In general, when you run a for-profit company, the board has a responsibility to the shareholders to not hurt them financially. A nonprofit doesn't have these constraints - who would they be hurting? So if a nonprofit wants to do some weird financial transaction, and the board all agrees, they can usually just do it.
For example, a nonprofit can agree to sell its assets in a complicated deal, and there is no real "external review" of this. So, you could create a for-profit subsidiary that is wholly owned, and then sell off some or all of its stock to a new group of investors. Or create different types of stock, capped or noncapped or preferred or unpreferred or whatever, and allocate different amounts of that to different groups.
In particular, as long as both OpenAI leadership and the leadership of OpenAI's nonprofit parent firm (which are the same people, maybe?) agrees to this round of Microsoft investment, they can probably rewrite the terms in any way they want. Including in such a way that leaves the ownership being 49% Microsoft, 49% other investors, 2% nonprofit parent.
OpenAI leadership and the leadership of OpenAI's nonprofit parent firm (which are the same people, maybe?)
exposing the burried lede :)But there's no ill intent. As long as it's not labeled as human. I guess it applies to everything, even sentient AIs, that it's fair as long as they don't promise services of a human.
I’d worry standardizing would negatively impact this.
If you would let the CCS consortium design a megawatt charger like Tesla‘s V4, mere mortals would probably not even able to lift it.
Only actions matter.
They pulled researchers into their own org and out of FAANG which I think was part of the motivation. They pitched it as open to the public, but I'm not sure that's what it was.
I think opinions also changed because of goal alignment and AGI safety ideas becoming better understood.
You don't know what you're talking about. OpenAI has done a lot of self publishing/arxiv to avoid getting slammed in peer review by the fact that none of what they have is open source.
How is https://github.com/openai/whisper not open source?
I used to work in NLP and the team next to me worked in speech to text. Though this was a decade ago and maybe terms have drifted? But it's listed on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_language_processing#Co...
There's something about AI tech where it seems important to the owners that it comes across as open and philanthropic, even when it isn't.
Personally, it sounds like a really sketchy way to work around privacy and copyright concerns. I.e. "we're just doing non-profit research", while smuggling the fruits of that research into the for-profit arm.
What's a profit cap? I've never even heard of that.
https://www.computerworld.com/article/2699555/google-acquire...
A big up round like this during a recession provides a very useful lens to see how OpenAI is bargaining here.
But also, in Microsoft's defense, AI is potentially dangerous! We NEED large corporations to control it behind closed doors. Think of the terrible things the unwashed masses would do with such a disruptive technology!
I, for one, would like to see legislation similar to that on cryptography, that bans exports and places heavy restrictions on who can access and develop such technologies.
I'm thinking maybe we could call it the "Save the Children from AI Super-Predators" act? Or maybe the "American AI Freedom" bill, since a similar naming scheme is working great for OpenAI? I'm totally open to input for names. Call your senator, today!
When OpenAI was funded as a non-profit in 2015, it raised $1 billion from investors that included YC Research. [1] Sam Altman was also the former president of Y Combinator. [2] How did OpenAI move from being funded entirely as a non profit to a for-profit company with less than 2% being owned by the non-profit?
[1] https://openai.com/blog/introducing-openai/
[2] https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/sam-altman-for-president