News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by ajmurmann on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:49AM (#34532268)
The funny thing is that doctors would be the canonical examples for most people. Yet, there is no license that stops a pediatrician from performing brain surgery. What stops the pediatrician from performing brain surgery is that no hospital would hire them as a brain surgeon, no insurance would insure their brain surgery and if something goes wrong they'd likely face a lawsuit they couldn't win. Why is the system able to judge the difference between a pediatrician and a brain surgeon but we need licensing to distinguish between doctor and non-doctor?
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:05AM (#34532496)
The answer is in your question.

It's the credentialing. The pediatrician lacks the credentials of a neurosurgeon. Just as non-doctors lack the credentials to work as a doctor. The hosptial, insurance, and court would all be looking at the credentials.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by 988747 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:11AM (#34533612)
Credentials are not the same as license. For example, software engineers do not need to pass any certification exams to practice software engineering, but companies still look at their education, years of experience, etc... Yes, it would make a recruitment process for doctors longer, as you would have to interview them, ask them questions to verify their medical knowledge, etc., but it is not impossible.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#34533677)
And yet, in your software example those companies overwhelming rely on degrees to credentialize candidates regardless of actual skill.

Licensing is merely a subset of the larger credentialing world. Even in your doctor example, the license is not the issue - board certification of a specialty would be the issue.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:22PM (#34534909)
You misunderstand licensing. Licensing ensures a minimum of conduct and creates a standard for liability for falling below that level of conduct.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:57PM (#34535662)
I know that perfectly well. That doesn't change what I've said as it applies to the examples above.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @01:02PM (#34535763)
It does. Licensing has nothing to do with your credentials past having them. The state bar doesn't care which lawschool you went to, your LSAT score, your GPA, etc.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @01:24PM (#34536202)
"It does"

How?

"Licensing has nothing to do with your credentials past having them."

The way that most credentialing is used for employment.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @01:31PM (#34536328)
That's separate from having your license. You don't need to be employed by a law firm to be a licensed atty
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @01:59PM (#34536872)
What's your point here? You still need a license.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:19PM (#34537228)
My point? That credentials are separate from the license and aren't part of the same thing. That's why many professions don't have licensing. They serve completely different purposes.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by giantg2 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @03:28PM (#34538292)
A license is a credential.

Not all credentials are licenses, but all licenses are credentials.

You can look up some definitions if you want. I'm done with this conversation as you are so set on arguing a tangent without an open mind.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:53PM (#34541899)
I did look up the definitions and they don't support your argument

License: a permit from an authority to own or use something, do a particular thing, or carry on a trade

Credential: a qualification, achievement, personal quality, or aspect of a person's background, typically when used to indicate that they are suitable for something.

Sure, you can characterize the license as an achievement. But it's really just a license.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:54PM (#34541907)
> Sure, you can characterize the license as an achievemen

Maybe, maybe not, but its 100% a qualification, so its definitely a credential.

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by freejazz on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:21PM (#34534876)
It's called malpractice. What you described is prima facie malpractice and a key element of malpractice is that it is a licensed profession with a standard of conduct.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by lostlogin on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:34PM (#34535173)
> there is no license that stops a pediatrician from performing brain surgery.

This isn’t the case everywhere. Where I am (New Zealand) each doctor has a scope of practice. You work within your scope. There may be conditions placed on a scope of practice too (eg supervision is required).

You can look up every doctor’s scope of practice and get a short summary of their training on the medical council website.

Other health professions follow a similar model.

https://www.mcnz.org.nz/registration/register-of-doctors/

Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by dinkumthinkum on Thursday January 26, 2023 @12:56PM (#34535638)
This is kind of an absurd example. The system is setup in such a way that such a person would be in enormous amounts of trouble even face criminal liability. They may not face a law called “practicing medicine without a license” but they would face negligent or other similarly severe charges. As well, the fact that this never, ever happens seems to indicate the current regulatory structure is enough for this.
Re:An AI robot lawyer was set to argue in court. Real lawyer... by lostlogin on Thursday January 26, 2023 @02:31PM (#34537454)
The US really doesn’t have the concept of ‘scope of practice’?

That’s what’s being argued here and other systems have it. It seems an obvious thing.