News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:05AM (#34516918)
If a person learns how to paint expertly by looking at (and even copying, stroke for stroke) paintings, would you consider that immoral, and those paintings having been stolen? If not, what would you say the difference is?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by infinitezest on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:32AM (#34517073)
There is the notable difference in the speed and scale at which a computer can be trained. The analogy doesn't really hold up in my opinion.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by neoromantique on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:22AM (#34517406)
So the analogy doesn't hold up because computer does it more efficiently?
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by jxf on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:24AM (#34517957)
That can be a valid reason to reject an analogy. For example, many people who would accept regular police patrols are not fine with the police installing a tireless ALPR scanner.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by neoromantique on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:53AM (#34518914)
Well, in police scanner example, problem people have with it is not its efficacy, but rather other surrounding concerns (like privacy).
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by throwaway4aday on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:02AM (#34517742)
So if there were a genius painter that learned various artistic styles on sight you would say that their work had no value?

I think you might be in trouble there, a number of savants have been known throughout history who have been able to learn various things with no instruction and simply by hearing or seeing a work done by someone else have been able to recreate it or produce something in their style.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:36AM (#34544259)
Being able to do something faster isn't automatically a moral principle. Even between two humans there will be big differences.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by adamauckland on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @06:47AM (#34517163)
Morality aside, an artist who entirely copies someone else's work would be looked down upon because they are not original or creating anything novel or new.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by pixl97 on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @11:11AM (#34520046)
So scribes were looked down upon in the middle ages for making copies of books before the printing press?

I think in the tech industry we get caught up on 'novel' and 'new' because duplication is cheap to the point of almost free.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by CatWChainsaw on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @05:56PM (#34525331)
Scribes were not authors. They were expected to copy. Bad faith.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:31AM (#34529567)
Morality is the only thing I'm querying here. No point changing the topic.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by wildrhythms on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @07:39AM (#34517543)
The difference is that a human made the artistic stroke-for-stroke reproduction through human skill and expertise. Even a counterfeit painting is an exercise of perception and interpretation. The value is in the human's hand in the output.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:51AM (#34518191)
That’s actually a good point. It is very much a non-trivial ability.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:32AM (#34529576)
Making a lump of silicon generate a painting is far less trivial. That's not relevant. Being trained on paintings was described as stealing, and unless your argument is that stealing is easy so anything non-trivial can't be stealing, I don't see the relevance.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by legutierr on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:04AM (#34517762)
It may be a technical violation of an artist's copyright for someone else to make a stroke-for-stroke copy of their work for learning purposes, but if that copy is never sold or publicly exhibited, it would be difficult for the artist to take action against that person. If the copy is made purely for educational purposes, that might even fall under fair use in the US.

When a commercial AI model is created, however, there is no educational or scholarly purpose. Arguably, a new work is being created in the form of the weights that constitute the model, where those weights contain an encoding of whatever works are included in the training set. In other words, the model as a work incorporates any copyrighted work that was included in the training set.

Wikipedia has a rather extensive article on fair use. If you look at the factors determining whether the incorporation of one work into another work is fair use[0], it would seem tough to shoehorn training of a commercial AI model into fair use.

On a moral basis, though, if you believe that copyrighted works should only be used with permission with the exception of clearly-delineated fair use, it is hard for me to understand why well-funded AI companies should be able to profit from those works without first obtaining permission.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use#U.S._fair_use_factors

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @08:49AM (#34518166)
This is kind of a tired reasoning. I don’t know what the goal of this kind of reasoning is. The fact is that virtually no one learns or dies art this way. No one in any statistically meaningful amount has a photographic memory and uses such memory to create new art stroke by stroke.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by shagie on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:45AM (#34518795)
There are many paintings that have been made following along to a Bob Ross video - using the same paints, the same brushes, and the same elements within the painting.

Even after following along and gaining the confidence to paint on their own, they continue to use the same approach to painting. Are those paintings afterwards derivative works and to be treated the same way as an AI painting asked to create a scene with certain elements in the stye of Bob Ross?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by dinkumthinkum on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @10:23PM (#34527355)
That is largely hobby painting and learning to paint. You’re conflating human skill to learn and adapt and go through a relaxing exercise to AI generated. It’s not a serious argument.
Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by robertlagrant on Thursday January 26, 2023 @04:34AM (#34529593)
> learn and adapt and go through a relaxing exercise

The AI is learning. Why is one of those things stealing and not the other?

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by shagie on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:01AM (#34532448)
My question is "what is a derivative work?" This is equally applicable to images generated for a hobby as it is for professionals. It applies to art generated with a paintbrush and canvas, on a painting app on a digital tablet, and as generated though an AI model.

The definition of a derivative work is agnostic to the means to create it. The final product is what is being evaluated.

If the answer is "but the Bob Ross paintings that are derivative works by amateurs are never sold and only hung at home - it would only be an issue if they sold them or tried to display them publicly as described https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/106 " - then I would agree.

If I create an image through any means - be it paint on canvas, stylus on tablet, or prompt and ML and don't violate 17 U.S. Code § 106 then there shouldn't be any issue.

If, however, I publish that image - again, no matter how it is created - then there is an issue. But it isn't the maker of the paints, or Adobe, or the creators of whatever ML model generated it. A program cannot hold a copyright and cannot itself create a derivative work. ( https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/us-copyright-offic... ) and so the issue of creating and publishing a derivative work is upon the human who did it - not the computer.

If you want to sue someone for publishing an image generated as "create a landscape of San Francisco in the style of Pixar" then have Pixar go after the person who published that image. It doesn't matter what process created that image.

Re:Show HN: I “wrote” a kids book with ChatGPT and Midjourney by the_af on Wednesday January 25, 2023 @09:06PM (#34526872)
Have you read "Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote" by Borges?

Part of the conceit of the story is that even a mechanical copy of a known work can become something else because of the inner experience of the person reproducing it. Menard's Quixote, his fictional author thought, was different because Menard knew things and lived through things that Cervantes before him didn't, and so the exact same words are injected of different connotations because of this.

It's absurd, but it explores something about authorship.

ChatGPT and AI have no inner lives, no authorial perspective, and so they cannot use this defense. In their case, a copy is truly "stolen" with no additional value.