based on this alleged limitation, can you list tasks that you think AI's won't ever be able to succeed at?
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:08PM (#34538003)
I think we will see AGI. But for the AI to be robust, it has to interact with the world, even if it is a simulated one. We need to build an AI that knows what a toddler knows before we can build one that understands wikipedia.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by rafaelero on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:36PM (#34538416)
Human text does interact with the real world, so I don't see the limitation. Adding more modalities (vision, sound, etc.) probably will increase performance, and I think this is where we are heading, but it's silly to say that any one of these modalities are not grounded in reality. It's like saying humans can't understand reality because we can't see infrared rays. I mean, yeah?, but it's not the only way of making sense of reality.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:25PM (#34539765)
Language is a representation medium for the world, it isn't the world itself. When we talk, we only say what can't be inferred because we assume the listener has a basic understanding of the dynamics of the world (e.g., if I push a table the things on it will also move). Having an AI watch youtube and enabling it to act out what it sees in simulation would give it that grounding. We are heading that direction. So, I agree ChatGPT is awesome. I don't believe it understands what it is saying, but it can if it trains by acting out what it sees on Youtube.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by boto3 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:50PM (#34537742)
It did, actually. The model was trained with multiple rounds of reinforcement learning where human judges provided the feedback: first with full answers, and then with ranking of answers as most relevant.

So the model in production is probably frozen, but before that it went through multiple rounds of interaction with the world.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:07PM (#34537985)
The reinforcement learning was on giving the right answer, not on interacting with the world. But there is movement in the right direction with https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/12/rt-1-robotics-transformer-... and other RL stuff. (RT-1 isn't RL but there is other related stuff that is)
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by boto3 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:57PM (#34538726)
Oh, you meant interaction as a joint training with images, actions, feedback etc. That would be the next generation I guess.

I am simply thinking of interaction here as similar to learning a language in a classroom. First the teacher provides sample questions/answers, then the teacher asks the students to come up with answers themselves, and tell them which one is better. The end result here is I think ChatGPT is quite good at answering questions and can pass as a human, especially if it's augmented with a fact database, so obviously wrong answers can be pruned.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by Turing_Machine on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:59PM (#34539499)
> It's because ChatGPT's knowledge doesn't come through interaction with the world.

We don't interact with the world directly, either. All we have are signals mediated through our nervous system.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:04PM (#34539552)
Sure, but what happens when you touch a hot stove?
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by Turing_Machine on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:32PM (#34539836)
The built-in weights in your brain are modified to discourage you from doing that again?
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:48PM (#34539998)
Right. Those are tied via evolution to the dynamics of the physical world. We can simulate the physical world and learn from that, but there needs to be a there there. Language assumes the listener already has that understanding.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by jmugan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:49PM (#34540011)
Sorry, I meant to say that it hurts. That's the dynamics of the world I'm talking about.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fwsgonzo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:36PM (#34537524)
It definitely could be - it's on every thread here and on reddit.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hprotagonist on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:30PM (#34537434)
maybe, but it's also just the fact of the matter.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by rafaelero on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:35PM (#34537505)
That's not even a testable claim. What does it even mean to "not know what it is talking about"? If OP tried to operationalize its beliefs by making some prediction, like listing tasks that AI will never be able to reproduce because it "doesn't know what it is talking about", then that would be a discussion.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hprotagonist on Wednesday February 01, 2023 @12:07PM (#34613626)
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:13PM (#34537118)
> and only gives you the most-likely response to your prompt

That "only" carries a lot of weight on its back.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by oxfordmale on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:19PM (#34537232)
The most likely response is not necessarily an accurate response. It claims dogs do not give birth to babies. That is indeed the most likely response as babies are mostly, but not exclusively, associated with humans. However, a five year old child would understand me if I told them my dog had babies.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fnordpiglet on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:37PM (#34537536)
Have you used chatgpt much?

I asked your prompt:

Do dogs give birth to babies?

> Dogs give birth to puppies.

I had a long discussion about the expansion do space and the Hubble constant, and tried to trick it in a variety of ways. It was correct in everything even though it wasn’t able to go into proofs and likewise. I then tried to convince it that the universe began as a small potato and wasn’t able to do it without directly telling it to assume it is and to create fiction off that concept. It was then able to make a credible theory of what the universe would be like if it started as a small potato, even going into how the texture of the potato would have caused variations in the density of mass, etc. Even then it would find ways to sneak in this isn’t true and that the universe was never a small potato. This is remarkable no matter the actual reality of what’s going on behind the scenes.

I would also note that human thought is just a bunch of gradient functions in the electrochemical space, and thus also follows a most likely path.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by oxfordmale on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:25PM (#34539057)
Yes, I have tried ChatGPT, and it told me dogs do not give birth to babies. However, ChatGPT doesn't provide deterministic answers and improves responses over time. Many of the internet examples no longer work.

I asked, "If a woman gives birth to a baby in 9 months, how many months does a dog take to give birth to a baby."

It answered, "Dogs do not give birth to babies."

Currently, it answers, "On average, a dog's gestation period (the amount of time it takes for a dog to give birth to puppies) is approximately nine weeks or 63 days."

It still doesn't understand pregnancy is a concurrent event (women can be pregnant at the same time)

Q: If a woman takes nine months to give birth to a baby, how long does it take a billion women to give birth to one baby?

A: It would take approximately 2.7 million years for a billion women to give birth to one baby.

I do love ChatGPT to help me write certain documents. For example, for a performance review, you can give it bullet points and ask to write a review. After correcting it with Grammarly, it is usually better than what I would have written.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by TchoBeer on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:38PM (#34539897)
>I asked, "If a woman gives birth to a baby in 9 months, how many months does a dog take to give birth to a baby." It answered, "Dogs do not give birth to babies."

to be fair, I'd probably say the same thing lol. "Baby" in this context was already primed to mean "human child."

>Q: If a woman takes nine months to give birth to a baby, how long does it take a billion women to give birth to one baby?

>A: It would take approximately 2.7 million years for a billion women to give birth to one baby.

I asked the same and it answered "It would still take 9 months for a billion women to give birth to one baby, as the length of time it takes for a woman to give birth is not affected by the number of women giving birth simultaneously."

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by hgsgm on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:56PM (#34540065)
> For example, for a performance review, you can give it bullet points and ask to write a review.

Please don't do this. It obfuscates what you are trying to communicate. You are harming your communication and your relationship.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by dns_snek on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:55AM (#34544693)
Still not as bad as it's going to be. I'd wager that within a year someone's going to write a script that compares your GitHub contributions against your peers, feeds all of your Slack/email conversations into ChatGPT for professionalism, tone, and helpfulness analysis and feeds it back into ChatGPT to produce a completely automated "performance review".
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by ryandvm on Friday January 27, 2023 @09:39AM (#34546519)
That's fine because within a year my and my peers are going to let ChatGPT write all our code and handle all our code review requests. It's going to be AI all the way down.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by oxfordmale on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:25PM (#34550545)
I am after a rewrite in more elegant language than I can produce myself. I do not auto-accept the review; it is a good starting point for me to tweak. Any written performance review is followed up by a face-to-face meeting to clarify anything written down. ChatGPT is a tool, not magic, however, I find it helps with writers block.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by smoldesu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:17PM (#34537191)
As far as most people can be fooled by coherent-looking text.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by helloplanets on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:25PM (#34537334)
Hold on, at least for me, 90% of the stuff is not just coherent-looking, but coherent. I do think that when it's wrong, it should give a heads up about not being certain about a subject. It's certainly tweaked to sound almost overconfident about every subject, which gives off a bullshitty vibe when the details of the explanation are wrong.

What sorts of subjects have you been trying it out with?

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by trefoiled on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:34PM (#34537486)
I think part of the point here is that ChatGPT has no clue what you might mean here by "certainty" or being "wrong," and the fact that people have the impression that it could have an idea of those concepts is indicative of people's poor understanding of what ChatGPT really is
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:39PM (#34537583)
Are you talking about the same people who couldn't agree about a vaccine? How is logical consistency going with humans?

Not to mention that a mere 700 years ago we were dying of bubonic plague and with all our general intelligence could not muster up the germ theory of disease. Not even to save our lives, you see, we are not generally general in our intelligence either, and make tons of mistakes.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by helloplanets on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:35PM (#34538397)
Could you elaborate on this?

It definitely is able to decipher whether it has knowledge about the future, or some specific political events. This is obviously a pretty straightforward bonus layer on top of the model itself, but couldn't there be an extrapolation of that system where it's not binary, but rather a range between 0 and 1? I'd imagine this wouldn't be the model itself doing the crunching of the previous tokens here, at least not the same instance of it, as it could be stuck in whatever character or loop of reasoning it has going on at the moment.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fnordpiglet on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:50PM (#34537737)
I’ve had pretty complex discussions about Buddhism, physics, and other subjects and it was generally erudite and accurate. In its current unrefined form it’s more useful than google is at providing understanding on most subjects, especially because it will attempt to answer my direct questions rather than providing documents with terms in them. In fact I think it’s probably one of the most useful tools I’ve ever used.

Has it given me wrong information? Absolutely. But it’s always been pretty obviously wrong, and I often use it to introduce me to a subject then follow up with google to verify details. I further fully expect this to improve.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by helloplanets on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:46PM (#34538576)
Yes, I've been going back and forth between Google and ChatGPT quite a bit lately. Sort of using Google as the verification step, after getting deeper into a subject.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fnordpiglet on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:36PM (#34539177)
For the haters, it seems incredibly likely that an IR system like google will be augmenting LLM and semantic reasoning systems to form a solution to the problems folks point. The problems chatgpt suffer from are solved and are complementary.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by abm53 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:16PM (#34537179)
> thought and heuristic patterns

I’m not sure these are well-defined enough terms to make this claim.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by smoldesu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:19PM (#34537216)
Heuristics is the ability to recognize multiple options and reason which one is correct. ChatGPT (and all GPT models for that matter) have a single context that doesn't get compared to other possible generations. You can back-propegate and see which tokens influenced the output most, but there is no evidence that AI can conceive multiple hypothetical responses and select the most-preferred one. At least not ChatGPT.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:01PM (#34537901)
Have you heard of "beam search"? The model keeps a number of optional lines of text without being greedy and picking only the most probable token every time. You can also sample with T>0 multiple times to get an ensemble of answers that can be used as input for another AI operation. You just need to do multiple interactions with the model.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by fsloth on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:26PM (#34537352)
"hardly any more innovative than a Markov chain."

Innovation is not invention. Innovation includes combining pedestrian concepts in novel ways. ChatGPT has the best ux and richest corpus of any markov chain I've ever used. It fits my bill of innovation combining sevaral things into a dang appealing product.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by visarga on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:02PM (#34537917)
Whatever they want to call it, it is here and it works.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by buescher on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:25PM (#34537341)
Except that the Mechanical Turk is actually playing chess - there is no hidden chess master.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by canjobear on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:16PM (#34537180)
Responses like this are highly predictable in response to prompts about ChatGPT.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by lostmsu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:24PM (#34537325)
The question is are we any more innovative than Markov chains.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by Swizec on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:37PM (#34537534)
> ChatGPT is hardly any more innovative than a Markov chain

A smartphone is hardly any more innovative than the ENIAC. And yet ...

Do not underestimate the power of making tech useful and accessible. The lightbulb means nothing without the power grid after all.

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by cwillu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:48PM (#34537707)
https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/janus-simulators

    But the essay brings up another connotation: to simulate
    is to pretend to be something. A simulator wears many masks.
    If you ask GPT to complete a romance novel, it will simulate
    a romance author and try to write the text the way they
    would. Character.AI lets you simulate people directly,
    asking GPT to pretend to be George Washington or Darth Vader.
[…]

    This answer is exactly as fake as the last answer where it
    said it liked me, or the Darth Vader answer where it says it
    wants to destroy me with the power of the Dark Side. It’s
    just simulating a fake character who happens to correspond
    well to its real identity.
[…]

    The whole point of the shoggoth analogy is that GPT is
    supposed to be very different from humans. But however
    different the details, there are deep structural
    similarities. We’re both prediction engines fine-tuned
    with RHLF.

    And when I start thinking along these lines, I notice that
    psychologists since at least Freud, and spiritual traditions
    since at least the Buddha, have accused us of simulating a
    character. Some people call it the ego. Other people call
    it the self.
Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by turtleyacht on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:05PM (#34538837)
What is the original code you had before your programmers were born?

The DM lowers the screen and looks at the group.

"That concludes this campaign. Next week, we'll start a new one."

Re:Yann LeCun: ChatGPT is 'not particularly innovative' by cwillu on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:04PM (#34540660)
Noteworthy that the brief openai outage coincided with this.

“…and then ChatGPT woke up and we had to put a bullet in the server. Service will be restored shortly.”