News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:25PM (#34497817)
The problem with the 2000s-era Microsoft method, as I understand it, was that the population sizes they used were too small. Stack ranking was done at the individual team level, and that did indeed lead to people sabotaging each other, because in a team of 10 only 2 people could get the highest pay raises and 1 person would be placed on a PIP (or whatever the ratios were).

But yes, all major companies still do something like this AFAIK, just with a larger population size now. Speaking from my experience at Amazon, the target was around 4%, but this was across entire departments. My department was 300 people. Is it possible that you can have a department of 300 people where you can't find 12 people who are below-average performers? Yes. Is it likely? No.

I don't know how many people the lead in the article managed. If it was a team of 15, he has a legitimate gripe. If it was a team of 200, not so much.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by acdha on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:42PM (#34497956)
That’s one of the two but the bigger problem is how you measure performance. It’s notoriously hard to measure outside of the simplest jobs and once you tell people they’ll be punished unless they juice a particular number, well, that encourages all kinds of undesirable behaviour: rigging tickets or other metrics, encouraging people not to do maintenance programming or hard tasks, setting competitors up to fail, not doing things to help or train less experienced colleagues because that isn’t captured, etc.

Yes, managers are supposed to keep that from happening but this policy tells them that a) you don’t trust them to do their job, b) their job now focuses on protecting their people from the system, and c) being busy playing the same game on their own personal behalf.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:04PM (#34498136)
The way it was done at amzn was to get all managers for the department together in a room and provide information about each of their team members and why they were ranked the way they were. If an employee was doing a small number of hard tasks and providing a lot of mentorship it was quite the opposite, they were much more likely to get a "highly valued" ranking than be marked as a low performer. Obviously if you use stupid metrics like lines of code or story points closed you will get stupid results.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by wpietri on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:20PM (#34498272)
I just want to be clear here that what you describe is not anything approaching measurement, let alone measurement of performance.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:33PM (#34498383)
I mean I've never seen any performance "measurement" system that isn't just subjective review with another name. Objective metrics can be useful, and certainly could be a part of a manager's evaluation of an employment, but they never tell the whole story. Someone who closes out tons of tickets but is a complete asshole and hated by their teammates should get a worse performance review than someone who codes less but provides mentorship and guidance and is generally pleasant to work with.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by wpietri on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:35PM (#34498403)
Sure. But stack ranking is built on the fantasy of measurable individual performance.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by ilyt on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:02AM (#34499523)
That's the problem. The system wants to assign one number to performance and fire based on that yet even getting an approximation of that is hard

> Someone who closes out tons of tickets but is a complete asshole and hated by their teammates should get a worse performance review than someone who codes less but provides mentorship and guidance and is generally pleasant to work with.

They should get a talk with their manager about the attitude and if they don't fix it they should be fired; not wait for any ranking to cull them.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by acdha on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:11PM (#34498198)
How did they reconcile that with a hard quota? I can see that working with a degree of trust but not a fixed percentage.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:29PM (#34498356)
Largely you're still ranking your performers from top to bottom, so it's a matter of placing the line at the bottom in the right place to get the desired percentage. Even then there was still a lot of debate among department managers around people on the borderline least effective category. There were usually very clear outliers who were definitely LE (people clearly coasting, people who didn't show up to work regularly), and sometimes that was enough. Other times managers did have to push each other to be brutally honest about those who were borderline, essentially asking, "If you fired this person and got a replacement, would the replacement be more effective than the current person within 6 months?"

Keep in mind it was never a hard quota, though in my case at amzn I did have a few times where the GM (so manager of ~1500 org) pushed back and said not enough people were in LE for our department, in which case a few borderline people did unfortunately have to get put into LE.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by the_af on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:55PM (#34498556)
Sounds hellish.

Also seems to ignore these aren't replacement parts, these are your team mates or reports, actual humans with names and families attached. If they weren't coasting or not showing up for work, what you describe sounds like yet another alienating, dehumanizing process at work.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by oblio on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @06:57AM (#34502495)
Your company probably does it, too, they just don't tell you and they're small enough nobody cares.

Unless it's a super small company or you're the owner of your company.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by the_af on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @07:50AM (#34502945)
My company probably does something like it, true.

What's hellish is that the ranking is forced, you must put people on a PIP or rank them "low", which is absurd. Being told to meet a quota for low performers is bizarre.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by NhanH on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:57AM (#34500778)
How big is a department at amazon? In other words, how many managers are in that conversation and how big are their team size?
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by oblio on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @06:56AM (#34502483)
He said that before already:

> But yes, all major companies still do something like this AFAIK, just with a larger population size now. Speaking from my experience at Amazon, the target was around 4%, but this was across entire departments. My department was 300 people. Is it possible that you can have a department of 300 people where you can't find 12 people who are below-average performers? Yes. Is it likely? No.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by whatshisface on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:37PM (#34497906)
Who's the next 4% after you lay off the last 4%?
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by georgemcbay on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:52PM (#34498033)
Hopefully your hiring processes suck so you can keep refreshing a new batch of people to get fired!
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by yborg on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:07PM (#34498162)
Managers who have a solid team will deliberately hire a drone to sacrifice annually, and you can blame the hiring process for a long time.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:00PM (#34498103)
If you have a hiring process that results in only a 4% bad hire rate, create a business right now because every business in the world will want to pay you massive sums of money for the secret to such an amazing process.

from my own experience, a bad hire rate of 15-20% is what I usually see accepted across the industry.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by whatshisface on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:09PM (#34498180)
Let me check the math here...

20% of the 4% rehired is 1/5th%, leaving 3 and 4/5ths of a percent of to come from the better performers.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by mjr00 on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:14PM (#34498675)
You're incorrectly assuming 4% are let go, which is untrue as many are provided coaching/guidance to fix performance issues, and not accounting for additional headcount.
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by fatneckbeard on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:42PM (#34498451)
most Amazon departments lose money.

so whatever psychopath games they are playing, its not working.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by ilyt on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:03AM (#34499527)
Actually lose money or provide value to other departments that earn money ?
Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by ilyt on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:00AM (#34499506)
>Is it possible that you can have a department of 300 people where you can't find 12 people who are below-average performers? Yes. Is it likely? No.

I mean, below average performers will be around 40-60% just because how averages work.

The problem is that the question is "is their performance low compared to team", while the question you should be answering is "is their performance low compared to the market.

If team's management is on point with hiring the "worst" won't be that much worse than average anyway, so if you want to replace the bottom few % you essentially waste time as new hires might be at same productivity level.

On other side if you recruiting sucks and 20% of the dept does the 80% of the job, it isn't going to help either.

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by grayfaced on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:40AM (#34500211)
No manager has direct insight into performance of 300 people (at least in tech). They have to rely on subordinate managers/teamleads, each of which can be unreliable for different reasons. Some may be playing politics, some may just be bad managers. Some will overhype their employees, some will be honest to a fault. Get them all in a ranking board, and all sorts of games get played.

If your team leads could be trusted to measure appropriately, you wouldn't need stack rankings because they'd correctly identify those under-performing. Stack ranking is conceding that your managers can't properly measure performance. Shouldn't that reflect more on management?

Re:Blizzard fires WoW Classic lead after he protests employe... by RandallBrown on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:57AM (#34500780)
The stack ranking on my team at MS was done across a team closer to ~60 developers. Each manager managed 5 or 6 and then they would all get together and fight for their team members. It was insanely toxic. Not sure if every team was the same.