Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney
by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:04AM
(#34517762)
It may be a technical violation of an artist's copyright for someone else to make a stroke-for-stroke copy of their work for learning purposes, but if that copy is never sold or publicly exhibited, it would be difficult for the artist to take action against that person. If the copy is made purely for educational purposes, that might even fall under fair use in the US.
When a commercial AI model is created, however, there is no educational or scholarly purpose. Arguably, a new work is being created in the form of the weights that constitute the model, where those weights contain an encoding of whatever works are included in the training set. In other words, the model as a work incorporates any copyrighted work that was included in the training set.
Wikipedia has a rather extensive article on fair use. If you look at the factors determining whether the incorporation of one work into another work is fair use[0], it would seem tough to shoehorn training of a commercial AI model into fair use.
On a moral basis, though, if you believe that copyrighted works should only be used with permission with the exception of clearly-delineated fair use, it is hard for me to understand why well-funded AI companies should be able to profit from those works without first obtaining permission.
When a commercial AI model is created, however, there is no educational or scholarly purpose. Arguably, a new work is being created in the form of the weights that constitute the model, where those weights contain an encoding of whatever works are included in the training set. In other words, the model as a work incorporates any copyrighted work that was included in the training set.
Wikipedia has a rather extensive article on fair use. If you look at the factors determining whether the incorporation of one work into another work is fair use[0], it would seem tough to shoehorn training of a commercial AI model into fair use.
On a moral basis, though, if you believe that copyrighted works should only be used with permission with the exception of clearly-delineated fair use, it is hard for me to understand why well-funded AI companies should be able to profit from those works without first obtaining permission.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use#U.S._fair_use_factors