News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by saghm on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:06AM (#34297393)
I've always found it pretty weird how common the idea is that companies _need_ to keep growing indefinitely, regardless of the size they've reach. If a company is sustainably making a profit (i.e. makes more money than it needs to spend to keep running) and will continue to for the foreseeable future, why do they need to grow their revenue even higher? It seems like the expectation is they need to do this so that the stock price can go up, but if people only buy the stock to sell it when it's worth more due to being larger, what's the actual connection between the stock price and the amount of money the company makes other than everyone just agreeing to pretend there's one? Ostensibly the reason stock is worth anything at all is that it could eventually yield dividends, but there's no reason that a company already making a profit can't just start paying dividends regularly without needing to ever grow any larger.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by evo on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:21AM (#34297461)
I suspect in reality the increasing compensation of the executive suite in stock, while intended to alleviate the principal agent problem, means that it's substantially more remunerative for leadership to try to goose their stock price by whatever means possible within their tenure than to steer the ship in a growth-agnostic fashion. Doubly so with modern big tech companies where RSU growth can fuel a big chunk of your salary costs for your tech department when your company is on the rise, but scare everyone off when the reverse is true.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by magic_hamster on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:23AM (#34297471)
Some people will say that companies need to grow to increase the bottom line, but my experience is that growth is actually a byproduct that indicates the health of your business rather than the actual goal. Growth is a result of competition, when new markets emerge, when competitors come up with better products, there is an opportunity to increase your market share and take in more revenue. Assuming you don't leave money on the table, it's understandable that you will compete and if you're doing well you will grow.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by Radim on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:26AM (#34297485)
The standard response is evolutionary:

If you leave profit (growth, resources) on the table, someone else will pick them up and beat you with it.

The supposed analogy is biological. You may choose to check out of the always-do-more-with-less rat race, or even out of existence completely. But that choice will help populate the world with "not your successors". Similar with companies: your "sustainably making profit" premise is incompatible with "willingly foregoes growth / change" – at least in the long term, due to competition.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by wizzwizz4 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @11:37AM (#34300522)
> at least in the long term, due to competition.

Assuming there's always some proportion of people who choose to do otherwise.

Humans are powerful enough now that, if we wanted to, we could stop this. It'd require collaboratively punishing defectors, of course – because some humans are greedy – but until (and if) we meet aliens, we don't need to live like this, provided we can learn to work together.

It's fortunate, then, that motivated collaboration can produce better results than competition. The collaborators might be able to win the Last Competition.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by mijamo on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:42AM (#34297599)
Yo be clear not all companies are expected to grow. But growth is the main characteristic of a certain kind of companies, and the reason why their stock can have very high PE ratio, because shareholders expect to get return in the stock going up instead of dividends. You have plenty of vale companies that pay dividends and do not grow very much, sustaining a healthy business on their market.

But the transition between growth and value is a bit tough. You need to stop hiring like crazy, intern promotions suddenly go more stale as a result, stock compensation is hurt a lot so your employees might not be super happy with it, the story is also appealing to a completely different kind of people, and your stock goes down a lot at first, all your financing suddenly gets a lot more expensive etc.

It is possible that we are witnessing that transition in some of the tech companies right now, as the symptoms match, but it really is too early to tell.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by jasode on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:27AM (#34297838)
>If a company is sustainably making a profit (i.e. makes more money than it needs to spend to keep running) and will continue to for the foreseeable future, why do they need to grow their revenue even higher? [...], but there's no reason that a company already making a profit can't just start paying dividends regularly without needing to ever grow any larger.

Your comment is common but it implicitly assumes a stable steady-state in the business landscape. (E.g. phrases such as "profit _will_ continue to for the foreseeable future,")

That type of thinking can work for local businesses (isolated from global competition) such as a small family restaurant. The owner opens a new restaurant with 10 tables and then maybe the business modestly grows to 15 tables a few years later and then stops growing. The owner is able to maintain a steady-state business of repeat patrons at the restaurant for decades with predictable profits. Another example of somewhat predictable profits on a larger scale are legacy oligopoly/monopoly businesses such as railroad companies.

But unlike local restaurants, many businesses have to aggressively compete in national and global markets and if it stops growing, it starts dying. Predictable profits are not guaranteed for the foreseeable future. That's why giants like Motorola and Nokia got their mobile phone business killed by a (growing) hobbyist computer company named Apple. (Motorola and Nokia are still big but not as big as they once were.) The businesses in hyper-competitive spaces like technology etc are a basically in a Red Queen race: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis

E.g. Why can't Blockbluster Video stop worrying about growth and just pay dividends from profits? Because an upstart like Netflix competed away Blockbuster's rental profits. Using hindsight, we can see that assuming Blockbuster could just pay "dividends regularly and for the foreseeable future" is flawed. The same broken assumption is happening to Netflix today: Why can't Netflix stop worrying about growth and just pay dividends? Because Disney+ and HBO MAX are competing away Netflix's profits.

Growing revenue and profits allows adaption to new competitive threats.

It isn't just the investors who want growing businesses. The prospective employees find them desirable too. Many talented graduates of engineering would rather get a job with a growing Apple than a declining Motorola/Nokia.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by pixelfarmer on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:48AM (#34297967)
> But unlike local restaurants, many businesses have to aggressively compete in national and global markets and if it stops growing, it starts dying.

How is a company dying if it continues to make profit in a changing market?

> Growing revenue and profits allows adaption to new competitive threats.

Adaption to "new competitive threats" is done by humans.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:57AM (#34298345)
> How is a company dying if it continues to make profit in a changing market?

Because, for example. their market is being steadily taken away by their competitors, and the company doesn't have a way to stop it.

Death takes time, and may not be apparent if you're only looking at profits. The company could be profitable, but less so every year. Or, the company could be growing its profits year by year, but by a smaller factor. In more general terms: your profit may be positive, but if any of its derivatives (first, second, N-th) is negative and you have no way to address it, then you're dying.

>> Growing revenue and profits allows adaption to new competitive threats.

> Adaption to "new competitive threats" is done by humans.

Yes, but having more resources lets those humans invent and execute such adaptations better - in the same way it's easier for individuals and households to adapt to changing life circumstances when they have savings and a stable income source, and the more of these they have, the easier it gets.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by jnovek on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:34AM (#34298578)
“Because, for example. their market is being steadily taken away by their competitors, and the company doesn't have a way to stop it.”

This is circular reasoning: companies must grow because because otherwise they will have their lunch eaten by other companies who are growing because they must grow.

I realize that this is an absolute basic tenet of capitalism that you’re talking about, but this response only explains where we are, not why we’re there.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:32AM (#34298964)
> This is circular reasoning

Yes. Or, in other words, a feedback loop.

> I realize that this is an absolute basic tenet of capitalism that you’re talking about, but this response only explains where we are, not why we’re there.

It does both: we are here because it's a self-sustaining negative feedback loop. How exactly we got here has been long lost to history, and the specifics don't matter anyway: what matters is, how hard would it be to break out of this state, whether it's worth doing in the first place, and, if we somehow break the cycle, what's there to stop us from immediately falling back into it.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by pixelfarmer on Sunday January 08, 2023 @04:37PM (#34303403)
The driving motivator is just greed, nothing else. Growth is not per se required to run a successful company for a long time, that is just plain myth. Nor is growth a guarantee to survive for a long period of time. It may increase the chances to stay afloat, but that highly depends on the circumstances. Also, as soon as you make growth the main motivator to run a company you are opening yourself up to go bust, inherently so.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:55PM (#34304249)
> The driving motivator is just greed, nothing else.

In some cases, sure. But I feel it's also a cop-out - it's easier to assume those business men are just driven by greed, than to look at the messy interplay of motivations and incentives that are the actual driver.

Perhaps that's too cynical a take, but I think it's quite common for small companies to focus on growth because... that's How Business Is Done. Many entrepreneurs are not experts in market economy, nor do they have everything figured out - they follow their intuition, what other entrepreneurs and business press says, etc.

> Growth is not per se required to run a successful company for a long time, that is just plain myth.

Define "long time". I believe that with competition and sufficiently long time, it's not a myth, but an inevitability.

> Also, as soon as you make growth the main motivator to run a company you are opening yourself up to go bust, inherently so.

You can always go bust. If you build a non-expanding, sustainable business, it's only a matter of time before change in the market, or competitors, or just plain increase of costs of living / inflation in general will force you to either grow or give up, as some nonzero amount of growth will be required to just maintain your status quo.

Turning this around, and giving another answer to the "driving motivator" question, you can view it through perspective of observer selection: pretty much all companies pursue growth, because those that didn't are no longer operating.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by pixelfarmer on Monday January 09, 2023 @03:07AM (#34307952)
You have to mentally split the "rules" defined by what I call the financial "economy" (which is rooted purely in belief), and the real economy, which is vastly more complex. Something related would be what a company focuses on: Profit/money and using what they are doing as a means to accomplish that, or having a company to actually accomplish a goal and that goal, the idea comes first. Latter opens up the possibility, given that the financial means are there, to even make losses now and then, because you want to invest (more heavily) in change for one reason or another.

Thing is, this "growth before everything else" mantra comes from the financial "economy". If you apply this to real economy, you are in for a surprise, because there are limits everywhere. Such limits don't really exist in the financial "economy". But in return it also means you can operate in the real economy for long periods without growth.

Why "economy"? Economy exists because humans split their time to do all the things to fulfill their needs, you know, survival (food, shelter, ...) etc. Without that you wouldn't have any economy (as in trading goods) to write home about. Note that I wrote "humans split their time"; if you automate all that the need to split their time is rendered pointless, which also drives this economy into the ground, i.e. it is not needed to that extent anymore.

That is different with the financial "economy". The main goal there is money, and the value of that is rooted in belief. Which renders everything else on top of that also belief/speculation. But because of that it can also grow endlessly. The problem with it: It doesn't put food on the table (nor does it provide a new table should it need replacement). This also means all the rules in that space are only valid in there, and may very well not work at all outside of it.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by TeMPOraL on Monday January 09, 2023 @04:37AM (#34308492)
> You have to mentally split the "rules" defined by what I call the financial "economy" (which is rooted purely in belief), and the real economy, which is vastly more complex.

I used to do that in the past, but the more I thought, the harder it got - today, what you call the "financial 'economy'" sounds to me like a natural outgrowth of increasing specialization in the "real economy".

> Something related would be what a company focuses on: Profit/money and using what they are doing as a means to accomplish that, or having a company to actually accomplish a goal and that goal, the idea comes first.

The former are what I used to call "toilet paper companies", as in "this company is doing computers or drugs now, but if it was cheaper to retool, it would be selling toilet paper or whatever else yields better profits this moment". The latter... mostly don't exist, I think. SpaceX is about the only example I can think of.

As much as it pains me, I came to understand that most companies exist primarily to make money for their owners, secondarily to pay salaries to employees, and thirdly (at best) to do something useful - and it can hardly be the other way. Not just because companies focusing on profit beat those focusing on the product/services - but also because that's what the owners and employees want. And it's not driven by greed.

I realized that when I stopped looking at the big corporations and startup unicorns, and instead looked at the local businesses I interact with daily: bakeries, convenience stores, pharmacies, barber shops, dry cleaning, ISPs, etc. None of them are in it for the idea, for the product. All of them are in it for the profit - because that profit is what gets them and their families some semblance of security and stability in this world.

Yes, it's not ideal, it's big part of the reason why every good and service seems to get worse with time, particularly as specific niches get hit by "financialization" trends. But it won't go away as long as everyone has bills to pay, food costs money, healthcare isn't simultaneously free and easily available, etc.

> Latter opens up the possibility, given that the financial means are there, to even make losses now and then, because you want to invest (more heavily) in change for one reason or another.

The "financial 'economy'" has this covered, too. In fact, they have terms and math and virtual products that cover it. That's the reason it exists: because as the "real 'economy'" gets larger, more complex, and more thought is put into it, people want to do more complicated things, and - perhaps most importantly - everyone wants to reduce their personal risks.

Want to build a factory making much-needed goods? You need more money than everyone in your village has put together. Are you a farmer who almost went into deep poverty last year, after most of your crops fell to a disease? You want some kind of safety net. Financial sector provides all that: loans, options, futures, etc.

> The main goal there is money, and the value of that is rooted in belief. Which renders everything else on top of that also belief/speculation. But because of that it can also grow endlessly. The problem with it: It doesn't put food on the table (nor does it provide a new table should it need replacement). This also means all the rules in that space are only valid in there, and may very well not work at all outside of it.

This stars with money itself - as you say, its value is rooted in belief. This by itself is pretty natural to humans - things like "company", "tribe", "government", "society", "money" - but also "family" - are all rooted in belief. Establishing such intersubjective beliefs is arguably humanity's superpower.

As for the rules in the financial space, yes, they're all abstract and virtual. That's the point. Much like money itself is the answer to barter not scaling to support growing population and increasing specialization, a lot of those financial industry inventions are ways to optimize trade by resolving some complexities in this abstract, virtual concept space. Your grain can be traded back and forth, changing its owners 20 times in a quarter, while never physically leaving your silo. Would it be better if it had to be trucked back and forth, just for it to look like "real 'economy'"?

All this is to say: yes, there's plenty of problems and pathology in the financial space, and it does a lot of bad things. But it also does a lot of good things, and it exists not just because of greed, but also because there's real need for it, and without it, the "real 'economy'" wouldn't support its own weight anymore.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by doctor_eval on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:36AM (#34298242)
I don’t understand your argument. Netflix, Blockbuster, Motorola and Nokia all pursued growth strategies, yet the latter three (at least) ultimately failed to maintain their lead in consumer facing markets. So how does that explain the need for perpetual growth? It doesn’t seem connected to your points.

And, in the case of Nokia specifically, maybe they would still be a significant player in the handset market if they had pursued profit by investing R&D into a smaller number of good handsets, rather than their growth strategy that, if memory serves, resulted in the release of one janky new handset every week.

It’s not like what Apple did was magic; it was mostly just hard work and vision. Motorola and Nokia lost their business by being unfocussed and stupid, not because they didn’t pursue growth.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by fragmede on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:10AM (#34298434)
Apple's iPhone launch included the vertical monopoly that was their magic. It addressed consumer needs like no other and everyone else was left playing catch-up.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by arka2147483647 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:35AM (#34298585)
Nokia/Motorola/etc tried to compete and research but ultimately failed. This is not a counterargument, but rather underlines the cutthroat nature of international competition.

> And, in the case of Nokia specifically, maybe they would still be a significant player in the handset market if they had pursued profit by investing R&D into a smaller number of good handsets,

They picked the wrong horse, as the saying goes. At the time it was not so obvious which thing was going to win.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by sokoloff on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:00AM (#34299137)
It’s not the pursuit of growth that matters, but the achievement of growth.

Companies need to grow in places because they will inevitably be shrinking in some places (as customers age or churn out, as competitors come in to compete in segments, as new substitutive goods compete for wallet share).

Even if you want to stay the same size, you will have some amount of growth in your strategy (or you’ll fail).

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by jasode on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:11AM (#34299709)
>Netflix, Blockbuster, Motorola and Nokia all pursued growth strategies, yet the latter three (at least) ultimately failed to maintain their lead in consumer facing markets. So how does that explain the need for perpetual growth?

You're laying out a cause & effect I didn't claim. I'm not saying "pursue growth guarantees success" -- which is unrealistic. A variation of your scenario is like asking, "Most novelists pursued growth of their audience but most failed so how do those failures explain why novelists want to grow their audiences?"

The # of failures is a different subject from the _motivation_ for growth.

My reply to gp was to dissect the flawed premise that profits are predictable and stable. It's that flawed assumption that makes it seem like growth is unnecessary.

In other words, even if you want to deliberately create a new company with a "no growth" policy, the outside world has its own freewill and doesn't have to cooperate with your goal. New competitors or changing consumer preferences can sabotage your "no growth" idea and erase the steady-state profits.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by doctor_eval on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:37PM (#34304068)
> A variation of your scenario is like asking, "Most novelists pursued growth of their audience but most failed so how do those failures explain why novelists want to grow their audiences?"

Not at all. You said,

> Why can't Blockbluster Video stop worrying about growth and just pay dividends from profits? Because an upstart like Netflix competed away Blockbuster's rental profits

And I simply don’t see the connection.

Blockbuster could have done any number of things to prevent their demise but pursuing a growth strategy in the face of an obvious threat to their business was not one of them. And their size - perhaps achieved from a growth strategy - did not protect them. It’s possible that their size, and the blandness that was necessary to get there - actually made them more vulnerable. (We used to call it “Lacklustre Video”)

The same for Nokia and Motorola. It’s a strategy of crap products built en masse to drive growth into every segment which makes a company vulnerable.

So I think novelists make for a poor analogy. And I think there are plenty of companies that pursue a sustainable profit strategy rather than a growth strategy.

It’s just that you don’t hear about them because they aren’t screaming for your business.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by jasode on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:28PM (#34305097)
>Blockbuster [...] their size - perhaps achieved from a growth strategy - did not protect them. It’s possible that their size, and the blandness that was necessary to get there - actually made them more vulnerable.

Again, you misunderstand my point and asserting claims I didn't make. To restate:

- growth by itself does not guarantee protection from competitors.

- a large company that became large from growth does not prevent them from stumbling over their own bureaucracy and losing to more smaller more nimble competitors who haven't grown into giants yet

Yes, it's obvious pursuing growth doesn't guarantee success. Blockbuster did try growing their streaming business to compete with Netflix but still failed. Lots of stories like that.

>pursue a sustainable profit strategy rather than a growth strategy.

The issue is that you're inserting the adjective "sustainable" as a presupposed condition which conveniently proves its own point. Thus in your mind, if it's "sustainable profits", it makes pursuing growth unnecessary. You've made the same exact assumption as the gp I replied to when he stated, "If a company is sustainably making a profit ..."

In the mind of many businesspeople, profits are not assumed to be sustainable. That's the key point. (E.g. Andy Grove's famous "only the paranoid survive"). Yes, you may have booked some profits for this quarter and try to make conservative assumptions for the next few but you don't know what competitors (many unknown to you) will do. Profits can suddenly flip from seemingly sustainable to unsustainable. What seemed like a "defensible moat" in Warren Buffet's can change and new competitors can just bypass the castle.

Business can grow with (1) new products/services or (2) new markets. Growth is one strategy to offset the shrinking of sales from previous products and/or loss of customers. Or put another way, "pursuing sustainable profits" is partially done by pursuing growth because the components of last quarter's profit number is declining. Netflix started the streaming business in 2007 and grew it before profits declined from the DVD-by-mail business. Streaming revenue didn't surpass DVD revenue until 2016. If Netflix didn't grow the new product (streaming) and let it cannibalize its older product (DVD), other competitors would do it anyway. Growth is adaptation to a changing world.

>And I think there are plenty of companies that pursue a sustainable profit strategy rather than a growth strategy.

Flip that around: A company can pursue growth strategy as one way to pursue sustainable profit strategy. Finding adjacent/complementary products. Finding adjacent markets.

The "sustainable profit" is the outcome of that.

If one is running a local Italian restaurant or a custom woodworking shop making custom furniture, competition isn't as cutthroat so finding ways to grow is less of a concern.

However, if one is starting a software SASS company with an initial successful product, the idea of growth will be on the radar because the premise of "sustainable profits" in the software business can't be assumed. That's because the SASS company can't control others such as Microsoft or AWS or some other unknown competitor offering a similar service for less (or even bundled for free).

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by pclmulqdq on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:14AM (#34298851)
There are several counterexamples to this idea, including companies 300+ years old, where a company does just fine without "competitive" expansion of its business, and where no competitors show up to eat their lunch.

The poster child for this model, I think, is Zildjian: the biggest global maker of cymbals. They have been doing it for hundreds of years, never expanded outside of cymbals, and continue to do well.

Companies run on this expansionist idea must keep expanding to avoid death, however, because they operate at unsustainable levels of expenses otherwise, and they hire managers on the premise of making bold moves to get promotions.

This "grow or die" mentality is entirely a cultural phenomenon of modern western companies, and they can absolutely opt out of it.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by jasode on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:43AM (#34299033)
>There are several counterexamples to this idea, [...] where no competitors show up to eat their lunch.

Yes, I understand that and already provided several counterexamples. (Local restaurants and legacy railroads.)

>The poster child for this model, I think, is Zildjian: the biggest global maker of cymbals. They have been doing it for hundreds of years, never expanded outside of cymbals,

I actually own a bunch of Zildjian cymbals and saw several documentaries about the brothers' split into Zildjian and Sabian. In any case, Zildjian did expand into other products outside of cymbals. From wikipedia:

- In 2010, Zildjian acquired the Vic Firth Company and in 2018 acquired the Mike Balter Mallet company expanding the company's product offerings to include a full range of drumsticks and percussion mallets.

Zildjian also sells electronics like earphones[1]. The daughters that inherited Zildjian wants the company to grow. The growth has not been as fast as a tech startup but they do want it to grow.

But even without expanding product categories, the company can also expand markets to sell to. That was one of the motivations of Zildjian expanding their manufacturing into Canada as that export location allowed them to sell cheaper cymbals to Europe.

>This "grow or die" mentality is entirely a cultural phenomenon of modern western companies, and they can absolutely opt out of it.

Not just Western companies. Also East Asia companies in Japan like Canon, Sony, Toyota wanted growth. Korea companies like Samsung and LG. And Africa companies in Ethiopia and Nigeria want to grow too.

But I do agree with the point you were trying to make: if you happen to pick a business domain that doesn't have cutthroat competition, there's less pressure to grow to avoid dying.

RIM Blackberry didn't get into the drums cymbals business (slower moving competition of hammering round sheets of metal) but the phones business (fast iteration competition of electronics). They grew until the 2007 Apple iPhone made their keyboard phones and 2-way pagers mostly obsolete.

If you're an entrepreneur who believes the "growth treadmill" is insane and stupid, you need to pick the type of business that aligns with that philosophy!

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=zildjian+in+ear+monitors

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by acdha on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:10AM (#34299214)
I think you have a valid point about not being complacent but all of your examples highlight how hard it is to pick a growth strategy which actually works long-term. Those companies all did what Wall Street analysts wanted but chasing that growth lead to their downfall: Nokia and Motorola cut things like R&D, which is expensive and uncertain, and focused on marketing & expansion. They cut deals which the cell carriers which produced big numbers but turned creative control of their product. Remember all of the calls for Apple to give Verizon what they wanted to gain access to their customers?

Blockbuster is a different industry but again they were focused on financial growth at the expense of the company. Trying to hit those targets meant they opened marginal locations and it also meant things like reducing “costs” like staffing (but not strategic investments like C-level compensation, of course) which had given them something Netflix couldn’t easily match.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by OtomotO on Sunday January 08, 2023 @05:28AM (#34297839)
It's a dogma, the dogma of neocapitalism... Endless growth.

Sort of like a malign tumor, which in the end kills the host and itself.

It's just propaganda. Nothing grows endlessly, apart maybe from human greed and idiocy.

Also some growth is "mandatory" because of inflation. If you don't grow your profits but there is inflation, your profits in reality shrink.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by ekianjo on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:35AM (#34298240)
growth means constant investment. The day you stop growing, your investment is capped or much more constrained, and it's only a matter of time until your company is over.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by kwhitefoot on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:47AM (#34298303)
It seems to me that they need to keep growing because they are in reality pyramid schemes with the people (and investment institutions) at the top wanting ever larger profits. The company gets bigger but the number of people at the apex of the pyramid does not.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:52AM (#34298326)
Due to inflation, basically. There is an effect like inflation which as far as I know is unnamed, where the credit growth & money creation in the economy hits asset prices and drives them up at a fast rate (eg, gold has been pretending to make real annual returns for the last few decades when we all know it isn't changing in value). A company that is treading water will still be growing in percentage terms year-on-year due to this, so a company that isn't growing is actually failing to position correctly vs the credit in an economy.

If that inflation wasn't part of the picture, companies holding steady would be more acceptable.

Although you wouldn't hear about it in the press; the hot companies are always the ones that are growing. There isn't much to say about companies that just sit there.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by fragmede on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:04AM (#34298392)
Would you mind explaining a bit more than "basically"? The money they take in also inflates, so if everyone who bought one last year buys another one, sales in dollars should increase by the same amount as inflation.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by arka2147483647 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:28AM (#34298530)
A company may not be able to increase prices as much as inflation eats. Eg, in 6 percent inflation, if you raise prices by 6%, it may result in customers shrinking their purchases by equivalent, or even larger amount. So after the price hike you could be worse off. That is the reason most companies often raise prices slowly in small increments over the months or years.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:15AM (#34298859)
If we're talking about sales, then sure that should go up by CPI inflation. I thought we were talking about stock prices. Same difference either way, steady state is for economic losers if the money supply is growing exponentially.

Historically "growth" has just been a word for increased energy availability. If it is supposed to measure something else it is a bit meaningless (if some dude plays a game for 2 hours a day, then next year spends 2 hours a day playing a "much better" game on a faster XBox, what does growth as a % even mean? If he spends more hours on a game is that growth? These are profoundly silly questions to spend time on). The rough thinking is we should keep pushing for energy growth until we physically can't any more, because that helps poor people not starve which is actually important.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by Folcon on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:34AM (#34298973)
If that's the goal and I agree that's not a bad goal at all, we seem to have decoupled that from the outcomes.

Are energy companies even really doing that much to grow their energy production? Are we seeing much in the way of producers materially investing in increasing their production thus flooding their markets in a race to the bottom? It feels like a lot of these things have stalled out at present, or am I being too cynical?

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by codethief on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:31AM (#34298959)
> The rough thinking is we should keep pushing for energy growth until we physically can't any more

Not sure that's a good idea, see https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:40AM (#34299018)
* * *
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by r3trohack3r on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#34299895)
I wouldn't put too much stock in our current believed limits on life in the universe. Humans are really immature in our understanding of the cosmos and many of these are fairly likely to be wrong.

Given what weve discovered (and been wrong about) so far, I suspect things like entropy and the heat death of the universe being limits on life will be chuckled at by future humans the same way we chuckle about the ether.

Those things are so far in the future and so poorly understood, declaring bankruptcy now would be premature. We have real problems that are a lot closer and easier for humans to overcome, like the complete extinction event facing our planet in ~400M years.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by Folcon on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:55AM (#34299108)
I forgot about this, but the point stands, we still don't use energy that we collect to achieving the outcome he states:

> that helps poor people not starve which is actually important

If we generalise that meeting a minimal bar on the Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, then we're still pretty poor on that front.

Thanks for the link, having read this, it's a valid counterpoint against generally increasing GDP as we currently think of it.

However a lot of discussions at present don't hold to limiting growth to Earth.

What this means however is up for grabs, it could take a very long time to figure out how to practically go further than Earth.

It is however probably worth more consideration than modern economics would give it.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by luma on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:52AM (#34299090)
Inflation isn't the problem, it's investors. As others have noted, inflation is a wash for most cases. Investors expect regular returns and they sit on your board and they are NEVER satisfied.

When you put the world's greediest individuals in charge of what your business should do next, don't be surprised when the answer is ALWAYS "give us more money".

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:03AM (#34299160)
People expect their assets to earn 7%+ per year, both via individual retirement accounts and taxpayer funded defined benefit pensions. If that assumption is not met, then those debts cannot be repaid, which means someone (or everyone) has to take a hit on quality of life. This is politically unpopular because people get disappointed when their expectations are not met.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by luma on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:49AM (#34299518)
Your argument here is that rich people expect to continue getting richer on account of... already being rich.

I will sleep like a baby if their expectations of continued "being rich for no work" doesn't pan out for them.

Get a job, slackers.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:56AM (#34299578)
My argument is that a very large proportion of people benefit from borrowing from the future (obviously some more than others). Enough that it is politically unpopular to vote against the government ensuring these returns.

For example, taxes are lower today because of off the books borrowing from the future via these expected future asset valuations, as well as people liking their own 401k/IRA account numbers going up.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by chalst on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#34299904)
> My argument is that a very large proportion

What is the actual proportion?

The proportion you argue is neither here nor there.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#34300146)
Whatever the actual proportion is, it is evident over many decades, that it is sufficiently large to ensure the election of leaders that will backstop asset prices.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by wizzwizz4 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @11:32AM (#34300471)
> Whatever the actual proportion is, it is evident over many decades, that it is sufficiently large

Sufficiently-powerful. Don't confuse the two. In an ideal world, one would be indicative of the other, but history suggests this hasn't been the case. (No comment on the contemporary political situation.)

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by perryizgr8 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:55AM (#34298337)
Population is growing. Your company's target market is a subset of population. Unless your target is a niche that nobody new is joining, then your company must grow just to maintain status quo. If you sell phones and you're not growing, it means you are actually contracting. That's why everyone is crazy behind growth. It means your business is not dying.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by ViViDboarder on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:40AM (#34299970)
Theres that kind of growth, and then the expectation that you grow into every conceivable vertical to expand more rapidly or support stock prices for an otherwise stagnant business.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by refurb on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:19AM (#34298881)
No industry is stagnant. Consumer demand changes, technology changes, competitors changes.

The car industry is a great example. If you're not growing (in the most basic sense - new products, new markets), you're dying.

That's even more true in tech.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by marcosdumay on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#34299901)
As those things usually go, this is caused by government policy (and do not happen on the entire world).

The US in particular greatly disincentive dividends, putting larger taxes over them than over any other form of profit accumulation.