News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:57AM (#34516859)
I hate this so very much.

Automating creativity is so gross. Never mind the fact that these models are trained on stolen artwork and texts.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by svantana on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:15AM (#34516975)
On an emotional level, I totally agree. But as a developer of creative tools, I've been trying to make sense of what's good and bad in this field. Arguably, all creative software is at least partially automating creativity (photoshop, ableton etc). But my conclusion so far is that the gross part is when the user inputs a vague request and a finished product comes out. Contrastingly, if the user can make continuous changes with realtime monitoring of their actions, then that is an instrument - mostly amplifying the creative impulses of its user (which is good).
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dalbasal on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:40AM (#34517548)
It usually trends to the way over time.

When you're demonstrating or studying a tech (like we're doing with gpt now), there's a tendency to go "here's what it can do." Once people start using it for more mundane work, the focus becomes "here's what I can do with it."

It probably doesn't matter what children's stories language models can write themselves. It matters what stories people can write using them. Same for software/graphic design/law/etc. These are just tech demos.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by svantana on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:30AM (#34519372)
I think (and hope) you're right. Recently, someone coined the phrase "bach faucet" to describe the mundanity of an "AI" that can compose millions of novel bach fugues that are indistinguishable from the real thing [1]. At the end of the day that is just pointless - abundant art serves no purpose in society, and its value will be zero when considering supply and demand.

[1] https://twitter.com/galaxykate/status/1583907942834716672

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dalbasal on Thursday January 26, 2023 @06:07AM (#34530245)
Precisely.

OTOH... using AI to create art shifts around supply and demand such that there will be practical implications. The way email correspondence between A customer and a bank may look very different once both are using GPT enabled email clients.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by lfkdev on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:03AM (#34516895)
If it works, it'll be used. Are you grossed out when using a calculator? I hope so
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by mysterydip on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:38AM (#34517116)
The square root of 3.5 is always the same value, so why bother doing it less efficiently? The same is not true for creativity.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:12AM (#34517833)
Mathematical concepts are in the public domain. The art used to train these models are not
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by pixl97 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:22AM (#34520191)
I mean the concept of public domain is fungible when companies like Disney can pay off their favorite politicians to get 20 more years of monopolies on their ideas that 'steal' from the society they live in.

Being that there is enough of a debate on this topic alone that's been raging for decades it's not easily decidable by a one liner.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @05:19AM (#34529916)
true. Personally I think the concept of public/private domain is a good thing. But like all good things, they get abused by bad actors who are huge corporations. But the artwork and texts used for training these models are often coming from small independent creators. The same creators who will be sidelined by this new technology. Bitter pill to swallow
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:05AM (#34516918)
If a person learns how to paint expertly by looking at (and even copying, stroke for stroke) paintings, would you consider that immoral, and those paintings having been stolen? If not, what would you say the difference is?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by infinitezest on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:32AM (#34517073)
There is the notable difference in the speed and scale at which a computer can be trained. The analogy doesn't really hold up in my opinion.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by neoromantique on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:22AM (#34517406)
So the analogy doesn't hold up because computer does it more efficiently?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by jxf on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:24AM (#34517957)
That can be a valid reason to reject an analogy. For example, many people who would accept regular police patrols are not fine with the police installing a tireless ALPR scanner.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by neoromantique on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:53AM (#34518914)
Well, in police scanner example, problem people have with it is not its efficacy, but rather other surrounding concerns (like privacy).
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by throwaway4aday on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:02AM (#34517742)
So if there were a genius painter that learned various artistic styles on sight you would say that their work had no value?

I think you might be in trouble there, a number of savants have been known throughout history who have been able to learn various things with no instruction and simply by hearing or seeing a work done by someone else have been able to recreate it or produce something in their style.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:36AM (#34544259)
Being able to do something faster isn't automatically a moral principle. Even between two humans there will be big differences.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by adamauckland on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:47AM (#34517163)
Morality aside, an artist who entirely copies someone else's work would be looked down upon because they are not original or creating anything novel or new.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by pixl97 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:11AM (#34520046)
So scribes were looked down upon in the middle ages for making copies of books before the printing press?

I think in the tech industry we get caught up on 'novel' and 'new' because duplication is cheap to the point of almost free.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by CatWChainsaw on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:56PM (#34525331)
Scribes were not authors. They were expected to copy. Bad faith.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:31AM (#34529567)
Morality is the only thing I'm querying here. No point changing the topic.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by wildrhythms on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:39AM (#34517543)
The difference is that a human made the artistic stroke-for-stroke reproduction through human skill and expertise. Even a counterfeit painting is an exercise of perception and interpretation. The value is in the human's hand in the output.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:51AM (#34518191)
That’s actually a good point. It is very much a non-trivial ability.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:32AM (#34529576)
Making a lump of silicon generate a painting is far less trivial. That's not relevant. Being trained on paintings was described as stealing, and unless your argument is that stealing is easy so anything non-trivial can't be stealing, I don't see the relevance.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:04AM (#34517762)
It may be a technical violation of an artist's copyright for someone else to make a stroke-for-stroke copy of their work for learning purposes, but if that copy is never sold or publicly exhibited, it would be difficult for the artist to take action against that person. If the copy is made purely for educational purposes, that might even fall under fair use in the US.

When a commercial AI model is created, however, there is no educational or scholarly purpose. Arguably, a new work is being created in the form of the weights that constitute the model, where those weights contain an encoding of whatever works are included in the training set. In other words, the model as a work incorporates any copyrighted work that was included in the training set.

Wikipedia has a rather extensive article on fair use. If you look at the factors determining whether the incorporation of one work into another work is fair use[0], it would seem tough to shoehorn training of a commercial AI model into fair use.

On a moral basis, though, if you believe that copyrighted works should only be used with permission with the exception of clearly-delineated fair use, it is hard for me to understand why well-funded AI companies should be able to profit from those works without first obtaining permission.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use#U.S._fair_use_factors

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:49AM (#34518166)
This is kind of a tired reasoning. I don’t know what the goal of this kind of reasoning is. The fact is that virtually no one learns or dies art this way. No one in any statistically meaningful amount has a photographic memory and uses such memory to create new art stroke by stroke.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by shagie on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:45AM (#34518795)
There are many paintings that have been made following along to a Bob Ross video - using the same paints, the same brushes, and the same elements within the painting.

Even after following along and gaining the confidence to paint on their own, they continue to use the same approach to painting. Are those paintings afterwards derivative works and to be treated the same way as an AI painting asked to create a scene with certain elements in the stye of Bob Ross?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:23PM (#34527355)
That is largely hobby painting and learning to paint. You’re conflating human skill to learn and adapt and go through a relaxing exercise to AI generated. It’s not a serious argument.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:34AM (#34529593)
> learn and adapt and go through a relaxing exercise

The AI is learning. Why is one of those things stealing and not the other?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by shagie on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:01AM (#34532448)
My question is "what is a derivative work?" This is equally applicable to images generated for a hobby as it is for professionals. It applies to art generated with a paintbrush and canvas, on a painting app on a digital tablet, and as generated though an AI model.

The definition of a derivative work is agnostic to the means to create it. The final product is what is being evaluated.

If the answer is "but the Bob Ross paintings that are derivative works by amateurs are never sold and only hung at home - it would only be an issue if they sold them or tried to display them publicly as described https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/106 " - then I would agree.

If I create an image through any means - be it paint on canvas, stylus on tablet, or prompt and ML and don't violate 17 U.S. Code § 106 then there shouldn't be any issue.

If, however, I publish that image - again, no matter how it is created - then there is an issue. But it isn't the maker of the paints, or Adobe, or the creators of whatever ML model generated it. A program cannot hold a copyright and cannot itself create a derivative work. ( https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/us-copyright-offic... ) and so the issue of creating and publishing a derivative work is upon the human who did it - not the computer.

If you want to sue someone for publishing an image generated as "create a landscape of San Francisco in the style of Pixar" then have Pixar go after the person who published that image. It doesn't matter what process created that image.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by the_af on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:06PM (#34526872)
Have you read "Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote" by Borges?

Part of the conceit of the story is that even a mechanical copy of a known work can become something else because of the inner experience of the person reproducing it. Menard's Quixote, his fictional author thought, was different because Menard knew things and lived through things that Cervantes before him didn't, and so the exact same words are injected of different connotations because of this.

It's absurd, but it explores something about authorship.

ChatGPT and AI have no inner lives, no authorial perspective, and so they cannot use this defense. In their case, a copy is truly "stolen" with no additional value.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by newswasboring on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:56AM (#34517217)
All advances in creative tooling are automating creativity. What are you on about? Look at photoshop color selector automates mixing paint, digital filters for audio automate analog mixers. This attitude towards AI creative tools is gatekeeping.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:24AM (#34517430)
The people who wrote the Photoshop source code were paid for their contributions with full consent that their work would be included in the product and sold for a profit by Adobe. The artists whose work was fed into these systems did not consent, nor were they paid for their contribution. In fact, I have seen a few reports of people using these systems to generate lookalike artworks intended to resemble the work of specific working artists—artists whose livelihoods depend on client commissions. The only way that these systems could produce knock-off artwork after receiving a prompt containing that artist's specific name is if the artist's own copyrighted work was used in the training data.

Do you have any doubt that many working artists' copyrighted work was included in the the training data that produced these systems, without those artists licensing their work for that purpose?

It's not gatekeeping to insist that a project obtain a voluntary license from the people who contribute their work to a project.

And it's not gatekeeping to point out the fact that these platforms have only been successful by using working artists' copyrighted work in violation of their rights, without asking permission or providing compensation.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by scrollaway on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:34AM (#34517493)
Be real, copyright/attribution is only one complaint, a tiny part of the sudden hatred against AI art/creativity.

When somebody brings up the invention of photoshop, they're not trying to disprove a point about paying salaries to the devs, and I am sure you knew that.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by Quarrelsome on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:13AM (#34517840)
> Be real, copyright/attribution is only one complaint, a tiny part of the sudden hatred against AI art/creativity.

When the artists whose work was stolen to train these models are compensated for that work then maybe its a "tiny part". Until then it is taking peoples work and using it to create an ultimate competitor in their own market that they cannot compete with. They now have to compete against themselves and they haven't even been paid for that "privilege".

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:41AM (#34518106)
beautifully put
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by newswasboring on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @12:47PM (#34521555)
This kind of wording reminds me of a very old (probably outdated) argument about theft of digital goods. In meatspace when you steal something you are depriving someone of a thing. If I steal your biscuit, you don't have the biscuit. But if I copy a picture of the biscuit you are still left with your own picture, perfect and identical in every way. If I'm not reselling that image to everyone, you lost on that one sale. I wonder if openAI goes and pays retail price for each image they used, would this discussion finally end?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:19AM (#34517903)
No, your perspective on this is all wrong. The outrage about AI art is not about how it empowers its users.

Rather, the problem is that these systems only exists today because of the involuntary contributions of the very same people who are likely to be put out of business.

It really is about the how the contributors to these systems are being treated. The coders that contributed to Photoshop are analogous to the artists whose work was used to train these models. The difference between them is that the former gave their consent to the contribution, and the latter did not.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by scrollaway on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:15AM (#34518459)
So, my perspective on this is all wrong, despite the fact that the original poster wrote, pretty damn specifically, "Automating creativity is so gross. Never mind the fact that these models are trained on stolen artwork and texts."

That's it, that's the entire post. Never mind the "stolen artwork" argument, you still have people upset about "automating creativity".

So, like I said, it's one part of it.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:46AM (#34518823)
My mistake. Your perspective is not all wrong. You're just focusing on the wrong thing.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by oytis on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:45AM (#34519613)
This is a legit complaint, but is realistic to overcome in future I think. There have been reports of OpenAI hiring software engineers to train AI models to write code in their language. Can be done with art as well, just will take time. It's an impressive demonstration of what is achievable though.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by newswasboring on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @12:12PM (#34521010)
We are talking past each other. I am not talking about, and indeed am not interested in, the compensation discussion. I will let other people battle it out. I was just responding to calling automation of art gross. I don't know who you are talking to.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by nemo44x on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:13AM (#34517843)
It’s not gatekeeping to value the outcomes of work created this way less than you would from the mind of a human.

Saying that I agree with you in that I see this technology as a tool that can be used by humans to make amazing things. No one really has yet as the outputs have just been blunted, sloppy things. But if I’m an artist I see these tools as the latest tool to help make things.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by newswasboring on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @12:08PM (#34520946)
> It’s not gatekeeping to value the outcomes of work created this way less than you would from the mind of a human.

There is a difference between saying something is less than and calling it gross. Also, imho, value of art is usually the art not the process. Sometimes it is the process, like someone showing off a new method but that is of interest to very, very few people. Just like academic papers' methodology section. Even within the larger community, it's useful to only a few people. (Apart from just checking someone's work)

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by Jataman606 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:43AM (#34518123)
What is wrong with gatekeeping? It's not like everyone needs to be able to make art. Also, i don't know much about Photoshop, but most digitatl filters usually act the same as analog mixers. They do not automate anything.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by 5040 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:39AM (#34518745)
It's not like everyone needs to make photographic reproductions, why not delegate the task to photorealistic painters? Now that we've gotten used to the convenience of having a camera in our pocket, who would suggest banning photography?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by the_af on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:56PM (#34526820)
Most people don't make good photographic reproductions. They have mobiles with cameras, sure, but they cannot take an interesting or even technically good photo.

Good human photographers are still a thing. They can even get a job out of it! There are books about photos by photographers of renown.

AI automation here would be more like AI deciding which photos to take, and taking them for you, with your interaction limited to "take some nice photos of my vacation". Then some other AI could give likes to the photo, closing the loop so that humans need not be involved at all in that silliness of photography!

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by social_quotient on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:16AM (#34517356)
Don't take this as a trolling question, but I can't help but wonder if this sentiment towards AI generated art and creativity is similar to how a chef might feel about shrink wrapped frozen food factories. Just like how a frozen meal can be thrown in the microwave and still be considered a meal, AI generated art can still be considered creative and beautiful. But, as we all know, the timing and execution to properly deliver a "real meal" from a chef is far different than a frozen meal from a factory.

I find myself conflicted on this topic as I can see how the makers of yesterday have been replaced by process automation, taking away some of the magic of the creation process. But, just as a frozen meal from Costco has its place, so does AI generated art. The macro level ingredients may be the same, but the final product is different.

Before fast food, the number of chefs and home cooking would have had to be far higher and/or more frequent than now. Some would argue that we are paying the price for all that processed food now, but others would argue it's the only way to scale people's lives and their time.

I agree that something "feels" different about midjourney making artwork that I likely could never make myself, but I'm struggling to fully have a reason or complete reasoning for why. And then I wrestle with, is this a normal evolution problem? Just this time it hit something nearer to me personally and it impacts my life.

Would love to hear other's thoughts on this.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by jxf on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:20AM (#34517919)
I think there are important differences between this situation and your chef/frozen food analogy that cause it to break down:

* A digital image is permanent. A meal, by design, is consumed and has a very specific lifespan.

* A digital image is trivial to duplicate and consume again. A meal can be very hard to duplicate (and may even require another chef, or food scientists). No two people can consume exactly the same meal.

* A digital image is not required to survival. Regular intake of food and water is (at least for humans).

and so on.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by glofish on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:27AM (#34519328)
I think the whole food analogy is missing the main point we are not reusing someone else's food to create a new frozen food.

Frozen-ness is about mass production - but not about the origin of that food. It just conflates unrelated issues.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by Jataman606 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:36AM (#34518064)
Food is essential to our survival. No matter how much effort you put into making food, you have to make something to eat or you buy food that is cooked by someone else. So making it more accessible for people who don't have time, money or necessary skills has completely no downsides.

Art is just something we do and consume for fun. We don't need to make art more efficient, because there is already too much art to consume in a lifetime. Also there is no requirement to consume as much art as possible. And automating art making means that there will be even more average art that anyone interested will have to sift through to find something nice.

Overall all of this effort could be put into automating something that will make everyday life easier, like if you want to make art more accessible then for example automate translations so we can read books or watch movies that we previously couldn't.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by jkepler on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:32AM (#34518656)
Art is more necessary to survival than one might think. Consider the "Quartet for the End of Time,[1] an eight-movement piece of chamber music by the French composer Olivier Messiaen, written and first performed while he was a Nazi prisoner of war in 1941. And even when it comes to food, eating well involves creativity: arranging textures, colors, nutrition, etc. The French speak of l'art de la table, or the art of a well-served meal that encourages conviviality and conversation.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quatuor_pour_la_fin_du_temps

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by glofish on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:25AM (#34519305)
But it is not like that ... at all. Analogies run the risk of being completely wrong.

A frozen food is made of real food, the process all starts from scratch with "natural" ingredients (well ingredients).

The frozen food vs fresh cooked food is more like a film vs live acting. Or listening on tape vs a live concert. Even this analogy is lacking, a frozen food is made fresh at some point, it is about mass production not origin and ownership.

The frozen food is not food from your kitchen (or trashcan) remixed and added onto other people's plate.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by pixl97 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:06AM (#34519963)
Um, I'm pretty sure your analogy fell off the truck and got ran over at some point...

Trying to take the 'freshness' of food and compare it to storytelling is just an abject failure here as the vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaast majority of storytelling has no freshness at all, it's rehashing of the same basic plot elements, hell, was it the Greeks that stated this a few thousand years ago?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by glofish on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @12:03PM (#34520876)
you are conflating storytelling with the plot ... see how easy is to criticise analogies ...

there is/was plenty of fresh storytelling in every age

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by pixl97 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:02PM (#34521802)
And you're confusing the tall flowers from the field. Dime novels and pulp mags are a great example of this. You're remembering the good stuff because it's stuck around and the cheap, mass produced trashed ended up in a burn pile.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by epistemer on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @03:31PM (#34523763)
I have gone from using midjourney for hours a day in amazement to being completely sick of it and anything it outputs in less than a month.

I have seen hundreds of perfect variations on Duchamp's Fountain in my life too. AI Art is very much like Fountain variations without the human Duchamp involved. Then some AI Art fool extrapolating from that and believing Home Depot has an entire section dedicated to museum quality variations on Fountain.

The actual output is a very small aspect of the phenomena of "art".

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by tomp on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:33AM (#34517490)
At best you could claim “pirated”, definitely not “stolen”.

IMO piracy should be morally encouraged

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:09AM (#34517803)
Do you think it's moral for a big corporation to profit on pirating works from small artists?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by tomp on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:16AM (#34517871)
For-profit piracy is questionable (there’s pros and cons, it could unleash a ton of creativity) but what we’re discussing here is non-profit, personal use piracy.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by makoto12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @01:36PM (#34522304)
I'm more referring to the companies offering the tools. While some are free to use (for now), they are still profiting from this type of personal use. often being able to convert to a paid model later down the line, think github copilot
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by chinathrow on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:38AM (#34517532)
I hate it as well but at this point, I think the cat's out of the bag. I think it's unlikely that legislation will be able to curtail any copyright infringement.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by throwaway4aday on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:58AM (#34517706)
Wee Hear in Formed that you got Shear in mee sheens and if you Dont Pull them Down in a Forght Nights Time Wee will pull them Down for you Wee will you Damd infernold Dog. And Bee four Almighty God we will pull down all the Mills that heave Heany Shearing me Shens in We will cut out Hall your Damd Hearts as Do Keep them and We will meock the rest Heat them or else We will Searve them the Seam.

Sign the petition below:

Ned Ludd

----------------

----------------

----------------

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by grugagag on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:24AM (#34517950)
Did we really NEED automation for writing kids books?

And for whoever is saying not automating these is gatekeeping let me ask you gatekeeping from what? You could write a kids book yourself without AI if you put your mind to it. It’s a super easy feat.

Can we strive to automate more boring stuff such as scrum meetings, filling out forms and paperwork in general?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:46AM (#34518146)
This “gatekeeping” accusation is so stupid. It’s a laughable conclusion of the current woke/victimization culture. I have seen people on HN refer to the idea of needing sone kind skill to do something creative/difficult as “ableist”.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by batch12 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:30AM (#34518005)
As someone who is not that great at creating art, I like it. It enables me to build more things than I could before. I don't find it much different than a website builder is for people who lack those skills.

Thinking more deeply, I find that AI art has no real value to me, though. I wouldn't hang it on my walls or hope it survives for my kids. If I had written the algorithms that power the model, then I'd feel like more of a stakeholder and maybe I would see the output as something with long term value. To me it feels more like fast food. It fills the void, but it's nothing special-- it's disposable 'art'. But maybe that's just me.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by thfuran on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:42AM (#34518115)
Yeah, cameras are just the worst. Won't someone please think of the painters?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by gardenhedge on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:06AM (#34518353)
Kids books don't take much creativity
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by adamsmith143 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:49AM (#34519689)
>Automating creativity is so gross. Never mind the fact that these models are trained on stolen artwork and texts.

King of bad takes. Painters literally said the same thing about Photography.

>these models are trained on stolen artwork and texts.

And the neural networks in human artists' brains is exempt from this logic why? Because it's biological and not silicon?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by the_af on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:15PM (#34526927)
> Painters literally said the same thing about Photography.

I think this is itself a bad take, for several reasons.

First, that something false was said in the past doesn't make it false today for a different thing.

Second, that wasn't the argument painters "literally" used. Did they claim that taking photos was "stealing" their paintings/reality?

What some may have claimed is that it took no skill or that it was cheating, or that it would put painters out of work. We now know all of these assumptions were wrong.

Photography doesn't "automate" creativity, as anyone struggling to take an interesting photo that tells a story can tell you.