News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by nfcampos on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:47PM (#34443939)
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by metacritic12 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:03PM (#34444158)
It seems like this follow up paper clarifies the data's vision a lot more. Notable changes from the previous version discussed in a sister thread here:

- There is no more emphasis on price-only-inflation-adjusted returns. Good riddance: getting rid of dividends makes no sense and is borderline intellectually dishonest just to make the point.

- He no longer argues stocks don't work for the long run, just that bonds were as good in the past. This is a lower bar to meet as bonds in the past, especially corporate bonds as he's included, are actually quite risky!

- Finally there is some argument to be made that bonds are better investments when monitoring technology is poor -- since insiders can steal equityholders' wealth. But the 20th century invented good accounting, auditing, etc to reduce that and drive up equity returns.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by dot1x on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:07PM (#34444222)
> getting rid of dividends makes no sense and is borderline intellectually dishonest just to make the point

How so? Once you retire, you don't let dividends reinvest. Makes perfect sense.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:14PM (#34444328)
You should be taking money out at your chosen rate, not depending on how those companies choose to allocate money between dividends vs. buybacks vs. cash piles vs. reinvestment. So treating dividends as reinvested by default makes sense to me.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by metacritic12 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:21PM (#34444393)
Exactly -- dividends and share buybacks are nearly the same, but the original paper stripped out the first.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:23PM (#34444420)
Why would you exclude part of the total return on an investment? It'd be like ignoring the principal value of a bond because you expect to live on the coupon. Cashflows are cashflows.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by dot1x on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:47PM (#34444698)
Because you'd be selling it as you earn it to be able to live on on retirement. In fact, dividends wouldn't even be enough.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ikiris on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:55PM (#34444807)
but they still exist and can be a large fraction of the value...
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by hartator on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:28PM (#34444491)
> Once you retire, you don't let dividends reinvest. Makes perfect sense.

You don't let interests from bonds reinvest as well then.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by danuker on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:22PM (#34444412)
Dividends aren't enough to cover living expenses.

If you plan to withdraw 4% per year, so you preserve your wealth indefinitely, you're more than 2 percentage points short when the dividend yield is 1.71% [1]

If you want to live solely from dividends, you'll need more than double the capital.

If you want to die with zero [2], it's impossible.

I'd much rather invest in a dividend-accumulating index fund and sell as I please.

[1] - https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-dividend-yield

[2] - https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/52950915-die-with-zero

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by dot1x on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:46PM (#34444681)
Seems like you agree returns would be even worse since you'd take out more than the dividend to survive.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:56PM (#34444809)
Once you start selling off your assets, the """returns""" are worse, but equally so no matter what you invested in. It's better to leave that math out of the situation and look at the returns of the actual assets by themselves. Which includes reinvesting.

If you really want to factor in the sell-off, then every dollar of dividend means one less dollar of sold stock. If dividends go higher than withdrawals for a year, then you need to buy more stock to compensate. So the math comes out the same. What you don't do is ignore dividends, or let excess dividends pile up in cash form. Which the original paper apparently did.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:33PM (#34445229)
You can absolutely die with zero: buy a life annuity and let someone else worry about the problem.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ghaff on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:08PM (#34445638)
I think parent is saying that you can't die with zero if you plan to live off dividends. (Because you need to keep owning the stock throwing off the dividends.)
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:19PM (#34445748)
OK sure; same's true of bonds or CDs or any other asset type though no? The point is that "invest in equities with dividend reinvestment until retirement and then buy a life annuity" is a totally viable strategy. That's basically the way pension saving in the UK works historically, for example.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ghaff on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:39PM (#34445991)
Right. Life annuities may or may not be a good deal. But that's certainly the main way to not be essentially forced to pass on assets. (Modulo real estate you own and are living in.) And, as you say, defined benefit pensions basically work the same way--although, in the US, current ones are fairly uncommon outside public sector--although a lot of people still have them from years past.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:40PM (#34446016)
In the UK this is actually the typical pattern for defined-contribution schemes; I haven't looked recently but it used to be the case that you were legally required to buy an annuity with 75% of your tax-deferred retirement savings.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ghaff on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:49PM (#34446123)
Interesting. I'm not sure how common annuities outside of defined benefit pensions are in the US. My impression is not very.

I've noticed them mostly in the form of charitable trusts (which can offer the benefit of basically shielding large asset gains from taxation). But it doesn't seem to be a widely-used investment strategy in general. Maybe it's more common if someone doesn't have an interest in passing down any money.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by rgmerk on Thursday January 19, 2023 @09:11PM (#34448359)
You’re not required to any more, but there are heaps of people on annuities there.

I haven’t read anything about it yet but a lot of them must be in pretty awkward straits because most aren’t fully indexed to inflation…

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by gpderetta on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:11AM (#34451494)
The rules were changed some time ago; also buying an annuity hasn't been worth it for a while.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by 8note on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:58PM (#34446248)
I'd expect a good portion of deaths involve very expensive health care for the last few months or years of life.

Live off dividends, then sell to pay for the healthcare right before you die

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by rgmerk on Thursday January 19, 2023 @09:28PM (#34448469)
In the US.

In most other developed countries a) healthcare is funded by the government (to a first approximation). b) end-of-life healthcare expenditure is considerably lower outside the US.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ghaff on Friday January 20, 2023 @09:07AM (#34453302)
And Medicare for those 65 and older in the US is funded by the government.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by gkuan on Thursday January 19, 2023 @08:26PM (#34448050)
It may be hard to imagine, but dividend yields were not always this low [1]. Investopedia has it usually something healthy over 4% up until 1990s it seems. Over that 1926- time frame, dividends are said to have contributed 32% of the total return of S&P 500 [2].

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/071616/history...

[2] https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/research/article/a-fundame...

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by user_named on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:24AM (#34450102)
US stocks are arguably overpriced leading to low dividend yields. In emerging markets you easily get 5-7%.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by whall6 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:13PM (#34444304)
There are enough “cash cow” securities that maintain a same / similar share price by distributing heavily for this to make sense. The price wouldn’t show the whole story and the cash could go much further over 100 years than just sitting in a bank account.

I don’t know many people that spend 100 years in retirement.

Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by danielmarkbruce on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:04PM (#34444909)
It's not a chart of "how much money does Jonny have".
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by coliveira on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:17PM (#34445045)
Removing dividend does make sense because dividends are taxed. You cannot reinvest all dividends, unless you're using a tax advantaged account.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:26PM (#34445152)
So are bond coupons, and (within the current regime) at a disadvantageous rate relative to dividends!
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by lexapro on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:48PM (#34445397)
Price increases are taxed as well (eventually), do you also remove them?
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by fshbbdssbbgdd on Thursday January 19, 2023 @05:08PM (#34446352)
Stepped-up basis takes care of that. Buy, borrow, die!
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by MichaelDickens on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:23PM (#34445795)
This might justify discounting dividends (eg reducing them by 20%), but not removing them entirely.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by nwiswell on Thursday January 19, 2023 @07:19PM (#34447548)
Moreover the more modern approach is share repurchases, which are largely not subject to the tax drag and use the same money that was used historically for dividends.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 19, 2023 @09:27PM (#34448458)
It is worth noting that until 1982, stock buybacks were illegal—deemed as market manipulation
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by joshlemer on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:52AM (#34449702)
And since a few years ago they are highly taxed in Canada.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by coliveira on Friday January 20, 2023 @08:14AM (#34452670)
It is still market manipulation, but made legal by the US gov, like other crimes such as lobbying.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by xwolfi on Thursday January 19, 2023 @08:22PM (#34448014)
Dividends aren't taxed where I am, and it skews our investment, even towards US stocks. I find it interesting to include.
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by gbasin on Friday January 20, 2023 @10:09AM (#34454097)
The 3rd one is interesting and something I hadn't considered as much before — may be applicable still in less regulated markets
Re:Stock Market Charts You Never Saw by danuker on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:17PM (#34444352)
Data is available as a spreadsheet here: https://www.edwardfmcquarrie.com/?p=579