People—including some here—choose risk to life for greater productivity, all the time. Every advocate of going back to the office, in places without excellent public transit or walkability, is proposing to trade some serious micromorts for extra productivity (driving's dangerous).
So comparing "directly dying from construction" to "commuting in a car" is a big reach.
Diet, stress, physically-taxing-if-not-directly-fatal jobs, cancer-linked chemicals, pollution, etc. Tradeoffs made at both the societal and individual level every day.
Even in cars, consider the difference in attention "death from direct failure of the vehicle or manufacturer" gets compared to the more-random "accident that could've happened to anyone" increased-death-probability cases.
And that ties us neatly back to construction! We have many more things in place for construction safety - from regulations to equipment to practices - but it doesn't prevent there from being any loss of life, still. We just don't want to go backward.
aren't these both random 'accidents that could've happened to anyone'
do you maybe think that the foreman on a construction site sometimes picks one of the employees and orders him to get killed that day or something
I was a Title Runner when I was 18 in Reno. The Clarion had been purchased, and renamed Atlantis - and they were adding on/remodeling it...
I was driving by and there was a crane lifting a pile of I-Beams to the top of the tower... and as I was driving, I looked and thought "Damn, that would suck if they dropped that"
THE CABLE IMMEDIATELY BROKE and all the beams fell like 15 stories!!!
I got really freaked out and said "Ill never focus on disasters like that again."
Luckily nobody was injured, but I was mentally scarred.
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=joe+rogan+annie...
Maybe having more food delivery guys on the road is worse than more commuters, for public safety? Let's wait and see how 2022 did.
That's hiw I understood it from the guys who's job it is to make money by selling auto insurance anyways.
Depends. I think the Manhattan Project killed more people (not including using the bombs in combat).
[warning: auto-play video]
It is an interesting history of the Mohawk ironworkers who built NYC. I came across another exhibit once that said that the ironworkers originally took the jobs because, culturally, they appreciated the risk and heroism, and then it became a tradition of the tribe. In fact, it was probably this risk tolerance that kept them working without harnesses and lifelines for as long as they did.
At the end of the above article, it says that 30-50 ironworkers still die each year.
Are you sure of that? If the pandemic brought me any surprising new insight, then it would be how big the part of any given population is with hundred thousands dying if it just inconveniences them a little less. It needs no war, it needs people not being able to go to the hairdresser for a month.
"Overall, 15,021 non-Qataris died in the country between 2010 and 2019, according to the government. A Guardian analysis in February 2021 found that more than 6,500 migrant workers from India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka had died in Qatar since the award of the tournament. The death records were not categorised by occupation or place of work."
It's a normal number considering Qatar's 3 million population is 90% expats.
this is about ten times the average death rate for young people today but it still doesn't seem like an unacceptably dangerous workplace environment in the sense that if you worked in an environment that dangerous all your working life you'd still make it to retirement age with about 90% probability
that's a similar level of risk to smoking cigarettes, but of course you can't make a living smoking cigarettes, so i think skyscraper construction is somewhat more morally defensible
we aren't talking about the mines of potosí or something here
WRETCHED! I FN HATE the the world cup (FIFA) --> one of the most corrupt institutions.
The conditions of the living quarters for the workers for FIFA on the world cup builds are horrific.
Plus, they wouldnt pay the workers, would seize their passports and beat them.
No safety equipment, and extremely hot working conditions. Some of the temps were as high as 125F and these guys are doing really hard physical labor.
-
Actually there are a bunch of vids on the conditions:
https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=working+conditions+of+build...
My only reservation is that the OP fails to mention that some workers died during the construction of The Empire State building: According to the builder, "only" 5 workers died, but according to a newspaper, 14 workers died.[a] No one in the developed world would want to finish a project faster and for less money if the cost had to be measured in human lives.[b]
--
[a] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empire_State_Building#Construc...
[b] In some parts of the world, projects are routinely finished faster at the expense of human lives. For example, according to https://www.theguardian.com/football/2022/nov/27/qatar-death... , between 6,500 and 15,000 workers died, and more were injured, to build all the stadiums and facilities in time for the World Cup in Qatar, a tiny country in the Middle East / Western Asia with a total population of under 3M people.