News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:23PM (#34497218)
Tipping is a system in which customers explicitly, optionally, and variably share some of the cost of labor. It has the features of allowing individual patrons to modulate the labor subsidy they provide, based on their current price sensitivity, the value they place on warm fuzzies (don't dismiss this!), the relationship they want to build with the business, and the service they perceive themselves to be getting.

You can't do all these things with prices; prices apply universally across customers, and for the most part in the hospitality industry they can't float (see airline tickets as an example of a floating price, and the sheer loathing it creates in the customer base).

Later

I also should have added, and probably led with, the fact that tipping addresses a big agent-principal problem in hospitality: in restaurants where servers rely on tips, their incentives are strongly aligned with those of customers; without tips, virtually all the incentives are aligned with that of management.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by godelski on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:32PM (#34497307)
I disagree with this. I'm reading your claim as "you should pay people so they become your friends." There's plenty of stores I've been regulars at that don't have a tipping system that I've become friendly with staff with. When I was a teenager and worked at movie theaters I became friendly with many regulars and tipping doesn't exist there. The warm fuzzies come from social interaction, face recognition, and being rememberable through your good/frequent business and friendliness. It feels wrong to suggest we should be buying them. That would just be confirming the bribery/feudal aspect of the system. I also don't think this helps those working non-tipped based jobs.

I don't want to abolish tipping, but instead I want to raise the minimum wage, make prices transparent (I am also a proponent of including tax in price listings), and making not tipping socially acceptable. If we have to supplement wages with tips then our economic system is broken (and akin to feudalism). If you want to provide an extra reward or explicitly bribe an employee for faster/better service (or to flex your wealth), I have no qualms.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:35PM (#34497344)
When I pay people to perform services for me, I don't operate under the illusion that we've become friends. I go to my favorite restaurant in Chicago and get brought a couple dishes on the house as soon as we're seated --- that's not because we're friends, it's because I've built a business relationship with the restaurant (and its servers). It's exactly the same dynamic as exists for airline customers who pay up for the airline lounge.

That relationship with the servers, by the way, also has a name: it's a principal-agent problem. Servers have competing incentives: to serve the interests of customers (better service) or the business (reduce ongoing costs). Tipping shifts the incentives around. You could attempt that shift with other mechanisms, like after-dinner surveys, but you know how well that'd work.

It costs time, effort, and money to provide better service, so I'm not from where you get the moral dimension of having to buy them. They have a cost; of course you have to buy them.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Volundr on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:51PM (#34497485)
> It costs time, effort, and money to provide better service, so I'm not from where you get the moral dimension of having to buy them. They have a cost; of course you have to buy them.

It's an odd industry where you perform a service, then hope your customer decides to pay you for it.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:40PM (#34497940)
Variable compensation is widespread across all sorts of industries; tipping is just one (limited) flavor of it.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Volundr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:38PM (#34499344)
What other industries let the customer decide after the fact what (or if) they will pay for the service?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:40PM (#34499359)
Babysitting.

(Obviously, you don't decide if you're going to pay for restaurant service; you decide only whether you're going to hold up your end of a cost sharing deal.)

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lotsofpulp on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:52PM (#34499446)
What? I have not heard of a babysitter agree to babysit without also agreeing on a price beforehand. Where does this happen?

I definitely would not trust my kids with someone willing to accept that deal.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#34499535)
You generally tip babysitters (especially if you want them to be available in the future).
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:05AM (#34499543)
> Babysitting.

Not generally.

> Obviously, you don't decide if you're going to pay for restaurant service; you decide only whether you're going to hold up your end of a cost sharing deal.

Tipping is not a “deal” that you have committed to, by definition.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by watwut on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @03:30AM (#34501019)
No? The price for babysitting is always agreed up front. At least, I never seen anyone babysit or have babysitter without price being clear.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Kagerjay on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:02AM (#34500380)
Massages too (massage envy)

The tipping there is kind of stupid since they tip at the base cost of the massage even if you get a discount for the membership.

Probably going to cancel it given how expensive it's getting

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Analemma_ on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:04PM (#34499069)
As the meme goes, "that's a nice hypothesis you've got there. Be a shame if someone were to test it". If tipping fixes a supposed incentive problem that exists with tip-free service, than restaurant service should be better in North America than anywhere else in the world. Is it? Empirically, no. And even locally there is no gain from tipping: Seattle has several tip-free restaurants and the service is indistinguishable from the rest of them.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by qnr on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:30AM (#34500165)
I consider obligatory 20% tipping as that weird American thing along with guns and (absence of) healthcare. People have elaborate arguments and discussions about them, and the side in favor can look very rational and plausible, and their hypotheses can even have a lot of explanatory power, but they are easily refuted by looking at basically every other developed country.

I travel a lot and eat out a lot and I haven't noticed any discernible difference in service between the countries with obligatory, optional and prohibited tipping.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by drstewart on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:37AM (#34500603)
That's interesting you consider tipping an American thing, I'm guessing you aren't very well traveled as you clearly haven't been to Canada or the Middle East.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by verall on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @01:50AM (#34500281)
There are certainly places without tipping, with much worse and much better service than America. Why? It's cultural (duh). And in American culture, you tip mechanically if you can afford it and your experience wasn't notably incredible or terrible.

In some places, it is acceptable to raise your hand and call for service. In other places it is not. If you know that it not acceptable, and you do it anyways, you're sort of an asshole. It's the same with tipping. You're not some iconoclast who will personally change the culture.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lxgr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:08PM (#34499107)
> Servers have competing incentives: to serve the interests of customers (better service) or the business (reduce ongoing costs). Tipping shifts the incentives around.

If that were true, we'd empirically be able to observe better service in countries with a tipping culture than in those without.

In my experience, that is not the case at all.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:16PM (#34499170)
I don't want to start a nationalist flame war here, but: you and I should agree to disagree on this one. (Austria was lovely, though, from one end to the other.)

It is not, for what it's worth, my contention that tipping is the only way restaurants can work, or even the best one; only that it is a rational system.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lxgr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:26PM (#34499257)
> [...] it is a rational system.

I don't disagree on that, and I can see both how it developed and why some people prefer it.

But as a participant in interactions where tipping is expected, I very subjectively find it somewhat exhausting. I'd happily pay more, on average, and be rid of the (albeit small) decision each time.

> Austria was lovely, though, from one end to the other.

What gave me away? :) I'm glad you enjoyed it, and I hope you did tip – contrary to what some guide books say about Germany and Austria, tips are very much expected, although at a different percentage than in the US. (Coffee house waitstaff in the latter being rude is to be expected regardless of your tip rate – supposedly it's part of the charm.)

Regarding my experience with non-tip cultures, these are mostly limited to a few countries in Asia (where waitstaff will at least anecdotally follow you onto the street, returning your tip/accidental overpayment).

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:33PM (#34499307)
Nothing gave you away: Austria (particularly Vienna, but also Salzburg) were simply the examples that jumped out of my mind as the best service experiences I had in Europe. We tip everywhere, even when it marks us as obnoxious Americans; we're well (over)trained by our culture. :)

What you're saying here, about tipping being exhausting: I don't deny that at all. I can absolutely understand the preference against it. And: Japan is a good counterexample: very good service culture, no tipping.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Larrikin on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:27PM (#34497245)
The existence of restaurants, barber shops, delivery services, all over the world in first world and developing countries indicates it's possible to run a business successfully without relying on charity or variable pricing models.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by godelski on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:34PM (#34497323)
To specifically counter Tp's claims, I think we should note that these services also have plenty of friendly relationships between employees and customers.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:40PM (#34497393)
That's explicitly part of the idea.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:29PM (#34497259)
Cost sharing isn't charity.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Larrikin on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:34PM (#34497331)
A business that can't stay open when consumers pay the price for their services or goods is absolutely relying on charity donations to stay open.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:38PM (#34497365)
I don't follow. When you pay for a meal with the tip, you are paying the price for the services and goods.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Larrikin on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:45PM (#34497437)
When I pay for a meal in Japan (often times with better, fresher ingredients, and prepared with more care) I pay for the meal and the service without a tip. It is the norm all over the world.

What makes the US so special that we have to provide charity on top of the price of the meal.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:47PM (#34497451)
As has been explained repeatedly, you're not providing charity; you are sharing some of the restaurant's labor cost. When you refuse to tip, you aren't withholding charity; you're refusing payment.

Why does Japan do this differently? Japan is a different place.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Zxian on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:09PM (#34497673)
The business transaction between me and a restaurant is for the food and service they provide. I pay the restaurant, the restaurant pays the labour.

Refusing to tip isn't refusing payment. If it were, I'd be illegal (i.e. theft). Labelling this as "sharing the labour cost" is precisely the problem at hand.

If I hand my pizza delivery driver a $5 bill, I intend it to be a bonus for the driver, not a subsidy for the business. I have zero incentive to pay the business any more than the prices they advertise.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:42PM (#34497953)
No, in an American restaurant, the business transaction is between you, the restaurant, and your server. You are explicitly given permission to refuse (extra) payment to your server, and the restaurant (to a limited extent) backstops that risk for the employee. You're going to have bad relationships (and experiences) with American restaurants if you make a habit of undertipping.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by vuln on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:39PM (#34498864)
In an American retail or grocery store is my business transaction between me, the store and the cashier?

What's the difference between a server and a cashier? One walks between point a and b instead of standing in place? How much should I tip a cashier; 20% of the cost of my groceries?

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:40PM (#34498873)
No, grocery stores aren't restaurants. The difference is restaurants elect to establish different terms.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by vuln on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:15PM (#34499160)
If my grocery store has a hot bar of to go food that is packaged by the employee and handed to me to eat on their patio or take home. Should I tip that employee? If they worked at a restaurant they would tipped. My point is the waiter chooses to take less pay in hope of a tip, while the grocery store employee would rather know what their check is going to be and have stable reliable verifiable income. Wait staff don't have that. They make $0 on paper, they take the risk to avoid taxes, while the grocery store employee pays their "fair" share of taxes and social programs. While the waitstaff complains about tips and not earning a living wage.

Complaining about a job they chose when there is a multitude of jobs that you know exactly what you're getting paid based on your hours.

All this being said I do tip. I don't mind it. I find it hilarious when they spin the iPad around around to "answer a few questions" ie "please please tip me, I'm not gonna look or judge you but I am going to look and judge you and most likely passive aggressively spell and say your name wrong to show you why you should tip better!!"

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:18PM (#34499184)
Does the point of sale system ask for a tip? Is there a check with a tip line on it that you sign? Is there a prominent tip jar? Then: tip (or do business elsewhere). Else: don't.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:06AM (#34500409)
You're missing the point. The existence of that line or that jar will change whether tipping exists, even though your relationship with that person hasn't changed at all.

So maybe it's not really a three way relationship in any of these situations.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by molotovh on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:42PM (#34498452)
You're absolutely correct regarding tips being a "subsidy for the business". The reason "tipped minimum wage" (where it exists) is lower than actual minimum wage is because the business claims a "tip credit" towards meeting their minimum wage obligation. They're essentially telling the government "this person will make up the difference (or more) in tips, and that will meet our legal obligation to pay the minimum wage."

In most jurisdictions, this is figured by taking the employee's wages plus reported tips for each pay period and dividing them by the employee's clocked hours for that pay period. If that result is not at least actual minimum wage, the employer normally owes the employee the difference.

I don't know if it's a lack of knowledge or actual malicious pay practices (probably some of both), but number of people I meet in the service industry who don't know that last bit and tell me they've never been paid the difference for "dead" shifts (those that generate little to no tips) is staggering.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by godelski on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:53PM (#34498978)
> I don't know if it's a lack of knowledge or actual malicious pay practices (probably some of both), but number of people I meet in the service industry who don't know that last bit and tell me they've never been paid the difference for "dead" shifts (those that generate little to no tips) is staggering.

That's because wage theft is relatively common among the service industry and is also why several states outlawed special wage. You can probably imagine how easy it is to perform wage theft in this situation simply because how difficult accurately calculating that differential is. You're basically relying on every single person to act in good faith in an environment where every person has large incentives to act in bad faith (employers can easily get away with not paying and employees can easily pocket tips and not report them. One of these, or just the perception of, can create a coupled feedback loop with the other).

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @02:03AM (#34500394)
It is when it's optional. Charity with a guilt trip.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by notfromhere on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:26PM (#34497241)
Except many other industries don't have tipping and the price of labor is just built into the cost.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by detaro on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:27PM (#34497248)
That's not a counter to anything tptacek listed?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by notfromhere on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:36PM (#34497347)
You can take it the other way and tip literally every profession.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:39PM (#34497376)
You can. It's a system that makes more sense for some occupations and less for others, but plenty of occupations besides hospitality are routinely tipped. You tip your hotel housekeepers, don't you?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lotsofpulp on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:54PM (#34499457)
Why would you assume that? When I worked as a housekeeper, few left tips. And I do not see why they would need to.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#34499529)
Excuse me, in what way are hotel housekeepers not in hospitality industry?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by notfromhere on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @03:14PM (#34509576)
Why not just pay people their wage rather than ask customers to decide if that person is worthy of making money today
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by ot on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:54PM (#34497517)
Those same arguments apply to several other professions where it is not customary to tip. The reality is that tips are expected only for the lower social/economic classes, where it is acceptable that the price for labor is set based on the whims of the customer instead of being pre-agreed (which, personally, I find degrading).

Right-leaning people like it because it creates a power dynamic. Left-leaning people like it because they delude themselves that they're helping the working class. In both cases, it boils down to paternalism, and all other reasons are rationalization.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @08:41PM (#34497949)
It's true that you can run any industry without tipping, but that's not really saying anything interesting, because you also demonstrably can run industries with tipping. I don't like tipping for the power dynamic or because I'm "helping the working class"; I just get the logic of it, and am fine playing along.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by godelski on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:46PM (#34498918)
It's true that you can run any industry with tipping, but that's not really saying anything interesting, because you also demonstrably can run industries without tipping. I like tipping for the power dynamic and because I'm "helping the working class"; I get the logic of it, and am fine playing along.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:01PM (#34499048)
I don't claim there's anything interesting about observing that tipping exists; it obviously does, and is a system that has been functioning in America for generations.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by godelski on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:18PM (#34499187)
The issue is that you're vehemently defending this practice. As far as I can tell the only reason for this is simply because of momentum. None of the arguments you are making really make much sense. There's strong evidence to the contrary in fact. Not only is the practice particularly unique to America (and Canada), but the practice and laws defending it just enable wage theft (employers not paying minimum wages by claiming tip credits that don't exist). The practice was developed during feudalism and was a form of oppression. The current practice also divides the working class and prevents them from working together in a larger coalition advocating for a larger minimum wage. No one here is really against the concept of tipping, but people are upset about its expansion and that the practice is essentially required. You have said that the money is optional, but we all know that this isn't exactly true. Technically/legally yes, but in practice this doesn't work out. People aren't tipping for service, they are tipping to avoid bad service (as many have said here) and to avoid social stigma from their peers. This is not the system you have laid out in your many comments, this is just a convoluted form of class oppression and wage theft. Sometimes we need to reevaluate things we've been doing just for the sake of doing. Momentum is not a reason to continue a harmful practice.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:21PM (#34499202)
The issue is that we disagree. I don't think vehemence enters into it. The appeal to feudalism isn't persuasive; all sorts of things are traceable back to feudalism (something about feudalism being a pit stop most of our cultures took at some point), and not all of them are bad.

People shouldn't "tip for service". That's not how tips work. Tip mechanically: at a restaurant, divide by 10 and double (keep it simple include the drinks in the tab). If you're sitting there stewing about whether you achieved the requisite level of service, you're the feudalist.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lxgr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:17PM (#34499179)
Is it on a good track to continue existing, though?

TFA is specifically describing how the kind and number of situations in which a tip is expected/asked for (if only by a payment terminal interface) is rapidly expanding – and if every service is tipped, no service is tipped.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:19PM (#34499188)
I don't follow your logic. If every service has an element of optional, variable, explicit customer sharing of labor costs, no service does?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lxgr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:30PM (#34499284)
A tipping decision is a decision in the end, which are drawing from a limited mental resource, according to some research. The way in which our mind typically handles repeatedly having to decide is by developing some simple heuristics and effectively running on autopilot most of the time, following them mechanically.

I could imagine a not too distant future in which tipping evolves into a quasi-fixed-rate quasi-tax, with only exceptional or atrocious service warranting a deviation from a cemented social norm.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:36PM (#34499334)
What you describe in your last sentence is, I think, exactly how restaurant tipping works. It's best to look at it as a 15% labor tax, with an optional 5-10% upcharge if you're happy (or have a general policy of retaining a reputation as a good tipper).

Another similar example (probably outdated): airport skycaps.

An example of a tipping system in America that doesn't work that way (yet) is hotel housekeeping; a surprising number of people don't even know that there's a tipping custom there at all.

The "quasi tax" thing sounds alarming, but it doesn't bother me at all; it's just another way of expressing costs and prices. Things will cost what they cost one way or the other. If tipping becomes so common that everything has 5-15% tacked onto it (I doubt it'll happen, but we'll stipulate), base prices will fall. Businesses can't simply banish demand curves! There is ultimately a market clearing price.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lxgr on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:41PM (#34499368)
> [...] a 15% labor tax, with an optional 5-10% upcharge if you're happy [...]

Ah, yes, that is in fact almost exactly my mental model for how to tip in restaurants or cafes (albeit with a conversion factor to the rate I was socialized with).

What always blindsides me is tipping in a place I (or even some locals, apparently?) don't expect it. And generally speaking, I much prefer taking social cues from local friends or other patrons than from a device.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by ot on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:56PM (#34499009)
You're fine playing along because you're on the winning side of the deal.

Say you were a software contractor, would you be ok with working for a customer based only on an "expected price range" with a 4x spread, over which the customer has complete unilateral discretion, decided only after the work has been completed?

If your first instinct is "that's different", I'd like to know how.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:00PM (#34499042)
In what way am I on the winning side of this deal, and how might I find myself on the losing side of it? If you're thinking that I'm beating out the people who can't afford to tip, you should bear in mind that the abolition of tipping would mechanically imply prices raising across the board to the average level of the previous tipping. TANSTAAFL.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by ot on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:07PM (#34499093)
> how might I find myself on the losing side of it?

Like I mentioned above, by having your livelihood depend on the whims of customers that may be offended by not having been treated with sufficient deference.

> abolition of tipping would mechanically imply prices raising across the board to the average level of the previous tipping. TANSTAAFL.

Quite the strawman, I never claimed tipping is extra cost, I just find the practice degrading. I would be very much in favor of bundling all costs in the displayed prices, like it happens in the rest of the world.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:10PM (#34499125)
Most people's livelihoods depend to some extent on other people's whims. I tip mechanically, and think everybody else should too: as I said, it's a cost sharing mechanism. Part of the problem I think nerds like us have with tipping is that they think it's something they have to figure out, like a Yelp star rating. No: just divide by 10 and double, end of story.

I'll go you one further and candidly tell you that what I perceive lurking in the subtext of HN's biannual tipping freakout is the frustration some nerds have that they don't get to inflict their whims on American servers, because their tips are expected to be automatic. They feel ripped off by the expectation. That's the fucked up belief, right there.

You can feel free to ask one of your server friends how degraded they feel by your tips. I think you'll be surprised.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by ot on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:21PM (#34499203)
This thread is surreal. You started with "Tipping is a system in which customers explicitly, optionally, and variably share some of the cost of labor.", and now we got to no, actually, there is no optionality or variability, why would you want there to be any?

So we're back to tipping being just a way to artificially display lower prices on the menu and enjoy the psychological deception?

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:24PM (#34499234)
You have the option of not tipping mechanically; you might, for instance, find it acceptable to subject working class people to your whims about the quality of your service. I do not. Regardless, generally speaking, you are socially expected to tip at least 15% any time you dine out at a full service restaurant in America.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by watwut on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @03:34AM (#34501054)
> Regardless, generally speaking, you are socially expected to tip at least 15% any time you dine out at a full service restaurant in America.

Then it amounts to psychological trick to make prices artificial seem lower. With added bonus of being able to bad faith argue "it was your choice".

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:50PM (#34499431)
I read about a study that found that the most pro-tip group of people are older men ... that is the way to buy love for them.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by runnerup on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:33PM (#34498388)
> I also should have added, and probably led with, the fact that tipping addresses a big agent-principal problem in hospitality: in restaurants where servers rely on tips, their incentives are strongly aligned with those of customers; without tips, virtually all the incentives are aligned with that of management.

Very astute of you to mention this, though “address” and “cause” could be used interchangeably.

When I was a bartender it was always in my interest to give away free alcohol to my highest tipping customers, who generally understood that it’s customary to add 50% of the cost they would have paid to their tip for each free drink.

At a very surface level, the tipping system incentivizes employees to steal product from the business to give to customers. But the game theory gets very complicated. Sometimes this results in a great customer base that forms the core of a “social engine” that powers the popularity of a bar/restaurant and results in a win-win-win. Bar owners set various levels/thresholds/criteria for how much free sample can be given out and under what circumstances.

Tl;dr: the principal-agent problem can almost never be solved to align all parties in a system.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by alluro2 on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:57PM (#34499014)
Friendliness or a general level of service is in a lot of industries considered a competitive factor that contributes to increased customer lifetime value through repeat sales, loyalty etc.

Why should the restaurants be any different? If I like the food and the service, I'll want to come again - the restaurant increases their earnings that way and both I and the business are happy.

The question then again comes down to how is that an incentive for the workers. The obvious answer is that their pay should be linked to the earnings of the business. The fact that it is not shows the fundamental problem with current state of capitalism, where the primary goal is to exploit the work of the workers below your financial level (as a business owner) and increase your wealth based on the ever-increasing difference between costs / wages and revenue.

The incentive of business is in conflict with incentive of workers, and the interest of customers - business will be motivated to use the workers willing to work for less, count tips towards salaries, but also use lower quality/cost ingredients etc.

A system where the worker salaries would be linked to revenue, with some nuance of course, would ensure top quality / service / products for the customers, fair reward and aligned incentives for the workers, and access to top tier employees (since they would want to work for businesses with higher revenue), happy customers and increased revenue to the business.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:05PM (#34499073)
People keep asking "why should American restaurants be different?"

The answer is simple: because they choose to set these terms.

Restaurants are far from the most idiosyncratic businesses customers interact with. Buy a plane ticket sometime! Different businesses have different pricing structures.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lotsofpulp on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:00AM (#34499501)
They did not set the terms.

There is no clear disclosure that you will need to pay more than the listed prices to get your food as you should.

Also, if you go to a counter service business, and the point of sale system asks you to tip, again, the terms were not set prior to engaging in the transaction.

In another comment, you write:

> You're going to have bad relationships (and experiences) with American restaurants if you make a habit of undertipping.

I classify this as the restaurant (and waiter) violating the terms. You do not get to claim your prices are low and then spring and increase on people, even if it is a “cultural” norm.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:08AM (#34499572)
Did you see that sign "Welcome to the United States" when arriving at the airport? That was the clear disclosure that from this point on, every restaurant price is [menu price] * 1.3. Just keep that in mind when ordering.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by lotsofpulp on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:11AM (#34499597)
No, that sign is clear disclosure that you are being welcomed to the United States.

Even if we assume the person is familiar with American culture, it is only restaurants with wait service having prices times 1.3 (including sales tax).

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @12:17AM (#34499655)
Everyone knows that in the US, price = menu price + tip + tax. "Everyone knows" is enough of a disclosure.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by getoffmyyawn on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @10:57AM (#34505222)
That's nonsense. If that were true, not tipping in an American restaurant would give the owner the right to take me to small claims court to recover the missing tip. Do you really think simply stating that "everyone knows" would convince a judge to rule in the restaurant's favor?
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday January 29, 2023 @09:44AM (#34568549)
No, but you are very likely to be publicly humiliated, bodily fluids been added to your dishes should you dare to visit that restaurant another time, and yes, there were cases when police was called on account of insufficient tips.
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by maerF0x0 on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:12PM (#34499138)
It also allows game players to simply avoid tipping entirely, thereby getting a much cheaper set of good across all of the places that take tips.

Reinvest the savings and get rich off the stupidity of the system. Belligerence seems to be the only way to fix the system.

Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by tptacek on Monday January 23, 2023 @11:15PM (#34499157)
Re:Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes by mixmastamyk on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @03:12AM (#34500880)
And managment should be aligned on happy customers if they want to stay in business for long. Maybe I'm missing something else.